Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel increasingly alienated by Tory voters?

358 replies

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 14:11

I am in despair as to where our country is at. With the cost of living crisis looming (and already beginning), this winter is going to be brutal and likely life ending for so many in the UK, and the current aspiring leadership of the Tory party seem to be more interested in litigating culture wars and appeasing NIMBY pensioners in the Home countries than actually addressing any of the serious problems in the UK.

I've never been a Tory voter, but I've always been able to get along with people who have different views (provided they aren't racist/homophobic etc). But how anyone could see all the misery and deprivation on the horizon, look at the prospective leaders and frontbenchers with their complete lack of sultions, and continue with supporting them is genuinely beyond me. I find myself slowly being consumed by bitterness and rage against people for their views, and it frightens me. Am I alone in this?

OP posts:
Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 15:42

downnative - haha! I'm not in the least bothered about what you appreciate or don't in what I said about the DUP deal. We all know what happened and we all remember how the money was miraculously found within days of May claiming that there was no magic money tree. The money was found to enable her to stay in government. It was shoddy behaviour, made worse by her misleading the Queen.

As for the rest we've both articulated how we feel about FPTP and PR. I don't know why you deem it unserious, but it's of very little consequence. Don't know also why you seem to assume I'm not already campaigning - plenty of people are. I'm not going to be reporting back to you - what's the point? I know what you believe and you know what I believe. I don't think we're going to advance much further.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 15:30

AndreaC74 · 11/08/2022 15:20

Someone on 21k doesn't benefit from a MW rise, wages have been supressed, do you not remember 10 years of wage freezes and 1% pay rises? & private sector followed suit

Many of these folk are still at the bottom of the wage ladder and don't pay much tax.

The 45% came about after it was cut from 50% in 2013, std 40% has remained unchanged but the tories have frozen rates bringing more people into these higher rates, i'll give you that.

But a better run economy would mean a higher tax take and higher thresholds.

No, you are making no sense at all now. The minimum wage increases helped those on the bottom pay, by definition. If someone was not helped by the NMW increase then they were not at the bottom.

Come on, admit it, you have criticised them for something but hadn’t checked the numbers first.

AndreaC74 · 11/08/2022 15:20

ImWell · 11/08/2022 14:51

Well no, it shows that they increased the top rate of income tax to 45% and added 2% national insurance on top.

And how can you possibly claim that they have cut wages at the bottom when the national wage has increased so much faster than inflation? It’s clearly not true.

Someone on 21k doesn't benefit from a MW rise, wages have been supressed, do you not remember 10 years of wage freezes and 1% pay rises? & private sector followed suit

Many of these folk are still at the bottom of the wage ladder and don't pay much tax.

The 45% came about after it was cut from 50% in 2013, std 40% has remained unchanged but the tories have frozen rates bringing more people into these higher rates, i'll give you that.

But a better run economy would mean a higher tax take and higher thresholds.

DownNative · 11/08/2022 15:12

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 11:37

well we had the sorry spectacle of May bunging public money to the DUP for their support to make up her government, so FPTP certainly doesn’t protect us from that.
by and large however coalition governments can work quite well and it would break the wretched two party system here, which has not worked well forva long time.

May didn't "bung money to the DUP". The money was for Northern Ireland and NOT the DUP under the powersharing rules.

Since Stormont was mothballed by SF, civil servants allocated, distributed and spent the money in Northern Ireland on behalf of Stormont.

This is very democratic. In fact, a Supply Of Consent and Confidence deal like that also is done in PR systems. So, it is democratic and a feature of democratic systems in practice!

So, I don't appreciate your insinuation it's dodgy, wrong or illegal.

The UK is NOT and never has been a two party state. It is a multiparty state. The United States is a literal two party state.

Although Scotland uses a PR system, it is often referred to as a one party state. The reality there is that a minority party who cannot get elected DIRECTLY ends up wagging the SNP dog to get concessions that are NOT supported by a majority of the electorate.

So, PR is not always representative and neither is FPTP. There's pros and cons to both.

But I suspect you're just having an online whinge rather than wanting to seriously discuss PR v FPTP. You could always join a PR campaign, you know.....let us know how you get on.

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 15:01

Well if you looked at what I have said in my last few posts, I did say that both sides were engaging in divisive behaviour.
My point is that the government, who actually should be setting an example and offering a better tone, engages in divisive rhetoric.
No, I didn't see the thread you mention.
For what it's worth I know quite a few civil servants whose political views range across the whole spectrum. I don't think they are particularly left wing, but that really wasn't the point of what I was saying.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 14:57

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 14:54

Well that's just one tiny part of it i'mwell - there's all the other rhetoric from government about 'leftie lawyers', 'leftie civil servants' 'clamping down on woke nonsense' portraying universities as places that only encourage leftwing thought, as opposed to honing critical thinking skills. It's been going on for years - I haven't forgotten the Mail Headline 'Enemies of the People' referring to judges, which the Attorney General refused to condemn.
It's pretty bad faith to try to pretend it's just one issue.

