Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to think we can extend this list a lot? Surely almost every book and film could have a content warning for something?

166 replies

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/08/2022 07:57

The Times today reports that ^universities have started removing books from reading lists to protect students from “challenging” content and have applied trigger warnings to more than 1,000 texts, a Times investigation has found.
Ten universities, including three from the Russell Group, have withdrawn books from course study lists, or made them optional, in case they cause students harm. The texts include the 2017 Pulitzer Prize-winning novel The Underground Railroad, by Colson Whitehead, which has been “removed permanently” from a course reading list at Essex University because of concerns about graphic depictions of slavery.^

There are many serious and obvious things to say about this, but they're all in the article. The aspect that engaged me is that it gives the list in full. I am certain we could help out the university sector by pointing out other potentially distressing books.

Here are some of the examples:

The Ancient Mariner, S. T. Coleridge University of Greenwich Content warning: Animal death, human death, supernatural possession

Persuasion, Jane Austen Aberdeen Portrays views of gender and class identity that are rooted in the context of early nineteenth-century England

The Waste Land, TS Eliot Aberdeen Contains references to death and war

The Iliad, Homer Highlands and Islands Violent close combat

Oliver Twist, Charles Dickens Royal Holloway Child abuse

Kidnapped, Robert Louis Stevenson Aberdeen Kidnapping [No! I'd never have guessed it would cover this subject]

The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Agatha Christie Greenwich Contains murder [What! Shocked, I tell you, shocked]

And my favourite: The Bible York Shocking sexual violence

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/339af864-17ce-11ed-b1f4-627a202c7457 (Sorry, I don't have a share token for the article, but you can read it for nothing by signing up with your email address. That way you get to read a few free articles every month.)

So, what are your suggestions of content warnings for university students?

Here's mine:
The Very Hungry Caterpillar - contains description of an eating disorder and consequent physical discomfort

OP posts:
Saucery · 10/08/2022 12:00

Mamette · 10/08/2022 11:58

Peepo

graphic scenes of war and lack of indoor plumbing

Not to mention doggies in doorways who shouldn’t be there!

Mamette · 10/08/2022 11:58

Peepo

graphic scenes of war and lack of indoor plumbing

ClaudineClare · 10/08/2022 11:58

Personally I'd have gone with the news that blackouts are being considered in January, but that's just me

Exactly. Diversionary tactics to keep the plebs' attention off the real issues.

Halsall · 10/08/2022 11:56

SpindleInTheWind · 10/08/2022 08:08

The Oxford Dictionary - contains words

😂😂😂

SleeplessInEngland · 10/08/2022 11:56

ClaudineClare · 10/08/2022 11:39

The Times article is a load of bollocks, as givemushypeasachance posted. Designed to get people frothing over nothing. Also handy for the Tories as it gives the media something to grill ministers about rather than the real issues.

Why do people fall for this shite?

People fall for it because everyone likes feeling superior to the generations that came after them. "In my day we were made of stronger stuff!"

The Times probably submitted thousands of freedom of information requests and happened to find a handful of books out of hundreds of lit courses that were dropped for vague reasons and has made a front page story out of it.

Personally I'd have gone with the news that blackouts are being considered in January, but that's just me.

JudgeJ · 10/08/2022 11:52

Popcorncovered · 10/08/2022 08:17

The Railway children - children should not play near the tracks or make contact with strangers

Nor should a teenage girl be waving her undergarment at a train!

JudgeJ · 10/08/2022 11:51

Breezycheesetrees · 10/08/2022 08:12

I actually thought the examples in your OP we're your spoofs at first. FFS. I work alongside a handful of young graduates in a sector which probably attracts this kind of bullshit more than some, and I find it exhausting how much attention is meant to be given over to alleviating anxiety or uncertainty in the workplace. I'm fairly sure there's a connection. There's so much fragility on display in the workplace which I'm certain wasn't there when I began full-time work 20 years ago. It's really not healthy.

Of course it wasn't there 20 years ago, the whole concept of 'safe spaces', removing books in case they cause anxiety and all the other crap is breeding a generation of whimps who can't face anything because they've never had to. Many TV programmes now have a 'warning' about being 'upsetting to some people', if you're that easily 'upset' don't watch Midsomer Murders etc, dimwit.

NippyWoowoo · 10/08/2022 11:46

Meanwhile, the same pathetically fragile, emotionally stunted students are downloading violent porn and staying up until 5am playing Call of Duty online.

I don't know that these are the same groups of students

ClaudineClare · 10/08/2022 11:39

The Times article is a load of bollocks, as givemushypeasachance posted. Designed to get people frothing over nothing. Also handy for the Tories as it gives the media something to grill ministers about rather than the real issues.

Why do people fall for this shite?

Andante57 · 10/08/2022 11:32

It’s no big deal, just an advance acknowledgment that some people might find the themes difficult because of their personal experience

Oopsfellover so what happens if your students do find these themes difficult? Do you abandon the text and find something else?

CulturePigeon · 10/08/2022 11:22

oopsfellover

My point is that nearly all literature and art can be 'challenging' to 21st C folk. Try reading Wuthering Heights!! Very tough, very sadistic - and truly shocking even today. In art - think of the scenes of cruelty which are pretty much stock-in-trade for the Old Masters. I cannot look at Breughel's Massacre of the Innocents, for example. It's powerful stuff and it's meant to upset us sometimes - and it's OK to be upset. If we weren't - that would be a worry.

Yes, of course you would treat school students with due consideration for their youth and lack of life experience. But for the rest of us, university students included, there are such things as blurbs and synopses, surely, if you're very shockable. I count myself as shockable - and there are bits of literature which have had a profound effect on me. But I'd be insulted if someone tried to 'prepare' me for them. My own teachers (and I, when I was teaching) would tell the students what a book was about before starting to study it - it's part of the process and common sense to do that. But there is a difference now, I think, whereby adults are treated as little children who must be protected. It's particularly ironic, as a PP said, when you bear in mind the horrendous (to me) stuff that youngsters choose to expose themselves to in terms of violence, sex and aggressive language.

It's OK to say fuck and cunt on TV but a massive fuss is made about other words. I'm not too bothered by the f and c words in the context of a really good drama, but I do see the irony here - that's now OK, and other (until now perfectly good) words are taboo. While not minding the 'swearing' so much myself, I do see that making a fuss over other words (eg gender specific ones, not racially abusive ones) is very ironic. I don't have a problem with fashionable people choosing to use, say 'actor', when talking about Judi Dench, but vetoing the use of the word 'actress' is going too far.

givemushypeasachance · 10/08/2022 11:18

They wrote an article that makes it sound like universities across the country are removing hundreds of books but that just isn't true. Since it's behind a paywall, everyone just relies on the headlines and the summary tweets that don't explain the actual data.

"They submitted 300 FOIs and found evidence that two books had been removed from reading lists. But they went ahead and wrote the story they had decided to write anyway... The piece also contradicts almost every piece of evidence it provides in support of the story — if you read on long enough, it turns out the University of Essex actually removed The Underground Railroad from one module because another book was better-suited to the course." twitter.com/tpgcolson/status/1557277139413630976

MuddlerInLaw · 10/08/2022 11:09

DowningStreetParty · 10/08/2022 09:40

There’s a democracy problem being built in if people can’t think critically about what they read.

How are these very young people with their redacted reading lists ever going to feel equipped to actually do anything about the horrific ongoing injustices in the world…. when they can’t even manage to read novels about them?
Who do they think will be running the country for them on their behalf if they rule themselves out? It’s actually very dangerous to shut your eyes and ears to difficult things for any length of time.

Running the country is what we’re training AI to do …

currahee · 10/08/2022 11:07

How times have changed. I had a module on my English literature degree for which Naked Lunch was required reading.

Verbena1 · 10/08/2022 11:03

Winnie the Pooh. Shows worrying depression among the donkey community.
Swallows and Amazons. Children in boats with no lifejackets
Wuthering Heights. Familial discord, ghostly self harming, likely to trigger images of Kate Bush in alarming top register notes

in fact, just about anything ever published.

SleeplessInEngland · 10/08/2022 11:03

This is one of those things certain sections of the media seem to be obsessed with but I just can't muster up the same outrage.

It's one thing for books to be outright banned but courses change selected readings all the time, and good literature will prevail beyond the classroom anyway.

Brefugee · 10/08/2022 10:56

If you were a 17 year old girl who’d been sexually abused you might find the Handmaid’s Tale pretty tough

but it should be up to the course tutors, and the student themselves, to check what the content is. And if there are (as it seems from some pp) websites where you can check a book for triggers - at 17 it is not too much to ask that they do that? Blanket banning in case there is possibly maybe someone in a class of 30 or a course of 60, who might be triggered is batshit.

sueelleker · 10/08/2022 10:55

CurbsideProphet · 10/08/2022 08:01

The Famous Five - children completely unsupervised for days on end, parents should be referred to social services.

Likewise most of the "Swallows and Amazons" series.

undermilkjug · 10/08/2022 10:44

I think the problem with this is that the most powerful and memorable literature is also disturbing - the whole point of it is that it creates an emotional response in the reader.

Like a PP, I read Beloved by Toni Morrison recently - it is astonishingly powerful and novels by black women (especially Nobel Prize for literature winning black women) are few and far between. It is hugely distressing and triggering. It is still an amazing book.

If books are to be deselected from reading lists (not just trigger warnings) because they have the power to disturb, people will not actually get to really see how powerful and world changing literature can be.

Waitwhat23 · 10/08/2022 10:44

I've just realised a previous post of mine was cut off. This is what it meant to say!

I can certainly see the point of trigger warnings for things like suicide, death, miscarriage etc (although not banned) but some of the trigger warnings listed on some of the websites are somewhat odd. One which jumped out was 'historical age gap depictions'.

Waitwhat23 · 10/08/2022 10:41

At least two books have been removed. One temporarily and one permanently.

  • *Details here -

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/08/09/universities-admit-purge-challenging-books-protect-students/

It's just 'frothing' though, right? (Incidently, I'm surprised that that word doesn't have a trigger warning).

FatherJacksBrick · 10/08/2022 10:33

I've just looked across my bookshelf in an attempt to find something funny to add, but realised that EVERY BOOK I own from Terry Pratchett to the Buffy spin off series would probably get cancelled for something.

On the other hand, my dad could have done with a trigger warning when he bought me Jean M Auels "Valley of Horses" as a 10 year old because we had a long road trip coming up, I liked horses and he'd promised me a new book for the journey 😆

Miffee · 10/08/2022 10:30

Underanothersky · 10/08/2022 10:26

Shush, don't let the truth and common sense get in the way of mumsnet frothing about political correctness gone mad wokeness

Of course its overstated, it's the conservative press. It is still worrying, books that have the potential to rattle you should surely to god be the number one priority for these courses not optional extras.

If you are studying it surely having a strong emotional reaction to literature should be encouraged not avoided.

Underanothersky · 10/08/2022 10:26

oopsfellover · 10/08/2022 10:06

I don’t think any of the books have been ‘banned’, have they? Might be wrong, only read the bit of the article I could see without subscribing. But I think things can be overdramatised at times.
Literature will ideally be understood in its context, but as a teacher I think you do have to be careful with some themes. I’m an English teacher and tend to give what might be called a ‘trigger warning’ (not a phrase I’d actually use) if something like suicide, rape/sexual violence, racism or mental illness is likely to come up in the lesson. It’s no big deal, just an advance acknowledgment that some people might find the themes difficult because of their personal experience. It’s true though that you could
find something for almost every text!

Shush, don't let the truth and common sense get in the way of mumsnet frothing about political correctness gone mad wokeness

Miffee · 10/08/2022 10:22

Saucery · 10/08/2022 08:38

One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest - misogyny, extreme violence, abuse of people with mental health issues, racism.
30 years ago I had a really good discussion with a tutor at one of the universities on that list about this book. I was there for interview and was reading it as I waited. He came out and said something along the lines of “Fascinating book! Come in and tell me what you think about it!”

I read that book as a child. I think maybe 10/11? Parents let me read anything in the house which was a lot.

I loved it. Not because I understood the themes but because I was in awe that a book could be narrated by somebody who had one foot outside of reality and the challenge of figuring out what was true. It was a great learning experience. Unreliable narrators remain one of my favourite literary devices to this day.