Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked at how common gaslighting is

42 replies

crochetmonkey74 · 10/08/2022 07:56

Out and healed from a relationship where gaslighting was a problem in the last few months (fuelled by cowardice on his part)
Am dating again, some successes, some not so much but the thing I have noticed is that gaslighting is so so common. Over really trivial things. (Who said they would call first is one example) I'm not talking about genuine mistakes here, I'm common sense enough to know the difference. In the example above, an online date was reluctant to arrange a real life call, didn't do it, we rearranged and then he didn't reply to the arrangement. Couple of days later he messaged as if nothing was wrong. When I said in polite terms he had been too flaky and clearly didn't want to move on from the constant messaging, he made a story up about how I had got the dates wrong, he only wanted to fit in with me etc etc. When I replied with a screenshot to prove that was all bollocks, he said "fair enough, worth a shot" as if the gaslighting was a thing he'd been caught out in!!!
He is just one in a line of varying degrees of it. I'm a teacher and even at school we are trying to tackle the easy way boys slip into lying or massaging the truth (also more to female teachers) whereas girls tend to tell a story more like the truth.
I'm not bothered or invested about this guy in particular, we were only at the chatting stage, I'm more shocked at how prevalent GL is!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Elvira2000 · 15/08/2022 05:52

My DS thinks that a plausible version of events is philosophically the same as the actual truth if noone can prove otherwise and hasn't compunction about lying.

This is what I dealt with at school. It was always the boys (in my experience). And so common in my last school, that is definitely one of the reasons i left. I hate it.

BritWifeInUSA · 15/08/2022 05:28

MissMaple82 · 10/08/2022 09:05

There's a big difference between lying and actual gaslighting though. Gaslighting, like narcissistic is become a throw about term for shitty behaviours, but it goes much deeper than just that.

Thank you! I agree!

Gaslighting is thrown out there far too easily these days. There’s being deceitful such as claiming you didn’t say or do something purely because you’re too cowardly to deal with the consequences, and there’s sustained mental torture to the point where the victim questions their own sanity. The latter is gaslighting. The former is being a coward.

The very nature of gaslighting means that it can’t really be used to describe a one-off or a trivial incident. It’s a prolonged, calculated form of mental abuse. I’ve seen on here posters telling an OP her husband was gaslighting because he told the OP he didn’t like the new outfit she had bought and that it made her look fat. Sure, it’s not kind to say that. Could even be labeled as hurtful or upsetting but it’s a million miles from gaslighting, especially as it may even have been true (just not what the OP wanted to hear).

crochetmonkey74 · 15/08/2022 00:24

I think people just find these words trendy and use then without understanding them to sound all learned and well read
I think that's really reductive and patronising.
People don't need to gatekeep, maybe people aren't jumping on the bandwagon, or getting it wrong. Maybe now there's more awareness, people have a name for what they've been experiencing and can get support.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 14/08/2022 09:22

Like others said, gaslighting is different to lying. It has a specific purpose which is more sinister.

People have a habit of throwing germs around like narcissism, gaslighting, anxiety etc without understanding what they mean. If someone is being nasty, they are automatically called a narcissist. If someone is lazy and doesn’t want to do something, they have anxiety all of a sudden. Anyone lying nowadays must be gaslighting others.

I think people just find these words trendy and use then without understanding them to sound all learned and well read.

blackheartsgirl · 14/08/2022 09:00

AdamRyan · 10/08/2022 11:21

Was there any indication that girls don't do it too?

Nope there wasn’t, and I wasn’t arguing just stating my experience.

I’m well aware that gaslighting behaviour/playing games occurs in females.

I was just sad that my own daughter does it to me

crochetmonkey74 · 10/08/2022 18:03

I'm wondering if you're more inclined to view dishonest behaviour more negatively from boys than from girls
Definitely not, as I said before it's a school wide focus for us, not a personal response

OP posts:
Bubblebubblebah · 10/08/2022 13:10

Scuttlingherbert · 10/08/2022 08:32

I think there's a difference between lying and gaslighting.

