Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel increasingly alienated by Tory voters?

358 replies

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 14:11

I am in despair as to where our country is at. With the cost of living crisis looming (and already beginning), this winter is going to be brutal and likely life ending for so many in the UK, and the current aspiring leadership of the Tory party seem to be more interested in litigating culture wars and appeasing NIMBY pensioners in the Home countries than actually addressing any of the serious problems in the UK.

I've never been a Tory voter, but I've always been able to get along with people who have different views (provided they aren't racist/homophobic etc). But how anyone could see all the misery and deprivation on the horizon, look at the prospective leaders and frontbenchers with their complete lack of sultions, and continue with supporting them is genuinely beyond me. I find myself slowly being consumed by bitterness and rage against people for their views, and it frightens me. Am I alone in this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DownNative · 14/08/2022 16:01

Besides, it's all well off topic, @AndreaC74 . You have still been unable to show how it's undemocratic to exclude people and groups from the political process.

It's clearly not.

Good day to you!

DownNative · 14/08/2022 16:00

AndreaC74 · 14/08/2022 14:50

@DownNative Nope, "Actively supported" means one thing only, if he'd said "He Supported..." (which many of your examples go on about) then fair enough, i'd agree, its the Actively, that totally changes the meaning....

Aside, Don't know why you are so invested in something another poster said.

No, "actively supported" does not equate to aiding and abetting terrorism.

It is true Corbyn supported PSF/PIRA acts of terrorism. As did Abbott and McDonnell, so that was three very good reasons to keep them out of Government.

Adams and McGuinness liked having them involved in their Republican front pressure groups. But didn't trust them with actual details of their plans for murder.

AndreaC74 · 14/08/2022 14:50

@DownNative Nope, "Actively supported" means one thing only, if he'd said "He Supported..." (which many of your examples go on about) then fair enough, i'd agree, its the Actively, that totally changes the meaning....

Aside, Don't know why you are so invested in something another poster said.

DownNative · 14/08/2022 14:02

AndreaC74 · 13/08/2022 07:04

Well we obviously have a very different interpretation of the word "Support"

His complete post...

Well yes, he was. He actively supported their campaign of bombing in mainland Britain, and argued against those who though otherwise
I know that many people want to rewrite history, and pretend that he was some kind of “let’s bring people together” peacemaker, but he wasn’t; he supported only one side, the IRA

As i said, supporting a bombing campaign would be illegal, yet Corbyn was never charged ... so either the security services are inept or he didn't support bombings, numerous quotes where he said he condemned all violence.

Perhaps either you have evidence of this "active support"

No, you completely misunderstand the phrase "He actively supported their campaign of bombing in mainland Britain, and argued against those who though otherwise" @ImWell typed.

They clearly meant Corbyn was in favour of the Provisional Sinn Féin and Provisional IRA campaign of terrorism. In other words, he was in favour of it. This is not illegal itself.

See Labour's David Winnick's talking about how he argued AGAINST Corbyn that the Provos were NOT justified in their terrorism as well. It's just not an illegal act to argue you believe PSF/PIRA were justified even though they were not.

Abbott and McDonnell had the same view as Corbyn - they supported PSF/PIRA terrorism against the British State and the British people.

Had Corbyn's sympathising went as far as to actively aid and enable the Provos to carry out a bombing campaign....he'd have broken the law and been arrested.

As for how the Security Forces regarded Corbyn, this is common knowledge top in Northern Ireland, Westminster and Dublin Castle:

"I used to look at him when he used to visit Belfast in the 1980s, when he was running around with guys who had done some hortible things, and think: "who is this guy? What is he thinking coming here?" I think our colleagues in England would have been more concerned with his antics. They would have panicked at some of what he got up to."

And:

"He (Corbyn) was someone who was bringing these people (PSF/PIRA) just to put pressure on the government, as opposed to saying, "You need to get these people (PSF/PIRA) to stop the violence and then we can so business...that these people need to make a declaration of intent to say we are going to stop, and that wasn't coming from Jeremy Corbyn."

