Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our attitude towards the elderly is bad in the UK?

110 replies

Fifife · 10/08/2022 09:56

Currently on holiday in Crete, it's my first time here. I can't believe the difference you see the very elderly all the time at the tavernas sitting relaxing with their friends and friends. Playing games together, laughing joking they seem to be very much still involved in society. It's made me sad , the elderly seem to become invisible at home. What could we do to change this ?

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 14:55

Mascia · 10/08/2022 14:48

Your mum sound so much like my MIL!
Waiting for us to take her places and then barely walk once we’re there and just wait in the car…

She‘s also hardly engaging with her grandchildren - she loves them and wants to see them, but then she just sits there watching telly. I‘m not expecting her to run around with them, but at least have a chat or read a book together.

i have noticed elderly people seem to be less tolerant of small children in the U.K. I don’t know if it’s because they can’t really remember how their own kids were at that age, but it’s all ‘when I was younger children never tantrummed’ ‘when I was younger children were better behaved’ etc.

in other countries they seem to love small children and don’t just see them as ‘there to spoil the peace’.

so maybe it’s a two way thing.

Mascia · 10/08/2022 14:48

Limesaregreen · 10/08/2022 13:56

@Mascia exactly. It’s the person’s attitude. Just because someone is getting on a bit or frail, if they are not engaged or interested in anything else it makes it difficult. My DM wouldn’t go anywhere too far and barely talk when we took her places. We still do but her cognitive decline I’m sure is exacerbated because she has followed the same routine with little interaction so actually has nothing to talk about. My friends’ parents on the other hand are engaged with life and participate as much as possible.

Your mum sound so much like my MIL!
Waiting for us to take her places and then barely walk once we’re there and just wait in the car…

She‘s also hardly engaging with her grandchildren - she loves them and wants to see them, but then she just sits there watching telly. I‘m not expecting her to run around with them, but at least have a chat or read a book together.

Fifife · 10/08/2022 14:29

Tropicalsquirrel · 10/08/2022 14:23

I live in Singapore and find the city centre/restaurants/all public spaces are much more family and all-age friendly throughout the day, and most noticeably in the evenings, than in the U.K. Same in Vietnam, and in Italy. In the U.K. the drinking culture seems to make city centres no go zones after 6pm which is such a pity.

You also get groups of older people gathering here in the void decks (public spaces) under the Housing Development Board blocks of flats (imagine council flats but 80% of the population live in them and there’s none of the stigma you get in the U.K.) to play mahjong, chat to friends, eat, or do hobbies like showing off their songbirds.

Plus there’s fundamental differences in how older people are seen- filial piety is enshrined in law, with parents able to sue adult children for support if they are not giving them enough, housing is often built with multi-generational living in mind. It’s not perfect, as older Singaporeans are often significantly less well off than their children due to the way the country developed, and there are issues with elder abuse etc, but it seems to work well.

My MIL is Singaporean and I've visited quite a few times and I agree. The elderly are more visible there as well and seen with all age groups. I think the UK has a very individualistic society.

OP posts:
Tropicalsquirrel · 10/08/2022 14:23

I live in Singapore and find the city centre/restaurants/all public spaces are much more family and all-age friendly throughout the day, and most noticeably in the evenings, than in the U.K. Same in Vietnam, and in Italy. In the U.K. the drinking culture seems to make city centres no go zones after 6pm which is such a pity.

You also get groups of older people gathering here in the void decks (public spaces) under the Housing Development Board blocks of flats (imagine council flats but 80% of the population live in them and there’s none of the stigma you get in the U.K.) to play mahjong, chat to friends, eat, or do hobbies like showing off their songbirds.