Lying is saying something that is not true, maybe to get out of trouble or for other reasons.

Gaslighting is very specifically lying or taking other actions to make someone doubt their own sanity.

Agreed

AdamRyan · 10/08/2022 13:01

Dotjones · 10/08/2022 11:32

It's not gender specific, it's just that "playing games" has always been an acceptable part of a woman's arsenal and now men are catching on to how effective it can be too. It's not that the problem is worse now, just that there is more awareness.

What? Men have learnt gaslighting from women? What twaddle

Some not very nice humans lie and gaslight. The recommended strategy is to avoid

justmaybenot · 10/08/2022 12:00

I feel like in general people fib and lie way too easily and honesty is no longer a very strong value - so many times on MN people's advice is to lie to get out of things - eg pretend you have COVID if you have unwanted visitors, or that your child is busy if you don't want them to go to a party etc. I find it really strange as lying was a deeply serious misdemeanour in my family/school when younger and I wonder if it's no longer treated as such.

spirit20 · 10/08/2022 11:43

"I'm a teacher and even at school we are trying to tackle the easy way boys slip into lying or massaging the truth (also more to female teachers) whereas girls tend to tell a story more like the truth'

I would see 'telling a story more like the truth' as lying as well, unless the story is 11% the truth. I'm wondering if you're more inclined to view dishonest behaviour more negatively from boys than from girls. As a teacher myself, I know boys will try it on with female teachers more and girls will try it on with male teachers more.

I don't think lying and gaslighting are the same - kids will lie to try and get out of trouble, but gaslighting is more when someone is trying to gain power over you, make it seem like whatever happened is your fault and make you doubt yourself.

Dotjones · 10/08/2022 11:32

It's not gender specific, it's just that "playing games" has always been an acceptable part of a woman's arsenal and now men are catching on to how effective it can be too. It's not that the problem is worse now, just that there is more awareness.

AdamRyan · 10/08/2022 11:26

Loopsa · 10/08/2022 09:10

I know people like this, and they get on a lot better in life than I do. I have been told that sticking to truth/facts, or being honest about things that show you in a poorer light shows low intelligence and a distinct inability to maximise the situation. Added to that the conversations about how subjective truth is in most matters and it's all a bit of a headache for me!

This is the problem. Its not "clever" to lie, it's dishonest. People who are honest aren't stupid. If everyone lied whenever it suited them, society would break down.

Also, it's not a good long term strategy. Lying and gaslighting might work in the short term but in the long term you lose the trust of the other person as they figure out what you are doing.

Unfortunately I agree with op, once you've been on the receiving end of systematic gaslighting you see it everywhere.

AdamRyan · 10/08/2022 11:21

blackheartsgirl · 10/08/2022 10:06

girls/women do it as well.

unfortunately dd15 does it to me (sadly learnt from her dad, my ex)

she’s not very good at it and I call it out every single time but it’s hurtful

Was there any indication that girls don't do it too?

AdamRyan · 10/08/2022 11:20

I think gaslighting has 2 components: 1) lying and then when caught 2) blaming the other person to avoid admitting the lie. So denying the event ever happened, making up a plausible alternative solution and acting as if you truly believe that's what happened, claiming the other party said/did something they didn't....
It's the second bit that's so infuriating as it's extremely disrespectful and also takes advantage of people's tendency to see nuance/accept responsibility

blackheartsgirl · 10/08/2022 10:06

girls/women do it as well.

unfortunately dd15 does it to me (sadly learnt from her dad, my ex)

she’s not very good at it and I call it out every single time but it’s hurtful

80sMum · 10/08/2022 10:02

PineForestsAndSunshine · 10/08/2022 08:25

I think there is gaslighting, in the sense of purposefully trying to make someone question their reality for the purposes of unsettling and controlling them, and there is lying to save one's arse.

