Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel increasingly alienated by Tory voters?

358 replies

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 14:11

I am in despair as to where our country is at. With the cost of living crisis looming (and already beginning), this winter is going to be brutal and likely life ending for so many in the UK, and the current aspiring leadership of the Tory party seem to be more interested in litigating culture wars and appeasing NIMBY pensioners in the Home countries than actually addressing any of the serious problems in the UK.

I've never been a Tory voter, but I've always been able to get along with people who have different views (provided they aren't racist/homophobic etc). But how anyone could see all the misery and deprivation on the horizon, look at the prospective leaders and frontbenchers with their complete lack of sultions, and continue with supporting them is genuinely beyond me. I find myself slowly being consumed by bitterness and rage against people for their views, and it frightens me. Am I alone in this?

OP posts:
Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 12:37

There’s quite a move in Canada to reform the system. I don’t think many people would think that the US system was one to emulate.
There were complaints about FPTP throughout Labour’s term in office, so I don’t think your claims about the left are justified.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 12:28

OnlyEverAutumn · 11/08/2022 12:21

@ImWell do name me all the countries where FPTP works well? Not sure why you’re being deliberately obtuse but 🤷‍♀️.

UK, Canada, India, the USA.

Remember, we had a referendum on an alternative vote system, and it was roundly rejected. Complaints about our system seem to really only be heard when the left aren’t doing very well.

OnlyEverAutumn · 11/08/2022 12:21

@ImWell do name me all the countries where FPTP works well? Not sure why you’re being deliberately obtuse but 🤷‍♀️.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 12:10

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 12:07

YANBU

Times like this I'm grateful that I've never associated with or befriended a Tory voter in my life.

So don't have to deal with it irl when discussions arise

And how’s life in that echo chamber working out for you? Has it been a great way to change oriole’s views, get them to move over to your side, that sort of thing?

I suppose I shouldn’t joke, I’ve never knowingly employed a lefty, but they are unavoidable if you live a normal sort of life.

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 12:07

YANBU

Times like this I'm grateful that I've never associated with or befriended a Tory voter in my life.

So don't have to deal with it irl when discussions arise

ImWell · 11/08/2022 12:06

OnlyEverAutumn · 11/08/2022 12:03

@ImWell Italy is an utterly ludicrous example as I’m sure if you have even the tiniest grasp of the history of European politics you would know full well! 😄

Why not look at all the FUNCTIONING democracies that use PR and the fact that no new democracies look at FPTP and say “ooh that looks like a fab way to run a country”?! 🤦‍♀️

So if we only look at the countries where it works well then we’ll see it working well?

That’s true, but not really the best way to judge which system is best.

OnlyEverAutumn · 11/08/2022 12:03

@ImWell Italy is an utterly ludicrous example as I’m sure if you have even the tiniest grasp of the history of European politics you would know full well! 😄

Why not look at all the FUNCTIONING democracies that use PR and the fact that no new democracies look at FPTP and say “ooh that looks like a fab way to run a country”?! 🤦‍♀️

ImWell · 11/08/2022 11:54

OnlyEverAutumn · 11/08/2022 11:39

@Pinkandwhitestripes totally agree. The flip/flop governments we have in the UK do not work. Functioning democracies in N Europe all seem to make PR work and manage the smaller parties. There’s no argument for FPTP.

Italy’s a good example of what can happen under PR. Once parties don’t need to stay together to protect their vote share you can get a multitude of tiny parties and the inability to hold any functioning government together for long.

It’s been a bit better in recent years, but before that it was a real mess.

The in France we have PR for the presidency, requiring shenanigans behind the scenes to keep out the “wrong” parties from getting involved.

OnlyEverAutumn · 11/08/2022 11:39

@Pinkandwhitestripes totally agree. The flip/flop governments we have in the UK do not work. Functioning democracies in N Europe all seem to make PR work and manage the smaller parties. There’s no argument for FPTP.

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 11:37

well we had the sorry spectacle of May bunging public money to the DUP for their support to make up her government, so FPTP certainly doesn’t protect us from that.
by and large however coalition governments can work quite well and it would break the wretched two party system here, which has not worked well forva long time.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 07:49

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 01:33

Some votes are worth more than others under FPTP - that’s the problem. Under PR votes are much more equivalent. The doc posted above from the Electoral Reform system makes the difference quite clear. Yes, PR allowed UKIP a disproportionate number of MEPs in the European Parliament, but it was fairly done. So yes we’d see more of the smaller parties, but we should do. The Greens would see more MPs too.
There were a lot of complaints about FPTP under Labour and rightly so. It’s high time we adopted PR imho.

