Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think residential areas and homes are not meant to be offices?

165 replies

MossOwl · 10/08/2022 09:57

Inspired by the thread where the poster whose neighbour had a very important job and was in very important meetings all day and please could she keep her kids out there own garden, outrageous if you ask me!

I think there is a problem with homes and residential areas being turned into offices. My husband also has a very important job with important meetings and I am expected to go about the house not making any noise, I can't hoover or run the washing machine even watching TV is out of bounds. He also complains about neighbours cutting their grass or getting noisy work done to their homes and even the noise of kids playing out. I tell him to go into the office but he hates the 45 min commute and says he prefers working at home at the kitchen table as opposed to going into the office.

Another neighbour has also complained about the noise from their neighbours during the day, during the school holidays, their neighbours have three kids and they have the garden set up with a trampoline, paddling pool and swings which can be noisy but what else are kids supposed to be doing in the summer?

When other neighbours were on holiday they were out in the garden and were playing some music it was kind of loud but they don't play it all year round they were just trying to enjoy a staycation and they got people shouting to keep the noise down as they were working.

I've told my husband that if he wants to keep working from home and not get disturbed then we will have to move to an area with less neighbours where he can have his own office cabin in the garden. During lockdowns and the pandemic we all made the best of it but now office workers do have a choice to go back but many would rather still work at home and expect their families and neighbours to tiptoe around them.

AIBU to think that homes and residential areas are not really suitable to be offices?

OP posts:
ILikeHotWaterBottles · 10/08/2022 12:21

We have separate work areas at home, and you know what I do when there are kids making noise outside? I close my window, I know! Strange concept, but windows open AND close. It's amazing how many people in 'very important' jobs don't know this, they are supposed to be intelligent but haven't understood this?

MossOwl · 10/08/2022 12:16

@FictionalCharacter Well this is what I think as well, that if he went in 2 or 3 days a week and then got the noise cancelling headphones it would be a big improvement but you should see his pained expression when i ask him if he's going into the office at some point during the week its like I just asked him to eat shit.

There is also the issue of our different patterns of energy so that he is more mentally focused in the morning and I am more focused in the later afternoon which is when he is winding down and starts popping into see what I am up to every 5 minutes disturbing me when I am working, then I get ratty at him and feel bad. It was all so much better when he worked in the office!

OP posts:
Goldbar · 10/08/2022 12:15

Maybe just go on cooking strike until he moves?

antelopevalley · 10/08/2022 12:12

The idea that offices are insulated from noise is rubbish.
WFH I hear way less noise than I did in the office. Plenty of offices are on main roads and next to shops. My office was in the city centre with shoppers, buskers, music coming from shops, and traffic all adding to the noise. The only quiet offices I have worked in are those on out-of-town industrial sites.

FictionalCharacter · 10/08/2022 12:07

jeaux90 · 10/08/2022 11:59

In the last few days I've seen several posts about men with "very important jobs" being insufferable, selfish knobs.

Why on earth do we put up with that nonsense?

I'm a single mum in a male dominated industry and I'm also very senior. I work at home a lot more than I used to but certainly do not behave in the way described on the threads.

Just entitled, overly self important, dickish behaviour.

100% - and I’ve just noticed that he’s choosing to work at the kitchen table! He’s working in the kitchen, which is obviously in use as a kitchen!
@MossOwl You’re making excuses for him. He does not have to work in the house, and if he chooses to he doesn’t have to sit in the kitchen complaining that it’s a kitchen. His commute isn’t that bad and you would all benefit from him going to the office at least some of the time.

DangerouslyBored · 10/08/2022 12:04

DH and I both WFH. It works v well but we live rurally with only three other houses as neighbours and they also WFH a lot of the time.

It helps that we have our own offices. DH has the study and I’m lucky enough to have a garden office. Sometimes dogs bark in the middle of calls or workmen occasionally knock on the door during presentations which is really off putting but in the main, WFH works for both of us as we both have the type of roles where we need to concentrate and the office environment is not designed for complete focus. I get so much more
done when I’m WFH compared to being at office. All in all, WFH is wonderful but only if you have the right set up.

PeppaPigIsBacon · 10/08/2022 12:03

I do agree that homes are homes and shouldn’t be expected to be quiet to accommodate office work.