Corbyn also supported the Troops Out Movement which was a Republican/PSF/PIRA front group. The aims of this organisation was also delegitimised by the GFA. Troops Out Movement was really a pro-IRA movement aimed at convincing enough gullible, naive uninformed British people in Great Britain to pressure the UK Government to withdraw the British Army completely. Such a demand would NOT have led to peace, but to all out civil war in Northern Ireland. It's other aim of "self-determination for the Irish people as a whole" also clashes with the GFA which does NOT give this as it recognises Northern Ireland's people are the only ones who can make decisions for Northern Ireland's future.

Some Provos have since admitted they "just couldn't crack that nut" in turning the British people against the British Army and Ulster's British citizens.

Whichever way you turn, Corbyn, Abbott and McDonnell constantly supported the aims, agendas and methods of the Republican Movement aka Provisional Sinn Féin and Provisional IRA aka The Provos.

Supporting such dangerous terrorist organisations in this manner isn't illegal. But aiding and abetting terrorism is which is something they didn't do.

So, no, you continue to misrepresent what @ImWell actually said as you're not doing well in the debate at all.

One thing you will never find from Corbyn is a statement condemning PSF/PIRA violence UNEQUIVOCALLY. A genuine, reasonable and honest person would condemn any terrorism in strictly unequivocal terms when asked to do so. Corbyn never, ever dies.

I can condemn PSF/PIRA unequivocally in the same way I can condemn the PUP/UVF unequivocally. I do NOT under any circumstances need to qualify condemnation of PSF/PIRA with that of PUP/UVF - it's not necessary, but is something a supporter of each terrorist group actually does. 🤔

AndreaC74 · 13/08/2022 07:04

DownNative · 12/08/2022 21:15

And misinterpreted it completely....🤷‍♂️

Well we obviously have a very different interpretation of the word "Support"

His complete post...

Well yes, he was. He actively supported their campaign of bombing in mainland Britain, and argued against those who though otherwise
I know that many people want to rewrite history, and pretend that he was some kind of “let’s bring people together” peacemaker, but he wasn’t; he supported only one side, the IRA

As i said, supporting a bombing campaign would be illegal, yet Corbyn was never charged ... so either the security services are inept or he didn't support bombings, numerous quotes where he said he condemned all violence.

Perhaps either you have evidence of this "active support"

DownNative · 12/08/2022 21:15

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 21:03

FFS i cut n pasted his exact quote.

And misinterpreted it completely....🤷‍♂️

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 21:03

DownNative · 12/08/2022 19:57

@AndreaC74 why don’t you try quoting the actual post made by @ImWell if you think that's what they said?

They did not state that.

But there is a body of evidence Corbyn supported Provisional Sinn Féin and Provisional IRA. As did his buddies Diane Abbott and John McDonnell.

No wonder Corbyn, Abbott and McDonnell couldn't succeed in the 2019 election. When the then PSF President and PIRA Commander Gerry Adams publicly supported Corbyn, that was it. And it was the first time Adams ever publicly did so. The last time too. He couldn't get his useful idiot over the line.

FFS i cut n pasted his exact quote.

DownNative · 12/08/2022 20:37

ImWell · 12/08/2022 15:42

Dear God you are dishonest. He supported them as in wanted them to win, and said so, that was not illegal.

Anyone who can support him after the EHRC report, and his sick comments this week on Ukraine is not worth engaging with further. Thankfully you will never, ever get a UK government that goes along with views like yours.

Neil Kinnock kept Corbyn at arms length when he was leader of Labour and for very good reason. Kinnock was furious with Corbyn's sympathising of PSF/PIRA.

Labour's David Winnick had debates with Corbyn on this issue and he was appalled:

"Where he (Corbyn) differed was Ireland. "I strongly disagreed with the line he took. I constantly argued that there was no justification for the IRA. I thought he was wrong."