You don’t think that civil servants tend to be to the left of the rest of society?

You haven’t seen the thread on here this week about academics conspiring to hound out anyone who would not repeat the left-wing shibboleth that trans women are women?

As for divisive, how about Rayner calling Conservatives scum?

ImWell · 11/08/2022 14:54

MarshaBradyo · 11/08/2022 13:06

Yep. There are many voters who have voted for them previously, whom they lost but could win back.

If only it wasn’t just insulting, or having a go at people and engaging with a more optimistic version of what they would offer.

Their supporters aren’t stupid, yet as shown here, they seem to have no interest at all in encouraging others to vote for them.

I literally can’t understand their thought process.

The conservatives, as you say, made huge gains in 2019, and the view of many on the left is to call all those ex-labour voters stupid, selfish racists.

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 14:54

Well that's just one tiny part of it i'mwell - there's all the other rhetoric from government about 'leftie lawyers', 'leftie civil servants' 'clamping down on woke nonsense' portraying universities as places that only encourage leftwing thought, as opposed to honing critical thinking skills. It's been going on for years - I haven't forgotten the Mail Headline 'Enemies of the People' referring to judges, which the Attorney General refused to condemn.
It's pretty bad faith to try to pretend it's just one issue.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 14:51

AndreaC74 · 11/08/2022 13:03

And yet higher earners are paying more under the Conservatives than under nearly all of Labour’s last time in government

Shows how badly they have run the economy & how they have cut wages at the bottom, so many don't earn enough to make any real income tax contribution.

Well no, it shows that they increased the top rate of income tax to 45% and added 2% national insurance on top.

And how can you possibly claim that they have cut wages at the bottom when the national wage has increased so much faster than inflation? It’s clearly not true.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 14:49

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 13:02

I think everyone in the country seems to be complaining i’m well. I think we seem to be incredibly polarised and divided. Yes, the left are complaining, but so are the right. Sick to death of the sneering comments about ‘woke’, ‘lefties’ ‘snowflakes’ and all the rest of it. But we have a government that has deliberately inflamed that. All this banging on about ‘woke’ issues at a time of national crisis.

It’s a reaction to Labour’s cast-iron commitment to allowing any man who’d like to go self-ID his way into women’s spaces, sports, prisons and refuges.

It’s not inflaming anything for the government to come out and plainly set out their stall to oppose this.

If Labour don’t want to be criticised for being enablers of abusive men then they need to stop enabling them.

DownNative · 11/08/2022 14:49

OnlyEverAutumn · 11/08/2022 01:47

@DownNative you can’t compare PR and FTTP as the same forms of democracy - of course you won’t always get the government you want (that’s obvious) but a PR system gives you a much better chance of getting a truly representative government. FTTP is a terrible voting system and would never be adopted by any newly established democracy.

If you read my comments more carefully, you'll find I wasn't comparing FPTP and PR as the SAME form of democracy.

On the contrary, I argued that both ARE democratic and they are also different ways of practicing democracy.

Your last line is simply your opinion and a purely hypothetical scenario in the rest of it. This is not a serious point backed by anything.

plainjane50 · 11/08/2022 14:19

Tory members = yes
Tory voters = no

MrsEdnaWelthorpe · 11/08/2022 13:39

HMSSophia · 10/08/2022 16:03

I used to care. I used to vote labour and try and do my bit to share my good fortune and make the UK a nicer fairer place to live in.

Now? Couldn't give a rats arse.

If the UK votes Tory again, then I am going to
A. Stop my voluntary work
B. Stop giving my employees above inflation pay rises
C. Stop giving my employees a profit share
D. Move abroad

Because the country will have shown me that it wants us to be selfish, greedy, and "me first", so that's what I'll become.

So if you don't get the government you want you're going to go out of your way to make the lives of people less well off than you even shitter?

Not a very good advert for the Labour party really- selfish and only interested in your own wellbeing. A bit like Tory voters are accused of being.

BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 13:16

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 13:02

I think everyone in the country seems to be complaining i’m well. I think we seem to be incredibly polarised and divided. Yes, the left are complaining, but so are the right. Sick to death of the sneering comments about ‘woke’, ‘lefties’ ‘snowflakes’ and all the rest of it. But we have a government that has deliberately inflamed that. All this banging on about ‘woke’ issues at a time of national crisis.

Absolutely, the Tory leadership are making fools of themselves banging on about being against 'woke' while people up and down the country are just trying to make an honest living in the face of a major crisis.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 11/08/2022 13:07

ImWell · 11/08/2022 12:41

Have you considered joining Labour? With that level of bigotry and ignorance you’d fit right in.

Haha they should - it’s the level these days

MarshaBradyo · 11/08/2022 13:06

ImWell · 11/08/2022 12:40

Do you think it’s mainly the left complaining now? I do. Incessantly.