However, I think there is also an issue generally that gardens, in particular, are used in a different (and noisier) way than they were a few years back. I know when I was growing up it was really only very young children that used gardens as play areas - most people didn’t have trampolines or much play equipment in the garden, hot tubs weren’t a thing, paddling pools were toddler-sized only. So the garden was for gardening and the occasional BBQ. And no one except builders played music in gardens, either. Now, it’s more an extension of living space, which does make things noisier for all concerned.

FictionalCharacter · 10/08/2022 12:00

That’s a husband problem and a neighbour problem, not a WFH problem. I WFH some of the time, my husband WFH sometimes, neither of us acts as if it’s our office and tries to tell everyone in the house to be quiet. The house is no more noisy than my workplace. For Teams or Zoom calls you can blur the background or select an alternative background, you don’t have to let everyone on the call see your house. A washing machine is just normal ambient noise and he should be able to cope with it. I have no time for people who feel entitled to bring the household and family life to a stop because they’ve chosen to WFH.
The enforced WFH period during lockdown was different because people were having to improvise, but where I work, you can only WFH if you have a suitable environment - privacy to ensure confidentiality, and a reasonable office set-up (not a laptop on your knee on the sofa). If you can’t achieve that you have to work in the office. Families aren’t expected to change their lives to accommodate a homeworker.

Ontobetterthings · 10/08/2022 11:59

When people say they have very important jobs what do they mean by this? What does he do?

jeaux90 · 10/08/2022 11:59

In the last few days I've seen several posts about men with "very important jobs" being insufferable, selfish knobs.

Why on earth do we put up with that nonsense?

I'm a single mum in a male dominated industry and I'm also very senior. I work at home a lot more than I used to but certainly do not behave in the way described on the threads.

Just entitled, overly self important, dickish behaviour.

Just10moreminutesplease · 10/08/2022 11:57

Working from home can work really well as long as you’re not an entitled dick about it.

I did it for a few years before my baby was born and managed never to complain about normal noise from outside.

My DH works from home now and doesn’t expect normal household noises to stop. If he has a particularly important meeting he will either go into the office or find a Starbucks meeting room or similar to use.

Stop letting your DH rule your life… it’s not ok that you’re expected to walk on eggshells around him.

SudocremOnEverything · 10/08/2022 11:56

This is much more a husband and logistics of your family issue that a WFH issue. He wants silence and no disturbances - but also to sit at the kitchen table while you and the kids are at home. That’s just an unreasonable position, and he doesn’t get to blame you for disturbing him by making lunch or vacuuming.

It’s like going to a softplay to have a work meeting and complaining the place is full of shrieking children and other people doing their own things. He either needs to accept that he will be disturbed at the kitchen table or go somewhere he won’t be disturbed. He doesn’t get to have his cake and eat it too.

Isonthecase · 10/08/2022 11:56

This does seem to be mostly poor communication. I work from home and have been absolutely fine, my team understands that sometimes there will be background noise (it's a heatwave, I'm working from the coldest room in the house), my husband gets notice that I have something I can't be disturbed on and then doesn't, and my neighbours and I give each other notice when we have a few hours here and there where being a bit quieter would be really helpful. It all works because we've all done what we can to minimise the impact on others.

LadyDanburysHat · 10/08/2022 11:56

OP your husband is a selfish twat. If he doesn't want you in the kitchen in the daytime then he needs to not make a fuss about you putting the washing on early, and tough if the spinning waked him.

I don't believe there is nowhere else in the house he can work. Until we moved recently I was in my bedroom at a compact desk in the corner. I also have two monitors, but I worked a way to squeeze a desk somewhere that the rest of my family weren't needing to use. Your husband has the choice of an office, I didn't. There is no way I would be tiptoeing around in my own home like you are.

CounsellorTroi · 10/08/2022 11:50

I am also amazed at how people seem to need silence to work in at home but most offices I have worked in have a certain level of noise and sometimes get disturbance from work men etc so an office is not always the most peaceful environment.

This. When I was working I had to put up with people standing talking next to my desk for ages, people having uproarious laughs across the room, unattended mobiles going off all the time, really loud typers, construction site outside, all sorts.

gannett · 10/08/2022 11:50

HughJarWang · 10/08/2022 11:25

WFH is the invention of the Devil. Everyone who's been WFH since Covid ought to push off back to their offices and let homes be homes again.

