Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our attitude towards the elderly is bad in the UK?

110 replies

Fifife · 10/08/2022 09:56

Currently on holiday in Crete, it's my first time here. I can't believe the difference you see the very elderly all the time at the tavernas sitting relaxing with their friends and friends. Playing games together, laughing joking they seem to be very much still involved in society. It's made me sad , the elderly seem to become invisible at home. What could we do to change this ?

OP posts:
Sartre · 10/08/2022 13:42

I think a lot depends on the elderly person and how much they want to go out and get involved with stuff. DH’s Grandad is in his mid 80s and he’s always out and about, still goes to the local pub to chat to people and goes out for a curry once a week with friends too. I know my friend’s grandparents are similar and are involved with a couple of local clubs too. My Gran is totally different, especially since covid and barely leaves the house. She’s only 77 which I don’t even consider to be ludicrously old nowadays but she has no life anymore and just sits at home alone using covid as an excuse despite having four vaccines… I feel sorry for her but we’ve tried to help numerous times and she isn’t up for accepting the help.

karalimed · 10/08/2022 13:28

Because this is the society that the elderly have created.

They had decades to teach their own children to be kind to the elderly, to foster community structures that encourage elderly people to participate, to keep housing costs low so that communities and families could stay together and that elderly people could be more easily cared for, to properly fund the NHS and social care.

But they chose not to do any of that. Instead they voted for Thatcher when she said "there is no such thing as society" and here we are 35 years later.

Those Greek elderly people put an effort into sustaining a culture that respects elderly people.

Mascia · 10/08/2022 13:28

Hardbackwriter · 10/08/2022 11:43

Let's be clear - 'adults' never cared for the elderly, women did. Nowhere seems to have solved the problem of how to care for older people outside institutions while also allowing women to have lives doing things other than caring for others.

That’s also a valid point.

Mascia · 10/08/2022 13:26

kisaki333 · 10/08/2022 11:27

Yes but the reverse is also true. I remember an English colleague of mine being super excited that her inlaws (fully retired) had agreed to take care of her DC one day per week! In my culture it's basically implied thr grandparents help in any way they can. You can't have it both ways: don't help your children once they are adults and then expect them to help out when you are old....

I agree with this and being originally from outside the UK (and Western Europe) I do sometimes see a sort of disconnect between generations here.

I remember there was a thread here during the Covid lockdowns where a woman said her family was beginning to fall apart will all the homeschooling and working from home. She was upset because her mum had refused to join their bubble to be able to help with the kids a bit.
Several people told her that it wasn’t her mum’s job to help out. I found that attitude rather cold - if I remember correctly the mum wasn’t particularly old, she just didn’t feel like helping.

gatehouseoffleet · 10/08/2022 13:07

I wonder if there's a link between cognitive decline and lack of involvement in society

there absolutely is - covid lockdowns made dementia and other cognitive decline worse

but lots of elderly people do have a social life; it will depend how healthy they are though, if they can still drive and if there is decent public transport and local facilities

GeekyThings · 10/08/2022 13:00

I think probably a large chunk of it is down to poverty - there are very high levels of elderly poverty in the UK, which can be isolating in the extreme, it makes travel and socializing difficult, and it also increases the likelihood of poor health, which then further isolates them.

I have noticed (I'm not originally from the UK) that there is more disdain in general towards older people and the elderly here than anywhere else I've lived, particularly from younger people. The number of times I've heard someone just scratching 20 that they won't respect anyone until that person's earned it is sadly quite high. They also don't seem to see the irony that they actually haven't lived long enough to 'earn' it themselves, and the elderly person has probably done a thousand more things just by virtue of longevity, so really you should automatically assume most of them have done something for that respect by now!

But still, I think the main thing driving it is poverty, which increases their ill health and isolation.

PoolSquid · 10/08/2022 12:56

I think if you actually look at research, UK ranks better than Greece regarding care of the elderly.

Don't try to draw conclusions based on some people sitting outside cafes in a holiday area!

