Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do beautiful women realize that ugly women are treated very differently?

560 replies

UglyNameChange · 10/08/2022 11:46

My friend (who is very beautiful) got into a relationship not so long ago and said how she hopes I’ll be soon in one too - she knows I’d like a relationship also.
Well, few days ago she was telling me to just go to a bar and get chatted up with men, it won’t be long etc. and I’d just had to laugh, and asked her does she remember any man to ever have done that before and why would is sudenly have changed.
I think I accidentally made things akward because she went really quiet.
She pretty much can go anywhere and men will start up conversation or get asked out.

And this made me think if she genuinely thought we all have the same opportunities?

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 10/08/2022 15:48

the bit about not looking as unattractive as you think is always a shit thing to say.
I remember Kathy Burke going on about this when some beautiful celeb went on about how all women are beautiful and you only have to believe in yourself.
Women like Kathy are not stupid. Treating them as if they are does not help.

MrsMcisaCt · 10/08/2022 15:48

From as far back as I remember I have been bullied for being ugly. I stopped going out socially in my teens and twenties because I couldn't cope with the jeering, sarcastic or downright hateful comments I received from boys and grown men. I missed out on a lot of experiences in my life because of how I look. So unfortunately I find it very difficult to have sympathy with women who complain about their beauty because they get too much attention from men. I suppose I will never understand the problems a beautiful woman experiences, and they will never understand mine.

Lifeadmin · 10/08/2022 15:45

I don’t think beautiful women are really aware of their attractiveness to men. However it’s a double edged sword, beautiful women can attract right arseholes, who are only interested in having a good looking partner. Their partner has no interest in them as a person And they get traded in as soon as they lose their looks. For example Rod Stewart and his team of tall blonde clones, although his latest wife seems to have bucked the trend.

ganvough · 10/08/2022 15:40

There's plenty of plain looking women in good relationships!! If you meet people at work or a hobby, or a party, where they get to know you first - charm and a nice personality can make anyone beautiful. Getting chatted up at a bar or in an environment where looks are everything isn't the best way even for attractive women.

Honestly what did you want her to say? If she'd agreed you were too ugly to pull you'd be here complaining how rude she is. Attention from men is not the same as them wanting a relationship with you.

If you're struggling with men, it's not your appearance. It will be a case of either just bad luck or maybe a personality that's not endearing. Making the most of what you have - styling yourself well, good hygiene, staying healthy and being pleasant can go a long way in charming men AND women.

cass5 · 10/08/2022 15:39

Just a provocative thought I have been entertaining for some time. I find interesting some comments statting to be unfair to be treated better for their looks, which is a genetic lottery, then for their talent, intelligence, skills, etc. But isn't intelligence, talent, and skills also to great extent genetically determined? Of course, you can work hard to develop certain skills, but the success to which you do it, and your inclination to do so, might be as influenced by random genetics as one's looks. Thus not sure it is more valid to be admired for one's intelligence then for one's beauty. And, in the same way beaty decays, so thus your mental sharpness.

lunar1 · 10/08/2022 15:37

I always reinforce with my sons that we judge people on their actions not by their looks or clothes they wear.

Buythebag40 · 10/08/2022 15:32

I know I'll sound like an arsehole saying this but when I was younger I actually had friends who would sometimes organise nights out behind my back - it was upsetting and I confronted one of them once when we were a bit drunk and she admitted that they wanted to go out and "cop off" and they felt they had more chance when I wasn't there as men used to chat me up first! She had a bit of a rant and told me it was hard hanging round with me sometimes as I'm "so gorgeous" that it makes other women feel inferior. I was shocked to say the least as imo none of us had ever had problems meeting men and this friend in particular had totted up many notches on the bedpost! IMO her problem was (and still is) her lack of self esteem in that she would go with anyone that showed any interest no matter how twatty they were. And it's still the same today tbh - she lets men treat her like shit.

So, just from an "attractive persons" perspective - it can be hurtful knowing that your oldest friends can be resentful of the way you look when it's really the least interesting thing about you. Anyway, I'm old now and it's not really a problem as we're all as wrinkly and saggy as one another!

And I bet you're not anywhere near as unattractive as you think.

Dalaidramailama · 10/08/2022 15:32

@lunar1

Absolutely. I think all we can do as mothers is just keep banging the drum about beautiful personalities and it’s not all about looks etc.

JustDanceAddict · 10/08/2022 15:32

Well I would say I was ugly in the facial dept but I’ve always had a decent figure and nice hair so they have compensated somewhat thank goodness.

i have been chatted up but am way past all that malarkey now and am embracing invisibility.

