Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask 'how much are you looking to spend?' Or similar when I'm asked what gift to get ds?

84 replies

anotherq · 10/08/2022 09:00

Imagine this
You speak to your son on the phone every day (usually dad)
It's your grandsons first birthday in 6 weeks.

Every couple of days the same conversation happens. Word for word, exactly the same

You ask your son 'what should we buy DGS for his birthday?'
Your son replies 'I'll ask anotherq what she thinks'

He then asks his partner and she replies (every time) 'how much are they looking to spend?'
He says 'I don't know. I think they'll be happy with about £100'
His partner replies 'ask them how much they'd like to spend and I will forward things I've put in a wish list'
Again, this is also WORD FOR WORD the exact same every time

For context, partner has been thinking, planning and browsing since March. She has narrowed down a list of three big (£70-£100) things and small and medium (from £20-£50) gifts
Partner doesn't want to assume grandparents want to spend £100 on a gift.
The son is guessing this amount from the top of his head
Partner says 'What if they do want to spent £100 but only want to buy a £50 gift? Or two? Or what if they want to spend £70 and want it split over a few items?' Who knows? (unless you ask...)

So now it's been two phone calls since they last asked and it's going to come up again soon
The son says partner should send a few things to his mum of different prices
The partner says, once again 'just ask your parents how much they would like to spend'

So, my question is, is there something wrong with your son saying 'how much would you like to spend?' In this situation? Would you be offended? I don't know if I am not understanding something here.
Happy to be told I am unreasonable and open to other phrasing suggestions please

OP posts:
ANUsernam · 10/08/2022 11:57

If you're keen to develop more of a relationship with your MIL why don't you call her directly about it all. I wasn't going to suggest it because it shouldn't be your responsibility to manage your DP's inability to communicate, but at the same time it sounds like you really want to improve the relationship with her and having your dp always act as middle man isn't going to help that.

Call her, have a chat about present ideas/ how useless her son is being incapable of asking about budget, personally invite her to the party and have a chat about what you're planning so she feels involved.

HangOnToYourself · 10/08/2022 11:51

"I expect them to be there" is way out of line and will absolutely not help you form a relationship with your MIL

ANUsernam · 10/08/2022 11:47

Given what you've said about the back-story/relationship with them, it sounds more like they'd be extra keen to make the effort to come to a party wherever you held it and to not want to upset you, than that they'd refuse to attend and expect a separate celebration.

Try not to let your dp create situations where none exist.

anotherq · 10/08/2022 11:42

@Duttercup thank you
I didn't realise how much I had to calm down until I read back my comment. It is coming across so strongly
I don't 'expect' them to be there. I wouldn't ever do that. That was the wrong thing to say. I HOPE they will be there is what I should have said.
See, I'm getting wound up over a POTENTIAL HYPOTHETICAL SITUATION

OP posts:
ANUsernam · 10/08/2022 11:41

I agree with you about asking what they're looking to spend, you don't want them either to feel that there's an expectation to spend more than they'd planned/offend them, by including items which are a lot more than their budget, or alternatively to include only low value items and have them effectively waste money by buying multiple low value items which won't all get used, when if you'd known they were happy to spend more they could have bought one big ticket item which will get a lot of use.

Your dp is being ridiculous not asking the question. That being said, it is on him if he won't all the question and gets the expectation wrong. So I'd just let him manage it the way he wants and either it'll be fine or he'll learn for next time.

zingally · 10/08/2022 11:41

I'd by-pass the somewhat-useless son and just forward GPs the list, and a "please let me know what you choose, so we don't end up duplicating! Thanks!"

End of problem.

anotherq · 10/08/2022 11:39

EmeraldShamrock1 · 10/08/2022 11:14

Just treat both grannies respectfully at the end of the day the DC benefit.

Your partner is probably worried as it isn't unusual to leave MIL out on things.

Include them both for the their first DGC birthday, give them small jobs.