Next you'll be insisting that only the English ship the elderly off to care homes.

cuddlybear21 · 10/08/2022 12:46

One difference in the UK is that uptake in university education has meant people move away from their family and then get a job in say a third city. Therefore, families live very far away form each other. In Europe - families live close to relatives so it's more natural to keep supporting each other. Unlike in the UK

SommerTen · 10/08/2022 12:37

I think it often depends on the older person and how social they are.
My colleagues Nan (97) is often out with her family having drinks and enjoying life! Even though she does have minor strokes now & again.
But my late Nan at 90 wouldn't leave the flat even to go for coffee as she'd become very paranoid... turned out she had dementia.

I know lots of people in their early - mid 70s who socialise but I struggle to think of them in the same age bracket as the very elderly.

Dilbertian · 10/08/2022 12:28

My parents, uncles and aunts, all over 80y old, live in England but are frequent visitors to Israel. They all notice a huge difference in the way they are treated in each country. They are far more invisible in England.

In Israel they get ushered to the fronts of queues by other customers and have doors held for them, for example. And this in a country with a well-deserved reputation for brashness and pushiness! Many local facilities issue them with priority cards as well.

In England the expectation seems to be that they will sit quietly and wait their turn, whenever it may come, in everything.

My parents have also commented that the most courteous and attentive service they receive here in England is often from immigrants, who appear to have infinite patience for the elderly.

SaintHelena · 10/08/2022 12:23

Must be that healthy Mediterranean diet!

I think there is possibly a bigger range of behaviours in the U.K. - so rich are off cruising (and the not so rich), fit and healthy are biking, going to the gym, but once you have health problems life will be more restricted.

ilovesooty · 10/08/2022 12:20

You only have to look at the posts on here. In the past week at least one poster has been a hair's breadth away from suggesting anyone over 70 should be killed off.

illiterato · 10/08/2022 12:13

@Jalisco yeah- I think the weather plays a big part in this discrepancy which probably actually isn’t as great as it appears. In Uk they are just socialising behind closed doors as too cold and wet. I guess depends what OP means by elderly but my parents are mid to late 70s and they and their friends are pretty active- DM plays tennis and does Pilates, goes to WI and book club and is active in the church. DF plays lawn bowls 5 days a week. They also have a dog and see people to chat to on their walks most days or arrange to walk with friends . But you wouldn’t see them sitting on a bench much. Their socialising is quite structured.

GingerbreadPerson · 10/08/2022 12:10

and

GingerbreadPerson · 10/08/2022 12:10

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 10/08/2022 10:14

I agree, I'm a nurse and have found with a lot of elderly people it's a case of 'out of sight out of mind' sadly.

It seems that way to me.
My neighbour spent 4 days trying to get an appointment with the GP with minor chest pains/palpitations which were very likely caused by stress. Phoned, was told to call again, then told to call at a certain time, then told to call at a different time, finally broke down on the phone and ended up in an ambulance. She just needed to speak to someone in the first instance instead of being fobbed off.

I see it a lot, older people being shoved out of the way in shops and streets, an ignored, but haven't ever seen it in other countries, where age is respected.

The attitude to many things in this country is disgusting.

Loopsa · 10/08/2022 12:09

Arbesque · 10/08/2022 12:01

There doesn't seem to be anything in between living independently at home or moving into a nursing home, unless you have lots of money.
Real care in the community - a nurse or doctor dropping in regularly etc has disappeared. The logistics of modern life mean adult children often don't live nearby or have to work full time to pay mortgages, long working hours and both partners having to work mean many neighbours don't know each other any longer.

It really is sad to see elderly people moving into care homes who, with a bit more support, could remain in their homes ir with family.

There is actually a lot of support where I live (UK) to allow people to stay in their homes for as long as possible, some people choose to go into residential care for social reasons as well as health ones, but even the type of accommodations available can vary, there are different levels of supported accommodation that can be accessed. There is a bigger problem of people who need full time support not getting it until their situation is dire.

Jalisco · 10/08/2022 12:06

There's some truth in this. But equally I would be socialising outside with my mates at the street cafes etc., if it didn't rain / wasn't freezing for 10 months of the year, followed by everyone complaining about the heat the other two months.