My experience:

-was bullied/teased at school for being ugly (mostly stopped by sixth form)
I used to ask my mum if I looked nice and she said ‘you have a nice smile’ - way to go, mum!
-found it hard to meet guys properly and rarely got asked out (although I am married it was my first proper relationship - thankfully my kids have not inherited the ‘bad’ side of my looks and are on the better looking side of average). husband is average looking - he has some nice physical features but I didn’t marry for looks!!
-job interviews - I was prob bad at them because I hated being judged so a bit of a vicious circle. I still hate them and cos I know my current job isn’t my last I’m gonna have to go through it all at least one more time!!

however, I have many friends, I get on with people well and when I do go out I look like a fun person to be around.

that said I’d swap my face for even an average one given half the chance as it would make me feel more comfortable in society.

antelopevalley · 10/08/2022 15:31

Do you really think ugly women do not get bullied? Do not get men shouting insults to them on the street?

lunar1 · 10/08/2022 15:29

@Dalaidramailama, it can definitely be a poison chalice for them can't it.

Ds1 lost a lovely female friend as she was bullied horribly for their friendship. They were in the same dance group so I would pick them up together.

Schools can be an awful place and in the end she distanced herself from him completely.

Timeturnerplease · 10/08/2022 15:28

TheLeadbetterLife · 10/08/2022 11:55

They don't realise, how could they? On the other hand though, I don't envy beautiful women. They get a rougher deal in a lot of ways from what I can tell, because they are given special treatment on account of their looks (through no fault of their own), which is a precarious thing.

I've only ever been judged by my brains and abilities, because my looks are nothing special. Therefore I don't feel like I have anything to lose as I get older, and my success or failure is within my own control.

I’d never thought of it like this before. Blimey, I wish someone had explained this to teenage me - took me until about 32 to come to terms with not being attractive!

Guiterrez · 10/08/2022 15:26

I was considered beautiful as a teenager and into my early 30's. One man told me that I was the most beautiful woman in the city. I look back and I can see it - I couldn't at the time. I did a little modeling but loathed it.

Now? My big boobs make me look bigger than I am, my 'prettiest eyes I've ever seen' (another stranger compliment) are tired-looking, I'm a little heavier, my hair that people once asked to touch is usually scraped in a band. In short, my beauty was very youth-based, I think.

I don't wear make-up really, I'm absolutely not interested in being attractive to anyone except my DH. I dress to conceal my figure, rather than show it off. I could look good and turn the odd head if I pulled out the stops, but I know that I pretty much blend into the background now, and that's fine.

So yes, I've been beautiful and now I'm not. I prefer being not. I hated the constant male attention: several times as a teenager, men stopped their cars and tried to actually touch me - just absolutely awful.

I know two women who I consider beautiful - they don't have to do a thing, the world almost stops around them just to gaze. They are both intelligent, wonderful, kind Latina women. They know the effect they have, but it's natural and not because they seek it out. One of them overcompensates with female friends, and is excessively smiley and self-depracting to redress some kind of unspoken balance.

ReneBumsWombats · 10/08/2022 15:22

The idea that beautiful people don't have personalities is ridiculous, as is the idea that there are no plain and boring people.

But what might be true is that if you're insecure about how you look and bothered by that, you might work on developing traits.

I'm sure being very good looking changes things. Makes you more likely to be a film star or trophy wife, for a start, if only by bringing the opportunity. But I do remember that other thread with beauties putting various things down to being above averagely attractive, and me thinking "that happens to me too, so there must be other ways it comes about". Being female, young and a healthy weight was probably a bigger factor...didn't need to look like Marilyn Monroe.

CulturePigeon · 10/08/2022 15:13

Beautiful looking women most definitely get the most attention.
After that most important thing seems to be just laughing whatever the man is saying/doing.

OP, I know exactly what you mean here! Your posts have made me think hard about this whole subject and I've realised that (being pretty average myself) I've never actually resented another woman, especially a friend, for being prettier than me...but oh boy, I really get pissed offwith the sort of women who giggle hysterically at anything some idiotic bloke does or says. Yes - this brought back many annoying memories.
(
I know that's not a good reaction, but if we're not being honest here, what's the point??)

I met a girl during the freshers' week at university (we were clinging together for warmth - we had little in common really) who was prettier than me but not stunning. She had clearly picked up the habit of giggling all the time with men, and they loved it. She didn't really say anything...except 'Oh my God!' or similar, but she didn't need to. The flattery of finding all these guys so hilarious worked its
magic very effectively. Proper conversation they certainly did NOT want - a bit depressing.

A PP was critical of the view that attractive people tend to have less developed or less interesting personalities, and I agree that this is a tired cliche and not always the case. I'm sure there are lots of intelligent, attractive people who don't conform to this cliche but the fact remains that (at least while they're young) really beautiful people can get away with doing very little - a smile, giggle or simper will get them attention and popularity. Other people do have to work a bit harder.

It's often the case that the most successful comedians of both sexes are not necessarily the most physically attractive.

blueshoes · 10/08/2022 15:13

I always feel sorry for ugly men as women will get a man no matter what she looks like.

You mean ugly men who are unsuccessful. Lot of successful ugly men have their pick of women - Bernie Ecclestone, Rupert Murdoch, Jeff Bezos, Bill Gates, Elon Musk, Harvey Weinstein (previously)

SizzlerFizzler · 10/08/2022 15:12

Of course beautiful people benefit from their looks. I know there's a lot of 'oh but they get harrassed by so many men' but beauty goes beyond people being sexually attracted to you. Beautiful people are shown preferential treatment in all aspects of life. From little things like receiving quicker service at the bar to bigger things like sailing through interviews. As humans we respond favourably to good looks. Countless studies show this.

i think it's a bit off to tell the OP she's lacking in self-esteem because she can see that beauty gives a person a head start when it comes to looking for romantic attachments.