There's quite a few other notable individuals including some who were part of the Good Friday Agreement negotiations who've said the same thing.

Notably, Corbyn had zero involvement in the Good Friday Agreement which he only supported after PSF/PIRA had been militarily defeated in order to do to them what was done to the Official IRA in 1973....force them into politics and to give up terrorism.

It says a lot Corbyn opposed the Anglo-Irish Agreement peace process in 1985 which PSF/PIRA also opposed. This agreement went on to become a foundation of the GFA itself, so wasn't massively different.

In the Leaders TV debate ahead of the General Election, an audience member challenged Corbyn on attending a meeting at Loughgall in 1987.

Corbyn response: "The contribution I made to that meeting was to call for a peace and dialogue process in Northern Ireland."

The audience member informed Corbyn he was from Northern Ireland and it was public knowledge that Loughgall meeting in 1987 in London was ONLY about commemorating PIRA terrorists. And not all victims of the Troubles as Corbyn lied about. At no stage was that IRA meeting in Loughgall about a "call for peace and dialogue".

It was about commemorating PIRA terrorists who'd just blown up Loughgall RUC police station and nearly succeeded in murder. The SAS recovered from the huge blast enough to open fire and neutralise the PIRA terrorists in 10 minutes.

Silence came from Corbyn on that one. The truth was he'd been honouring them - his words on that night is below.

"'I'm happy to commemorate all those who died fighting for an independent Ireland'.” - Corbyn 1987

Ooft! Right after the Loughgall terrorists were neutralised by the SAS too. Bad optics.

Hey, at least he never became PM!

Florenz · 12/08/2022 20:26

When have the demographics ever not favoured Labour? Doesn't seem to help them very much.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 20:14

WorriedMutha · 12/08/2022 20:07

I personally consider anyone voting for the current Tory shit show to be lacking in a moral compass. The only light on the horizon of the sorry state the nation has been driven to is that the demographics favour Labour. The Tories are ageing and when we finally kick them out, they can languish in hell for a couple of decades. Your welcome.

Your poorly-written whine has been noted.

The demographics don’t support Labour, but whatever keeps you happy…

WorriedMutha · 12/08/2022 20:07

I personally consider anyone voting for the current Tory shit show to be lacking in a moral compass. The only light on the horizon of the sorry state the nation has been driven to is that the demographics favour Labour. The Tories are ageing and when we finally kick them out, they can languish in hell for a couple of decades. Your welcome.

DownNative · 12/08/2022 19:57

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 15:30

You said He actively supported their campaign of bombing in mainland Britain

that would have got him several years in jail.

Now you wish to take back that remark, good on you for realising you misspoke as they say.

@AndreaC74 why don’t you try quoting the actual post made by @ImWell if you think that's what they said?

They did not state that.

But there is a body of evidence Corbyn supported Provisional Sinn Féin and Provisional IRA. As did his buddies Diane Abbott and John McDonnell.

No wonder Corbyn, Abbott and McDonnell couldn't succeed in the 2019 election. When the then PSF President and PIRA Commander Gerry Adams publicly supported Corbyn, that was it. And it was the first time Adams ever publicly did so. The last time too. He couldn't get his useful idiot over the line.

DownNative · 12/08/2022 19:52

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 15:36

@DownNative I can't really see what you are arguing for, you switch between general points and specifics, when it suits your narrative.

Just because a referendum is lost, does not mean the winning side has to ignore the opposing side, thats a choice.
Good governance is bringing the opposing side with you.

This country would so much better off if leave and remain had worked together but May made that was not going to happen.

Plenty of other non coalition parties get into power at a future date, ROI isn't the only country to have coalitions.

On the contrary, I have made very valid points that undermine YOUR assertion that "...excluding people because you don't like their politics is hardly democratic is it?".

It is clearly NOT dishonest.