Rather than whining on, they’d do far better trying to convince people to vote for their party. There’s an inbuilt bias towards Labour at the moment, due to the delayed boundary changes; if Labour can’t form a government under the current system then God help them.

Yep. There are many voters who have voted for them previously, whom they lost but could win back.

If only it wasn’t just insulting, or having a go at people and engaging with a more optimistic version of what they would offer.

Varoty · 11/08/2022 13:05

I’d love to vote Labour but unfortunately they told me and many other women to leave the party because we don’t believe that biological males can be women 🤷‍♀️

AndreaC74 · 11/08/2022 13:03

And yet higher earners are paying more under the Conservatives than under nearly all of Labour’s last time in government

Shows how badly they have run the economy & how they have cut wages at the bottom, so many don't earn enough to make any real income tax contribution.

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 13:02

I think everyone in the country seems to be complaining i’m well. I think we seem to be incredibly polarised and divided. Yes, the left are complaining, but so are the right. Sick to death of the sneering comments about ‘woke’, ‘lefties’ ‘snowflakes’ and all the rest of it. But we have a government that has deliberately inflamed that. All this banging on about ‘woke’ issues at a time of national crisis.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 12:54

Solonge · 11/08/2022 12:46

A lot of us feel like this. Tories seem to think the only thing that matters is tax cutting. They dont seem to understand that to live in a decent society, taxes are essential....high taxes are better. I have always believed I am lucky to live in a country where we pay decent taxes that provide care for the elderly, childcare for working parents, a great NHS....council houses, decent benefits for those that are disabled or unable to find employment. Then Margaret Thatcher was brought in as PM....she sold council houses...turning working class families against other working class families....who now perceive themselves are 'no longer working class as they own a property' the first time working classes were not supporting eachother, broke my heart. Now its all about selfish people looking after themselves...no care for others, self, self, self. Frankly ashamed to be British and now with Brexit...no chance of moving away because the cost of health cover for incomers too expensive. I feel your pain.

And yet higher earners are paying more under the Conservatives than under nearly all of Labour’s last time in government.

On the other side of the deal the minimum wage has increased far faster than inflation, as has the tax-free allowance, and higher earners have lost their tax benefits on pensions and have lost their tax-free allowance.

The narrative that the Conservatives are only about low taxes is not true.

Solonge · 11/08/2022 12:46

A lot of us feel like this. Tories seem to think the only thing that matters is tax cutting. They dont seem to understand that to live in a decent society, taxes are essential....high taxes are better. I have always believed I am lucky to live in a country where we pay decent taxes that provide care for the elderly, childcare for working parents, a great NHS....council houses, decent benefits for those that are disabled or unable to find employment. Then Margaret Thatcher was brought in as PM....she sold council houses...turning working class families against other working class families....who now perceive themselves are 'no longer working class as they own a property' the first time working classes were not supporting eachother, broke my heart. Now its all about selfish people looking after themselves...no care for others, self, self, self. Frankly ashamed to be British and now with Brexit...no chance of moving away because the cost of health cover for incomers too expensive. I feel your pain.

AndreaC74 · 11/08/2022 12:44

FOJN · 10/08/2022 23:15

I think people object to FPTP if their preferred party isn't winning. I think people also think it gives the conservatives an advantage. I wonder how MN posters would have felt about PR in 2015 when UKIP got 3.8 million votes which was 12.6 % of the vote share, the third largest goes share, and translated into over 80 seats when they ended up with one.

If the table you posted had included UKIP they would have been at the top of the list for highest number of votes per elected MP.

Nothing wrong with that, excluding people because you don't like their politics is hardly democratic is it?

One reason Brexit happened was Cameron's fear of losing seats to UKIP and people were supporting them because they felt their views on immigration were being ignored.

With Ukip having a voice in Parliament and therefore having their policies scrutinised, maybe they would have got less votes?

Arguing that you don't want PR in case fringe parties/voters have representation isn't really a good look from the right wingers on here.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 12:41

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 12:38

@ImWell

Why would anyone associate with people they deem devoid of any common sense or humanity?

As that's what Tory Voters are

As the saying goes they're either stupid, selfish or both

Have you considered joining Labour? With that level of bigotry and ignorance you’d fit right in.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 12:40

Pinkandwhitestripes · 11/08/2022 12:37

There’s quite a move in Canada to reform the system. I don’t think many people would think that the US system was one to emulate.
There were complaints about FPTP throughout Labour’s term in office, so I don’t think your claims about the left are justified.

Do you think it’s mainly the left complaining now? I do. Incessantly.

Rather than whining on, they’d do far better trying to convince people to vote for their party. There’s an inbuilt bias towards Labour at the moment, due to the delayed boundary changes; if Labour can’t form a government under the current system then God help them.

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 12:38

@ImWell

Why would anyone associate with people they deem devoid of any common sense or humanity?

As that's what Tory Voters are

As the saying goes they're either stupid, selfish or both