Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do beautiful women realize that ugly women are treated very differently?

560 replies

UglyNameChange · 10/08/2022 11:46

My friend (who is very beautiful) got into a relationship not so long ago and said how she hopes I’ll be soon in one too - she knows I’d like a relationship also.
Well, few days ago she was telling me to just go to a bar and get chatted up with men, it won’t be long etc. and I’d just had to laugh, and asked her does she remember any man to ever have done that before and why would is sudenly have changed.
I think I accidentally made things akward because she went really quiet.
She pretty much can go anywhere and men will start up conversation or get asked out.

And this made me think if she genuinely thought we all have the same opportunities?

OP posts:
Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/08/2022 11:44

ILPMSM · 12/08/2022 11:36

I didn't say anything like that. The OP said that maybe beautiful women don't realise that ugly women are treated differently. Throughout this thread beautiful women have complained about being constantly sexually harrassed whereas ugly or average women have complained about being ignored or insulted. Of course it isn't just beautiful women who get sexually abused but from this thread it seems like it's more common. The whole "Me Too" movement seemed to assume that everyone is in the same boat which isn't the case at all and does make me suspect that some beautiful women at least do believe it's the same for everyone.

Ugly women get assulted too. And they don't have to be grateful for a come on just because they are ugly.

Bangolads · 12/08/2022 11:36

*their

ILPMSM · 12/08/2022 11:36

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/08/2022 11:24

@ILPMSM This comment is a bit shitty. I had sympathy some with what you were saying until the metoo reference.So women should be grateful for crap and unwanted approaches from men because it can do wonders for their self esteem? Should they be grateful for sexual assult too, because that must mean a man really wants them? It's pretty much the same line of argument lots of men use to justify why they can treat women like pieces of meat.

I didn't say anything like that. The OP said that maybe beautiful women don't realise that ugly women are treated differently. Throughout this thread beautiful women have complained about being constantly sexually harrassed whereas ugly or average women have complained about being ignored or insulted. Of course it isn't just beautiful women who get sexually abused but from this thread it seems like it's more common. The whole "Me Too" movement seemed to assume that everyone is in the same boat which isn't the case at all and does make me suspect that some beautiful women at least do believe it's the same for everyone.

mam0918 · 12/08/2022 11:27

millymog11 · 11/08/2022 19:51

Stoma · Today 19:35

I'm no prude but I ask you, why use the word "punching"?

Why can they not just say something like "your other half is attractive mate you lucky devil" or some such? There has to be a "punch" in there doesn't there?

its a boxing term... boxers punch each other and are in weight catagories so that its 'safer' or 'fair' you wouldnt have a heavyweight against a lightweight.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/08/2022 11:24

@ILPMSM This comment is a bit shitty. I had sympathy some with what you were saying until the metoo reference.So women should be grateful for crap and unwanted approaches from men because it can do wonders for their self esteem? Should they be grateful for sexual assult too, because that must mean a man really wants them? It's pretty much the same line of argument lots of men use to justify why they can treat women like pieces of meat.

Bangolads · 12/08/2022 11:18

Yes I’ve been a beautiful women and a very ugly women so I do know. Maybe some aren’t aware but it’s not malicious. How would you be in there shoes? What I will say is that if you look around you women if all shapes, sexes and levels of beauty are in relationships and happy. Obviously there a millions of people out there and they’re not all looking for conventionally stunning people. There would be a chronically declining population and there isn’t is there.
Extreme beauty has little to do with it- all that guarantees is attention and that certainly doesn’t guarantee happiness. But you know all this- you’re not blind. This is definitely more to do with your own self esteem and how you connect to people. That’s not a criticism but more encouragement to take control and responsibility and stop being a wee bit silly.

ILPMSM · 12/08/2022 11:18

As an average looking person this thread just makes me feel sad. I can see that getting pestered all day by men you're not interested in would be annoying but I can't help thinking how nice it would be to get compliments occasionally, or chatted up, or get bought a drink - just once! It doesn't do wonders for your self esteem if you're never considered good enough. I remember when the "Me too" movement started, it just wasn't something I could really relate to at all.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/08/2022 10:51

I was attractive when I was younger. Not stunningly beautiful, but men certainly found me attractive generally. Clearly there are advantages, which you probably don't quite realise, especially when you are young and a bit naive. However there are downsides too. And you sometimes see the true nature of men in those situations too.