And this:

"Just because a referendum is lost, does not mean the winning side has to ignore the opposing side, thats a choice."

And yet it is common practice to ignore the dissenting opinion in order to implement the result.

The same happens in the aftermath of elections as we see all over Europe and the United States, for example.

That too is very much democratic.

And this from you:

"This country would so much better off if leave and remain had worked together but May made that was not going to happen."

May was trying to keep both Remain and Leave happy with her Brexit negotiations which pleased neither in the end. When it comes to implementing the results of referendums, it is not possible to give each side what they want, even in diluted form.

May wasn't trying to exclude any point of view. Her problem was you cannot serve two masters and democracy dictates ONE side must have their result implemented.

"Plenty of other non coalition parties get into power at a future date, ROI isn't the only country to have coalitions."

Hmm......was it not YOU who held up the Republic of Ireland's PR as an example for the UK to follow?!

Rather than accept that excluding both voters and parties IS a feature of democracy, you'd rather pretend it doesn't by making a generalised statement with no specifics?

Fine, but the point remains it IS democratic to exclude some voices and its a feature of democracy itself.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 15:42

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 15:30

You said He actively supported their campaign of bombing in mainland Britain

that would have got him several years in jail.

Now you wish to take back that remark, good on you for realising you misspoke as they say.

Dear God you are dishonest. He supported them as in wanted them to win, and said so, that was not illegal.

Anyone who can support him after the EHRC report, and his sick comments this week on Ukraine is not worth engaging with further. Thankfully you will never, ever get a UK government that goes along with views like yours.

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 15:36

@DownNative I can't really see what you are arguing for, you switch between general points and specifics, when it suits your narrative.

Just because a referendum is lost, does not mean the winning side has to ignore the opposing side, thats a choice.
Good governance is bringing the opposing side with you.

This country would so much better off if leave and remain had worked together but May made that was not going to happen.

Plenty of other non coalition parties get into power at a future date, ROI isn't the only country to have coalitions.

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 15:30

ImWell · 12/08/2022 12:54

What criminality? It was not illegal to hope that they won.

He was still saying he supported unification of the whole of Ireland in 2018, too.

He wanted Russia to be the ones to check the Russian chemical used to murder people in England, blames “the west” for the war in Ukraine, and publicly supported the antisemitic mural in London too.

The man is an abhorrent excuse for a human.

You said He actively supported their campaign of bombing in mainland Britain

that would have got him several years in jail.

Now you wish to take back that remark, good on you for realising you misspoke as they say.

Mischance · 12/08/2022 13:17

Justcallmebebes · 10/08/2022 14:20

These threads are getting really tiresome. The Tories have only been in for so long because they keep getting voted in by the majority of people. We live in a democracy which means the majority of people want them in. If they don't, they'll be voted out at the next election and then you will find that the alternative is just as bad, if not worse.

The opposition don't seem to have any real answers to the problems we're all facing either

I do not agree. In the first-past-the-post voting system a constituency can have an MP whom the majority of the constituents did not vote for.

If the opposing votes are split between several parties then the MP might not be in receipt of a majority.

DownNative · 12/08/2022 13:03

AndreaC74 · 11/08/2022 21:16

That doesn't make sense, most countries don't do referendums for starters and those that do, put in conditions, as do most organisations in the UK that wish to change their rules.
Cameron, being an idiot/tory (often the same thing) failed to do even basic research on his referendum.

PR allows the general pop. to have an MP, more or less whoever they vote for.

So i want the bigoted racist to have an MP so when he/she stands up in the commons and comes out with racist garbage we can all see and maybe even their voters can too?

With PR, just because a party fails to get into that years coalition, doesn't mean they never will.
Under FPTP, fringe parties never really have a say, 2010 excepted.

oh and just because something is Normal & Democratic, doesn't mean it cannot be improved upon.

