Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL is a snob

108 replies

wiltingrose · 10/08/2022 13:05

My MIL is a snob. And I am struggling to be around her.
I am from a normal lower middle class background, went to university, I had a student loan, and now have a great career.
My MIL looks down on people who have purchased "help-to-buy" properties, so much so that she wouldn't allow her own own daughter to purchase a flat in blocks where people had "help-2-buy" homes.
It's not only this, she makes other snide remarks as well.

I'm proud of what I've achieved. How do I keep MIL at arms length without causing damage between my DH and I. I get so annoyed that DH never calls her out on her out-of-touch comments. She boasts about what a liberal she is!
I want to limit visits to just xmas and easter. Has anyone managed to do this? and keep their marriage in tact?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IWentAwayIStayedAway · 11/08/2022 18:24

and oh god the thought of Xmas with someone you don't like. sounds difficult. im assuming it's a few days?

IWentAwayIStayedAway · 11/08/2022 18:23

why does dh have to tell her why you aren't there? that's on him. so for this weekend coming up can you be ill? he can tell them you're ill or your lying as you didn't want to go. his call

OhImVisiblyOver25 · 11/08/2022 18:08

Can you not just challenge them on it? I respectfully disagree with my PIL’s all the time. They are upper middle class, have never known struggle or hardship and have just bought a 4th house to air bnb in my hometown where the working class (like me) have been forced out of because all the second (and fourth!) home owners. Makes me fucking livid but they’re generally pleasant people and we tick along nicely.

notanothertakeaway · 11/08/2022 18:05

SleeplessInEngland · 11/08/2022 11:51

They absolutely will. Our granchildren will probably be horrified we ate meat. So it goes.

Perhaps a good reminder to go easy on people who have been brought up to think one way and can't conceive of another.

@SleeplessInEngland And that we thought it was acceptable to fly, or smoke, or drink alcohol, So many issues on which views change over time

sunglassesonthetable · 11/08/2022 13:03

*They absolutely will. Our granchildren will probably be horrified we ate meat. So it goes.

Perhaps a good reminder to go easy on people who have been brought up to think one way and can't conceive of another.*

I know some lovely people who hold different views on things to me.

Personally I don't think it's the opinions per se in this situation. I think the MiL's opinions are a bit of a red herring to the fact that she is a control freak who as OP says doesn't seem to like her. The snobbish opinions just add fuel to that fire.

HoppingPavlova · 11/08/2022 11:52

I get so annoyed that DH never calls her out on her out-of-touch comments.

Thats unreasonable. It’s not his role. Both my parents and DHs parents were racist, homophobic and everything else, essentially a product of their generation and upbringing. While we certainly didn’t share these views what’s the point ‘calling them out on it’ when people are set in their ways! We just explained to the kids (when young) they old peoples brains got very confused and said silly things that were not true. Obviously when the kids grew up they understood the situation. They loved their grandparents but appreciated their shortcomings (recognising the basis for it).

SleeplessInEngland · 11/08/2022 11:51

notanothertakeaway · 11/08/2022 08:40

So many threads where people have poor relationships with in laws who have outdated / unacceptable views. It's sad for all involved

I sometimes wonder if, in future, our children / grandchildren will roll their eyes at some of our attitudes eg if future society totally buys into trans ideology, will our generation be on the wrong side of history, horrifying younger family members with our attitudes

They absolutely will. Our granchildren will probably be horrified we ate meat. So it goes.

Perhaps a good reminder to go easy on people who have been brought up to think one way and can't conceive of another.

TeenageDirtbaggage · 11/08/2022 11:48

Help to Buy seems a weird thing to be snobby about. We used it 8 years ago, paid back the loan when we next remortgaged and the house is now worth £800k. Hardly hoi polloi status, I would have thought!

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 11:42

Are you sure it's help to buy she has issue with not shared ownership

As any new build could be done under help to buy

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 11/08/2022 09:57

Are you two even compatible? Are you going to end up wasting years of your prime just to inevitably end up divorced?

