Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - football against fence

134 replies

XCTX · 10/08/2022 11:14

Hi all

Need a quick bit of advice to make sure I'm not just being curmudgeonly!

Recently moved into a new property with a lovely back area and have found out that neighbours to the back kids have a penchant for football, resulting in constant balls against the fence when the weather is remotely nice. I can't explain how loud it is to the point where I hear it in my front room even with doors closed and TV on, during summer holidays it is making WFH impossible.

I've been round before and politely asked them if there was any chance of playing football away from the fence, was told "I have x amount of boys here, the football will hit the fence." - so that was helpful.

The fence itself is absolutely knackered from the constant impact to the point where we can see each into others gardens which I'm really not comfortable with - its only a matter of time before a fence panel comes in and the fence is damaged properly.

When balls come over I do keep them as its the only time i get any peace, when I say I keep them just to be clear they are welcome to come and get them back by knocking on the door but I wont be throwing them over. Not long ago got a head over the fence to say "weve looked through the fence and can see the balls in your back we've been looking for them can you throw them back" (this was an adult not a child) - really not comfortable with my neighbours looking straight into my back!

Added to this we've recently had an addition of a puppy join us who gets the fright of his little life when he's outside enjoying the sun and hears a huge bang, cue a fit of barking and a reluctance to go outside and pee.

I completely understand that kids make noise - as we all do! However this is becoming a bit much, my mind has occasionally wandered to saving some dog ablutions to place on the ball before throwing back next time and saying "oh sorry it landed in his business before i had a chance to bag it up!" but before getting there I want to know..

AIBU to return back round and be slightly firmer in asking the footballs to stay away from the fence - I am not wanting to tell people how to use their own personal gardens but its really impacting multiple areas of my life now

Also - any property experts out there - how do I find out who owns this fence from a boundary POV? No reference in my deeds... If it's me I will be replacing the panels and making it crystal clear any damage from impact will be criminal damage.

OP posts:
girlfriend44 · 10/08/2022 16:38

The correct thing to do if a ball comes over is actually to leave it where it is?

why don't you join in with them op ask if you can play too you might enjoy yourself and it will release the tension.

LuxembourglivinginDenmark · 10/08/2022 16:31

But regardless of you thinking its annoying it's still their garden and they can use it as they wish...
I would not recommend trespassing another person garden and ruin s fence. If they have video surveillance like many do they will have you on record.

sunglassesonthetable · 10/08/2022 14:44

...I suspect not!! Best to tell them to aim away from the house and annoy the neighbours, then everyone gets what they want (!)

Yes would want them to aim away from windows. 100% And aim at fence.

But I wouldn't be trying to annoy neighbours! 🙄

If neighbours mentioned it I would get a goal to absorb the ball and limit times.

XCTX · 10/08/2022 13:54

Also re: WFH being my choice.

My company sold up their offices and mandated a 100%WFH for all staff post pandemic, so unfortunately I have no choice unless I find another job.

Think you'll find thats happened with a lot of us "moany" WFH crew.

OP posts:
XCTX · 10/08/2022 13:52

Hi all,

Many thanks for the replies! Let me just say I do really, truly see both sides. Gardens are there to be played in, but I firmly believe this can be achieved without overly irritating anybody we share our fences with - and I am slightly shocked with the amount of posters whos summaries are "put up and shut up"

To be clear, i don't care about noise in general, hearing kids play is actually very pleasant, what I do care about is constant loud impact ricocheting throughout my house because of what I perceive to be selfishness.

I would like to play Devil's Advocate for a moment. To the posters firmly in the camp of "Kids need to play, there will always be balls hitting fences" can I ask if your own DCs were using the fence as a goal (as is happening here, apologies I didn't clarify that) and the solution to ensure minimum disruption to neighbours was to aim the ball away from the fence...and therefore back at your own house...would you still be so ardently passionate that kids need to exercise and find yourself saying "its ok if they hit the windows, walls, doors constantly and cause damage..kids need exercise and this sort of thing will happen!"

...I suspect not!! Best to tell them to aim away from the house and annoy the neighbours, then everyone gets what they want (!)

OP posts:
MolkosTeenageAngst · 10/08/2022 13:49

How often is it hitting the fence? If they’re kicking it continuously and purposefully against the fence so that they can play alone by kicking it and having it bounce back to the, then I would say YANBU. However if they are playing together and the ball just happens to hit the fence sometimes I feel that is normal usage. You can’t expect silence from other peoples gardens.