Thank you @EmeraldShamrock1 I really like your reply. I am definitely going to offer everyone a little something to do to be involved
Tbh I will need the help as DP is a show up to the event and head for the buffet type of man

Thank you for this kind reply. I think everything is going to be ok

OP posts:
anotherq · 10/08/2022 11:37

The party/get together I had in mind wasn't a party style or an OTT for a first birthday. I just wanted everyone to come together in one place and be around ds
It would just be our family spending the day together and a memory would be made

I really struggle being a ftm. I do everything alone and I am really trying my best but it's hard. And I feel bad taking help from my mum incase it upsets his mum

I think I need to one day sit with mil and ask if everything is ok. If there's something I am doing to offend her or if there's something I can do. Family means everything to me and I would love to have a blooming relationship with the parents away from DP. And them to have a bond with DS. And I want them to feel comfortable with me. And know that I'm not like dsd's mum and they can always see my ds. They really walk on eggshells around me so as not to overstep. I feel it and dp told me mil is scared because of the past
And I feel soooo bad for them for not getting that bond with dsd. It's not fair that just because their son wasn't with the mum that they had to be punished by losing out on precious time. I would never ever do that and maybe if I explained that they would let their guard down a bit?

I think DP being middleman is also a problem. It is making me sound grabby (I feel) by always saying 'I will ask anotherq'

I came here because I wondered if IABU to a very simple comment. Because o wasn't able to understand why it was a problem to say this

I am the type of person who when asked what I want for my birthday/Christmas I will say nothing rather than suggesting something. It doesn't feel natural to me. I get nervous and embarrassed and just repeat 'no no it's ok, you don't have to get me anything. Please but thank you so much'
And the thought of accepting a present then having to open it ... I can't even explain the feelings

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 10/08/2022 11:24

The parent in laws probably feel awkward, why not help them to feel extra welcome for the occasion instead of treating them as a bit of mumbling inconvenience not knowing what to buy or where the party is being held.

Craver · 10/08/2022 11:23

It's a first birthday not a United Nations Treaty!
Some clothes, books, toys. Provide receipts if you are concerned your daughter in law doesn't like them. Or cash / cheque for your desired amount £50 would be very generous but we all have different opinions on money. You are creating a monster debating every 6 months on Birthday /Christmas presents.

nokidshere · 10/08/2022 11:17

God i hate questions about gifts, why can't people just use their imaginations

Because, as we see on here everyday, then you'd have the recipients parent(s) moaning that they get trash/too much/too little/too plastic/too big/too small with cries of 'why don't the ask and get what we say'.

It's his first birthday that I am throwing at my mums house. She is not giving him a party, I am and I expect your parents to be there'

It's unreasonable of you to 'expect' others to do something just because you say so. It's very controlling.

Duttercup · 10/08/2022 11:17

She is not giving him a party, I am and I expect your parents to be there

...I think you need to calm down. It's a first birthday party. If they don't come, you can have a nice little tea party at theirs or something. I hate crossing the family streams, I just can't be arsed, maybe your husband feels the same way. You can't demand they attend.

Also, maybe they don't know how much they want to spend, maybe they want to pick the thing they think looks the nicest gift from the list? If I told my mum a few things, she'd be as likely to pick the £10 thing she thought was lovely as the £50 thing that filled her budget.

But mostly, calm down.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 10/08/2022 11:14

Just treat both grannies respectfully at the end of the day the DC benefit.

Your partner is probably worried as it isn't unusual to leave MIL out on things.

Include them both for the their first DGC birthday, give them small jobs.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 10/08/2022 11:10

Tbh I hate when people ask what they should buy my DC?

My question usually is what are they thinking of spending.

It means every year I've to research things I need to buy and give ideas for other people too.

Pick a gift any bloody gift, if they don't want or need it they'll return it.

MoodyTwo · 10/08/2022 11:04

Wow for a 1st birthday why are you stressing so much, just a roll of tin foil will work brilliantly they LOVE that.. what on earth is on the list that costs £70-£100 !!
I just got loads of things from Poundland for my DS first , bubbles and pop bottles that I filled sparkly glitter and such

CravenRaven · 10/08/2022 11:02

I think everything is going to be totally fine. I think he is making a massive assumption over nothing.

This may well be true. But even in this scenario, I think actions can speak much louder than words. If they are always invited but fine to decline without drama and whenever they do engage, they are made to feel genuinely welcome and wanted - over time they will relax and learn to trust. Hopefully.