"That doesn't make sense, most countries don't do referendums for starters and those that do, put in conditions, as do most organisations in the UK that wish to change their rules."

On the contrary, it DOES make sense since you argued that "excluding people because you don't like their politics is hardly democratic is it?"

It is a feature of democracy that various voices are excluded. Indeed, the UK Supreme Court ruling on who can conduct Brexit negotiations explicitly excluded the devolved administrations in Belfast, Cardiff and Edinburgh.

How exactly is it undemocratic to exclude voices?

In Europe, 48 different referendums have been held on different aspects of the EU. By definition, the losing voice is excluded from the implementation of the result.

"PR allows the general pop. to have an MP, more or less whoever they vote for."

And a government which brings me to:

"With PR, just because a party fails to get into that years coalition, doesn't mean they never will."

In the Irish Republic, democracy has spent decades keeping PSF/PIRA out of power which has its roots in the storming of the Irish Parliament in the early 20th century being taken over by masked gunmen and in PSF/PIRAs declaration in their green book the Republic is an illegitimate creation with an illegitimate government they must overthrow in order to govern the whole island themselves.

Hence, PSF/PIRA have yet to formally hold power in the Republic of Ireland.

This is normal AND democratic which destroys your assertion it's undemocratic to exclude the political voices you don't like.

"Under FPTP, fringe parties never really have a say, 2010 excepted."

Is it really desirable to have a fring party in government?

Not really and that's democratic too.

"...just because something is Normal & Democratic, doesn't mean it cannot be improved upon."

Perhaps, BUT that was not your assertion to which I responded which was this:

"...excluding people because you don't like their politics is hardly democratic is it?"

You're now engaging in a Shifting Goalpost Fallacy. Oh dear. First, accept your original assertion isn't valid and can't stand on its own two feet under scrutiny.

Then your new point could potentially be discussed.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 12:54

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 12:37

Why didn't he get arrested and charged for such criminality?

Of course Corbyn never supported the IRA and has consistently condemned violence in NI and GB, he also campaigned for people wrong convicted of terrorism.
He also supported the GFA.

www.channel4.com/news/factcheck/factcheck-corbyn-on-northern-ireland

What criminality? It was not illegal to hope that they won.

He was still saying he supported unification of the whole of Ireland in 2018, too.

He wanted Russia to be the ones to check the Russian chemical used to murder people in England, blames “the west” for the war in Ukraine, and publicly supported the antisemitic mural in London too.

The man is an abhorrent excuse for a human.

DownNative · 12/08/2022 12:45

BrokeAsABone · 12/08/2022 11:52

@DownNative so funny how you refer to Sinn Féin as Provisional Sinn Fein/Provisional IRA whilst not doing the same with the DUP, the incompetent political wing of the ACTIVE loyalist terrorists, the UVF. The DUP/UVF also formed the murderous Ulster Resistance. Considering the IRA have not been in existence for twenty five years yet it is the loyalist paramilitaries who are currently active with over 12,000 members and the LCC paramilitaries pull the strings of the DUP, I find your stance hilarious.😂😂

It's also funny to me that no Tory voter seemed to care that their party had a confidence and supply deal with a group heavily linked to and controlled by vicious loyalist paramilitary scum. But scum loyalists only targeted Irish lives so I guess that made it ok.🙄

Another fact to correct there is that the DUP aren't linked to the UVF.

The PUP is the political wing of the UVF. PUP = Progressive Unionist Party whose leader is Billy Hutchinson who justifies UVF murders in the same way SF/PIRA do.

Ulster Resistance was an absolute joke that only lasted a year.

And yet this has nothing to do with the point that PR does result in a party like PSF/PIRA being kept out of government!

DownNative · 12/08/2022 12:41

BrokeAsABone · 12/08/2022 11:56

I'd also like to remind people that Liz Truss and Brandon Lewis met some months ago with active loyalist terrorists who have been responsible for the loss of many innocent Irish lives and who hold their own communities in drug soaked fear.