If you are WFH then get noise cancelling headphones and accept the fact that you’re not going to get the conditions of an office from home.

sunglassesonthetable · 10/08/2022 13:42
  • we want kids to not be obese, to be strong and healthy then we’re also going to accept that they will make some noise in their gardens. Playing football is an escape for many kids. It gives them an outlet for their energy and keeps them emotionally happy. It certainly helps my kids when they’ve had a tough day.

That’s life OP. No man (or woman) is an island.*

Yep. And it's the summer holidays. Only four weeks and it'll be quiet again.

ThePomegranateClause · 10/08/2022 13:21

Lots of posters have obviously never experienced this behaviour. Having a ball slam intermittently against a fence is such a shock to the system, it really makes you jump. We used to have neighbours with teenage sons who used the fence as a goal, it ruined sitting in the garden for me, and I had to dash to get the ball so our dog didn't get it. One time the dog burst it before I got to it, I then wondered why on earth I'd been stopping her from getting the ball, so I let her get any that came over the fence. They stopped using the fence as a goal.

Lots of parents really don't care what distress or inconvenience their little darlings cause others.

vivainsomnia · 10/08/2022 13:19

I despair that so many people are trying to place restrictions on other people’s use of housing when the onus is on you to find a quiet place in your house. If you can’t, then go back to your work premises
So if my job at home entail using a very loud bell that I stroke every few minutes but unexpectedly, and the sound made you jump each time and made your baby cry, would it be fair on me that it would your problem and the onus would be in you to find somewhere quiet in your house?

The very vast majority of people wouldn't tolerate it, when it's kids, and involves play that mean their parents can get in with whatever they want to do, then it's ok!

rightonthyme · 10/08/2022 13:16

YANBU. I'd keep the balls too. If kids don't have consequences they'll never learn, thanks to the lax parents.

RelativePitch · 10/08/2022 13:13

That would drive me mad OP-my sympathies. I have a rescue dog who is pretty nervous and would bark like crazy if she had to live with a ball thumping continuously against our fence. Then there would two sources of nuisance noise for the neighbourhood. Just take comfort that there will be an end to it when school goes back and the weather turns.

rainbowmilk · 10/08/2022 13:05

HotHeatDays · 10/08/2022 12:55

We have this issue at the moment, along with making peoples front doors targets to kick at, whilst the parents laugh.

If you say anything you are told that children will be children.

Yep, I’ve had that one too (and “they’re only 8!”). Doesn’t help that there’s a park five minutes away but of course then parents would have to supervise rather than just chucking them outside and making them someone else’s problem.

You have my sympathies.

Wolfiee · 10/08/2022 12:59

RatherBeRiding · 10/08/2022 12:52

I'd be finding out whose fence it is - from the estate agents who handled the sale, or from the deeds, or the solicitor who handled the conveyancing.

If it's your fence - remove it and replace it with a very thick hedge and a fence on your side of the hedge to keep your dog in your garden. Preferably a very prickly hedge such as blackthorn. if your neighbours then want to put their own fence in front of the boundary hedge, that's up to them.

I like this idea, also the idea above this one so … wait until they’re out, look for a pre-damaged part of the fence and completely knacker it. Now you have a broken fence so you need to find out who’s responsible for it. If it’s them … they might be more careful about kicking stuff against it when they have to pay for the damage. If it’s yours, replace it with a thorny hedge and a fence on your side.

Notbluepeter · 10/08/2022 12:57

Noise cancelling headphones are your friend

latetothefisting · 10/08/2022 12:56

As one of the wfh I can see both sides - yes I understand that my need to work doesn't mean my neighbours should be silent, but excessive, and unnecessary, noise is equally as irritating whether I'm working or not, it pisses me off just as much when I've got a day off!

I don't think knowing the boundary necessarily helps - when the winds blew down a lot of the fences in my street it was established that when the plots were first created there weren't any fences included, so each fence just 'belonged' to whoever had put it up. So I'd go round and try again to ask politely to see if they can reduce the noise and at the same time say you notice the fence is getting a bit bashed, do they know whose responsibility it is to fix?

If it is their fence, I would build another one your side, and then a layer of bushes or whatever inside that - that will mask the noise as much as possible.

If they say it's your fence and your issue to sort, I would completely remove the fence and just plant a load of big trees/bushes there to maintain a boundary. Possibly some sort of chain wire to a certain height so your dog can't get through, but basically nothing that a ball can be bounced off! They can't complain if they've admitted it's your fence to do what you like with!