Imthedamnfoolwhoshothim · 11/08/2022 09:53

"DH you're mums a
cunt and as I didn't exit her body I have no need to ever see or speak to her again. Do what you want freely but I will never have anything to do with her again."

No Penis is ever good enough to deal with an awful MIL.

Grimchmas · 11/08/2022 09:06

Yep, get yourself a good therapist, one who wants to help you work towards not giving a shit.

DH says we are couple and we need to be a united front.

Just because DH says it, doesn't make it true. You are finding his mother extremely stressful to spend time with. He is not finding her that bad. This is inherently a difference and not "a united front." Side note: that phrase is generally used to mean two people standing up to somebody together, not in the way he is saying it, which is "please shut up and be a good little stepford wife". I find his attitude quite horrendous actually.

And if I'm not there he would need to tell them why I'm not coming to stuff.

So what? "DW can't come today because <benign excuse you have agreed beforehand>." Job done, no drama needed.

So I feel like I'm "locked" in.

You feel like you're locked in. The reality is you are free to do as you like. Take this to your therapist :)


He makes me go to other events with his friends as well, which I don't like.

Take this to your therapist too. Your H can't make you do anything, unless he's physically manhandling or threatening physical harm to you if you don't. If that's the case, you've got even bigger issues that you also need to talk to your therapist about.

But all his friends are quite public school in a caricature sort of way, and I don't find we have a lot of common ground.

I really do think it sounds like your H is from a background where women are not people in their own right but trophies to decorate his arm with to fit in with what mummy and daddy and his public school mates expect. I'd hate spending time with them too. The good news is that you don't have to. The bad news is that you appear to have stumbled upon the news that your H doesn't see you as an equal who has her own autonomy.

He says he hates going to stuff alone.

And you hate going to stuff that involves his mother or his mates. But he expects you to shut up and play along doesn't he? Because he sees his desire to not be uncomfortable as more important than your desire to not be uncomfortable. That's not equal, and that's not fair.

There is a middle ground compromise to be found, but you're going to need to do the work (in therapy or otherwise) to a) let MIL and public school boys wash over you, and b) learn how to stand up for your rights and what you want in your marriage, and c) recognise and be okay with a period of things being a bit uncomfortable as you start asserting yourself and your H/MIL/all sorts of other people will push back to try to keep you in the neat little box you have been conveniently sitting in. It takes tenacity, strong will and a willingness to let other people and yourself be uncomfortable to change status quo dynamics, but the rewards are there to be had for those who put the effort in.

Incidently, you also mention being very busy in a high stress job. Your overall stress burden will be contributing to how much your MIL stresses you out. If you prioritise relaxation and rest as a non-negotiable essential part of your life, everything is easier to deal with, I promise.

sunglassesonthetable · 11/08/2022 08:54

But have we met any of the other posters on MN?
Perhaps people ask questions because they want other people’s ideas/opinions? Or do you think MN should just be an echo chamber?

Give me a break. There is a massive difference between an echo chamber and talking crap.

Fairyliz · 11/08/2022 08:49

sunglassesonthetable · 11/08/2022 08:17

Perhaps you don’t like get because you are too similar? They always say men marry their mothers.

What complete arse. What exactly does this bring to a conversation about people you've never met?

@sunglassesonthetable
But have we met any of the other posters on MN?
Perhaps people ask questions because they want other people’s ideas/opinions? Or do you think MN should just be an echo chamber?

notanothertakeaway · 11/08/2022 08:40

So many threads where people have poor relationships with in laws who have outdated / unacceptable views. It's sad for all involved

I sometimes wonder if, in future, our children / grandchildren will roll their eyes at some of our attitudes eg if future society totally buys into trans ideology, will our generation be on the wrong side of history, horrifying younger family members with our attitudes

MintJulia · 11/08/2022 08:31

My ex-MIL had a problem with women who worked - she used to invite me to bridge or whatever and then say 'oh, yes, you work, don't you.' as if it was shop lifting.

I'd always bat it back, saying 'Yup, I contribute to GDP, great isn't it.' smile and wander off.