I think most people who fit into the 'save one's arse' category do it simply because they lack the skills to admit failure. Sometimes this comes from an upbringing where the consequences of admitting wrong-doing are worse than or equal to the consequences of lying, so they learn that it's best to chance a lie first. Sometime in men particularly I think it might be a result of toxic masculinity. In this case I think it is fear of being seen as being wrong, because being wrong is seen as a weakness. I always think Donald Trump is an excellent example of this!

I agree with this analysis.

WaveyHair · 10/08/2022 10:01

Happens all the time & spills over into work. Worked for someone who did this constantly so he and his side kick could get away with bullying and lying about me to their manager without facing consequences. Constant denial when confronted with facts - don't remember that been the favourite.

crochetmonkey74 · 10/08/2022 09:57

Yes I know the technical term and origin of it, I am saying how common it is, how this behaviour is trickling down. Maybe as we are more aware of it, we see it. I have met many men who are completely OK with making me feel like I was wrong, even when they know they are lying ( as was the case in my OP)

OP posts:
FOJN · 10/08/2022 09:33

I wonder if it is the intention or the effect which distinguishes between lying and gaslighting. The word originates from a film where the husband undertook quite a deliberate campaign to make his wife think she was losing her mind and to convince other people she was too but I think it's perfectly reasonable to apply it to situations where someone asserts themselves strongly enough, about something you know not to be true, to the point you doubt your own recollection.

For example: partner one asked partner two to pick up a loaf of bread whilst they're out, they discuss what type of bread and partner two agrees but then comes home without the bread.

Partner two says that the shop did not have bread but in fact forgot they needed to get bread, this is an arse saving lie.

Partner two aggressively asserts that partner one never asked them to get bread and partner one wonders whether they imagined the conversation. Partner two may claim they were never asked because they forgot so again it's an arse saving lie but it's still made partner one question their recollection. I think this is both a lie and gaslighting. Partner two may have genuinely forgotten about the bread but our memory can usually be jogged when details of a conversation our recounted, most people would then say, oh shit, sorry it completely slipped my mind rather than double down on insisting the conversation never happened.

balalake · 10/08/2022 09:14

Sadly not surprised.

crochetmonkey74 · 10/08/2022 09:13

AdamRyan · 10/08/2022 09:02

My DS thinks that a plausible version of events is philosophically the same as the actual truth if noone can prove otherwise and hasn't compunction about lying.
Whereas I was bought up that lying was morally wrong and lying about something was often more serious than the thing itself.
I do feel like something must have changed that makes it more acceptable?

recently, there was an article exploring why we have stopped believing experts and put equal weight on unsubstantiated social media - maybe this has had an effect too- people are no longer interested in the unequivocal truth- they will look for something that suits their outlook instead

OP posts:
Loopsa · 10/08/2022 09:10

AdamRyan · 10/08/2022 09:02

My DS thinks that a plausible version of events is philosophically the same as the actual truth if noone can prove otherwise and hasn't compunction about lying.
Whereas I was bought up that lying was morally wrong and lying about something was often more serious than the thing itself.
I do feel like something must have changed that makes it more acceptable?

I know people like this, and they get on a lot better in life than I do. I have been told that sticking to truth/facts, or being honest about things that show you in a poorer light shows low intelligence and a distinct inability to maximise the situation. Added to that the conversations about how subjective truth is in most matters and it's all a bit of a headache for me!

crochetmonkey74 · 10/08/2022 09:10

MissMaple82 · 10/08/2022 09:05

There's a big difference between lying and actual gaslighting though. Gaslighting, like narcissistic is become a throw about term for shitty behaviours, but it goes much deeper than just that.

of course, but in the context of this thread, we know what we mean

OP posts:
LadyDP · 10/08/2022 09:06

Reading and Learning. Thankyou

MissMaple82 · 10/08/2022 09:05

There's a big difference between lying and actual gaslighting though. Gaslighting, like narcissistic is become a throw about term for shitty behaviours, but it goes much deeper than just that.