I don’t agree. Under PR the votes for a minority party that can carry the balance between forming a coalition or not are given disproportionate weight, as their party gets to hold far more influence than their vote share should.

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 01:59

OnlyEverAutumn · 11/08/2022 01:47

@DownNative you can’t compare PR and FTTP as the same forms of democracy - of course you won’t always get the government you want (that’s obvious) but a PR system gives you a much better chance of getting a truly representative government. FTTP is a terrible voting system and would never be adopted by any newly established democracy.

Absolutely.

OnlyEverAutumn · 11/08/2022 01:47

@DownNative you can’t compare PR and FTTP as the same forms of democracy - of course you won’t always get the government you want (that’s obvious) but a PR system gives you a much better chance of getting a truly representative government. FTTP is a terrible voting system and would never be adopted by any newly established democracy.

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 01:33

Some votes are worth more than others under FPTP - that’s the problem. Under PR votes are much more equivalent. The doc posted above from the Electoral Reform system makes the difference quite clear. Yes, PR allowed UKIP a disproportionate number of MEPs in the European Parliament, but it was fairly done. So yes we’d see more of the smaller parties, but we should do. The Greens would see more MPs too.
There were a lot of complaints about FPTP under Labour and rightly so. It’s high time we adopted PR imho.

UWhatNow · 11/08/2022 00:31

“I also personally don't think trans women should be considered men in law…”

And yet this is exactly what is happening by stealth - aided and abetted by some political parties - and still you think I’m ‘exaggerating’ and that it’s all just a storm on a teacup about ‘pronouns and toilets’?

Just ask the poor woman who was raped on a uk hospital ward and the hospital denied there was a male who could’ve done it because they’d willingly logged his gender as female and accepted him as such. Wow - what a great loophole for predators to get access to females in various states of extreme vulnerability. But yeah… it’s just the usual terfy exaggeration and something most people don’t give a shit about eh?

…Until you’re the vulnerable woman in hospital and people wave away your concerns…

LearnedAxolotl · 10/08/2022 23:42

"Nimby pensioners". So much ageism on Mumsnet.

DownNative · 10/08/2022 23:23

Florenz · 10/08/2022 22:45

People's votes do count. just because your chosen party doesn't win in your seat, doesn't mean your vote doesn't count. It counts exactly the same as everyone else's vote. It is up to the parties to have enough appeal in different areas to win. The Tories have a broader appeal, in that enough people grudgingly vote for them in enough seats for them to win. A lot more people enthusiastically vote for Labour but they tend to be concentrated in certain areas .

Labour need to stop being concerned about being on the right side of history and concentrate on being on the right side of now. There's no point at all in looking to the past and saying how much better things would've been, or in looking to the future and claiming that demographics are on their side. It's never going to be the future.

Yes, and a feature of democracy is that there is usually some individual or group who don't get the government they voted for.

Shetland has been held by the Lib Dems since 1999 yet the SNP govern them as did Labour before them.

Does this mean it's undemocratic since Shetland didn't vote for the SNP by majority?

Of course not.

The same holds true for UK wide General Elections in which either the Conservatives or Labour win.

Getting a government you or your constituency didn't vote for in FPTP and PR is a feature of democracy.

Each person has one vote equal to all others. That is democratic.

ImWell · 10/08/2022 23:18

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 22:16

True. It was 13.9. I was mistaken on that.
i know not everyone can vote, but a government with an 80 seat majority chosen by so small a segment of the population is not representative. That is why proportional representation is much more democratic, as it actually reflects what each vote stands for.
we are the only country in Europe apart from Belarus to depend entirely on FPTP. Other countries may have some element of it, but this is tempered by other voting systems.

It is absolutely representative. Each constituency returns the MP who received the most votes in that constituency.

I think that very few of those complaining now were also complaining when Tony Blair had a larger majority on a smaller vote share.

FOJN · 10/08/2022 23:15

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 22:29

True, but when you have so many people whose votes don’t count because of the system, then political apathy is encouraged and that is a huge problem in this country. I think it would be much healthier to adopt a system of PR as they do in Ireland, where every vote makes a difference. At the very least I’d like to see mandatory voting.

I think people object to FPTP if their preferred party isn't winning. I think people also think it gives the conservatives an advantage. I wonder how MN posters would have felt about PR in 2015 when UKIP got 3.8 million votes which was 12.6 % of the vote share, the third largest goes share, and translated into over 80 seats when they ended up with one.