Plus there’s fundamental differences in how older people are seen- filial piety is enshrined in law, with parents able to sue adult children for support if they are not giving them enough, housing is often built with multi-generational living in mind. It’s not perfect, as older Singaporeans are often significantly less well off than their children due to the way the country developed, and there are issues with elder abuse etc, but it seems to work well.

ilovesooty · 10/08/2022 14:22

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 14:14

Anecdotal ‘I know an elderly person who voted Labour’ doesn’t mean anything. The fact is a 75 year old was twice as likely as a 25 year old to vote Conservative at the last election.

Part of the problem is that too many younger people don't vote at all. Over 75s do.

durianne · 10/08/2022 14:21

karalimed · 10/08/2022 13:28

Because this is the society that the elderly have created.

They had decades to teach their own children to be kind to the elderly, to foster community structures that encourage elderly people to participate, to keep housing costs low so that communities and families could stay together and that elderly people could be more easily cared for, to properly fund the NHS and social care.

But they chose not to do any of that. Instead they voted for Thatcher when she said "there is no such thing as society" and here we are 35 years later.

Those Greek elderly people put an effort into sustaining a culture that respects elderly people.

It's a mixture of factors, for sure and will vary a great deal depending on health, wealth, lifestyle, etc. It's obviously a generalisation but I do agree with with what @karalimed has written. We live in a selfish society which has been created by the older generation. They (en mass, obviously), bought into Thatcher's ideas, there is no such thing as society, etc. Personally, I think that's a terrible way to think and believe that it is to everyone's benefit to have lots of inter generational mixing but that is not the way the UK works. It's all very well Asian posters (or others) saying they are surprised by the way the elderly are treated in the UK but that's because many want to 'enjoy their retirement' or 'do their own thing', etc or retire to Cornwall without thinking things through. Their adult daughters (and sons) are under a lot of pressure to work nowadays and tend to have children later so it's harder and if you have isolated yourself and not been supportive or shown an interest over the years, relationships tend to be much less close or even deteriorate completely.

ilovesooty · 10/08/2022 14:20

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 14:14

Anecdotal ‘I know an elderly person who voted Labour’ doesn’t mean anything. The fact is a 75 year old was twice as likely as a 25 year old to vote Conservative at the last election.

I'm not disputing the fact that Conservative voting is skewed by age, but I resent the lazy stereotyping that goes on and the resultant feeling that as an older person I have to justify not fitting the stereotype.

The few people I know who vote Tory and voted for Brexit are almost all younger than I am.

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 14:18

For the record my 91 year old Granddad voted remain and loathed Boris and his cronies, so I am well aware that not every elderly person holds Conservative/Brexiteer views but the stats speak for themselves.

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 14:14

ilovesooty · 10/08/2022 14:06

There are plenty on this site alone who voted for Brexit and state their intention of voting Conservative as they did last time. I suspect most of them are a lot younger than I am.

Anecdotal ‘I know an elderly person who voted Labour’ doesn’t mean anything. The fact is a 75 year old was twice as likely as a 25 year old to vote Conservative at the last election.

ilovesooty · 10/08/2022 14:11

Babdoc · 10/08/2022 14:06

I’m at the “younger end” of elderly - 66.
I play in a table tennis club where two 86 year olds regularly thrash me off the table!
Similarly, at my bridge club, many of the top players are in their 80s. They also regularly play golf.
My church has a mix of parishioners from 3 to 92 years old, and runs a pop in tea morning popular with the older ones.( Who also take a turn on the tea rota). Our Sunday school teacher recently celebrated 50 years in post.
I think because of the climate, you don’t see the elderly outside so much as in, say, Greece. But you’ll find us at a multitude of evening classes, social clubs, yoga, tai chi, etc, and mob handed in garden centres!

My mother was active in the church and played table tennis weekly until she was 90 and dementia took over. She never drove but travelled all over the place by bus and walking, was in a drama group and had a friendship circle largely much younger than she was.

She didn't vote Conservative and I don't imagine for one moment she'd have voted for Brexit either.

