Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think residential areas and homes are not meant to be offices?

165 replies

MossOwl · 10/08/2022 09:57

Inspired by the thread where the poster whose neighbour had a very important job and was in very important meetings all day and please could she keep her kids out there own garden, outrageous if you ask me!

I think there is a problem with homes and residential areas being turned into offices. My husband also has a very important job with important meetings and I am expected to go about the house not making any noise, I can't hoover or run the washing machine even watching TV is out of bounds. He also complains about neighbours cutting their grass or getting noisy work done to their homes and even the noise of kids playing out. I tell him to go into the office but he hates the 45 min commute and says he prefers working at home at the kitchen table as opposed to going into the office.

Another neighbour has also complained about the noise from their neighbours during the day, during the school holidays, their neighbours have three kids and they have the garden set up with a trampoline, paddling pool and swings which can be noisy but what else are kids supposed to be doing in the summer?

When other neighbours were on holiday they were out in the garden and were playing some music it was kind of loud but they don't play it all year round they were just trying to enjoy a staycation and they got people shouting to keep the noise down as they were working.

I've told my husband that if he wants to keep working from home and not get disturbed then we will have to move to an area with less neighbours where he can have his own office cabin in the garden. During lockdowns and the pandemic we all made the best of it but now office workers do have a choice to go back but many would rather still work at home and expect their families and neighbours to tiptoe around them.

AIBU to think that homes and residential areas are not really suitable to be offices?

OP posts:
Imreallysnowedunder · 10/08/2022 17:41

@ApplesandBunions it would be unusual for a neighbour to impact on me really, outside of loud music and so on. But I do think that when you’re sharing your living space with someone else’s workspace it can be quite suffocating and often the person who is working genuinely doesn’t realise.

JustLyra · 10/08/2022 17:39

I think it’s actually a combination of factors.

Some people, and industries, aren’t suited to people WFH in a residential setting.

DH works from home 50% of the time, but he gets that it’s a home first and foremost. He fits in round us (I’m a SAHP to a child with significant needs). He had to accept that the nurses will be in, the physio will be in, deliveries will come, DD will make noise, the older kids will make noise after school etc. He’s working in their space so he has to deal with that.

That said we’re lucky he’s senior enough that he could say “no, I’m not having three screens as there’s no space” and has the clout where he can still say “Sorry, my DD is having a bad day so you may hear some noise from downstairs” and if not be a problem.

My BIL is having an awful time because he was never expecting to wfh. He’s on the kitchen table and his job is precarious so while he’s searching for another SIL and their DC are tip toeing around and they’re all struggling. He’s only allowed back in the office one day a fortnight atm as they’ve sold off the bulk of their space and it’s now a fixed time you’re allowed in

I am more focused in the later afternoon which is when he is winding down and starts popping into see what I am up to every 5 minutes disturbing me when I am working, then I get ratty at him and feel bad”

This does make your DH sound like a bit of a dick though OP.

He who mustn’t be disturbed should have some respect for your job and not disturb you either. You shouldn’t be the one feeling bad.

TheOrigRights · 10/08/2022 17:30

Lunar270 · 10/08/2022 17:11

If your husband's job was that important OP, he wouldn't be working from home!

How do you come to that conclusion?

Lunar270 · 10/08/2022 17:11

If your husband's job was that important OP, he wouldn't be working from home!

QuebecBagnet · 10/08/2022 16:48

You’re not wrong. Lockdown was a nightmare. Dh bagged the spare room as an office so I was in the open plan kitchen/dining room. Doing live lectures. Dh used to wander in and turn the kettle on and nobody could hear me! Then he was grumpy when I banned him from cups of tea during lectures! 😆. I’ve got a garden office now.

Jolinar · 10/08/2022 16:44

Jeez. My DH has an "important job" (wtf). But he understands this is our home first and his office second. Same when I WFH.

Tomnooktoldmeto · 10/08/2022 15:31

I voted you’re not unreasonable but many firms like my DH’s sold their office space off during the pandemic and moved to a hybrid working model

DH’s nearest office is now 90mins away so he only goes in once a fortnight

However I do think your DH is really unreasonable. During the pandemic I had DH DS and DD all working over the internet from home both DC in their rooms and DH in our dining room

No one disturbed anyone else or impacted me because they all had noise cancelling headphones which are absolutely essential in this set up

it can work but requires everyone to play their part and not impose on others

ApplesandBunions · 10/08/2022 15:23

Imreallysnowedunder · 10/08/2022 14:07

No, I agree OP, although your husband doesn’t sound great tbh.

I haven’t read the other responses but I imagine they will be insisting the problem is the husband working in a communal area, and of course it sort of is (and being an arse) but generally speaking I don’t think WFH is great. Problem is, the people it isn’t great for are other family members and neighbours. The person WFH loves it so fiercely defends it … Will RTFT now [smile ]

Alternatively, you could have any number of neighbours who've been wfh for years but you aren't aware of it because actually it's no problem whatsoever for you.

