Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to think we can extend this list a lot? Surely almost every book and film could have a content warning for something?

166 replies

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/08/2022 07:57

The Times today reports that ^universities have started removing books from reading lists to protect students from “challenging” content and have applied trigger warnings to more than 1,000 texts, a Times investigation has found.
Ten universities, including three from the Russell Group, have withdrawn books from course study lists, or made them optional, in case they cause students harm. The texts include the 2017 Pulitzer Prize-winning novel The Underground Railroad, by Colson Whitehead, which has been “removed permanently” from a course reading list at Essex University because of concerns about graphic depictions of slavery.^

There are many serious and obvious things to say about this, but they're all in the article. The aspect that engaged me is that it gives the list in full. I am certain we could help out the university sector by pointing out other potentially distressing books.

Here are some of the examples:

The Ancient Mariner, S. T. Coleridge University of Greenwich Content warning: Animal death, human death, supernatural possession

Persuasion, Jane Austen Aberdeen Portrays views of gender and class identity that are rooted in the context of early nineteenth-century England

The Waste Land, TS Eliot Aberdeen Contains references to death and war

The Iliad, Homer Highlands and Islands Violent close combat

Oliver Twist, Charles Dickens Royal Holloway Child abuse

Kidnapped, Robert Louis Stevenson Aberdeen Kidnapping [No! I'd never have guessed it would cover this subject]

The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Agatha Christie Greenwich Contains murder [What! Shocked, I tell you, shocked]

And my favourite: The Bible York Shocking sexual violence

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/339af864-17ce-11ed-b1f4-627a202c7457 (Sorry, I don't have a share token for the article, but you can read it for nothing by signing up with your email address. That way you get to read a few free articles every month.)

So, what are your suggestions of content warnings for university students?

Here's mine:
The Very Hungry Caterpillar - contains description of an eating disorder and consequent physical discomfort

OP posts:
Grantanow · 10/08/2022 15:48

One step away from censorship. If students can't cope with reading challenging literature like Dickens or Shakespeare or Eliot they should not be at university. What's next? Medical students needn't view diseased patients in case they blub? Trainee vicars needn't read the Old Testament in case they are shocked by drunkenness and incest?

Brefugee · 10/08/2022 15:29

I was only able to find two trigger warning site specifically for books and both of them only had a limited number of books listed, none of the books I had as set texts were listed at all!

i mentioned the possiblity of such a site early on and then pp mentioned someone looking it up and i assumed these sites already existed. My bad.

Perhaps publishers/writers should think about doing that

Kanaloa · 10/08/2022 14:36

And also, removing a book from a course isn’t really ‘banning’ it. They’re not throwing every copy out of the uni library and burning it. Every year the books on my uni list change slightly, whether to reflect a change in topic, because a better/more appropriate book for that course was thought of, just for a change etc. It’s not banning the book to study a different one!

Kanaloa · 10/08/2022 14:34

Most universities do this. They’re not banning or pulling the books - just when I get my syllabus round or an email about a new book it might say ‘this book contains xyz, please contact the department if this raises any issues etc.’ Some of the books we study contain graphic scenes, sometimes of rape/murder etc. And people then know they’ll expect it. Those books aren’t then ‘banned.’

Miffee · 10/08/2022 14:27

SleeplessInEngland · 10/08/2022 12:34

It's a bullshit story anyway though. As this twitter thread explains: twitter.com/tpgcolson/status/1557277139413630976

TL:DR: only 2 books were removed from reading lists - our of 300 FOI requests - and in the case of the Unerground Railroad it's because they found a book on slavery that was better suited to the course.

So it's basically a front page story on one single book being removed to sensitivies. I guess they really wanted to make the drudgery of all those FOI requests worth it.

Well I feel like a bit of a twat for taking seriously to be honest. I do know better too. I think I was too excited for an opportunity to talk about Beloved to think straight.

The moral of the story is everybody should read Beloved.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 10/08/2022 13:54

Newrumpus · 10/08/2022 13:38

Spectacular missing of the point. Books should not be banned. One book being banned by a university is an outrage! It is newsworthy. Even if something else is also newsworthy at the same time.

I agree.

But in reality the vast majority of books are banned by people with a right wing agenda trying to censor books that discuss things like gender or racial issues.

Consistently the most banned and challenged books are books about race and racism, often by black writers. It's certainly not liberal wokesters trying to get black authors banned.

There's far more outrage over concepts like trigger warning, than about school boards banning Holocaust books and demanding that teachers teach both sides of the Holocaust.

Bloodybridget · 10/08/2022 13:47

We're going on a BEAR HUNT??? And this is marketed to young children??