If the table you posted had included UKIP they would have been at the top of the list for highest number of votes per elected MP.

ImWell · 10/08/2022 23:13

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 21:19

It’s not as simple as that. It’s that a Labour MP needs far more votes to get elected than a Tory one. A Green MP needs miles more votes. SNP MPs appear to be the easiest of all to elect. That isn’t right

This is not a systemic bias though, it’s a feature of a first past the post voting system.

One of the most egregious outliers of recent years was the UKIP return per vote. The party that wins tends to require fewer votes per MP than the parties who lose, but that’s a winner / loser bias, not a Tory / others one.

DownNative · 10/08/2022 23:09

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 22:29

True, but when you have so many people whose votes don’t count because of the system, then political apathy is encouraged and that is a huge problem in this country. I think it would be much healthier to adopt a system of PR as they do in Ireland, where every vote makes a difference. At the very least I’d like to see mandatory voting.

And yet the Republic of Ireland is just ONE place above the United Kingdom in the Democracy Matrix.

Just 0.006 points separates them.

The turnout in the Republic of Ireland GE was 62.9% in 2020 whereas it was 67.3% in the UK GE in 2019.

Voter apathy is clearly NOT solved by PR either, especially as there is other explanations for it than apathy with the electoral system of choice.

PR systems have their weaknesses just like FPTP systems do. There is no one size fits all as we can see around the world.

Just 22 countries have mandatory voting and roughly half of these don't even enforce it. Part of democracy is people can choose to vote or not rather than being compelled to do so by law.

AndreaC74 · 10/08/2022 23:07

XingMing · 10/08/2022 22:05

I don't think the union voice is stronger in Europe @BirmaBrite but the workforce is listened to for its ideas and trusted not to rock the boat without good reason. UK labour relations have always tended to be contentious and confrontational.

I've wondered this, is it because of poor management or our general adversarial way of doing things.. them n us, divorce, HoC's.. always confrontational.

Certainly in Sweden, employees seemed to have significantly more rights than anything i experienced working in the UK.

Or is it our obsession with class?

DownNative · 10/08/2022 22:50

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 22:16

True. It was 13.9. I was mistaken on that.
i know not everyone can vote, but a government with an 80 seat majority chosen by so small a segment of the population is not representative. That is why proportional representation is much more democratic, as it actually reflects what each vote stands for.
we are the only country in Europe apart from Belarus to depend entirely on FPTP. Other countries may have some element of it, but this is tempered by other voting systems.

You're confusing democracy with the concept of fairness. Democracy itself does not mean it equates to fairness - see the Lincoln quote.

Both FPTP and PR systems are democratic since the electorate consent to them. They're just different practices of democracy.

The UK does not depend entirely on FPTP as regional elections in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland all use differing forms of PR. At local level, London also has devolved powers and not dependent on FPTP either.

In practice, it is erroneous to assert that the UK is the only country in Europe to depend on FPTP excepting Belarus. Indeed, the UK is heads and shoulders above Belarus in the democracy stakes, so that kind of assertion seems more like exaggeration reliant on ignoring the aforementioned inconvenient facts.

The Democracy Matrix ranks the UK at 17th globally and 14th Europe. We are classed as a Working Democracy.

Belarus, on the other hand, is ranked 155th globally and is classed as a Moderate Autocracy.

So, your assertion by implication and inference that the UK is undemocratic like Belarus based on nothing more than using a democratic system such as FPTP simply falls flat on its face.

There is no comparison between the UK and Belarus here. Spurious correlations are easily made and pretty common, but are not inherently valid in themselves.

RayneDance · 10/08/2022 22:49

Op I feel so sorry for you and people who think like you..
I had my very hard times in the middle of a labour government and it was horrific. I'm ashamed to say I voted them in and they shat on me

We need to move beyond this thinking
.
What we need is a New political model that may have an MP at the top but then gets professional in to change things.

Florenz · 10/08/2022 22:45

People's votes do count. just because your chosen party doesn't win in your seat, doesn't mean your vote doesn't count. It counts exactly the same as everyone else's vote. It is up to the parties to have enough appeal in different areas to win. The Tories have a broader appeal, in that enough people grudgingly vote for them in enough seats for them to win. A lot more people enthusiastically vote for Labour but they tend to be concentrated in certain areas .

Labour need to stop being concerned about being on the right side of history and concentrate on being on the right side of now. There's no point at all in looking to the past and saying how much better things would've been, or in looking to the future and claiming that demographics are on their side. It's never going to be the future.