But very few people really believe their fears with be fine just because someone says they will be.

luckylavender · 10/08/2022 10:59

anotherq · 10/08/2022 10:52

The issue regarding it being at my mums is hypothetical
They haven't been told that's where I've decided to have it. It's totally convenient for them, us and the rest of the family. It's right in the middle of us all

DP thinks his mum is going to think it's all about my mum and she's throwing it etc but I've asked him to explain this is me doing the party and my mum doesn't have anything to do with it but he simply said 'I will but you know what she's like'

But I don't think she will feel this way. I think everything is going to be totally fine. I think he is making a massive assumption over nothing. Unless they are telling him things in private which I've asked and he's said no. He just thinks this will be how they will feel because it's not at their house (his words not mine)

I'm recognising more as I write this that I have a DP problem
It's like he just thinks there is going to be a big drama and fall out over anything that might be competition with his mum. But by him even mentioning the worst possible scenario it gets me stressed. And probably gets my back up a bit because I feel myself going into defence mode

It's a 1st Birthday. Nobody cares. Such a drama.

luckylavender · 10/08/2022 10:57

I'm with he Dad. Mother sounds really controlling. If this if for a First Birthday then the road ahead looks rocky.

GratefulMe · 10/08/2022 10:56

You really need to relax. A first birthday doesn't need this level of angst. You have a long road ahead.

CravenRaven · 10/08/2022 10:53

It sounds like a lot of hard work for a first birthday - the presents for which are likely to be ignored, forgotten, lost or broken. I'd tell them anything they want to get him will be gratefully received and leave it at that.

Ditto a party. A one year is not going to care whether they are there or not and saying you "expect them to be" sounds like a one way street to bad blood, to me.

Lighten up. Let them slowly build a relationship at their pace and see what happens. Because your current way is going to result in angst and heartache for someone, if not all.

anotherq · 10/08/2022 10:52

The issue regarding it being at my mums is hypothetical
They haven't been told that's where I've decided to have it. It's totally convenient for them, us and the rest of the family. It's right in the middle of us all

DP thinks his mum is going to think it's all about my mum and she's throwing it etc but I've asked him to explain this is me doing the party and my mum doesn't have anything to do with it but he simply said 'I will but you know what she's like'

But I don't think she will feel this way. I think everything is going to be totally fine. I think he is making a massive assumption over nothing. Unless they are telling him things in private which I've asked and he's said no. He just thinks this will be how they will feel because it's not at their house (his words not mine)

I'm recognising more as I write this that I have a DP problem
It's like he just thinks there is going to be a big drama and fall out over anything that might be competition with his mum. But by him even mentioning the worst possible scenario it gets me stressed. And probably gets my back up a bit because I feel myself going into defence mode

OP posts:
Louise56 · 10/08/2022 10:52

Just send them the list with prices, let them decide for themselves.

Eleusa · 10/08/2022 10:49

Between you, you’re managing to make a huge amount of stress around a baby’s birthday. It all sounds very angst-inducing and a lot of hard work.

On presents, just give a couple of ideas and ask what they got or else be vague and say “he could do with some books” and let them choose.

On the party, it all sounds a bit ott. Remember that your baby won’t have a clue about it being their birthday- this is all for you, not him. If your in-laws don’t want to come to the party, do something another time, it’s not a personal slight. This stuff is supposed to be fun 🙃

Easywhenyouknowit · 10/08/2022 10:45

I said 'what do you mean? Why would they not come to ds first birthday? It's their grandson? I don't understand?'

PIL didn’t come to our DC’s birthday, it’s not a big deal.
They are allowed to not want to come, never mind host it for you just because they have a downstairs bathroom. Honestly, with the gift thing and now the party, you really sound like you are trying to make them behave the way you want them to behave. You can’t control people in that way. Send them gift ideas, plan the get together at your house and invite them. If they come they come. If they don’t want to stand around chatting with members of your family and would rather see their DGC another time that really is okay.

PatientlyWaiting21 · 10/08/2022 10:44

sooo cheeky! Just send them the list!