JemimaPuddlegoose · 10/08/2022 13:45

Brefugee · 10/08/2022 12:56

but why should a teenage girl who's been raped and is suicidal be forced to read graphic depictions of rape?

but people aren't disputing that. People are saying that, yes, course tutors could let them have advance warning. But that students are perfectly capable of looking up the book on trigger warning sites?

Do you think there's some kind of universal "trigger warning site"? Because that doesn't exist. I just googled, and almost all of them are just for movies and TV shows, and it's hard to find genuine factual TW sites as many of the ones on google are Christian fundamentalist sites that exist to point out where movies breach Christian teachings.

I was only able to find two trigger warning site specifically for books and both of them only had a limited number of books listed, none of the books I had as set texts were listed at all!

I even googled the title of one of my past set texts + trigger warning and it didn't bring up anything except Amazon reviews.

"Perfectly capable" - but why should a student have to spend hours googling every single book title and going through Amazon reviews and scouring blogs for every single book just in case any of the books contain rape scenes (never mind that many students don't want or their teachers don't want them to read spoilers and plot summaries ahead of time) when a teacher handing out a sheet is so much simpler and easier?

Giving out a sheet and openly discussing trigger warnings also reassure students that they're allowed to opt-out of reading things like graphic rape scenes, because students from abused and traumatic backgrounds often struggle with asserting themselves. Can you imagine being 18 years old and having to approach say a 50year old male professor you'd never met before, and not only having to disclose extremely personal things about your mental health and the fact you were raped to him, but also make a demand changes to his curriculum? Many adults would struggle with that!

SleeplessInEngland · 10/08/2022 13:43

Books should not be banned

It's not been 'banned' ffs. What do you think that word means?

Newrumpus · 10/08/2022 13:38

SleeplessInEngland · 10/08/2022 12:34

It's a bullshit story anyway though. As this twitter thread explains: twitter.com/tpgcolson/status/1557277139413630976

TL:DR: only 2 books were removed from reading lists - our of 300 FOI requests - and in the case of the Unerground Railroad it's because they found a book on slavery that was better suited to the course.

So it's basically a front page story on one single book being removed to sensitivies. I guess they really wanted to make the drudgery of all those FOI requests worth it.

Spectacular missing of the point. Books should not be banned. One book being banned by a university is an outrage! It is newsworthy. Even if something else is also newsworthy at the same time.

ErrolTheDragon · 10/08/2022 13:34

Hotchox · 10/08/2022 13:08

And while I'm at it, does everyone up in arms here get similarly worked up about the little list of content warnings that pop up at the start of any non-PG programs on the telly? I genuinely can't see much difference between that and what the universities are doing? It's just about making an informed choice surely?

No difference between wanting to watch a tv show in your own home (where you may have children and teens present) and adults who've signed up for an English Literature degree?

Hotchox · 10/08/2022 13:08

And while I'm at it, does everyone up in arms here get similarly worked up about the little list of content warnings that pop up at the start of any non-PG programs on the telly? I genuinely can't see much difference between that and what the universities are doing? It's just about making an informed choice surely?

Hotchox · 10/08/2022 13:03

twitter.com/tpgcolson/status/1557277139413630976 - much fun as this thread is, it doesn't look like many books were banned anyway - the Times article is something of a stretch - only TWO books seem to have been removed from reading lists.

Furthermore, while I'm sure everyone's having a lot of fun thinking up absurd trigger warnings, I know a kid with PTSD, and the last time he was 'triggered', he beat the shit out of a kid who happened to be standing nearby. So in the light of scenarios like that, perhaps universities would prefer there to be too many trigger warnings than not enough....🤔

Brefugee · 10/08/2022 12:56

but why should a teenage girl who's been raped and is suicidal be forced to read graphic depictions of rape?

but people aren't disputing that. People are saying that, yes, course tutors could let them have advance warning. But that students are perfectly capable of looking up the book on trigger warning sites?

JemimaPuddlegoose · 10/08/2022 12:47

Most books that get censored are censored because they're too "woke", not the opposite.

Historically it's right wing and far right wing influences who censor and burn books, but where's the outrage over that amongst all the mockery of "woke snowflakes"?

Books about the Holocaust were banned from Tennessee schools last year, ostensibly due to them containing swear words but it's hard not to see a very direct link between banning Holocaust books and announcements (eg the one in Texas which came just three months before the Holocaust book was banned) that schools "must teach both sides of the Holocaust" in the interest of "fairness".

It's not woke eft wing snowflakes trying to push Holocaust denial in schools, and that's far more serious than letting girls who have been raped opt out from reading Tess of the d'Urbervilles.

DdraigGoch · 10/08/2022 12:38

IStandWithMaya · 10/08/2022 09:21

Cinderella - child cruelty

Sleeping Beauty - sexual advance by male whilst she is sleeping

Snow White - offensive to those with genetic height difference

Hansel and Gretel - child abduction and torture

The Emperor's New Clothes - man exposes his genitalia

You should see what the Brothers Grimm originally published. The evil stepsisters hacking off their heels in an effort to fit into the glass slipper...

SleeplessInEngland · 10/08/2022 12:34

MuddlerInLaw · 10/08/2022 12:21

ClaudineClare · Today 11:58
Personally I'd have gone with the news that blackouts are being considered in January, but that's just me

Exactly. Diversionary tactics to keep the plebs' attention off the real issues.

Personally, (what with all the decades and degrees and letters after my name,) I’m more than capable of reading an article in The Times, drawing my own conclusions, engaging with a humorous MN thread on the subject and keeping a critical eye on national affairs …

It's a bullshit story anyway though. As this twitter thread explains: twitter.com/tpgcolson/status/1557277139413630976

TL:DR: only 2 books were removed from reading lists - our of 300 FOI requests - and in the case of the Unerground Railroad it's because they found a book on slavery that was better suited to the course.

So it's basically a front page story on one single book being removed to sensitivies. I guess they really wanted to make the drudgery of all those FOI requests worth it.

DdraigGoch · 10/08/2022 12:28

SpindleInTheWind · 10/08/2022 08:08

The Oxford Dictionary - contains words

And definitions of words. It's very triggering to know what words mean, you know.

FOJN · 10/08/2022 12:27

Personally, (what with all the decades and degrees and letters after my name,) I’m more than capable of reading an article in The Times, drawing my own conclusions, engaging with a humorous MN thread on the subject and keeping a critical eye on national affairs …

Show off 😁

JemimaPuddlegoose · 10/08/2022 12:24

I'm honestly not saying this to be argumentative (for once!) but there is this assumption that uni students are soft and middle class and from sheltered backgrounds where they've never been exposed to anything horrible. In reality it's the opposite: trigger warnings are there primarily to protect students from severely traumatic backgrounds, and in my experience it's mainly those students asking for them.

Yeah okay it's obviously laughable to TW Agatha Christie as containing murder, and Ancient Mariner being TW "supernatural possession" made me laugh, but why should a teenage girl who's been raped and is suicidal be forced to read graphic depictions of rape? Or a child war refugee read about battles and massacres?

I studied comparative literature which was King Lear and a modern re-telling called A Thousand Acres. I'd read King Lear before and was fine with it. I didn't know until I was halfway through that A Thousand Acres is all about incest and a dad raping his daughters, and as an incest survivor living alone in a bedsit with (at then undiagnosed) clinical depression and PTSD and without any support, being forced to read a book about incest really fucked me up and did a lot of damage to the point it made me start self-harming for the first time. I wish I'd been told ahead of time that it was specifically about incest. Nothing to do with being a "snowflake" since King Lear is far more violent and graphic.

My study partner at uni was another mature student who'd come to the UK as a refugee and worked at the Foreign Office as an interpreter, and because of the languages she spoke, most of her work was translating testimony from torture and genocide survivors. She asked to have one of her set texts (an autobiography from one of the Beirut hostages) changes because it was too overwhelming and close to home.

Waitwhat23 · 10/08/2022 12:24

Saucery · 10/08/2022 12:00

Not to mention doggies in doorways who shouldn’t be there!

Also, the whole concept of the hole in the page. It gives you a glimpse of the page ahead but who knows? There might be untold horrors hidden around the sides!

MuddlerInLaw · 10/08/2022 12:21

ClaudineClare · Today 11:58
Personally I'd have gone with the news that blackouts are being considered in January, but that's just me

Exactly. Diversionary tactics to keep the plebs' attention off the real issues.

Personally, (what with all the decades and degrees and letters after my name,) I’m more than capable of reading an article in The Times, drawing my own conclusions, engaging with a humorous MN thread on the subject and keeping a critical eye on national affairs …

Puppypads · 10/08/2022 12:09

SpindleInTheWind · 10/08/2022 08:08

The Oxford Dictionary - contains words

😂😂😂

JudgeJ · 10/08/2022 12:07

Verbena1 · 10/08/2022 11:03

Winnie the Pooh. Shows worrying depression among the donkey community.
Swallows and Amazons. Children in boats with no lifejackets
Wuthering Heights. Familial discord, ghostly self harming, likely to trigger images of Kate Bush in alarming top register notes

in fact, just about anything ever published.

The father in S and A would be on some Social Services naughty step for “Better drowned than duffers, if not duffers won't drown.”, one of my favourite quotes about child rearing!

JudgeJ · 10/08/2022 12:01

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/08/2022 09:34

Moby D—k
say No more

Didn't I read recently that something that was named after Dick Turpin has had parents demanding it be renamed Richard Turpin to protect their sprogs?

Swipe left for the next trending thread