Now I am not quite as attractive (age, weight etc), and I can tell the difference. I am noticed less, looked at less. Less doors are kept open for me, or offers to help me with my lugguage or with work or whatever. But I also feel I am taken far more seriously.

UglyNameChange · 12/08/2022 10:44

Smithy8001 · 12/08/2022 10:14

This is so true, I think you see the true nature of me when you are objectively unattractive. I remember meeting up with an old school friend who was stunning at school, she mentioned a boy we knew at school and described him as “so sweet and funny”. He was actually a nasty bully who used to endlessly mock me for being ugly. We had totally different experiences of the same boys it turns out.

This is absolutely true.

My beautiful friends have had so many times boys/men do them all kind of favours.
And in their experience most men are lovely and helpfull.
And it’s of course wonderful that that’s their worldview.
But it is indeed a very different story from my side.

OP posts:
Iamnotattractive · 12/08/2022 10:26

Smithy8001 · 12/08/2022 10:14

This is so true, I think you see the true nature of me when you are objectively unattractive. I remember meeting up with an old school friend who was stunning at school, she mentioned a boy we knew at school and described him as “so sweet and funny”. He was actually a nasty bully who used to endlessly mock me for being ugly. We had totally different experiences of the same boys it turns out.

Oh yes, had the same experience at school.

And the reverse is also true, you do also see very decent boys/ men that are... I don't know how to describe it, a little bit less outwardly "alpha" in their behaviour, and therefore almost invisible to women, especially during teen/ young adult years? They don't see you as a sexual object either, but also don't suffer from sudden shyness and don't get white-faced and tongue-tied in front of you, and strangely enough, a friendship develops easily I have quite a few good male friends from school / uni.

Smithy8001 · 12/08/2022 10:14

True nature of *men I mean

Smithy8001 · 12/08/2022 10:14

Iamnotattractive · 12/08/2022 09:59

Our DM was very disparaging about men, probably because of all the crap she got from them.
I think it works in the opposite situation as well. I have yet to be wrong about the quality of a single man that my friends introduce. They joke that I am a witch with fortune-telling abilities, but I simply (and secretly) base my judgment on how they treat me, an objectively unattractive woman. Showing genuine interest in me as a person, or just as a minor annoyance they need to put up with in front of my friend to earn brownie points. A litmus paper that has never been wrong so far.

This is so true, I think you see the true nature of me when you are objectively unattractive. I remember meeting up with an old school friend who was stunning at school, she mentioned a boy we knew at school and described him as “so sweet and funny”. He was actually a nasty bully who used to endlessly mock me for being ugly. We had totally different experiences of the same boys it turns out.

SwordToFlamethrower · 12/08/2022 10:02

I never thought I was conventionally beautiful but I have been told I am and have amazing curves. I've been pestered by men my whole life and hated it. Men make certain assumptions about your intelligence, based on the size of my breasts and I hate it.

I thought once I hit my 40s I would start to become invisible. But at age 45, the men who pester you just get older. I am now pestered by 60+ men. I'm even married, but it doesn't actually stop.

Iamnotattractive · 12/08/2022 09:59

Our DM was very disparaging about men, probably because of all the crap she got from them.
I think it works in the opposite situation as well. I have yet to be wrong about the quality of a single man that my friends introduce. They joke that I am a witch with fortune-telling abilities, but I simply (and secretly) base my judgment on how they treat me, an objectively unattractive woman. Showing genuine interest in me as a person, or just as a minor annoyance they need to put up with in front of my friend to earn brownie points. A litmus paper that has never been wrong so far.

Cherchezlaspice · 12/08/2022 09:36

@Iamnotattractive You sound like great fun. I often ponder what it would be like to be my dog. I suspect it would be a life of high melodrama punctuated by dreams of squirrels.

Lots of posters on this thread are coming across as really kind, funny (@ReneBumsWombats has made me outright cackle several times), intelligent people. Which isn’t as common an occurrence as one might wish and is interesting on a thread about looks.

