Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel increasingly alienated by Tory voters?

358 replies

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 14:11

I am in despair as to where our country is at. With the cost of living crisis looming (and already beginning), this winter is going to be brutal and likely life ending for so many in the UK, and the current aspiring leadership of the Tory party seem to be more interested in litigating culture wars and appeasing NIMBY pensioners in the Home countries than actually addressing any of the serious problems in the UK.

I've never been a Tory voter, but I've always been able to get along with people who have different views (provided they aren't racist/homophobic etc). But how anyone could see all the misery and deprivation on the horizon, look at the prospective leaders and frontbenchers with their complete lack of sultions, and continue with supporting them is genuinely beyond me. I find myself slowly being consumed by bitterness and rage against people for their views, and it frightens me. Am I alone in this?

OP posts:
Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 22:29

Florenz · 10/08/2022 22:20

People moan about the government in every country, regardless of what voting system is used. It'd be the same politicians involved regardless. The major parties are coalition parties, it's just that the coalitions are within the party instead giving each segment of the party different names.

True, but when you have so many people whose votes don’t count because of the system, then political apathy is encouraged and that is a huge problem in this country. I think it would be much healthier to adopt a system of PR as they do in Ireland, where every vote makes a difference. At the very least I’d like to see mandatory voting.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 10/08/2022 22:21

Yanbu. How anyone with school age children could consider voting Tory is mystery. They are actively and directly damaging their children's future lives on numerous fronts.

Florenz · 10/08/2022 22:20

People moan about the government in every country, regardless of what voting system is used. It'd be the same politicians involved regardless. The major parties are coalition parties, it's just that the coalitions are within the party instead giving each segment of the party different names.

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 22:16

DownNative · 10/08/2022 21:48

Three things here:

  1. It was actually 13,966,451 million people who voted Conservative in the 2019 General Election.

  2. The entirety of the UK population does NOT have the right to vote. No country does that!

No, the UK electorate is 47,567,800 million voters. The percentage of the total UK electorate who voted Conservative in 2019 was 29%.

But only 67.3% of the total UK electorate voted in the 2019 General Election which means the Conservative vote share was 43%.

In context, the term "majority" simply means "the greater number". No party will get a majority of the total electorate in a multi party state. We'd need to be a two party state like the United States and I don't think that'd be a popular suggestion.

As above, fewer people voted for Labour, Lib Dems, SNP and so on.

"Of the people, by the people, for the people" - Abraham Lincoln

Democracy basically means the people cast their votes as they see fit. That's power of the people. FPTP is not undemocratic since the electorate consent to the system. It is just one form democracy takes amongst others.

  1. As for your last comment vis a vis Belarus, the Polish and Spanish Senates still use FPTP.

Outside of Europe, the United States, Canada and India are three examples of countries using FPTP.

True. It was 13.9. I was mistaken on that.
i know not everyone can vote, but a government with an 80 seat majority chosen by so small a segment of the population is not representative. That is why proportional representation is much more democratic, as it actually reflects what each vote stands for.
we are the only country in Europe apart from Belarus to depend entirely on FPTP. Other countries may have some element of it, but this is tempered by other voting systems.

XingMing · 10/08/2022 22:05

I don't think the union voice is stronger in Europe @BirmaBrite but the workforce is listened to for its ideas and trusted not to rock the boat without good reason. UK labour relations have always tended to be contentious and confrontational.

XingMing · 10/08/2022 21:56

Unions in Germany are better integrated into corporate decision-making in that there tend to be union board representatives speaking for the work force in companies over a certain size (don't ask for details of how big, but the labour force has a voice and is consulted). I don't know a lot about French unions or Spanish or Italian.

BirmaBrite · 10/08/2022 21:48

Are Unions stronger in other European countries @XingMing ?

Were there any laws introduced in the UK during this timespan that diluted their influence further ?

DownNative · 10/08/2022 21:48

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 14:52

Our voting system is extremely undemocratic, so actually they are not voted in by the majority of people. Only 13.2 million out of a population of 67 million voted Tory, and that was enough to give them an 80 seat majority. The only other European country to be so antiquated in Belarus.

Three things here:

  1. It was actually 13,966,451 million people who voted Conservative in the 2019 General Election.

  2. The entirety of the UK population does NOT have the right to vote. No country does that!

No, the UK electorate is 47,567,800 million voters. The percentage of the total UK electorate who voted Conservative in 2019 was 29%.

But only 67.3% of the total UK electorate voted in the 2019 General Election which means the Conservative vote share was 43%.

In context, the term "majority" simply means "the greater number". No party will get a majority of the total electorate in a multi party state. We'd need to be a two party state like the United States and I don't think that'd be a popular suggestion.

As above, fewer people voted for Labour, Lib Dems, SNP and so on.

"Of the people, by the people, for the people" - Abraham Lincoln

Democracy basically means the people cast their votes as they see fit. That's power of the people. FPTP is not undemocratic since the electorate consent to the system. It is just one form democracy takes amongst others.

  1. As for your last comment vis a vis Belarus, the Polish and Spanish Senates still use FPTP.

Outside of Europe, the United States, Canada and India are three examples of countries using FPTP.

XingMing · 10/08/2022 21:47

The Tories were, between the 1970s and 1992 (when we failed to failed to ballot the public on the Single Europe Act, under Major) very much in favour of free trade and free movement... travelling towards political and currency union was regarded as a step too far. Then Gordon Brown ruled out joining the Euro in about 1998.

