Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just not want to be friends with this woman?

130 replies

Pckitin · 10/08/2022 13:27

My husband has children with his ex girlfriend, we have been together for 5 years now, married for 2 and I get on with DSC very well. They are 9 and 11. We also have DC together.

My husband's ex is okay... She's not the worst but there have been times when I've been a bit Hmm at the things she's done or said to DH. We've always been civil face to face and I've never spoken to her directly as I've not felt any need and seemingly neither has she until now.

My husband told me yesterday that she has requested my telephone number and suggested via him that maybe we should get together sometime for a drink.

I'm actually a bit taken aback as she's not really expressed any desire like this in the past. We've been civil as I say, we've had brief pleasant conversations at events like birthday parties or pick up but that's it.

I don't want to sound petty but my immediate response is no. Apparently the telephone number thing was said with the excuse that I look after DSC sometimes so she should be able to contact me. And the drink thing... Who knows the motivation.

Firstly, if there is a problem she can contact my husband who can contact me and secondly DSC has a phone so not really any need for her to need my number imo. I don't want this being open to requests or questions etc .. anything I do to help my husband out with childcare (not that regular) is between me and him and I've no desire to be contactable by her when she maybe needs something. I'm not part of their co parenting arrangements.

But most importantly, I just have no desire to be friends with this woman. I don't want to go for drinks or to discuss my life with her, the way things are now is fine with me. Everyone rubs along okay for the most part and, as I say, there have been times where I've found her behaviour questionable and she just isn't someone I want to be particularly friendly with.

What say you MN?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hapinthewood · 12/08/2022 08:46

I wouldn't have dreamed of trying to develop a friendship with my ex's new partner. One time she was buying suncream for their family holiday and asked my ex to message me to check the brand and factor were ok with me, which was very nice of her. But other than that, I don't need any contact.

billy1966 · 12/08/2022 08:29

aSofaNearYou · 11/08/2022 15:49

See this is how I feel but seems like the minority on this thread. I can understand blended family conflict and holding people at arms length when there is or has been drama and animosity. But assuming there's not massive backstory over bad behaviour, money conflicts, CF childcare behaviour etc, why wouldn't you want to be in a good social relationship with all the adults involved in your kids/stepkids lives.

From the parents POV, sure, but people need to understand that there is less incentive for the step parent to feel that way, especially when there are potential downsides (but even without them). I'm not that bothered about being close socially to the other adults involved in my step kids life. It's not high on my priorities.

Meanwhile I don't want to welcome messages (any really) from their mum into my life and I don't particularly want much contact with an ex of my DP's. It's not that hard to understand.

Agree with this.

@GengisK, completely disagree with you and your claim to have "every right".

How bizarre.

There isn't anyone you have every right to a relationship/conversation with.

Certainly not with the new partner of your ex partner, even if they are involved with your children.

You can work to foster a polite relationship with this person, but you have absolutely zero rights if they don't wish to engage with you.

I would run a mile from someone so controlling as to think my involved with their ex had them thinking they had ANY rights over me, or my time, even if there were children involved.

Also as an ex, you do NOT get to assign "co parenting" status on another person.

Very strange.

Many step parents have absolutely no wish to co parent, as is their right.

You can be involved in a childs life through a partner and have no part in co parenting them.

I have seen it done very successfully.

aSofaNearYou · 12/08/2022 08:16

Well said OP.

Pckitin · 12/08/2022 06:47

It's interesting the different ways people view things I guess because to me you just sound quite controlling GengisK.

I'd be immediately put off if my husband's ex was talking about having "every right to X Y Z". .

Your exes girlfriend is a person with just as much right as anyone to decide who she does and doesn't want to get to know. You don't get to override that just because you're a mother and I'd find it disrespectful and inconsiderate to have that repeatedly ignored.

DHs ex and I have already spoken before and it's already comfortable enough at family functions. I was not the OW, there was no air to clear in that respect and we've always been civil.

I don't want people I don't know around my children. Would you?

It's not up to you. Your ex is as much your child's parent as you are and you don't get to dictate who he does and doesn't have around your children. I could want to know all I like but that doesn't mean I have a right to demand it.

I do disagree about the co parenting thing. I'm not co parenting with her. At the most I guess I'm parenting with my DH when the DC are here but I'm certainly not in any sort of co parenting relationship with his ex where I'm required to discuss their care with her etc..

I agree she should have given you follow up info when your ex had an accident. I would have done in that situation.

I suppose technically if she really was so inclined, she could get my number off DSC.

OP posts:
GengisK · 12/08/2022 02:21

As a mother who has tried to even get on an acquaintance level with my ex-husband's girlfriend for three years, I absolutely find it to be unreasonable. I don't want to be her friend, but she IS apart of our co-parenting relationship because she's around my children. If it were the other way around and a man was involved in my children's life, I'd want him and my ex-husband to have an amicable relationship as well. If anything it's to be sure everyone is on the same page and feel comfortable at family functions.

You're around her children. She has every right to at least a conversation with you, if for no other reason than to feel comfortable with you as an influence on her children. It's disrespectful and inconsiderate to keep her at arms length like that.

My ex husbands girlfriend did a wonderful job of turning me away from feeling supportive and happy for their relationship to hating her. Three years and she couldn't sit down for coffee, instead choosing to block my number after verbally insulting me multiple times. I've been nothing but respectful and kind to this woman, even while she was treating me like dog poo, simply because I'm his ex wife. We recently had an emergency where he had to be taken to the hospital and admitted. You think communication will be fine until it isn't. She called me from a private number, which luckily I answered, and I had no way of getting follow up information for days. As if my children didn't need to know the condition of their father or what hospital he was even at. I have every reason to hate this woman for shacking up with my ex while we were still married, but ironically it's been me that encouraged their relationship and kept him in check when he was starting to screw it up. Her gifts? I pick those out. Her relationship with my kids? I keep them respectful and in check. 🙄

Whether you like it or not they and her by extension are your family. You are co-parenting their children if you're doing anything at all that involves them. The very least you can do is have a friendly conversation and her number for an emergency. What you are doing is straining that relationship with her and that will cause issues with their co-parenting eventually. I don't want people I don't know around my children. Would you?

Get over whatever weird feelings you have and be decent about it. Nobody needs to be involved with people who have children if they're going to cause problems with the other parent. You don't have to be her friend but you do need a working relationship.

aSofaNearYou · 11/08/2022 15:49

See this is how I feel but seems like the minority on this thread. I can understand blended family conflict and holding people at arms length when there is or has been drama and animosity. But assuming there's not massive backstory over bad behaviour, money conflicts, CF childcare behaviour etc, why wouldn't you want to be in a good social relationship with all the adults involved in your kids/stepkids lives.

From the parents POV, sure, but people need to understand that there is less incentive for the step parent to feel that way, especially when there are potential downsides (but even without them). I'm not that bothered about being close socially to the other adults involved in my step kids life. It's not high on my priorities.

Meanwhile I don't want to welcome messages (any really) from their mum into my life and I don't particularly want much contact with an ex of my DP's. It's not that hard to understand.

wordler · 11/08/2022 15:28

mycatisannoying · 11/08/2022 01:42

I feel a bit sorry for her! She probably just wants to get to know you a little and for the rapport to be good - for the benefit of the children - rather than pledge lifelong friendship.

See this is how I feel but seems like the minority on this thread. I can understand blended family conflict and holding people at arms length when there is or has been drama and animosity. But assuming there's not massive backstory over bad behaviour, money conflicts, CF childcare behaviour etc, why wouldn't you want to be in a good social relationship with all the adults involved in your kids/stepkids lives.

It's not going out for girls nights every week, it's checking in maybe once every few years, and it gives you a great base for easy-going relationships for all the joint occasions which come up over the years - big birthdays, weddings, christenings. And any sad or stressful issues - serious illness etc.

My SDs are now both in their 20s and started to want some of the big family occasions to have all of us there DH and me, their mother and her husband. It's nice for them to not have to choose which house to go to for Christmas occasionally for example. We can all have a nice time together every once in a while and it means the world to my DSDs.

CelestiaNoctis · 11/08/2022 01:53

Sounds perfectly reasonable of you. Sounds like you function great and there's no need to be friends. Is there a milestone birthday coming up or anything?

mycatisannoying · 11/08/2022 01:42

I feel a bit sorry for her! She probably just wants to get to know you a little and for the rapport to be good - for the benefit of the children - rather than pledge lifelong friendship.

Wannago · 11/08/2022 01:28

Would you be wanting the DSC to be making the call "Daddy has had a heart attack you need to pick us up urgently"

No obviously not but they have her number and I can get it from them or use their phone if necessary.

But that may mean negotiating with a panicking 9 or 11 year old to get their phone - or to ask them to do it/dictate the number while they are panicking. Or if they are not panicking and don't understand, explaining to them exactly why you need their phone without panicking them. Kids get very possessive about their phones. Will they listen to you in this kind of circumstance - especially if you are yourself pretty close to panicking? And of course if it is a car accident with DH and the DSC .... Presumably you know DH's password, but it might mean finding his phone and unlocking it, assuming not smashed.

I know these get more and more unlikely, and maybe this risk is worth to you given that it sounds like if you do exchange numbers you will have to set some pretty firm boundaries about use. Can you have the number (so you can ring her in an emergency) but block anything incoming?

SplendidUtterly · 10/08/2022 19:38

As someone else already said my mum didn't have my dad's new wife's number and they definitely weren't meeting up for cosy drinks. It's weird.

aSofaNearYou · 10/08/2022 19:21

I read her requests to DH as her realising as the kids get older your significant role in their life isn’t going to be limited to physical care - you’re going to be an influence on them and they re going to know and talk about you a fair bit. And so she may be thinking she should improve her relationship with you to better support her kids. That doesn’t necessarily mean being friends, just being friendly in the way you can be friendly with people at work whom you wouldn’t want to be friends with, or extended family members, or such. Something that allows for more fluid communication because of a shared concern and a better understanding of each other to facilitate the care of your DSC.