MarvellousMonsters · 12/08/2022 09:34

I am considered above averagely attractive, and I can honestly say it's given me zero advantages, in some ways it's been the opposite. Men have viewed me as a trophy, but not treated me with respect or dignity, I may get hit on, but it's from a very shallow perspective, once the conquest is achieved and they discover I have a brain and opinions and am not just decorative the novelty wears off. To compound this other women are often bitchy and jealous, assuming that I think I'm something special, or think I want to steal their man. I've even had friction at work as a result. I'm done with it. I don't wear make up, I don't style my hair, I don't dress 'nice' and I'd quite like to be viewed as a person rather than a thing of beauty.

Yes I'm aware men find me attractive, but I'm also very aware that this hasn't helped me in my life one single bit. I am a lone parent, I earn a low wage and have an invisible chronic health condition. Trust me, my lovely cheekbones and great skin are not helping me navigate life at all.

Iamnotattractive · 12/08/2022 09:20

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 08:40

I'm not denying any of your experiences, but honestly, that stylist must have been utter shite. Makeup can be absolute witchcraft in the right hands and someone at that level should have been able to make you look like a woman even if you were a man.

If you are very tall and broad shouldered, I wonder if you're getting the Dorothy Zbornak treatment. I couldn't understand why there were so many ugly jokes when Bea Arthur was not ugly at all, quite beautiful in my opinion. I'm coming to the conclusion that it wasn't that she was ugly, it was that, being very tall and straight-shaped with a gravelly voice, she just wasn't very typically feminine looking.

I'm taking on board everything you're saying and grateful to you for sharing. Just wondering, within having seen you, if it's something like that.

That stylist made me look the absolute bestest I have ever been (and probably will be) in my life. Have quite a few photos from the event, I still like myself in them.

Not all angular like Bea Arthur (which probably would be closer to a supermodel standard these days), more built like that strong girl from Encanto (forgot the name). Not bulging muscles, just extra-wide rib cage and shoulders / arms, no hips or bum. Topped up with E sized breasts too, which looks like I am wearing a stuffed bra or balloons under my top.

I have to have my work blouses/shirts tailor made, as the alternative option is to wear off the shelf size 18 on the top (just to fit in - neck, shoulders, upper arms, and it still sits weirdly) and 8 on the bottom. Or to wear stretchy tops, but then the effect of a guy wearing a stuffed bra is even more pronounced. Grin

Blessed with a masculine face too. Nothing alarming, but a very masculine jawline, low brow, and even male pattern baldness starting now. My brother, with the same features, is a very attractive man, and has absolutely no issue with female interest all his life. I have never been asked out or chatted up in my life by a man, I always had to make the first move and chase, chase, chase... and never had a long-term relationship, have always been left for a prettier woman very quickly.

I strongly suspect I might have had some sort of a testosterone glitch during the puberty, but now all seems to be within the normal range. I don't complain though, my life is pretty amazing. I do sometimes think about how would it be to live in a beautiful woman's skin just for a day, but then I often think how would my life be if I were my cat, so it is more a thought experiment than some burning desire or raging envy (I do envy the cat a bit though).

speakout · 12/08/2022 09:04

"a pretty little thing"

I would be pissed off if my friends said that to me.

Is a "pretty little thing" something to aspire to? It makes my skin crawl.

VK456 · 12/08/2022 08:56

According to my friends, I was a pretty little thing years and years ago.
I was never, ever approached or chatted up. I must have given off the wrong vibes or my friends weren’t telling me the truth!

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 08:40

Iamnotattractive · 12/08/2022 08:32

Yes. Also all suggestions to dress up and use make-up.
One time when I used a professional (celebrity level) make up and hair artist and wore an amazing gown (for a white tie event), I was mistaken for a cross-dressed man. 😁 Actually happened on another occasion too, without embellishments this time. I am significantly taller than an average man, and significantly wider in shoulders than an average man, with very rough features. Not fat, actually quite fit.

I'm not denying any of your experiences, but honestly, that stylist must have been utter shite. Makeup can be absolute witchcraft in the right hands and someone at that level should have been able to make you look like a woman even if you were a man.