The only thing you can do is show you really aren't bothered what she thinks, that her views are irrelevant to you. And spend as little time with her as possible. If she comes to your house, always be very busy cooking or gardening or dealing with something so you don't have time to talk to her. Leave her to your DH. She's his problem, not yours.

Martinisarebetterdirty · 11/08/2022 08:26

I think you have a DH problem here. He is the one making you feel locked in to seeing her and his friends, when clearly you don’t want to. Just tell him no that may work for you but it doesn’t for me and I am equal in this. If you need to compromise go every other time. I do think it’s your husband causing the problem here, I rarely see my MIL, sure DP would like me to go more but we have no interest in each other so I don’t go.

sunglassesonthetable · 11/08/2022 08:17

Perhaps you don’t like get because you are too similar? They always say men marry their mothers.

What complete arse. What exactly does this bring to a conversation about people you've never met?

Fairyliz · 11/08/2022 08:13

I can’t believe the number of posters saying to not see her based on a few silly comments. I disagree with her about help to buy, but realistically how often do you talk about this?
Based on your post you sound just as much of a snob. Making sure we know you are middle class not a ‘chavvy’ working class person. Of course you have an education and a good job not like those lazy work shy thicko’s.
Perhaps you don’t like get because you are too similar? They always say men marry their mothers.

Adversity · 11/08/2022 08:09

DH Mother is a misogynist she also has a belief system that I do not share, not a religion by the way and is very particular.

I have let her negative traits in my eyes wash over me for almost 30 years and deep down I pity her. She can hold a very decent conversation though her opinions are almost always the opposite to mine, her finishing school did a good job in that respect. His sister even now in middle age gets in to situations that are ridiculous she does share similar opinions with me but conversations with her are tedious beyond belief.

The world would be extremely dull if we all agreed. Accept that it’s ok to not like someone. This also includes people not liking you.

Thisbastardcomputer · 11/08/2022 08:04

I have your problem in reverse, my daughter in law sees me as a total snob. My Mother was an opinionated snob and I very much kicked against it.

We were brought up in completely different circumstances, which gives us different views on life.

I don't give opinions on anything to her or my son, I help them financially now and again.

I'm low contact with them, they had their first baby last year which was very premature, I kept in touch and visited more often during this period but more often was once a month for a couple of hours.

I've noticed her attitude is growing towards me again, so I don't message or visit regularly, which is a shame but you can't mix chalk and cheese.

BoxOfCats · 11/08/2022 07:34

Your DH is being ridiculous. You're not joined at the hip. I just had a weekend visiting my family, DP of ten years stayed home to feed the cats. He's overthinking it that he would have to explain your absence, it's perfectly fine for him to say you were busy or it wasn't a convenient day for you to come!

Holly60 · 10/08/2022 21:59

@wiltingrose bless you I'm sure I'd love to be your MIL to :)

From your update- if you feel she is not very to YOU and that she doesn't like you, and it's affecting you, of course you have the right to not see her.

It's one thing to have a view point on something, it's another to be unkind to/about someone.

CheGuevaraandDebussy · 10/08/2022 17:56

Bodice · 10/08/2022 13:35

Your seriously suggesting your DH sees his mum less because she has some different views on life. Do you have sons of your own. I hope for your sake they marry women that are exactly the same as you.

Your (sic) seriously suggesting "I would never suggest to my DH to limit contact." means "seriously suggesting your DH sees his mum less because she has some different views on life" Do you have children of your own. I hope for your sake they learn how to comprehend plain English.

Ponderingwindow · 10/08/2022 17:22

You can’t go through life arguing with every relative over every thing you disagree with them on. She is entitled to have views you don’t like. She is even entitled to have views that are offensive.

you have to decide your limits. My limit is exposing my child to racism or sexism. If you express those views in front of my child or engage in behaviors that reinforce those views, I will call them out. If the problem continues, we will leave. My family got their act together surprisingly quickly.

the rest of it, I have to let it go. Sometimes my husband and I commiserate in the car on the way home.