Bollocks to this. I've been WFH since 2009 and have no intention of setting foot in an office ever again.

But part of the reason it's so much better is that the ambient noise at home is far less distracting than an office environment. Neighbours playing music, kids playing on the next street, DP cooking, a TV two rooms away - none of this remotely stops me getting on with work, including Important Meetings. If I particularly need a bit of quiet I close the door and windows and tell DP to keep it down for half an hour. And at times I'm the one playing the music or taking a meeting in my garden.

It's a lot better than trying to block out the 5 simultaneous inane conversations in earshot in an open-plan office while also being alert enough not to be rude if spoken to or, heaven forbid, to hear if someone says something relevant to work. Or trying to dodge the small talk or random announcements about nothing.

But it's unreasonable to expect total silence while you work, whether that's in an office or at home. OP's husband is a dick. If he prefers WFH, I get it! It's much better. But if he can't cope with the washing machine or TV in another room while he works then he's not suited to it.

And why can't he communicate his needs in advance? If one room isn't suited for a meeting I can pick up my laptop and go to another for half an hour. If there's a particular time of day I need the house to be more quiet than usual I tell DP in advance and we work around each other. I do not believe anyone's job requires dead silence, not even a washing machine, for the entirety of their working day.

TeddyTonks · 10/08/2022 11:49

Ugh he sounds annoying. I have a 'pretty high up stressful job', as does DH but neither of us thinks this gazumps the others or the DCs right to a nice normal homelife. We hybrid work and it's a choice between neighbour/DC noise or other people's phone calls, annoying colleagues interrupting, cleaners and maintenance people in the office. We both cope fine with it. If there is a very specific (maybe once or twice a week) thing where we can't be disturbed we'll facilitate that for the other, but otherwise it's business as usual about the house, just with a courtesy closing of doors when boiling the kettle or whatever other noisy activity may disturb the other.

UnboxedThoughts · 10/08/2022 11:48

You can book rooms in your local library, often for free. Or just find a quiet nook and get on with it. I've worked from home for years and sometimes pop in just for a change of scene.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 10/08/2022 11:46

I've always WFH. One of the positives of COVID has been that this is becoming more normalised. My home is quieter and more pleasant than my office. Mind you, I do my own washing and so put the machine on when it suits me. Wouldn't mind maid service though!

carefullycourageous · 10/08/2022 11:45

MossOwl · 10/08/2022 11:38

The kitchen table really is our only option unfortuanately, there isn't space for a big enough desk elsewhere, I have a small desk I use in the bedroom which barely fits and its too small for him to get his monitors on. I think if he did do the hybrid thing like go in 2 or 3 days a week and then have good noise cancelling headphones he could use when he was home for calls and general working then that would be a good compromise from him as at the moment all the compromise is mine.

I genuinely find it hard to believe there are no other options to having the camera pointed into the kitchen. I WFH during COVID in a very small house - we moved the furniture at the start of the work day and moved it back at the end. Yes it is a PITA but the set up you have at the moment is a PITA.

SeaToSki · 10/08/2022 11:44

Have you thought about buying a bigger desk/table to fit his two monitor set up on in another room?

Can he spin the kitchen table during the day so he sits with his back to the wall and then you cant be seen by his camera

Have you insisted on a compromise so that you can have a life too, rather than everything being his way

gatehouseoffleet · 10/08/2022 11:44

The kitchen table really is our only option unfortuanately, there isn't space for a big enough desk elsewhere

does he HAVE to have two screens? I use a laptop with a screen but I only use the screen, I don't use both screens. I also don't have a big desk but can fit both. So can DH and his desk is smaller than mine.

gatehouseoffleet · 10/08/2022 11:43

OP if he has to work in the kitchen that just isn't acceptable. He has several options:

get a shed in the garden and work there (or a proper garden office)
go into office
go to a local co-working space
find somewhere in the house (it probably does exist = what about your lounge, for example)

You need to say that the kitchen working needs to stop.

MossOwl · 10/08/2022 11:41

I'll ask him about the monitor stands. I also don't want to make this all about my poor husband (though pita he may be) as its clearly an issue for other people as well with other posts and my own experiences in my neighbourhood and that of friends.

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 10/08/2022 11:38

Is there a space elsewhere in the house for a desk? I have a basic desk and it can hold two screens no problem..