Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to think we can extend this list a lot? Surely almost every book and film could have a content warning for something?

166 replies

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/08/2022 07:57

The Times today reports that ^universities have started removing books from reading lists to protect students from “challenging” content and have applied trigger warnings to more than 1,000 texts, a Times investigation has found.
Ten universities, including three from the Russell Group, have withdrawn books from course study lists, or made them optional, in case they cause students harm. The texts include the 2017 Pulitzer Prize-winning novel The Underground Railroad, by Colson Whitehead, which has been “removed permanently” from a course reading list at Essex University because of concerns about graphic depictions of slavery.^

There are many serious and obvious things to say about this, but they're all in the article. The aspect that engaged me is that it gives the list in full. I am certain we could help out the university sector by pointing out other potentially distressing books.

Here are some of the examples:

The Ancient Mariner, S. T. Coleridge University of Greenwich Content warning: Animal death, human death, supernatural possession

Persuasion, Jane Austen Aberdeen Portrays views of gender and class identity that are rooted in the context of early nineteenth-century England

The Waste Land, TS Eliot Aberdeen Contains references to death and war

The Iliad, Homer Highlands and Islands Violent close combat

Oliver Twist, Charles Dickens Royal Holloway Child abuse

Kidnapped, Robert Louis Stevenson Aberdeen Kidnapping [No! I'd never have guessed it would cover this subject]

The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Agatha Christie Greenwich Contains murder [What! Shocked, I tell you, shocked]

And my favourite: The Bible York Shocking sexual violence

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/339af864-17ce-11ed-b1f4-627a202c7457 (Sorry, I don't have a share token for the article, but you can read it for nothing by signing up with your email address. That way you get to read a few free articles every month.)

So, what are your suggestions of content warnings for university students?

Here's mine:
The Very Hungry Caterpillar - contains description of an eating disorder and consequent physical discomfort

OP posts:
oopsfellover · 10/08/2022 10:22

@CulturePigeon you talk about ‘delicate 21st century sensibilities’ and people being ‘conditioned to be offended’ as if these are part of a trend that should be sneered at and swept aside. However I think these generalisations can be a bit too easy. If you were a 17 year old girl who’d been sexually abused you might find the Handmaid’s Tale pretty tough - not because of your over-delicate sensitivities but because of your traumatic lived experience. If you were a young black person who’d been racially
abused you may not be comfortable with the ‘n word’ popping up in a Tennessee Williams play, however much someone explained its context to you.
That doesn’t mean that those texts should be avoided or banned, but being careful isn’t the same as being ‘offended’ in the way I think you’re using the term.

And of course you can say ‘actress’; some people just feel you don’t need the gender differentiation.

HesterShaw1 · 10/08/2022 10:19

MagpiePi · 10/08/2022 10:14

This is what I was thinking.
Or is it because having any kind of negative emotion is now regarded as a mental health crisis?

Exactly. Feeling temporarily down is now a condition.

We can't exist on a higher plane of positive emotion permanently. And when we don't, we're not ill.

MagpiePi · 10/08/2022 10:14

giffyg · 10/08/2022 09:52

I don't understand the thinking, is it to pretend that this stuff doesn't happen?

This is what I was thinking.
Or is it because having any kind of negative emotion is now regarded as a mental health crisis?

HesterShaw1 · 10/08/2022 10:14

Little Women

Contains the death of a much loved character. Distressing scenes which some readers may find upsetting.

Miffee · 10/08/2022 10:13

If you are studying anything where you are reading fiction surely books with the power to disturb you should be top of the pile.

I remember the feeling that Beloved left me with. That book. Jesus Christ. It was amazing, I felt like I was in a walking round in a fog for days after. Utterly horrifying and challenging. The exploration of maternal love was extraordinary.

I will never read it again. It was too hard. I am so glad I read it though. How can you understand the power of literature if you avoid those things??

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/08/2022 10:12

Whatsnewpussyhat · 10/08/2022 09:35

Meanwhile, the same pathetically fragile, emotionally stunted students are downloading violent porn and staying up until 5am playing Call of Duty online.

The issue is they are fully aware of violence but they are becoming detached from the actual human cost of it. The consequences of human behaviour individually and at a larger scale.

Books that make you feel sad, mad, disgusted or anything else are doing the job intended by the author.

Trigger warnings for Jane Austin because of classism and sex inequality?
We're still fucking living it!

Why are these young adults being brought up thinking they must be protected from any, perfectly normal, negative emotions?

Brilliant points.

OP posts:
oopsfellover · 10/08/2022 10:06

I don’t think any of the books have been ‘banned’, have they? Might be wrong, only read the bit of the article I could see without subscribing. But I think things can be overdramatised at times.
Literature will ideally be understood in its context, but as a teacher I think you do have to be careful with some themes. I’m an English teacher and tend to give what might be called a ‘trigger warning’ (not a phrase I’d actually use) if something like suicide, rape/sexual violence, racism or mental illness is likely to come up in the lesson. It’s no big deal, just an advance acknowledgment that some people might find the themes difficult because of their personal experience. It’s true though that you could
find something for almost every text!

Popcorncovered · 10/08/2022 10:05

But anything could be "triggering", depending on your life experiences.

Waitwhat23 · 10/08/2022 09:59

whataloadabullocks · 10/08/2022 09:43

I think it would have to be pre c.21 especially teen Children's books. Harry Potter must be very triggering; so much death oh but hang on hasn't JK been cancelled? so presumably all her texts are band anyway. Hunger Games is another one.
If it wasn't so serious this thread would be brilliant, but the undercurrent of what's happening to our higher education is appalling; a population unable to think for themselves is a population which is easy to controlSad

On one of the trigger warning websites, one of the listed triggers is...Harry Potter references. Even its existence is triggering.

I can certainly see the point of trigger warnings for things like suicide, death, miscarriage etc (although not banned

giffyg · 10/08/2022 09:52

I don't understand the thinking, is it to pretend that this stuff doesn't happen?

CulturePigeon · 10/08/2022 09:46

I can't trust myself to say much on this question - sorry to sound like the DM, but - have we gone completely mad?

People need to understand that the past was a different place. They thought differently and acted differently there. To miss the most incredible achievements of literature, art and drama because an outmoded word is used, or because contemporary attitudes don't match up to our enlightened times, that's a terrible loss and harmful to our cultural life.

I cannot believe the pathetic attitudes that so many institutions (universities, BBC, National Trust etc) seem to take about 'warnings'. It's really infantilising people - the idea that we need protection from anything which might offend our delicate 21st century sensibilites. But then, we've all been conditioned to be offended as much as possible - it's surely a measure of your worth if you can find more things to be offended about than the next person. On MN alone, there are regular competitive 'more offended than you' threads.

If you have any historical perspective, you'll recognise that we are living through a sort of new puritan age - rather like the Commonwealth under Oliver Cromwell. Or perhaps a sort of Orwellian 'newspeak' and 'Big Brother is Watching You' era. Neither of these observations are at all original, but so many people don't seem to see it. You can't say certain words now (eg actress) which used to be perfectly fine English words, yet somehow we're all supposed to accept the 'f' and 'c' words without question in broadcasting and print??? They are just different value-systems - depending totally on fashion.

Mumofgrownupkids · 10/08/2022 09:45

The Tale of Peter Rabbit. Loss of a parent in infancy, violence towards animals, gun violence (all by Mr McGregor).

As for Watership Down, well....

peekiboo · 10/08/2022 09:44

Little Miss Twins.

Enmeshed sibling relationships

whataloadabullocks · 10/08/2022 09:43

CosyHappy · 10/08/2022 09:32

Save time and burn everything written pre c.20th because at that time female writers were largely excluded from published authorship?

I think it would have to be pre c.21 especially teen Children's books. Harry Potter must be very triggering; so much death oh but hang on hasn't JK been cancelled? so presumably all her texts are band anyway. Hunger Games is another one.
If it wasn't so serious this thread would be brilliant, but the undercurrent of what's happening to our higher education is appalling; a population unable to think for themselves is a population which is easy to controlSad

CounsellorTroi · 10/08/2022 09:42

I’ve seen episodes of Star Trek The Next Generation carrying warnings for language when the only language in them is Capt Picard saying “What the hell’s going on?’ Or muttering “merde” under his breath, the horror the horror.

DowningStreetParty · 10/08/2022 09:40

There’s a democracy problem being built in if people can’t think critically about what they read.

How are these very young people with their redacted reading lists ever going to feel equipped to actually do anything about the horrific ongoing injustices in the world…. when they can’t even manage to read novels about them?
Who do they think will be running the country for them on their behalf if they rule themselves out? It’s actually very dangerous to shut your eyes and ears to difficult things for any length of time.

Newrumpus · 10/08/2022 09:37

The Emperors New Clothes could
bring about the downfall of modern society. Imagine if people got the idea of going around and staying the bleeding obvious!

Brefugee · 10/08/2022 09:36

Also isn't the point of novels like Oliver Twist to provoke social change? Dickens kick started a lot of that with his accurate portrayals of poverty etc

Whatsnewpussyhat · 10/08/2022 09:35

Meanwhile, the same pathetically fragile, emotionally stunted students are downloading violent porn and staying up until 5am playing Call of Duty online.

The issue is they are fully aware of violence but they are becoming detached from the actual human cost of it. The consequences of human behaviour individually and at a larger scale.

Books that make you feel sad, mad, disgusted or anything else are doing the job intended by the author.

Trigger warnings for Jane Austin because of classism and sex inequality?
We're still fucking living it!

Why are these young adults being brought up thinking they must be protected from any, perfectly normal, negative emotions?

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/08/2022 09:34

Moby D—k
say No more

Treabrea · 10/08/2022 09:34

HobnobbingAboutHobnobs · 10/08/2022 08:36

We're going on a bear hunt - hunting mentioned repeatedly, challenging situations encountered, and extremely poor parenting by the father (who takes their kids into a bear cave?)

I was surprised when I watched the cartoon version to find that what I assumed were the mum & dad were actually the elder brother and sister. Think we can add leaving children with unsuitable care givers to the warning.

Brefugee · 10/08/2022 09:32

I’ve lost two pregnancies in the last year and repeatedly found myself reading books that have baby loss or infant death as a key theme, with no indication from the cover. Like a pp I wouldn’t mind being forewarned so I can brace myself or put off reading that one for a while.

I'm very sorry for your losses. What, i think, would help anyone in your position (and many other things that may trigger people could be included) is if a website like Goodreads would have lists of books with triggers. No explanations, just "if you don't want to read about X don't read A, B, C etc"

So you could just look up the tag "miscarriage" and you'd get a list of books to avoid.

Because, of course, the absolute KEY point of some of these is the element of surprise, shock and disbelief that happens when they turn up in the text.
When reading the 5th Harry Potter book i didn't know about a character death - i knew nothing. So when it came it was BAM!
Reading the 6th, i knew there would be a character death and spent a lot of time wondering when i turned the page if This Was It. And it spoiled the book a lot.

Books used to have blurbs which gave a brief summary. The blurb has given way to gushing reviews that give you no clue what the book is about. It infuriates me. I don't want spoilers (I'm odd in that i don't even want to hear "oh it has a great twist" because my brain spends time trying to work it out in advance) but a general outline is always good.

Have just finished reading a page turner that i thought would be a relatively harmless thriller - turned out to be extremely violent in places. Totally works within the novel, excellently written, but if I'd known that was coming I'd have been waiting for it and the effect would have been ruined.

CosyHappy · 10/08/2022 09:32

Save time and burn everything written pre c.20th because at that time female writers were largely excluded from published authorship?

Phineyj · 10/08/2022 09:31

I adored the Chalet School, but I'd add dreadful things done to the grammar of other European languages. Also making parenting multiple children look too easy (Jo).

continueorterminate · 10/08/2022 09:30

FrancescaContini · 10/08/2022 08:14

😂 Words! They can be so HARMFUL

Literal literary violence!

Swipe left for the next trending thread