Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are preschools allowed to reject children because they are not toilet trained?

66 replies

BenjiLove · 10/08/2022 12:42

Just that really. My DS was toilet trained for 6 weeks or so - but has regressed & is now having accidents and wanting his nappies back again.

DS is due to start preschool in Sep. The preschool is Ofsted registered (the rest of the school is private) - as it's an early years provider and has the free hours.

Anyway - in the contract it says children must be fully toilet trained, if they're not, can be removed and not even given deposit back.

It also says they can reject children if they are have SEN or are challenging and it affects others.

Surely if they're ofsted registered they need to be more inclusive than this?

I was so impressed with the facilities and the preschool staff I met, and DS's current nursery is falling apart (no staff, having to close for random days) , so keen for the move - but starting to panic I've been seduced by the fancy stuff and it's not particularly welcoming or inclusive??

OP posts:
Marvellousmadness · 10/08/2022 15:57

Whatever you do

Do NOT put him back in nappies
He has turned 3 you said. Recently. So he is old enough to be potty trained. Just because he regressed doesn't mean this will last weeks/months. Try different ways to encourage him.

But honestly: If I ran a kindy i would ban the non potty trained kids too . Imagine 30 kids that wee them selves several times throughout the day. You cant really blame them can you...

TiddleyWink · 10/08/2022 15:57

BeanieTeen · 10/08/2022 13:41

Surely ratios should be set to ensure the kids’ needs can be met. Not pushing kids to act more advanced than they are in order to allow for higher ratios?!

But children aren’t expected to act more advanced. Generally it’s expected that 9 out of 10 children are toilet trained by the age of 3 - it says this on the NHS website - and of course within the ‘9’ that accounts for the occasional accident, that’s normal and shouldn’t be a problem.
In a pre-school class of 30, having 3 children in nappies shouldn’t be an issue.
But I think in the last few years ‘1 out of 10’ still in nappies at the age of three has become far from the reality. It’s much more than that. And that makes things difficult.

I agree that most kids can be reasonably reliably potty trained before age 3. Mine absolutely were. But refusing any help with wiping so that a three year old walks around basically soiled until home time is heartbreaking. See PP. I maintain that I don’t believe a pre school is the right place for many three year olds if they expect basically entirely reliable potty training and totally independent wiping. An environment where three year olds are entirely responsible for independent toileting is absolutely in my view, pushing them to be more independent/advanced than is suitable for the vast majority. There is a big spectrum between basically potty trained and suited to an environment with zero help! It’s not babying them to expect that three year olds will have accidents and need help quite regularly, which PPs have said isn’t accommodated at their pre schools. I find that inappropriate and sad.

SleepingStandingUp · 10/08/2022 15:50

DS went to a state school nursery, they obv loved them trained but had a dedicated changing space so understood it didn't always happen. They did prefer pull ups once they were 4 if still not dry so they could do more of it themselves but never refused to help, never sent ak I'd home smeared in poo or called a parent to change a nappy like some of my friends school did.

Hopefully my twins will be dry by 3 when they start there but at least I'm not panicking about us being basically victimised for failing at patenting if not

SleepingStandingUp · 10/08/2022 15:47

2) if you child has SEN we may not be able to accommodate that, if you don't disclose any SEN before your child starts we can take the place away with immediate affect honestly there is No chance I'd want my kids here. I know you said your desperate as you need to work etc but I'd be working out the cancellation clause and looking for anything else. Lots of people don't know their kid has SEN at 3 and they're going to kick you out if yours does, or regresses and has too many toilet accidents??

picklemewalnuts · 10/08/2022 15:32

Be careful with accidentally pressuring him 'because, big boy school'.
Mine was a bit slower managing, and I reminded him the teachers wouldn't be able to help him... as a result he had his first accident in ages from trying not to go at school.

Basically they like them to be trained, know there will always be occasional accidents, and can't manage regular accidents because of staffing ratios.

Chooksnroses · 10/08/2022 15:26

Aria2015 · 10/08/2022 12:47

I think they can. At my son's preschool they had the same rule. I had to potty train him early because he's summer born and so was only just 3 when he started. He was toilet trained by the time he started, but he struggled to pull up his pants and trousers / shorts and they were always getting on at me about it! Telling me they don't have the time and resource to help him and I needed to work on it at home (I was!!). They also wouldn't help with wiping at all so he would get in a mess if he pooped when he was there and he ended up holding it in until he got home because he found it stressful. I spoke to lots of friends who had had similar experiences at their preschools too so unfortunately it seems to be the norm in a lot of places ☹️.

Imagine the outcry if this was old people we were talking about? Where is the dignity and respect in allowing a child to remain soiled because he cannot yet manage to wipe himself efficiently? I speak as an ex childminder, foster carer and nursery nurse. If you work with young children in any capacity you should expect to have to help with personal care sometimes.

x2boys · 10/08/2022 15:25

BenjiLove · 10/08/2022 14:37

@redYellowandblue Yes - they receive funding from the LA.

Right, well I'll be supporting my DS to be as confident as possible by September start but if they kick up a fuss if he has accidents or needs help - then I know where we stand & that they can't just say they won't accept him. He's only just turned 3. Some days are absolutely fine, but others he wees anywhere and everywhere.

I would keep him at the current nursery but their staff issues have got so bad that they are starting to close on random days & they seem so so stretched. And there there is no way of getting another place anywhere in time for Sep. To be honest, the preschool was lovely and the kids were all having lots and lots of fun when I went to look round - but the contract they've sent me and communications with them over the summer is like something from the victorian era.

Honestly he might be fine my oldest who has no disabilities, was three years and two months when it finally clicked ww had been training him from two and a half some children just take a bit longer and its not uncommon for three year old to have accidents ,my youngest child who has severe autism was a who different matter but that's s different scenario.

CryCeratops · 10/08/2022 15:22

I’m surprised to hear people saying it’s ok or normal for preschools to exclude children who aren’t toilet trained.

When I was looking at pre-schools for DC - a preschool attached to a primary school rather than a nursery - he wasn’t yet toilet trained.

I mentioned that to the teacher in charge, and they told me that they weren’t legally allowed to refuse children who aren’t toilet trained.

As it turned out, DC had cracked toilet training by the time he started, so it wasn’t an issue for us in the end.
But in the meantime it was a relief to know that he’d still be allowed into preschool if he did struggle to get the hang of toileting.

BenjiLove · 10/08/2022 14:37

@redYellowandblue Yes - they receive funding from the LA.

Right, well I'll be supporting my DS to be as confident as possible by September start but if they kick up a fuss if he has accidents or needs help - then I know where we stand & that they can't just say they won't accept him. He's only just turned 3. Some days are absolutely fine, but others he wees anywhere and everywhere.

I would keep him at the current nursery but their staff issues have got so bad that they are starting to close on random days & they seem so so stretched. And there there is no way of getting another place anywhere in time for Sep. To be honest, the preschool was lovely and the kids were all having lots and lots of fun when I went to look round - but the contract they've sent me and communications with them over the summer is like something from the victorian era.

OP posts:
KrisAkabusi · 10/08/2022 14:32
  1. if your child endangers other children we can remove them without a months notice 2) if you child has SEN we may not be able to accommodate that, if you don't disclose any SEN before your child starts we can take the place away with immediate affect.

I think these are reasonable clauses to be honest. They're not saying they don't accept SEN children, they're saying that you must let them know if your child has additional needs. You can't just rock up on day 1 without having informed them as that doesn't give them the chance to put any additional supports required in place.

Comefromaway · 10/08/2022 14:31

well I didbn't disclose any SEN when both of my children started th nursery at a private school because at that point we had no idea! Things can manifest at any time.

Cuck00soup · 10/08/2022 14:29

there are two clauses 1) if your child endangers other children we can remove them without a months notice 2) if you child has SEN we may not be able to accommodate that, if you don't disclose any SEN before your child starts we can take the place away with immediate affect.

Is may doing some heavy lifting here?

Does it mean they would consider the individual child and their needs?

redYellowandblue · 10/08/2022 14:23

If they receive 3 and 4 year old funding from the LA they cannot refuse a child who is not toilet trained.

It is the same for any funded provider and the rule has been in place for at least 16 years.

Orangesare · 10/08/2022 13:57

Lots of preschools where I live (only a few nurseries) and none of them exclude children in nappies. Most of the preschool take two year olds so that’s probably why. I do know of one school nursery that doesn’t like to take children in nappies.

Goldbar · 10/08/2022 13:57

TiddleyWink · 10/08/2022 13:28

One of the reasons I personally think that a good nursery is better than pre school. We send children to school early enough as it is in the Uk, why push to get them into a school type environment at age 3?! The very fact that they won’t deal with issues that are very, very normal for kids of that age means that to me they’re not a very appropriate environment.

Some people who go for pre schools criticise nurseries for not doing enough on the education/school prep side, but a good one will. Our nursery is ofsted outstanding and does amazing work to get the kids school ready, my son had zero issues transitioning and had been doing lots of early phonics type stuff with the staff (play based) because he was interested and ready. But, he was also in a nurturing environment where he got hugs and help wiping his little bottom if he still needed!

Completely agree. I hope things work out for the OP and her DS before September but I would not have wanted to potty train before my DC was ready or have it be a source of stress. And for us, that was when DC was 3 years 2 months to around 3 and a half for being completely confident.

Even at reception level, toileting accidents are very common amongst new starters and I'd expect any decent school to deal with them discreetly, competently and without excessive fuss to parents.

newnamenellie · 10/08/2022 13:49

I’m a pre school teacher.

No, we cannot exclude children who are not potty trained.

BeanieTeen · 10/08/2022 13:41

Surely ratios should be set to ensure the kids’ needs can be met. Not pushing kids to act more advanced than they are in order to allow for higher ratios?!

But children aren’t expected to act more advanced. Generally it’s expected that 9 out of 10 children are toilet trained by the age of 3 - it says this on the NHS website - and of course within the ‘9’ that accounts for the occasional accident, that’s normal and shouldn’t be a problem.
In a pre-school class of 30, having 3 children in nappies shouldn’t be an issue.
But I think in the last few years ‘1 out of 10’ still in nappies at the age of three has become far from the reality. It’s much more than that. And that makes things difficult.

WhatIsModeration · 10/08/2022 13:34

Aria2015 · 10/08/2022 12:47

I think they can. At my son's preschool they had the same rule. I had to potty train him early because he's summer born and so was only just 3 when he started. He was toilet trained by the time he started, but he struggled to pull up his pants and trousers / shorts and they were always getting on at me about it! Telling me they don't have the time and resource to help him and I needed to work on it at home (I was!!). They also wouldn't help with wiping at all so he would get in a mess if he pooped when he was there and he ended up holding it in until he got home because he found it stressful. I spoke to lots of friends who had had similar experiences at their preschools too so unfortunately it seems to be the norm in a lot of places ☹️.

That's absolutely shocking! What a disgusting way to treat little kids that need help 😡 Your poor boy 😔

TiddleyWink · 10/08/2022 13:31

Also surely the fact that ratios don’t allow for the staff to meet the normal basic needs of three year olds means that something isn’t quite right with the pre school set up? Surely ratios should be set to ensure the kids’ needs can be met. Not pushing kids to act more advanced than they are in order to allow for higher ratios?! Honestly, find a good nursery if you can and leave school until reception, by which time potty training is highly likely to be done and dusted. Pushing kids before they’re ready in order to convenience adults is never going to end well.

Rosehugger · 10/08/2022 13:30

I think it's absolutely fucking outrageous for a nursery to say that when they accept children from age 2. Don't care about having enough staff, obviously at 2 or 3 or older there will always be a number of kids who are not secure with using the toilet - particularly at the start when things are unfamiliar, and nurseries either need to have enough staff or don't operate at all.

TiddleyWink · 10/08/2022 13:28

One of the reasons I personally think that a good nursery is better than pre school. We send children to school early enough as it is in the Uk, why push to get them into a school type environment at age 3?! The very fact that they won’t deal with issues that are very, very normal for kids of that age means that to me they’re not a very appropriate environment.

Some people who go for pre schools criticise nurseries for not doing enough on the education/school prep side, but a good one will. Our nursery is ofsted outstanding and does amazing work to get the kids school ready, my son had zero issues transitioning and had been doing lots of early phonics type stuff with the staff (play based) because he was interested and ready. But, he was also in a nurturing environment where he got hugs and help wiping his little bottom if he still needed!

DappledThings · 10/08/2022 13:19

I'd choose a nursery that goes up to school age rather than a school attached one.

DC2 was fully toilet trained at 2.5. DC2 needed help past 6 so even once he started actual school because of chronic constipation and knock-on effects. His nursery/pre-school were absolutely fine about it and worked with us to help him make progress.

This school's attitude sounds awful all round.

modgepodge · 10/08/2022 13:18

No idea of the legalities (I’m under the impression they can’t legally refuse if not toilet trained but I don’t know for sure) but from the point of view of the pre school - the ratio of children to teachers is 1:13 if the teacher is qualified. I can only imagine attempting to teach (not just care for) 13 small children whilst also trying to change nappies or deal with constant accidents. My daughter turned 3 in April and could theoretically have attended her pre school from 2 but I’m only putting her in from September (so almost 3.5) as I didn’t think her toileting was reliable enough (despite training over a year ago!!) until now - I felt a childminder with 1:3 ratio was better for her until she was more reliable.

Comefromaway · 10/08/2022 13:17

(6)A duty to make reasonable adjustments applies to the responsible body of such a school.
(7)In relation to England and Wales, this section applies to—
(a)a school maintained by a local authority;
(b)an independent educational institution (other than a special school);

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/schedule/13

x2boys · 10/08/2022 13:17

Allmarbleslost · 10/08/2022 13:10

This is very common in pre schools. They don't have the staff to accommodate dozens of kids in nappies. So many children are toilet trained much later these days it seems and it must have an impact.

I think there is a misconception about loads of kids still being in nappies, my son started at a mainstream school nursery when he was three in nappies due to his severe autism and learning disabilities, he was the only child in nappies, imhe than went to a special school and is now 12 and only came out of nappies a couple of years ago I don't know why people think parents just can't be arsed toilet training their children, because it's really bloody hard having an older child in nappies, there is usually a reason for it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread