Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to think we can extend this list a lot? Surely almost every book and film could have a content warning for something?

166 replies

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/08/2022 07:57

The Times today reports that ^universities have started removing books from reading lists to protect students from “challenging” content and have applied trigger warnings to more than 1,000 texts, a Times investigation has found.
Ten universities, including three from the Russell Group, have withdrawn books from course study lists, or made them optional, in case they cause students harm. The texts include the 2017 Pulitzer Prize-winning novel The Underground Railroad, by Colson Whitehead, which has been “removed permanently” from a course reading list at Essex University because of concerns about graphic depictions of slavery.^

There are many serious and obvious things to say about this, but they're all in the article. The aspect that engaged me is that it gives the list in full. I am certain we could help out the university sector by pointing out other potentially distressing books.

Here are some of the examples:

The Ancient Mariner, S. T. Coleridge University of Greenwich Content warning: Animal death, human death, supernatural possession

Persuasion, Jane Austen Aberdeen Portrays views of gender and class identity that are rooted in the context of early nineteenth-century England

The Waste Land, TS Eliot Aberdeen Contains references to death and war

The Iliad, Homer Highlands and Islands Violent close combat

Oliver Twist, Charles Dickens Royal Holloway Child abuse

Kidnapped, Robert Louis Stevenson Aberdeen Kidnapping [No! I'd never have guessed it would cover this subject]

The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Agatha Christie Greenwich Contains murder [What! Shocked, I tell you, shocked]

And my favourite: The Bible York Shocking sexual violence

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/339af864-17ce-11ed-b1f4-627a202c7457 (Sorry, I don't have a share token for the article, but you can read it for nothing by signing up with your email address. That way you get to read a few free articles every month.)

So, what are your suggestions of content warnings for university students?

Here's mine:
The Very Hungry Caterpillar - contains description of an eating disorder and consequent physical discomfort

OP posts:
Phineyj · 10/08/2022 09:29

And surely the point of Jane Austen is we can still appreciate Anne Elliot's being talked into a bad decision by her family despite the long ago setting, changes in society etc. Amazing really. Books are amazing!!

newrubylane · 10/08/2022 09:29

Agatha Christie book with the word 'murder' in the title has a murder in it - shocker!

I feel like there might be a very few cases where a trigger warning is useful where the content is presented in a particularly graphic way, but some of these are just infantilising.

MuddlerInLaw · 10/08/2022 09:27

OMG - the entire Chalet School series would be banned. Child abandonment, child neglect, kidnap, classism, and other uncomfortable hierarchical structures, unrealistic models of easy international travel, and, conversly, depictions of violence and perilous escape across mountains. Numerous upsetting instances of child illness. Parental illness and death. Gender stereotyping. Exposure to extremes of temperature. Enforced darning. Shock

Phineyj · 10/08/2022 09:26

I read a book called Children of the Dust, when I was at school, as did some of my friends. It was about a post nuclear holocaust society.

My goodness it was terrifying. I can still remember details of it now and I'm nearly 50.

I don't know that I'd ban it though. It's an achievement, isn't it, printing words on paper that stick around in someone's mind for over 3 decades?

IStandWithMaya · 10/08/2022 09:21

Cinderella - child cruelty

Sleeping Beauty - sexual advance by male whilst she is sleeping

Snow White - offensive to those with genetic height difference

Hansel and Gretel - child abduction and torture

The Emperor's New Clothes - man exposes his genitalia

SpindleInTheWind · 10/08/2022 09:15

Down With Skool! - unreliable narrator describes scenes of Fotherington-Thomas skipping like a girlie

DillonPanthersTexas · 10/08/2022 09:11

They must have shat the bed when they came across the 'Mr Men' books.

user1471447863 · 10/08/2022 09:10

The Bible - infanticide, genocide, incest, murder - and that barely scratches the surface

Redshoeblueshoe · 10/08/2022 09:09

Three little pigs. Animal cruelty, torture and death.

balalake · 10/08/2022 09:08

Any memoir by a reality 'star', to warn that it is probably fictional.

countrygirl99 · 10/08/2022 09:08

ErrolTheDragon · 10/08/2022 08:50

Mog the forgetful cat: verbal abuse of animal, home invasion and depictions of the police.

Not to mention Goodbye Mog.

Black Beauty - animal cruelty.

I washing to suggest Black Beauty. I'm 63, must have read it 100s of times but I still cry at the fate of Ginger so definitely needs to go on the list to spare poor cherubs the trauma.
But you've gone and made me realise I haven't read it in while so now I will read it next and cry again. And afterwards I will go and hug my own black horse and remind him he's a lucky bugger.

NippyWoowoo · 10/08/2022 09:06

On a serious note though, at age 10 we read a school text called Island of the Blue Dolphins (based on a true story). It contains themes like abandonment, isolation and involves a horrific death. It was incredibly sad and haunting and I still think about it to this day.