Not necessarily you specifically obv, you might live in the middle of nowhere, be familiar with all your neighbours or whatever. But generally.

FictionalCharacter · 10/08/2022 15:21

MossOwl · 10/08/2022 12:16

@FictionalCharacter Well this is what I think as well, that if he went in 2 or 3 days a week and then got the noise cancelling headphones it would be a big improvement but you should see his pained expression when i ask him if he's going into the office at some point during the week its like I just asked him to eat shit.

There is also the issue of our different patterns of energy so that he is more mentally focused in the morning and I am more focused in the later afternoon which is when he is winding down and starts popping into see what I am up to every 5 minutes disturbing me when I am working, then I get ratty at him and feel bad. It was all so much better when he worked in the office!

“the issue of our different patterns of energy so that he is more mentally focused in the morning and I am more focused in the later afternoon which is when he is winding down and starts popping into see what I am up to every 5 minutes disturbing me when I am working, then I get ratty at him and feel bad”

No no no! HE disturbs YOU when you are working and YOU feel bad? He doesn’t respect your work AT ALL but wants you to bend over backwards to accommodate his. This is nothing to do with “different patterns of energy”, it’s about him believing he and his work are much more important than you and your work, and he’s making sure you know it.

This is horrible disrespect from him and I’m sorry, you’re letting him do it.

Nyfluff · 10/08/2022 15:18

I need to WFH due to disability, my neighbour has been doing loud construction for 15 months. Whenever that noise stops (it continues over the weekend), the kids or dog are making noise. Their construction has broken some of my property. I bought a detached house in a predominantly elderly neighbourhood thinking I would be OK, but there is an unfortunate history with these particular neighbours being a nuisance/very inconsiderate/double standards. They believe they're Very Important just like the OPs neighbour on the other thread. It makes it utterly miserable and I hate living beside people like them. I still find myself being considerate of them and go along with their entitled requests that are difficult for me.

I think there should be some compromise within your own home e.g. not vacuuming or playing loud music during office hours, but normal cleaning, cooking and watching TV is fine if that's what you normally do. I don't see how that level of noise is any worse than the normal noise of an office.

CoffeeWithCheese · 10/08/2022 15:11

I wear loop earplugs most of the day just to calm my jangling nerves from the constant meeting calls a bit, watch TV with subtitles on on mute or have noise cancelling headphones on full-time. It's the expectation and assumption from employers that the rest of people's families will just make this work (and yes DH's not wanting to go back to the office as well) that really pisses me off.

CoffeeWithCheese · 10/08/2022 15:10

CravenRaven · 10/08/2022 13:23

I think the chief problem is that people chose their homes for a specific set of criteria that suited their budget and family lifestyle. However, the pandemic has changed the criteria.

e.g. if you bought a house with enough bedrooms for all but none spare and now need an office space, it's just no longer suitable in the way that it was.

But the spiralling costs of houses and other things mean that, for many people, the option to simply choose again and move home is not realistic. So they have to make do instead.

I've wfh for some years so my house was chosen with a room specifically to use as an office/spare room hybrid. There are 2 other adults in the house most days and all the surrounding houses have children. There is noise - but nowhere near as much as I find in an office.

If there is noise outside, I close the window. If there is noise inside, I close the door.

This - and it's rare to see a poster on MN actually "getting" how the goalposts have shifted and not everyone is in a position to move away from neighbours, or have a spare room or understairs nook to turn into an office.

We did not earn much when we bought this place - bought it at the absolute bottom of the market and got incredibly lucky to be able to get it. 2 bed house - open plan downstairs - and it worked well for us plus one child, and we've made it work for two kids while I retrained and career switched - but we'd hit the point where it was getting too small before the pandemic struck and were trying to eek out a couple more years of it. The kids have the large bedroom as they've got more stuff and benefit from the space and we essentially have the box room, with fitted wardrobes to absolutely maximize the space in there already. Can't go up into the loft as we don't have the roof height to do so (or spare cash) and there's not really space for any garden solution (plus our neighbours are always out with music blaring).

Cobbled through the pandemic with me doing a uni degree in the conservatory under a slightly leaky roof, and DH on a desk in an alcove in the lounge - but he's now stuck with a permanent "hybrid" arrangement of one day a week in the office and bloody hell this summer's been grueling - with him complaining about noise, the kids wanting to be able to be kids, me caught in the cross fire (waiting on start date for my job) and I fucking hate living like this. Going to take a few months of my new job working before we're in a position to look to move house and they're going to suck!