Dalaidramailama · 10/08/2022 15:11

@lunar1

Agreed. I have two sons. One is exceptionally handsome, fuck knows how but he seems to have got the whole families best features all rolled into one. It’s actually annoying when people make comparisons with my other son but i am waffling now.

Anyhow he had a girlfriend who he was with and he really liked her but then lots of people in his year group started asking him why on Earth he was going out with her because she was fat. Well I’ve brought my son up to respect girls and certainly not to be horrible based on appearances etc so he ignored the comments entirely.

Anyway in the end she dumped him because she too was sick of the grief she was getting by others who said she was punching. How disappointing is this? She was a lovely girl and my son was gutted. He’s since been asked out by conventionally prettier girls but he’s said no as he said they can be mean.

its a minefield out there! You see it on here sometimes a wife who feels a bit insecure if her husband is better looking than what she is.

beastlyslumber · 10/08/2022 15:07

Surely it depends on the confidence and judge of character of the individual woman as to who they choose to go out with, and if you are pretty you have a wider not smaller pool to choose from and have more chance of getting it right, and are more likely to tell them to get lost if they turn out to be a twat.

Yes, exactly.

maranella · 10/08/2022 15:07

x2boys · 10/08/2022 12:38

It's much more than being beautiful irs also about sex appeal, some people can be objectively beautiful ,and have zero personality, and some people can average or below average looking but , have a brilliant personality, be flirtatious and become increasingly attractive to others the more people get to know them
Also it's a cliche but beauty is very much in the eye of the beholder .

I agree. Looks aren't everything. Being friendly, chatty, open, approachable, fun and confident are actually much more attractive traits that just beauty on its own.

Doubleraspberry · 10/08/2022 15:06

ReneBumsWombats · 10/08/2022 15:02

As a general rule I would, but when they tell me xyz happened to them and it's also happened to me, why can't I say so? I'm average looking but I've had an absolute shit ton of street harassment and objectification, as well as more positive experiences.

It got separated by posts in between but that post was in response to this:

I actually think it's quite endearing that she has no perception of things being different for you both.

It shows that she has no sense that you are in any way less attractive.

Rosehugger · 10/08/2022 15:03

I was gorgeous in my early 20s and never went out with a narcissist or anyone that bad really. I don't think it follows that beautiful women only attract narcissists! Surely it depends on the confidence and judge of character of the individual woman as to who they choose to go out with, and if you are pretty you have a wider not smaller pool to choose from and have more chance of getting it right, and are more likely to tell them to get lost if they turn out to be a twat.

Smithy8001 · 10/08/2022 15:02

Doubleraspberry · 10/08/2022 14:58

It's frustrating to have your own lived experience denied though, isn't it? By people who've never experienced it. It's no different to men telling women they're imagining sexism, or a white person telling someone of colour that they themselves 'don't see colour' so society doesn't discriminate.

If someone tells you they are treated differently, why not believe them?

Totally agree with this.
I’ve noticed that some men seem to feel a sort of righteous anger towards a woman they perceive as ugly. I’ve had men shout insults at me as I’ve walked down the street, “woofing” etc. There’s a strange contempt there, like you don’t have a right to exist because you are ugly.

ReneBumsWombats · 10/08/2022 15:02

Doubleraspberry · 10/08/2022 14:58

It's frustrating to have your own lived experience denied though, isn't it? By people who've never experienced it. It's no different to men telling women they're imagining sexism, or a white person telling someone of colour that they themselves 'don't see colour' so society doesn't discriminate.

If someone tells you they are treated differently, why not believe them?

As a general rule I would, but when they tell me xyz happened to them and it's also happened to me, why can't I say so? I'm average looking but I've had an absolute shit ton of street harassment and objectification, as well as more positive experiences.

beastlyslumber · 10/08/2022 15:01

So, you might get fewer, way fewer, approaches or offers from men if you’re less attractive, but there’s also a good chance you’ll get better quality offers too imho.

As a not-beautiful woman I have also been targeted by narcissists and wankers. I've been raped, stalked, sexually abused, sexually harassed, catcalled, verbally abused etc. Being average-looking has not protected me from sleazy behaviour by men. I have no idea whether I would experience more of this kind of thing if I was beautiful, but I'm sure I would have had less verbal abuse, and sure I would have had a lot more men falling over themselves to be nice to me and do stuff for me. I also expect I would have got more of the jobs I wanted, had more attention and opportunities, etc. So on the whole, I'd rather be beautiful! Maybe the really nice men wouldn't approach me, but if I was beautiful I could approach them without fear of rejection. So yes, I'll take it!

I think some of the 'but it's awful to be beautiful' comments are peoplejust trying to reassure themselves that it's not actually just fucking great good luck to be gorgeous.