XingMing · 10/08/2022 21:42

No @BirmaBrite they objected to joining the EEc, as it was, because of the union bloc vote. The unions were reluctant to see their influence diluted, so it took until the 2000s to win them round. It was part of the reason that Corbyn couldn't give a straight answer yes to the Remainers in 2019. His political career had been founded on opposing the EU.

Florenz · 10/08/2022 21:41

The reason Labour appears to "need more votes to get elected" is because of the areas where they win so heavily. If fewer people in those areas voted Labour, but they still got enough votes to win the seat, it would mean Labour "needed less votes to get elected". Which is of course ridiculous.

BirmaBrite · 10/08/2022 21:39

@Florenz But the system is what it is

Which is fine if you are talking about a countries democratic system, but not if you are talking about its healthcare system ?

Quincythequince · 10/08/2022 21:36

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 21:19

It’s not as simple as that. It’s that a Labour MP needs far more votes to get elected than a Tory one. A Green MP needs miles more votes. SNP MPs appear to be the easiest of all to elect. That isn’t right

What are you on about?
Within any one constituency, the winner needs a specific number to win, irrespective of party. A Labour MP in Hammersmith and Fulham won’t for example need more than a Tory one.

Different constituency’s have different numbers of people it’s true, but within each one it’s level pegging in terms of who wins. Blue won’t get votes in on fewer minimum votes than Red.

BirmaBrite · 10/08/2022 21:34

@XingMing most of Labour's policy history since the 1970s was based on opposition to the EU.

That's an interesting statement, did they hate it because the Tories were very much for it then ?

fakenamefornow · 10/08/2022 21:34

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:24

You said you paid 18k tax per year? That’s no where near six figure salary amounts.

I’ll rephrase, most people with talent and up to date skill sets are leaving. Think engineering and tech and nothing is keeping them here.

So after 12 years of Tory rule, people who can, are leaving the country to escape? Is that what you're saying?

Florenz · 10/08/2022 21:32

But the system is what it is. It's up to the parties to appeal to enough people in enough areas to win. There's no point piling up votes in safe seats when winning by 1 vote gets you 1 seat in the commons, and winning by 100000 votes gets you the same 1 seat in the commons. A party needs to have broad appeal to a wide range of people in order to get into government, which is how it should be. If it was just a sheer nationwide popular vote there'd be no reason for the government to do anything outside of a few major cities.

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 21:32

BirmaBrite · 10/08/2022 21:28

At least the Tories delivered for their brexit supporters

I think you are being a teeny bit premature, the Tories have delivered Brexit, that much is true, have they 'delivered' the Brexit that they promised, that is beneficial to all those who voted for it, remains to be seen. They made a lot of promises that are yet to materialise. They still might I suppose ?

Well Jacob Rees Mogg thinks we might see benefits in 50 years.

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 21:31

XingMing · 10/08/2022 21:29

Dido Harding, John Penrose's wife, was in charge of a racecourse before she was given a £37 billion pound contract to run test and trace, which was a spectacular failure

But before that, she ran TalkTalk which is still a substantial complex multinational utility company. Not brilliantly mind.

Fair enough, but as you say not well and not a background that set her up for Test and Trace, so the outcome was not surprising. She’ll have been richer though.

XingMing · 10/08/2022 21:29

Dido Harding, John Penrose's wife, was in charge of a racecourse before she was given a £37 billion pound contract to run test and trace, which was a spectacular failure

But before that, she ran TalkTalk which is still a substantial complex multinational utility company. Not brilliantly mind.

BirmaBrite · 10/08/2022 21:28

At least the Tories delivered for their brexit supporters

I think you are being a teeny bit premature, the Tories have delivered Brexit, that much is true, have they 'delivered' the Brexit that they promised, that is beneficial to all those who voted for it, remains to be seen. They made a lot of promises that are yet to materialise. They still might I suppose ?

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 21:22

This explains the problem with the electoral system a bit.

To feel increasingly alienated by Tory voters?
XingMing · 10/08/2022 21:20

@BirmaBrite most of Labour's policy history since the 1970s was based on opposition to the EU.

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 21:19

Florenz · 10/08/2022 21:14

The whole "we don't have democracy because most people didn't vote Tory" argument is ridiculous. Even more people didn't vote Labour. Even more than that didn't vote Libdem. Labour need to stop making excuses and start winning elections, and if they don't win, accept that people weren't buying what they were selling, and adapt accordingly, instead of blaming everyone else except for themselves.

It’s not as simple as that. It’s that a Labour MP needs far more votes to get elected than a Tory one. A Green MP needs miles more votes. SNP MPs appear to be the easiest of all to elect. That isn’t right

XingMing · 10/08/2022 21:18

@awonderfuladventure I only read the Telegraph from your media list, and yes, I completely understand its political stance. But it provides a platform for large numbers of interesting thinkers to roll out their ideas in public. The Guardian does likewise from another political standpoint. I will make up my own mind, having read both perspectives, where my view lies, And I also read the Times, NYT, and occasionally bits of the FTT, the Economist and the Western Morning News. I am a social liberal, who doesn't believe in free lunches or free rides.

BirmaBrite · 10/08/2022 21:16

The whole reason why Labour now support brexit is because so many Labour supporters voted for it!

Do they 'support' it or do they accept it is now 'done' as in the UK has left the EU ? Because even if they did or didn't support it, that is where where we are now, we have left the EU.