Believe me I'm amazingly good at creating space where there's none, and I've eeked out so much longer in this house than most would have done, but no amount of amazing desks and kallax holes can find a spare room where there is none.

Adversity · 10/08/2022 15:03

DH WFH most days and worked for an entire year at home. He is head of his dept. Next door was renovated for 4 months by the developer that bought it. He has noise cancelling headphones. He just lets me know if he is in calls by the door being shut, if he isn’t he leaves it ajar.

Arbesque · 10/08/2022 15:01

Where are all these super quiet offices that so many claim to work in? Any where I've worked you have to listen to other people's chatter and phone calls, people walking up and down the corridor on mobiles, roadworks going on somewhere, etc etc

It's no quieter than working from home.

Isonthecase · 10/08/2022 14:55

Yeah, we also have rules in the office about twerps who think everyone has to tiptoe around them for their Very Important Meeting and that they have the right to disturb the whole floor. You do wonder what they're like at home when you see their behaviour to people they perceive as less important than them.

ApplesandBunions · 10/08/2022 14:48

KettrickenSmiled · 10/08/2022 13:01

I think there is a problem with homes and residential areas being turned into offices. My husband also has a very important job with important meetings and I am expected to go about the house not making any noise, I can't hoover or run the washing machine even watching TV is out of bounds. He also complains about neighbours cutting their grass or getting noisy work done to their homes and even the noise of kids playing out. I tell him to go into the office but he hates the 45 min commute and says he prefers working at home at the kitchen table as opposed to going into the office.

You don't have a problem because homes & residential areas are being used as offices.
You have a problem because your DH is self-important twat who genuinely believes that his wishes are more important than anybody else's.

Exactly. This isn't a wfh problem, it's an entitled unrealistic twat problem.

waterrat · 10/08/2022 14:45

This is just more attacks on children using their own neighbourhoods to play - now they have to worry about home workers.

When I work in the office - it's a real hubub, lots of people talking on the phone etc / having meetings in small groups

There is no reason with headphones/ insulation etc that anyone should be bothered by a few hours each summer holiday day of kids playing..

cestlavielife · 10/08/2022 14:42

Put dh in a soundproof pod
www.busypod.co.uk/

Up to him to make wfh work
Either put up with domestic sounds or make soundproof pod

maddening · 10/08/2022 14:09

I wfh (hybrid) and have no issue with other people using the house as a house, I close the door and wear a headset for meetings, would have to be v unreasonable behaviour to get to the point that it was annoying me.

I also have no issue with reasonable sound outside, and if something like major building works were going on and it was so bad I couldn't concentrate I would move to another area of the house or go in to the office.

WeAreTheHeroes · 10/08/2022 14:08

YABU - it's some people who aren't suited to wfh. There's no issue re: admin work from home from an insurance perspective, etc and if you have the space. The people who complain about the noise of ordinary life whilst they're working - and they're always men - should either accept it and shut up or go into the office. Or rent an office somewhere.

Imreallysnowedunder · 10/08/2022 14:07

No, I agree OP, although your husband doesn’t sound great tbh.

I haven’t read the other responses but I imagine they will be insisting the problem is the husband working in a communal area, and of course it sort of is (and being an arse) but generally speaking I don’t think WFH is great. Problem is, the people it isn’t great for are other family members and neighbours. The person WFH loves it so fiercely defends it … Will RTFT now [smile ]

ErrolTheDragon · 10/08/2022 14:04

It's not so much that residential homes aren't suitable to be offices, it's more that people like your husband aren't suitable to work from home.

Yeah...

I've wfh ever since I moved here in 1995. It's a residential area, of course I expect neighbours to go about their lives including kids, dogs etc.
Theres a clue in the description - it's working from home. Which is also DHs home and was DDs. If I need quiet I shut the office door, and I use a headset for meetings.

Trying to WFH if you don't have a room you can use as an office with a door you can shut isn't likely to work well long term if it's also home to other people.

Movinghouseatlast · 10/08/2022 13:59

My neighbour is a Judge and she manages to work from home in a terraced house with lots of people walking straight past her house all day!

Butteryflakycrust83 · 10/08/2022 13:58

Its only a problem if you are self entitled and think that YOU are the most important person in the house/street who couldn't possibly be disturbed.

No TV? I would tell my DH to do one if he said that while I was home.

He needs to make a room an office and get headphones.

KettrickenSmiled · 10/08/2022 13:51

Thank you @Scarlettpixie that was a more gracious response than I likely deserved Wink

However, I now need to take another point to task:
i was really responding to the OP who seemed to be under the impression that you couldn’t dry washing outside if it was done in the evening.
According to Mumsnet Lore, you CANNOT leaving washing hanging outdoors overnight. It leads to sinister stuff like your clothes getting darked on, & - horror of horrors - spiders may rub their willies on it.

Truth!