None of that is OPs problem, she's not a tool there to better serve the kids. She's her own person, she has plenty of reasons to not want to do this and she is entitled to put those above the wishy washy notion that this might vaguely benefit the kids.

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 10/08/2022 19:12

My dm and sm socialised together. Too bloody weird - don't do it op.
Oh and it wasn't genuine. Sm just wanted to know dm wasn't shagging df behind her back.

SemperIdem · 10/08/2022 19:00

It’d be a hard no from me too op

WibbleBibble · 10/08/2022 18:51

My mum never had a phone number for my dads new partner and there was never an issue. Id not get involved either op

C8H10N4O2 · 10/08/2022 18:46

Krakinou · 10/08/2022 18:20

@C8H10N4O2 she’s not able to contact the mother in emergencies though. She would have to use her husband’s or his children’s phones.

She is able to contact the ex through DH or the DC phones if needed. Its worked for them perfectly well for several years Perhaps the OP could have the ex's number but not the other way around if really necessary.

If the OP was claiming a relationship with the ex because of wanting to be involved in the children's arrangements or expecting the ex to be friends and have social arrangements then most answers here would be roasting her for her temerity. Similarly if a mother posted expecting her ex and current DH to be chums and be part of the parenting conglomerate she would be told that was her responsibility not the second husband's.

Stepmums here can't do right for doing wrong.

strawberry2017 · 10/08/2022 18:43

I feel like meeting up with her once can't hurt. I feel like by refusing you will cause more issues.

Badger1970 · 10/08/2022 18:35

She could just be reaching out for a whole host of reasons, and I think I'd be kind and offer direct contact but with boundaries in place as to what you're comfortable with.

Idontgiveashitanymore · 10/08/2022 18:30

I would say no!
tell your husband that she is his responsibility not yours.

Hereforaccountability · 10/08/2022 18:26

I'd say you're really busy with work or something at the moment, but let's swap numbers in case of emergencies, and leave it there.

Then if she has a specific concern she can call/message you directly, and if it turns out to be difficult and she wants to cause trouble then I guess you could block her.

We don't know her intentions, but you are in a blended family together. I suggest you compromise this way.

KettrickenSmiled · 10/08/2022 18:24

Krakinou · 10/08/2022 18:20

@C8H10N4O2 she’s not able to contact the mother in emergencies though. She would have to use her husband’s or his children’s phones.

The horror! having to use a different phone in this much-vaunted emergency!

It's been like this for 5 years & neither OP's husband or his ex have had an issue with it. As they're not bothered about it, I don't know why a bunch of strangers are.

Unless it's just a convenient stick to beat a stepmum with ...

NumberTheory · 10/08/2022 18:22

I get not wanting to be friends with her. But she hasn’t actually asked for that.

I read her requests to DH as her realising as the kids get older your significant role in their life isn’t going to be limited to physical care - you’re going to be an influence on them and they re going to know and talk about you a fair bit. And so she may be thinking she should improve her relationship with you to better support her kids. That doesn’t necessarily mean being friends, just being friendly in the way you can be friendly with people at work whom you wouldn’t want to be friends with, or extended family members, or such. Something that allows for more fluid communication because of a shared concern and a better understanding of each other to facilitate the care of your DSC.

Your concerns over being contacted and seen as a go-to for childcare issues is understandable and real, but you can put that boundary in place easily enough. If she’s been reasonable and civil up to now there’s no reason to think she’s suddenly going to become unreasonable because she has your phone number and you’ve seen her a few times without the kids. I think your immediate hostility is counterproductive to an easy life if she and your DH have a good co-parenting relationship and unlikely to be the best for the kids.

Krakinou · 10/08/2022 18:20

@C8H10N4O2 she’s not able to contact the mother in emergencies though. She would have to use her husband’s or his children’s phones.

sonjadog · 10/08/2022 18:14

As you know this woman and the way she has interacted with you and your husband for the last five years, I would listen to your hunch that she wants your number so she can badger you for childcare. If you feel you can't say no to giving it to her, then I would be prepared with a stock answer, "You will have to contact husband to discuss that" for every time she messages you about it.

C8H10N4O2 · 10/08/2022 18:12

ErmIDontKnow · 10/08/2022 18:06

I dont understand the contempt you seem to have for this woman. You come across really arrogant in your posts to be honest, very unpleasant

If you dont want her to have your number just say no. Didnt need a whole rant about her on mumsnet did it, post after post about why you dont want to give it to her.

Your all coparenting whether you like it or not, you dont have to be best friends with her but you definetly need to change your attitude about her

I'm glad my kids dont have a father because its women like you I'd worry about him ending up with

The OP made it perfectly clear that she has a perfectly civil relationship with the ex and is able to contact her in emergencies already. She simply doesn't want to be best friends beyond that and has already said exactly why.

Stepmothers can't do right for doing wrong. If they don't act as surrogate mothers and act as besties with the ex they are hard/cold/unpleasant, but if they form a bond with the DSC and get involved in the parenting relationship and arrangements they are usurping the mother's position.

Swipe left for the next trending thread