Wish we weren't so young when we read it.

shinynewapple22 · 10/08/2022 09:05

Agree @Thatswhyimacat

Thatswhyimacat · 10/08/2022 09:00

Taking The Underground Railroad as an example as I just read it so it's fresh in my mind:

Yes there is a lot of horrific content in it and I have no major problem with adding a warning, but I'd think anyone who'd read the blurb and knows it's about slavery should have a rough idea of what sorts of things happened then? I thought there was a whole push now to decolonise reading lists and include more books by black voices such as Whitehead, more reading on the unpleasant parts of history that tend to get whitewashed and glossed over, more education on the horrors of those times, more books about black history and historical figures? How are people supposed to learn about slavery if they can't read books that depict what it was like?

As I said, trigger warnings I don't really mind, but straight up removing a recent award-winning novel by a black author about Black history because it's upsetting is a huge shame and also seemingly missing the point of education.

NippyWoowoo · 10/08/2022 09:00

The Nancy Drew series - TW: childhood trauma due to death of a parent, neglect by living parent, exploration of domestic staff

Her father leaves her to be 'raised' by a household servant, but she's allowed to run amok and get up to all sorts of trouble.

ErrolTheDragon · 10/08/2022 08:58

A brief warning about themes is one thing.

This is about universities removing serious texts from their reading lists, which is quite another. No wonder students are complaining. They're also being stifled from having different views on interpreting texts.

Luxa · 10/08/2022 08:56

The dictionary

Contains the definition 'Woman - adult human female'

SpicePearl · 10/08/2022 08:53

WhosthatGirlJess · 10/08/2022 08:51

I read Crash at uni - the one about people getting off on amputations. Pretty hardcore for a very naive and sheltered 18 yo. I imagine that would have been removed too. It's ridiculous.

These works are triggering in many ways but literature is art and art is meant to be provocative and cause a reaction including strong feelings. And of course people do need to be exposed to things out of their comfort zone. Where will it bloody end? If we remove grisly descriptions of slavery say, will another generation grow up reading nothing about it and never be able to understand how terrible it was for the people living in that reality? It becomes an abstract concept, it's something that happened to someone else, easy to deal with, and people are removed from violence (bit like shooting prostitutes and running people over on GTA with no consequence), and the word itself just becomes meaningless. Too easy for it to happen again.

But content warnings aren’t about telling people not to read something. It’s literally just a heads up that it might be a tough read if you have personal experience in that area.

NippyWoowoo · 10/08/2022 08:53

Brefugee · 10/08/2022 08:08

It's ridiculous. I get they're challenging, that is the point of them. And from what i see on MN if this is extrapolated to all parenting over the last, say, 20 years - it's because children aren't robust enough.

They can't even leave them at parties anymore, per another thread 😂

SlagathaChristie · 10/08/2022 08:53

"That's not my..." Usborne baby book series: encourages non-consensual touching.

BarbaraofSeville · 10/08/2022 08:53

This thread may explain all the warnings at the beginning of Netflix/Amazon programmes.

The sorts of things I watch never seem to feature the terror they're warning about and I was starting to think that they just included all the warnings randomly, but it's probably that the horrors are all there, they're just so benign that I've just not noticed them as a 40 something brought up on Enid Blyton books and the sorts of public information films that involved Grandad falling off a stool or a child been electrocuted when flying a kite next to power lines.

I expect that the Tufty Club doesn't exist any more either?

SpicePearl · 10/08/2022 08:51

I’ve lost two pregnancies in the last year and repeatedly found myself reading books that have baby loss or infant death as a key theme, with no indication from the cover. Like a pp I wouldn’t mind being forewarned so I can brace myself or put off reading that one for a while.

With recent reports about the sexual abuse and harassment rife in private schools and ongoing sexual consent issues for freshers I imagine there are lots of topics that female students might want to be aware of before diving into an assigned text.

runforyourdog · 10/08/2022 08:51

The Gruffalo, reference to murder and death

WhosthatGirlJess · 10/08/2022 08:51

I read Crash at uni - the one about people getting off on amputations. Pretty hardcore for a very naive and sheltered 18 yo. I imagine that would have been removed too. It's ridiculous.

These works are triggering in many ways but literature is art and art is meant to be provocative and cause a reaction including strong feelings. And of course people do need to be exposed to things out of their comfort zone. Where will it bloody end? If we remove grisly descriptions of slavery say, will another generation grow up reading nothing about it and never be able to understand how terrible it was for the people living in that reality? It becomes an abstract concept, it's something that happened to someone else, easy to deal with, and people are removed from violence (bit like shooting prostitutes and running people over on GTA with no consequence), and the word itself just becomes meaningless. Too easy for it to happen again.

ErrolTheDragon · 10/08/2022 08:50

Mog the forgetful cat: verbal abuse of animal, home invasion and depictions of the police.

Not to mention Goodbye Mog.

Black Beauty - animal cruelty.