Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does she *Need to go full time if I don’t *Need her to?

87 replies

Charliesays77 · 09/08/2022 22:05

I’m British but live abroad.
Where I am, compulsory schooling doesn’t start until age 6, pre school is age 3-6 and it’s optional.
Dd is 4 and I’d like to send her part time, I’m a Sahm at present (due to complete masters next year-hopefully!) and Early years & Primary school teacher.
We do lots of activities at home, lots of outings, lots of play dates and playgrounds and so on. Dd can read short words and write a little, I’m not overly concerned about the educational aspect at all. Socially we see lots of friends and play with neighbours.
Would it be weird to send her part time, at least for the first year-say two days per week or would you put her in full time, if you didn’t *Have to?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Intothewoodland · 10/08/2022 09:24

Charliesays77 · 10/08/2022 09:07

@Intothewoodland This is the thing…I have two years until she has to go to formal school and full time.

My approach would probably be to work up to full time. I would probably keep her part time for now then aim for her to be doing full time in the play based setting by the end of the year before she goes into the formal learning environment.

dottiedodah · 10/08/2022 09:12

I think it depends on the other children really .would others be doing the same or would she be going mornings or whatever then missing lunchtime play and afternoon story colouring and so on .they tend to settle quite quickly. Would she still be able to socialise at home if other children are at school

Charliesays77 · 10/08/2022 09:07

@Intothewoodland This is the thing…I have two years until she has to go to formal school and full time.

OP posts:
Intothewoodland · 10/08/2022 08:38

My son has been in reception the last year and has loved it. It is very informal and play based but he has also got used to school routines and traditions which he has loved. Year one will be different and much more formal learning. It would have been quite a jump for him to go two days a week in a different setting to full time in school.

Timeforanewnamenow · 10/08/2022 06:22

Augend23 · 09/08/2022 22:28

I was very tired by going to school full time, but I also tend to think 2 days a week is very little. Presumably it's not formal if she's in a kindergarten setting. I definitely see benefits to sending her part time, but I'd probably go with 3 days a week so she has enough time to bond with the children there and feel part of what's going on?

I would do 3 days a week too. I think 2 is a bit unsettling. Then she still has 2 bonus days with you !

mrssunshinexxx · 10/08/2022 05:57

@Charliesays77 I'd do 2/3 days a week maximum

wildseas · 10/08/2022 05:50

Do you speak English with your dd ? What is your home language ? Is she native speaker level in the country language ? Is she truly bilingual or does she still make mistakes / have an accent in one of the languages?

you don’t have to answer those questions here but they are worth considering - if the country language isn’t her home language I think 4 or 5 days at school would be a better choice.

SpidersAreShitheads · 10/08/2022 05:21

I have quite an alternative view on schooling. My twins (DS and DD) went to nursery P/T and then attended school F/T until they were 10 and then we locked down for COVID. That was the March of Y5 for them.

They've never returned to school. We discovered they blossomed with home education and the incredible anxiety that DS struggled with every week disappeared. without using up every scrap of his resilience in just making it through school DS had so much more capacity to take on learning and engage in life. DD was similar although her anxiety was so much more masked than DS. We discovered during lockdown that she'd essentially been copying the other pupils a lot of the time and couldn't actually follow/understand instructions on her own.

My two are autistic, DS was in a special school and diagnosed at age 4. DD was diagnosed age 10 which was confirmed during lockdown. Obviously this plays a big part but I think the principles are the same.

My approach has always been that - if needed - you can catch up with academic knowledge but it's much more difficult to mend mental health or to get over anxiety. In other countries formal education doesn't start until age 7, and our infants seem so very tiny and young. I was a school governor for more than five years and at a lovely, lovely school. The head there came from an alternative background and also believed forcing learning and curriculum on very young children wasn't right and that they'd learn so more through play. I very much appreciated his experience and insight into this, and he embedded it as much as possible but OFTSED and the National Curriculum left his hands tied somewhat.

What I'm saying is that it's possible for children to bloom and grow beautifully without going to school at all. Two days sounds like a lovely compromise. And definitely full days; that gives her the experience of a full day at school which is very different to just a morning. You've already said if she wants to go more, you'll accommodate this so I think it's a great balanced approach. Your DD will benefit so much from spending nurturing time with you while she's not completely exhausted from being at school 5 days a week from such a young age.

Just also pointing out no criticism at all for those where 5 days per week is right for their child. Every child is different and that's what I think is important - being able to make choices to create an environment which suits your child. Given what you've said re anxiety and being so young, I think a slow and steady approach would be perfect. And I'm sure the days with you will be absolutely wonderful for her, and she'll learn all sorts of things that stand her in good stead for the future.

mathanxiety · 10/08/2022 04:22

My DCs went to school in the US where formal kindergarten starts at age 5.

All the local preschool options were two and a half hours a day for four days only. Maybe point out to your parents and British friends that the British expectation of very young children being in school all day, five days a week, with full uniform, is an anomaly.

I agree with your gut feeling that 4 is so young to have children in Reception. Despite the claim that it's play based, there is an expectation that phonics will be tackled, and there are benchmarks to attain.

I would send your DD for 3 consecutive days per week. See how she does on the third day each week for about three weeks.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 10/08/2022 03:59

3 & 4 year kindy here are both part time 2-3 days a week. I think that works well. First year of school most kids are between 5 & 6. For me if I was at home during the week I wouldn't do more then 3 days.

StClare101 · 10/08/2022 03:42

I wouldn’t send full time at that age unless I wanted/needed to.

Both our kids went to a preschool program that was 5 days per fortnight. It was perfect for them and for us because we didn’t need full time care at that stage.

Aintnosupermum · 10/08/2022 02:26

It wholly depends on your child, where you live and what the curriculum is.

In Denmark they start formal education at 6 but lots of learning takes place in their nursery program. They learn how to communicate, work in a team and their gross physical development is impressive. The parents supplement with academics at home. Our youngest went through it and honestly I wasn’t impressed. She did learn Danish though.

In the US, it depends where you live but generally speaking you can find excellent programs which are a shorter day and very much play based. We did the public school program and it was great. They used tools of the mind which is based on the Russian system. 100% play based and excellent at allowing the child to develop at their own pace. My elder two did this program and it worked. 8:30am - 2:30pm was the full day schedule and that included a nap time for 45mins after lunch. You could pick up your child after lunch if there was an issue, otherwise, as it was government funded, you needed to attend the full day program with less than 10 consecutive days absent in a year. They strongly encouraged any travel as was considered excellent for their development.

zoeFromCity · 10/08/2022 02:18

I am from region where school starts for 6 yo.

I went for 3 days when I was 5, more wasn't possible due to lack of places. It was technically enough, but I'd prefer (both back in time and in retrospect) doing a bit more, so starting part time at 4 and (almost) full-time at 5 sounds great. I would think about 3 days for now though (maybe 2 full and one half), just to be present more often than not and build better friendships.

Lately the law changed, so every 5 yo either goes to pre-school, or come for observation sessions, just to confirm they are developing well and will be ready for school. This is connected with semi formal curriculum for 5 yo (colours, songs, animals, drawing, recognising sounds in words). It is understood as good balance between allowing families to govern their lives and ensuring children are ready.

What would change the position for me would be if your family language doesn't match language used at school, in such case I'd definitely vote for more time at pre school.

TheWordOfBagheera · 10/08/2022 01:57

I'm in a country that sounds similar to what you're describing. The youngest in the year start K at 3 which feels tiny for school (the ages follow the actual year rather than the school year so if your bday is sep-dec you're one of the youngest).

I skipped the first year of kindergarten for mine and only put them in for the second, except for one who was desperate to start sooner. They all did perfectly well socially and academically. I wouldn't have wanted them to skip K completely as having a 'fun' year feels important, but skipping only the first year worked well and might be another option for you?

SunscreenCentral · 10/08/2022 01:36

Where I live, 5 is the preferred age for starting. It's permissible to put them in after their 4th birthday.
Circumstances permitting most people I know go for after the 5th.

5zeds · 10/08/2022 01:23

I’ve done both (as in sent earlier and later). It sounds like she’s happy, learning and settled, so there’s no reason really to send her at all. The negatives of not going full time are (more for girls than for boys because of how they socialise) that she may find friendships a little more difficult. You may also find there are less of her age group around during school hours and less clubs/activities. She may miss things like performances and trips or dress up days which can be a problem. From your point of view you get all the hassle of school but have less time child free to compensate. Try not to do all the mundane chores while she’s in school or she will miss learning lots of life skills and experience.

id just go with what works for your child. As far as academics or long time social skills etc, I honestly think she could stay home till 7 and be fine.

liveforsummer · 10/08/2022 00:37

Agree though 3 days is good for continuity. Also does she need to learn a second language or do you speak that at home anyway?

liveforsummer · 10/08/2022 00:36

Did started school in a country with similar - to use the school pre school you'd have had to go every day. If wanted 2 days then a private nursery which plenty people did. Much like the UK there was a mix of fill and org time based on need although the pre school was still fairly play based it was more formal than a UK nursery.

BungleandGeorge · 10/08/2022 00:31

Some children struggle to settle on 2 days a week, you might find going 3 days is easier on her (one of them could be a half day if you like).

Goldencarp · 10/08/2022 00:27

Charliesays77 · 09/08/2022 22:23

@Goldencarp What would be your reasons for keeping them at home until 6, if you could?
When I mention doing part time to people, they seem to think it’s crazy or they don’t understand.

@Charliesays77 . I personally think kids start school too young in this country. I loved having them home and was in a position to stay home with them so it made sense for us.

mamabear715 · 10/08/2022 00:17

I agree with @Rowen32
Follow your instincts, OP.
I'd have kept mine at home until they were 21 if it had been up to me! (They might have had a better education too.. )

dreamingbohemian · 10/08/2022 00:09

Because you shouldn't mistake the lack of formal curriculum for the enormous amount of educational and social learning that's going on, and bc the preschool community can be a nice little family that will be harder to join if you are that PT. Also language reasons assuming it's at least bilingual.

I would send Mon and Tues, take a break Wed, then Thurs and Fri. And feel free to take ad hoc days a lot.

People love the idea of starting proper school at 6 but that late start is really assuming kids are in preschool for a few years before.

That's just my experience from Berlin though! Its different everywhere.

Pythonesque · 10/08/2022 00:08

I agree that part-time sounds entirely sensible in your position. I'd aim to find out more about the preschool routines, which activities tend to occur which mornings and afternoons, as part of deciding which days to send her at first.

My eldest niece had a wonderful year when she was 5, in yr 1, as her mother was on maternity leave and an enlightened head teacher was happy to authorise partial attendance for some children. So Fridays (except when there was something special on at school) became days for outings, to the zoo or museums or whatever. It worked brilliantly and they would have done another year the same only the head changed and everyone had to be in 100% again. Those outings were much quieter and easier on a weekday than they would have been on weekends.

Threelittlelambs · 10/08/2022 00:07

I was happy for mine to go part time two days a week. It meant I could get things done and they’d have more of my focus on the days they were at home.

Sarahcoggles · 09/08/2022 23:58

Part time definitely.
I've never understood the desire of SAHPs to send their kids off to full time pre school as soon as they can, unless they have issues that make child care difficult. I have teens now who barely know I exist. Make the most of these early years!