HotHeatDays · 10/08/2022 12:55

rainbowmilk · 10/08/2022 12:28

^this. The kids where I live kick their balls against the cars and front doors and their parents just tell anyone complaining to fuck off. Shared this on a thread once and was told that it’s nicer to see them outside than indoors. Not for me it’s not!

We have this issue at the moment, along with making peoples front doors targets to kick at, whilst the parents laugh.

If you say anything you are told that children will be children.

Sux2buthen · 10/08/2022 12:53

So you keep the balls until they ask for them back in a way you have decided is acceptable.
They can have them on your terms
I'd give them back and say please can you ensure this stops for my puppy's sake and because it's a pain.

RatherBeRiding · 10/08/2022 12:52

I'd be finding out whose fence it is - from the estate agents who handled the sale, or from the deeds, or the solicitor who handled the conveyancing.

If it's your fence - remove it and replace it with a very thick hedge and a fence on your side of the hedge to keep your dog in your garden. Preferably a very prickly hedge such as blackthorn. if your neighbours then want to put their own fence in front of the boundary hedge, that's up to them.

FatEaredFuck · 10/08/2022 12:51

In all honesty I would hasten the fences demise. Wait till the neighbours are out for the day and go to 'inspect it' and give it a swift hard pull. If it's your responsibility to replace, take your time. Dont let the kids in the garden to retrieve the ball. Dont answer the door.

If the fence is theirs the financial hit may stop them playing football going forwards.

walk your puppy so he can toilet in the meantime.

waterrat · 10/08/2022 12:50

It's the summer holidays. Kids are usually at school and won't be playing in the garden fir most of the year.

You have zero right to demand a workable environment In a residential home. If you need quiet in order to work go and hire an office space.

Children and their balls have been driven off residential street by the huge rise in car ownership over the past 20 years. They have lost the freedom to play out.

Now the work from home shift means people want silence from gardens as well

Children need to play. Balls hitting a fence is not anti social behaviour particularly given it will on balance be something that happens on a minority of days in the year

GeekyThings · 10/08/2022 12:46

YANBU, because they're kicking it hard enough and enough times to actually damage the fence. Doesn't matter who's fence it is, I wouldn't want my neighbour destroying the fence on one side of my garden, that's ridiculous and un-neighbourly.

I'd ask them again nicely if they'd consider getting a net, and also when they're going to repair the fence. If they don't answer positively, go with your idea of replacing it (if it's yours) and threatening them with criminal damage if they destroy this one - they'd have had a chance if you'd offered them an alternative first, that would make it entirely their own doing.

Minikievs · 10/08/2022 12:46

I think kids playing football in the garden, and kids using the fence to kick a football against, are two different things.

YWBU to get annoyed with the first, but YWNBU to be annoyed with the second.
If the ball hits the fence by accident sometimes, fine, but from what you describe, they are repeatedly kicking it against the fence as the game. This would drive me bonkers. When my son does it, I tell him to stop. It's loud, annoying, and you can play football without smashing it repeatedly against the fence.

sunglassesonthetable · 10/08/2022 12:46

I would put a sturdy fence up on your side. It will be double thick then and muffle the sound somewhat.

I would also ask if they could not do it before 11am say, as a compromise. And in return start throwing balls back ( if you see them)

Bear in mind we are in August and thats only about 4 weeks away from kids disappearing off to school again during the best part of a day.

Ultimately though you lost me a bit on criminal damage.

Brefugee · 10/08/2022 12:43

We’ve lost 20 (soft) cricket balls already this summer because our neighbours don’t throw them back. I think they’re miserable but whatever.

why on earth can't they go over at the end of the day and ask for them back? Don't talk to the neighbours? Don't like them? Don't know them?

stockpilingallthecheese · 10/08/2022 12:42

SavoirFlair · 10/08/2022 11:45

It’s clear from the increasing number of threads, that people want to police activity during 0900-17:00 , due to WFH which some people think is an inalienable human right.

It’s the summer - you have your windows open, you chose to work from home. People will have kids home during the summer. The two may not be compatible, but your life and activity is not more important than another person’s.

I despair that so many people are trying to place restrictions on other people’s use of housing when the onus is on you to find a quiet place in your house. If you can’t, then go back to your work premises .

But if your neighbours kids make so may have noise you can hear it from the other side of your house with all windows shut is that fair? We have some extremely screamy kids out the back. I think listening to kids play in the garden is a nice noise, but hour after hour of literal shrieking and screaming is not. It's driving me mad in the house, let alone in the garden. OP you have my sympathies!