HibiscusIsland · 10/08/2022 14:07

I think the opposite. I think we tend to idolise the elderly and think they are all sweet and lovely and were hard working and deserving of help, but demonise the young and think they are all lazy, scrounging student loans etc and deserving of making things ever harder for them. In reality, some elderly are lovely and were hard working, some are horrible and the same for the young. That's certainly how the press portray different ages.

Babdoc · 10/08/2022 14:06

I’m at the “younger end” of elderly - 66.
I play in a table tennis club where two 86 year olds regularly thrash me off the table!
Similarly, at my bridge club, many of the top players are in their 80s. They also regularly play golf.
My church has a mix of parishioners from 3 to 92 years old, and runs a pop in tea morning popular with the older ones.( Who also take a turn on the tea rota). Our Sunday school teacher recently celebrated 50 years in post.
I think because of the climate, you don’t see the elderly outside so much as in, say, Greece. But you’ll find us at a multitude of evening classes, social clubs, yoga, tai chi, etc, and mob handed in garden centres!

ilovesooty · 10/08/2022 14:06

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 14:01

But most did. Thats point. Most of them vote Tory, most of them voted for Brexit.

They have been actively voting against the interests of their kids and grandkids for what? A trip down memory lane to a time that no longer exists?

There are plenty on this site alone who voted for Brexit and state their intention of voting Conservative as they did last time. I suspect most of them are a lot younger than I am.

ilovesooty · 10/08/2022 14:03

I've got a friend who's 87. She's had to stop driving in the last year due to eyesight problems but she still works and is one of the most stimulating and interesting people I know.

She still has a pretty good social life too.

Incidentally she's voted Labour all her life.

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 14:01

ilovesooty · 10/08/2022 13:58

Here we go. Of course young people are getting a rough deal but plenty of older people don't vote Tory.

But most did. Thats point. Most of them vote Tory, most of them voted for Brexit.

They have been actively voting against the interests of their kids and grandkids for what? A trip down memory lane to a time that no longer exists?

MermaidCheeks · 10/08/2022 13:59

The UK has inferior culture when it comes to how our children and elderly are treated and viewed.
I haven't RTFT and although I can't put my finger on why, I've definitely noticed a big negative difference between us and Mediterranean countries.

ilovesooty · 10/08/2022 13:58

Stellaris22 · 10/08/2022 13:53

I find it hard to have a particularly caring attitude when you look at the society we live in now. Young people with huge amounts of debt, unable to afford their own homes and struggling to live financially.

Perhaps if the older generation were inclined to vote for parties that don’t just financially benefit themselves the younger generation would be more inclined to help out more.

Its perfectly understandable for there to be resentment.

Here we go. Of course young people are getting a rough deal but plenty of older people don't vote Tory.

Technosaurus · 10/08/2022 13:57

I work in funerals so hear a lot of life stories. Seems to me to be two types of growing old:

  1. Getting out there having a ball
  2. Stuck inside waiting to die Thankfully, in my experience it's an even split between the two but there doesn't seem to be much of a grey area in between, sadly. The major determining factor between the two being health. If you're feeling alright, you're more likely to go out. If you've got a myriad tablets to take and find walking far a struggle, or indeed if you have to look after your husband/wife who is afflicted, you're more likely to stay in. The mind follows the body. Even for people in category 1, it's a slippery slope to category 2 that's hard to reverse - whether they be long term or simply a loss of confidence in going out following a fall etc. They simply lose interest in going out, socialising, making friends etc. Covid has also put a huge blocker up for many people.

I would agree with PP's that something as trivial as the weather may make the difference between the UK and abroad, I regularly hear "she wouldn't go out from December to March in case she slipped" style comments.

There's also the issue of general geography. The UK's cities and towns are largely quite sprawling, and public transport isn't brilliant outside of London. It's also quite common for people to move in later life to be nearer children/grandchildren, so they lose their friendship network overnight - regardless of one's age it's hard to start from scratch. I'd wager in Crete the villages are much smaller and it's more common for the kids to move to big cities for work with no expectation that Grandma will follow them.

It's up to each and every one of us to cherish our older relatives as best we can, but I don't think it's a nationwide 'sin'...

Limesaregreen · 10/08/2022 13:56

@Mascia exactly. It’s the person’s attitude. Just because someone is getting on a bit or frail, if they are not engaged or interested in anything else it makes it difficult. My DM wouldn’t go anywhere too far and barely talk when we took her places. We still do but her cognitive decline I’m sure is exacerbated because she has followed the same routine with little interaction so actually has nothing to talk about. My friends’ parents on the other hand are engaged with life and participate as much as possible.

ilovesooty · 10/08/2022 13:56

karalimed · 10/08/2022 13:28

Because this is the society that the elderly have created.

They had decades to teach their own children to be kind to the elderly, to foster community structures that encourage elderly people to participate, to keep housing costs low so that communities and families could stay together and that elderly people could be more easily cared for, to properly fund the NHS and social care.

But they chose not to do any of that. Instead they voted for Thatcher when she said "there is no such thing as society" and here we are 35 years later.

Those Greek elderly people put an effort into sustaining a culture that respects elderly people.

That's a bit of a sweeping statement
Not all elderly people voted for Thatcher.

spanishsummers · 10/08/2022 13:53

We have a dreadful attitude to elderly people, so I agree with you, OP. And some care homes are shit holes, and more of them are understaffed and poorly paid. Blaming older people for Thatcherism is ignorant, and if some older people are dull to spend time with, maybe their health is changing or they are changing as a result of extended social isolation.

Stellaris22 · 10/08/2022 13:53

I find it hard to have a particularly caring attitude when you look at the society we live in now. Young people with huge amounts of debt, unable to afford their own homes and struggling to live financially.

Perhaps if the older generation were inclined to vote for parties that don’t just financially benefit themselves the younger generation would be more inclined to help out more.

Its perfectly understandable for there to be resentment.

Limesaregreen · 10/08/2022 13:50

@karalimed yup! I agree.

And I also think a lot of it is weather dependent and person dependent. You need to keep working on those social circles throughout life, especially as you get older. My DM moved to be nearer her family but never engaged with her new local community directly when she was fit and able to. There is loads of stuff she could have partaken in but she just waited for her family to visit and take her out places then would complain she’d not seen anyone for days. It must’ve been so isolating for her but it was her own doing.

Mascia · 10/08/2022 13:47

arrogantorwhat37 · 10/08/2022 11:57

What a stunningly naive remark. Not all older people are physically or cognitively able to get out and about.
Remember tho' on MN, old people are just waiting for the DCs of MN posters to grow up so tjey can provide care for them...

I must say I had similar thoughts as @Louise56 based on the OP, since it mentioned elderly people out and about with their friends.

I‘d assume these people are physically and cognitively to do it, but they also have the will to be out and about, and that makes a difference.

My own MIL lives in a different part of the UK, but whenever we visit/ pick her up to visit us/ go on holiday together we try to include her as much as possible, but she seems to be withdrawing more and more into a „feeble old lady“ routine, disconnected from her surroundings, which doesn’t exactly make spending time together easier… It’s not a recent thing either, she’s had that tendency for quite a while now.

Whereas a friend of ours is similar age like my MIL, but seems to be much more connected to life, with hobbies, friends and so on.

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 13:46

karalimed · 10/08/2022 13:28

Because this is the society that the elderly have created.

They had decades to teach their own children to be kind to the elderly, to foster community structures that encourage elderly people to participate, to keep housing costs low so that communities and families could stay together and that elderly people could be more easily cared for, to properly fund the NHS and social care.

But they chose not to do any of that. Instead they voted for Thatcher when she said "there is no such thing as society" and here we are 35 years later.

Those Greek elderly people put an effort into sustaining a culture that respects elderly people.

True but you’ll be criticised for saying it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread