Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our attitude towards the elderly is bad in the UK?

110 replies

Fifife · 10/08/2022 09:56

Currently on holiday in Crete, it's my first time here. I can't believe the difference you see the very elderly all the time at the tavernas sitting relaxing with their friends and friends. Playing games together, laughing joking they seem to be very much still involved in society. It's made me sad , the elderly seem to become invisible at home. What could we do to change this ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
abs12 · 15/08/2022 12:11

Always a choice. However it's hardly that simple. Your comment is fairly dismissive. Elderly are often marginalised in society, alienated. Imagine knowing you're not as strong as you were and tire easily, it makes going out hard. Imagine not knowing how to use an ATM or even where to go at the bank to get money out? Imagine having no family to support you and worrying about spending money on an outing. Imagine hearing about crime and knowing you are vulnerable so are scared to leave the house. Imagine suffering from loneliness and it impacting your mental health to the point you can't leave the house. Imagine suffering from aging issues such as hearing loss or dementia and not knowing how capable you are of finding your way to the shops, the bus stop, or having your independence taken from you because you can no longer drive. Imagine being abused as you walk to buy milk by a disrespectful and unruly younger generation. imagine not having the confidence to make new friends in this strange new world. Imagine being scared of Covid to the point you feel it's safer not to leave home. Perhaps try thinking outside your own world.

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 16:28

Not sure how this is an attitude towards old people issue

More a cultural issue with how old people see themselves

My MIL is Spanish, and her mother is out all the time. Enjoying the sun, seeing friends, she is 90.

My own grandmother hasn't left the house for weeks as she is afraid to fall

My MILs mother is very much a 'if I fall and die, so be it' person

Lunalae · 11/08/2022 16:25

Keep in mind those old people chose to get up and go to a taverna to meet their friends.

My parents refuse to leave the house. They want to stay indoors and read conspiracy theories. They cut off all their friends years ago. They're utterly miserable and bitter and occasionally the family wonder what to do about them but frankly it's their business, not ours.

I'm sure if older folk want to go and meet friends in a cafe they can do so. But we have less community and less focus on social activity so if they're lonely... eh, I dunno, again it's on them to sort it out really. They're not infants and I'm loathe to infantilise them.

Sceptre86 · 11/08/2022 16:05

Yabu to think there is only one reason. Uk attitudes are very much you don't have children so that they care for you in old age and most don't because that familial or social expectation isn't there. In a lot of cultures, it's a sign of respect and love to take care of your parents when they need it as they did you. Where several generations live together you will see them out with nan or grandad. People move away for uni, for work and don't tend to move back when they have families. There is a bigger emphasis on nuclear families in the UK taking precedence. Only recently did I read a thread about a mil bereaved who's son was going to stay over every weekend for the foreseeable. His wife was not happy with the situation understandably as she wasn't consulted but not one poster suggested they ask mil to come and stay with them for a while till she was in a better headspace.

A simple reason compared to Crete is that depending on where you are on the UK the weather is often more than not wet or cold. If you no longer drive and need to walk to meet friends or get a bus it becomes a less attractive option. If you need to get a taxi it can become an unaffordable option. You've also mentioned you live in a semi rural area so if public transport isn't great or very often then how would older people get about assuming they don't drive?

Stellaris22 · 11/08/2022 13:06

If the older generation want to be treated kindly and with respect then they need to do the same to the younger generation.

Yes, we should care for our grandparents and everyone in society. But the older generation have made it incredibly difficult for the younger generation to help them.

SaintHelena · 11/08/2022 12:57

I've holidayed in Crete and was surprised how few young locals you see - I guess they've moved for work so there may not be another generation of oldies to sit in the sun together.

MereDintofPandiculation · 11/08/2022 10:19

I get what you mean maybe the boomers are a little more selfish than the silent generation That wasn’t what I was saying at all!

WhatNoRaisins · 11/08/2022 10:12

To be fair even in these different cultures there will also be people who are housebound. We need to be careful about how we romanticise family care, as PP have said it almost always falls on women and there will also be elder abuse and neglect going on within these families. People aren't perfect.

apintortwo · 10/08/2022 20:48

I agree with PP you can't generalise.

But the attitude you describe does not only happen in the UK, it's prevalent in other countries too

Stellaris22 · 10/08/2022 20:41

You could argue that no generation is treated well in the UK.

You can’t saddle the younger generation with debt just for wanting an education, unable to buy property and leading stressful lives just to pay bills and expect them to have the time or energy to worry about the elderly.

Of course not every pensioner votes Tory but you can’t deny Tory policy is aimed at pensioners to benefit them. The older generation can’t vote to make younger peoples lives harder and expect help back.

No generation has had it ‘easy’ but home ownership is far less accessible now and the older generation are benefiting from affordable housing that has only gone up in value.

Minimalme · 10/08/2022 20:27

One day my Mum will be very old and people will wonder why two of her daughters never visit, despite living in the next town.

They will think we are selfish but they won't know the truth about how that woman lived her life.

Some people earn their social isolation.

SaintHelena · 10/08/2022 19:09

My dear nan bless her soul babysat us constantly
Did dear nan have a full time job?

SaintHelena · 10/08/2022 19:08

Are all the moaning Minnie's on here really going to age into a close knit , supportive society with their DCs nearby so they can babysit or childmind - judging by the number of holidays they go on they're suddenly going to want to stay home, potter in the garden. We'll see.

Fifife · 10/08/2022 16:49

MereDintofPandiculation · 10/08/2022 16:19

This thread answers its own question, really. Lots of posts saying it’s the elderly’s own fault, for voting for Thatcher, not being interested enough in grandchildren, wanting to do in retirement things they weren’t able to do when working, etc. All of these saying basically “yes, we don’t treat the elderly well, why should we?”

And those seeking to give the contrary view, by examples of the elderly staying active, volunteering etc, are basically giving examples of the elderly helping themselves.

I get what you mean maybe the boomers are a little more selfish than the silent generation. My dear nan bless her soul babysat us constantly in my childhood. I used to go for weeks at a time my own parents have babysat my DD twice since she was born and she's 9 🤣🤣. My MIL who's Singaporean always asks to babysit DD and spend time with her.

OP posts:
cuddlybear21 · 10/08/2022 16:37

@Technosaurus in my case, its not simply the fact my parents voted for Brexit, its constantly hearing about how we (work in public sector) should stop complaining, poor people should just try hard enough etc and really all bad things are exaggerated. Its the complete lack of empathy now they've got their expensive house and final salary pension. I hope their expensive house they love so much takes care of them, cos am too busy working even harder to bring up my kids.

BeyondMyWits · 10/08/2022 16:22

Our cul-de-sac is a mini community. I've just come in out of the sun as I'm too hot, but there are folks from 6 out of 10 houses outside gardening, chatting, lending stuff, etc.most are elderly, though one has his son and grandchildren round teaching them cricket in the square.

We are in suburbia... I imagine it varies a bit depending where you are.

MereDintofPandiculation · 10/08/2022 16:19

This thread answers its own question, really. Lots of posts saying it’s the elderly’s own fault, for voting for Thatcher, not being interested enough in grandchildren, wanting to do in retirement things they weren’t able to do when working, etc. All of these saying basically “yes, we don’t treat the elderly well, why should we?”

And those seeking to give the contrary view, by examples of the elderly staying active, volunteering etc, are basically giving examples of the elderly helping themselves.

Technosaurus · 10/08/2022 16:08

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 15:49

I'm also uncomfortable with castigating people based on what they may or may not have voted for in the past.

Why? They’re basically still voting for the same thing, now. There doesn’t seem to have been an en masse change of heart.

If someone needs help, I'll help them. I don't care how they vote or what their views are to be perfectly honest.

If you'd leave a 90 year old Brexit voter sat in their own shit to their own devices in order to teach them a lesson because you disagree with their political views, that's up to you. But I won't.

awaynboilyurheid · 10/08/2022 16:03

I’ve seen Italian families on holiday who seem to have elderly relatives with them or sitting in groups chatting as you say more visible, I help care for my elderly mother, she has lost most of her friends yet I’ve got family that really don’t bother visiting, it’s very sad.

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 15:49

I'm also uncomfortable with castigating people based on what they may or may not have voted for in the past.

Why? They’re basically still voting for the same thing, now. There doesn’t seem to have been an en masse change of heart.

karalimed · 10/08/2022 15:48

ilovesooty · 10/08/2022 14:20

I'm not disputing the fact that Conservative voting is skewed by age, but I resent the lazy stereotyping that goes on and the resultant feeling that as an older person I have to justify not fitting the stereotype.

The few people I know who vote Tory and voted for Brexit are almost all younger than I am.

It's not just voting though is it.

Society is shaped by the people in it. Elderly people didn't spontaneously burst into existence at age 80. People in their 80s now were in their 40s in the 1980s. They were the ones in charge, making the decisions, bringing up their own children. We are now seeing the consequences of those actions.

Of course it's not all elderly people, but enough of them, otherwise how do you think it happened? Either a) this is a British cultural thing that has always existed or b) something changed.

Equally, if we as younger people want to be respected as elderly people we need to start taking action now. We need to start valuing family and community more.

Technosaurus · 10/08/2022 15:47

It's a massive myth that the elderly have all had it easy. Yeah their house prices went up but they also lived through the 3 day week, massive interest rates in the 80s, societal and technological change and all the industrial action that came with it along the way.

As an example: holidays. Most families I deal with holidayed in the UK or on campsites when they had their own children. So who are we to judge them for spending their retirement chasing the sun a bit? It's cheaper and easier now, they have the money, good luck to them.

I'm also uncomfortable with castigating people based on what they may or may not have voted for in the past. Everyone votes for their own reasons and it's based on personal circumstances at the time. A true left winger would show compassion to a 90 year old Tory voter who needs some assistance in later life, rather than say "bollocks to you, this is what you voted for in 1984"

RidingMyBike · 10/08/2022 15:43

They're everywhere around here - cafes, sitting in the park in the sunshine at this time of year, pubs, library, shops, the supermarket cafes, garden centre cafes seem to be a particular favourite.

They're normally with other older people though, presumably because younger people are working?

Just about every woman in the previous generations of my family stopped work to care for elderly parents (then inherited house when they died but remained single and living 'at home'), or moved back to the home city and went extremely part-time in order to care for parents and have a family of their own. None of the men did this. That isn't an option for me, even if I wanted to do it. There is no work for me in my home city, I work full-time and am the breadwinner and my family wouldn't be able to afford to live if I stopped work. Plus my pension is a lot lot worse than those of the two generations above me.

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 15:32

Same with me @bluescluesbluecow

My dad’s parents moved close to us as kids to help out, babysat on demand and probably had us 1 weekend in every 5 so they could have time together

now I’ve got kids my dad has buggered off to sunnier climes and just sends an Amazon delivery on birthdays

so if Dd doesn’t want to visit him in his old age, wouldn’t that be understandable?

bluescluesbluecow · 10/08/2022 15:06

Wouldloveanother · 10/08/2022 13:46

True but you’ll be criticised for saying it.

I don't know how true this is. I can only you off anecdotal evidence but almost every one my age 20-30 have spent ab significant part of their childhood being cared for by their grandparents (now 70-90). However now we are all having children ourselves, our parents are not babysitting or putting in the same effort their parents did helping them out with their children.

So as a result, the grandparents of my generation seem to be visited often by their own children, and adult grand children separately. I can't see my children being that involved with my parents when they are old amd frail and my children are adults because they haven't fostered the relationship with them.

It seems to be the same story with everyone I know.

And my grandparents still worked when they had us. I remember my grandad retiring. We were babysat every week and taken on holiday (all grandchildren from all of their children, 5 altogether) every week and at least one week away a year, usually more. (cheap camping)
We also had all of the grandchildren from all of our great aunties and uncles together.

My grandparents said that their parents helped a lot with their children so they helped alot with their children's children (my generation) but their children have skipped on helping out with their children's children and I think it'll have an effect on who is there to help out when they are old and need it.

I know nobody should have kids expecting others to look after them but babysitting your grand children so their parents can go Christmas shopping without them isn't that unreasonable I wouldn't think.

Swipe left for the next trending thread