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 12:06

Arbesque · 10/08/2022 12:01

There doesn't seem to be anything in between living independently at home or moving into a nursing home, unless you have lots of money.
Real care in the community - a nurse or doctor dropping in regularly etc has disappeared. The logistics of modern life mean adult children often don't live nearby or have to work full time to pay mortgages, long working hours and both partners having to work mean many neighbours don't know each other any longer.

It really is sad to see elderly people moving into care homes who, with a bit more support, could remain in their homes ir with family.

No, they couldn’t. Their homes are often the family homes they’ve had for years. Too big, stairs, steep driveways etc. They seem to get very emotionally attached to them and eventually end up in a vicious cycle of falling, hospital, back to unsuitable house, another fall. It costs the NHS a fortune.

And what family can live with them in their homes? Many are widowed, their kids have kids/jobs etc themselves.

Arbesque · 10/08/2022 12:01

There doesn't seem to be anything in between living independently at home or moving into a nursing home, unless you have lots of money.
Real care in the community - a nurse or doctor dropping in regularly etc has disappeared. The logistics of modern life mean adult children often don't live nearby or have to work full time to pay mortgages, long working hours and both partners having to work mean many neighbours don't know each other any longer.

It really is sad to see elderly people moving into care homes who, with a bit more support, could remain in their homes ir with family.

BlackBagABorderBinLiner · 10/08/2022 12:00

My skilled working class parents did nothing but moan about work in my childhood. in retirement they moan about the garden, putting out the bins, housework, getting the home food delivery into the kitchen.

They don't play any kind of role in looking after my kids and voted for Brexit despite both DH and I working across borders. Apparently the alleged threat of a European Army (we've heard this reason a few times from people too polite to be openly racist) was more important than our careers and industries.

My parents do hang out with a lot of other retired people of similar age, wealth and background, this helps insulate them further.

I journey through multiple emotional stages towards my parents having passed through respect, gratitude, tolerance, anger, ennui, duty and am now in indifference with boredom and resignation. I think i burned through grief a long time ago.

But I'm connected with lots of older people through a hobby - they all seem more balanced, more informed, more flexible and tolerant...... they warm my heart so its not a stone beating away in there.

arrogantorwhat37 · 10/08/2022 11:57

Louise56 · 10/08/2022 10:54

Surely it’s up to the old people? If they want to go out they can. I see old people out and about quite a lot where I live.

What a stunningly naive remark. Not all older people are physically or cognitively able to get out and about.
Remember tho' on MN, old people are just waiting for the DCs of MN posters to grow up so tjey can provide care for them...

crosstalk · 10/08/2022 11:57

Another one here who sees plenty of older people in the cafes and pubs and in various groups like WEA lectures, WI etc. There's also an impressive degree of neighbourliness in terms of looking out for/shopping for older people. Small rural town. However, a lot of it is not family - more friends - since families can often be far flung. In my own family we're mostly many hours away from each other but my great aunt, who lived close to 4 of her children and 6 grandchildren was brilliantly supported by them when she was frail.

BigWoollyJumpers · 10/08/2022 11:55

Down in deepest darkest Surrey, where health and wealth is very high in the elderly, they are all out and about in their cars (scary), and always pack the pubs, garden centres, and coffee shops. In DM's road (she has since died), but they were all 85+ living independent lives, going on cruises, in choirs, musical instrument clubs (ukelele's seem popular), walking groups, yoga, you name it. As others have said, in certain parts of the country, they seem to be keeping the economy going!

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 11:43

Yes agreed @Hardbackwriter

Hardbackwriter · 10/08/2022 11:43

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 11:09

I also think our new ‘way of life’ - having kids much later in life, less of them, working mums, astronomical prices of everything - means people are not in a great position to treat the elderly like they are treated elsewhere. Adults are in much less of a position to care for elderly relatives.

Let's be clear - 'adults' never cared for the elderly, women did. Nowhere seems to have solved the problem of how to care for older people outside institutions while also allowing women to have lives doing things other than caring for others.

Swipe left for the next trending thread