If you are very tall and broad shouldered, I wonder if you're getting the Dorothy Zbornak treatment. I couldn't understand why there were so many ugly jokes when Bea Arthur was not ugly at all, quite beautiful in my opinion. I'm coming to the conclusion that it wasn't that she was ugly, it was that, being very tall and straight-shaped with a gravelly voice, she just wasn't very typically feminine looking.

I'm taking on board everything you're saying and grateful to you for sharing. Just wondering, within having seen you, if it's something like that.

Iamnotattractive · 12/08/2022 08:32

strivingtosucceed · 12/08/2022 08:08

TBVH some of the posts here, especially about OP's supposed lack of self esteem are utterly ridiculous. Especially the ones also claiming that OP is better off being ugly/unattractive because apparently attractive women only ever get dickheads for partners.

I wonder exactly how self esteem covers you from being the least desired by every race including your own. Or from having messed up teeth you can't afford to fix. Or having a very obvious flaw like a missing limb, very visible scars or a droopy face.

At the end of the day we all have to be honest with ourselves. Attractive people get treated better, though what is considered "attractive" may change as the years go by. Not everyone has the means or incliniation to put in the work to become attractive, therefore those people will be treated slightly or markedly worse than attractive people. That's it.

Yes. Also all suggestions to dress up and use make-up.
One time when I used a professional (celebrity level) make up and hair artist and wore an amazing gown (for a white tie event), I was mistaken for a cross-dressed man. 😁 Actually happened on another occasion too, without embellishments this time. I am significantly taller than an average man, and significantly wider in shoulders than an average man, with very rough features. Not fat, actually quite fit.

MachineBee · 12/08/2022 08:17

I’m the daughter of an incredibly beautiful woman. My DSis and I were average in the looks department. We saw how pretty privilege worked for DM and realised at an early age it wasn’t there for us. It did teach us that while it opened doors and made life easier at a superficial level, being loved and recognised for who we are was more important. For mum, who also a very intelligent and capable woman, even when she found love (with our DF) or achieved success in other parts of her life, she struggled to believe it was real.

Our DM was very disparaging about men, probably because of all the crap she got from them. She was also very lonely as friendships with women were equally difficult. It made her very insecure and it affected her relationship with our DF, although he utterly loved her and was the most faithful and devoted husband, she constantly accused him of affairs and flirting.

When her looks faded in her 60s, she became very depressed and lost her confidence - because people now interacted with her differently to what she had known most of her life. Ironically, it was in old age after a stroke that left her partially paralysed that she came to believe our DF truly loved her for herself. Watching them interact in those final months was very touching.

Being beautiful can be quite a curse and it certainly tainted so much of life for my DM. I’m glad my looks didn’t define me like they did my DM - she could never be sure her successes in life were her own and not due to her beauty. I think that must be very tough to handle.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 08:10

Especially the ones also claiming that OP is better off being ugly/unattractive because apparently attractive women only ever get dickheads for partners.

That one is annoying. There are plenty of dickheads to go round.

strivingtosucceed · 12/08/2022 08:08

Iamnotattractive · 12/08/2022 07:11

OP, I had a similar thread a year or so ago. It went the same way, ie everyone is beautiful, have never seen an ugly person in my life, you just have poor self esteem and need to identify as pretty, absolutely everyone has a friend who is size 40 without teeth or hair, but men flock to her ignoring her supermodel friends, because she's confident.

TBVH some of the posts here, especially about OP's supposed lack of self esteem are utterly ridiculous. Especially the ones also claiming that OP is better off being ugly/unattractive because apparently attractive women only ever get dickheads for partners.

I wonder exactly how self esteem covers you from being the least desired by every race including your own. Or from having messed up teeth you can't afford to fix. Or having a very obvious flaw like a missing limb, very visible scars or a droopy face.

At the end of the day we all have to be honest with ourselves. Attractive people get treated better, though what is considered "attractive" may change as the years go by. Not everyone has the means or incliniation to put in the work to become attractive, therefore those people will be treated slightly or markedly worse than attractive people. That's it.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 08:05

Mississipi71 · 12/08/2022 07:34

You really are obsessed aren't you? Talk about an overly dramatic post.

Sure, but at least I'm honest about it. You're the one who's given more departure announcements than Terminal 5.