But, but, but....Jeremy Corbyn was an IRA sympathiser, amirite?

They met the Loyalist Community Council which, I'm sure you recall was set up by the British and Irish Governments jointly.

Indeed, the Irish Government has met the Loyalist Community Council. Here's the fact on the Irish Government's own website:

www.dfa.ie/news-and-media/press-releases/press-release-archive/2019/june/statement-by-tanaiste-following-meeting-with-loyalist-communities-council-.php

I'd be more than happy with any party controlled by a terrorist group or has links with one being excluded from all forms of government. That's my personal view.

But democracy and democratically elected governments have decided otherwise. Your attempted Whataboutery simply falls flat given the context of democracy.

So....what exactly does this have to do with the fact that PR systems can result in a party winning most votes AND being shut out of government in a similar way to FPTP?

Nothing at all.

It would appear such criticism of FPTP to replace with PR on this specific basis wasn't thought through.

Was it?

Clearly NOT.

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 12:37

ImWell · 12/08/2022 12:15

Well yes, he was. He actively supported their campaign of bombing in mainland Britain, and argued against those who though otherwise.

I know that many people want to rewrite history, and pretend that he was some kind of “let’s bring people together” peacemaker, but he wasn’t; he supported only one side, the IRA.

Why didn't he get arrested and charged for such criminality?

Of course Corbyn never supported the IRA and has consistently condemned violence in NI and GB, he also campaigned for people wrong convicted of terrorism.
He also supported the GFA.

www.channel4.com/news/factcheck/factcheck-corbyn-on-northern-ireland

DownNative · 12/08/2022 12:34

BrokeAsABone · 12/08/2022 11:52

@DownNative so funny how you refer to Sinn Féin as Provisional Sinn Fein/Provisional IRA whilst not doing the same with the DUP, the incompetent political wing of the ACTIVE loyalist terrorists, the UVF. The DUP/UVF also formed the murderous Ulster Resistance. Considering the IRA have not been in existence for twenty five years yet it is the loyalist paramilitaries who are currently active with over 12,000 members and the LCC paramilitaries pull the strings of the DUP, I find your stance hilarious.😂😂

It's also funny to me that no Tory voter seemed to care that their party had a confidence and supply deal with a group heavily linked to and controlled by vicious loyalist paramilitary scum. But scum loyalists only targeted Irish lives so I guess that made it ok.🙄

Intelligence reports from PSNI, MI5 and the Republic of Ireland's Gardai all confirm Sinn Féin is still controlled by the Provisional Army Council.

And all confirm they still have access to weapons.

The DUP are completely irrelevant to the fact SF/PIRA were frozen out of government in the Republic of Ireland after the 2020 election there. Of course, Northern Ireland has mandatory coalition powersharing, so the DUP would never be relevant to the point about being frozen out of government.

You thought you had a point for a minute....🙄

ImWell · 12/08/2022 12:15

BrokeAsABone · 12/08/2022 11:56

I'd also like to remind people that Liz Truss and Brandon Lewis met some months ago with active loyalist terrorists who have been responsible for the loss of many innocent Irish lives and who hold their own communities in drug soaked fear.

But, but, but....Jeremy Corbyn was an IRA sympathiser, amirite?

Well yes, he was. He actively supported their campaign of bombing in mainland Britain, and argued against those who though otherwise.

I know that many people want to rewrite history, and pretend that he was some kind of “let’s bring people together” peacemaker, but he wasn’t; he supported only one side, the IRA.

Itisasecret · 12/08/2022 12:13

VladmirsPoutine · 11/08/2022 21:30

In my humble opinion the tories are poor-hating racist scum.

It’s a main stream party. Which means that in a democracy people can be legal members. You do realise comments like this basically fall under hate crime and malicious communications? Why do you think it’s ok to talk to people like that? If someone took offence to a comment like that you and mn wouldn’t have a leg to stand on.