Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think someone isn’t owed an organ from a sibling?

216 replies

NellesVilla · 09/08/2022 19:06

I’ve known a few people- weirdly- that have given/received kidneys from other family members over the years.

I think that it is incredibly kind and selfless to do this for another person in need, but think that there’s so much guilt involved and that one person doesn’t owe a kidney, particularly if the recipient is not their own offspring.

I know 2 x people; basics as follows:-

  • R for recipient and D for donor/possible donor. They are siblings, but not close siblings or even really in touch.
  • R is on dialysis and is hoping to get a new kidney in the next year or so.
  • D- a sibling- not a close sibling, has been cited as a possible match. The parents are not able to donate and are hoping that D will “come good”.
  • D thinks that R should offer the kidney like it’s a sweet and that it’s nothing. Also, that is not needed by R. R also isn’t interested in any sort of relationship with D and is happy to take the organ and run.
  • D is- regardless of the relationship- v sympathetic towards this plight- but couldn’t be less interested in risking their life for someone who doesn’t give a fig about them.
  • Sadly, R has kids. D doesn’t but may do so in the future.
  • Everyone thinks “how nice” it would be for R to help their sibling, but wouldn’t dream of offering themselves- friends, family etc.
  • Lastly the most interesting fact is, that D’s partner-father to the kids- is also not keen on being tested and has made up every excuse/reason under the sun to avoid being so. The partner feels that it would be nice for R to help out their sibling- obviously!!
OP posts:
mbosnz · 11/08/2022 17:59

I scarcely think undergoing a rather serious operation, and literally giving someone a kidney rates merely as 'doing a nice thing'! It's not like taking in someone's parcel, or making sure they're stocked up with milk and bread upon their return. . .

whumpthereitis · 11/08/2022 17:55

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 17:51

@whumpthereitis

I never said it was a duty or anything of the sort

Most don't do nice things out of duty

Then no one should expect a sibling to give them an organ, or consider it ‘not nice’ if they choose not to 🤷🏻‍♀️

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 17:51

@whumpthereitis

I never said it was a duty or anything of the sort

Most don't do nice things out of duty

Toddlerteaplease · 11/08/2022 17:49

WhoMe231 · 09/08/2022 21:58

There was an article in the paper a few years ago, a girl (around 22 years old) gave her boyfriend her kidney…whilst she was recovering in hospital he cheated on her 😱 She said she is so angry to know her kidney is still out there in the world and she can’t use it. Made me seriously reconsider EVER donating anything of mine!

Wouldn't the recipient be in hospital longer than the donor though?!

whumpthereitis · 11/08/2022 17:39

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 17:30

@whumpthereitis

And the likelihood of both a sibling and your child needing your singular organ?

Very low

Again, not moral coercion, it would never be said but would be felt after the fact.

Oh please, such an attitude would be conveyed, either verbally or in actions. No one should feel compelled to give up organs, ever. It should only be a choice freely made.

Their children may not need it, no. That doesn’t mean they have a duty to give it to their siblings, however. Some people may decide to keep their kidney solely because they want to keep their kidney. That’s entirely reasonable too.

It’s wild what people think their siblings owe them. I don’t think being cut out by someone with such entitlement should worry anyone, tbh. If I ever found myself being faced with that I would actively encourage them to think as badly of me as they liked, far away from me.

Toddlerteaplease · 11/08/2022 17:37

I absolutely would for my sister. But we get on very well. And there are also a handful of others I'd give one too. But not if I was estranged I don't think,

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 17:30

@whumpthereitis

And the likelihood of both a sibling and your child needing your singular organ?

Very low

Again, not moral coercion, it would never be said but would be felt after the fact.

BadNomad · 11/08/2022 17:29

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 17:19

@whumpthereitis

Hardly moral coercion

Thankfully my family give a shit so this wouldn't be an issue, but I don't think too highly of those who would refuse to give a life saving organ to a member of their own family.

Especially 'just in case' someone more deserving needed it in future

But would you donate it to a family member who doesn't give a shit about you? One who won't give a shit about you afterwards either.

whumpthereitis · 11/08/2022 17:28

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 17:19

@whumpthereitis

Hardly moral coercion

Thankfully my family give a shit so this wouldn't be an issue, but I don't think too highly of those who would refuse to give a life saving organ to a member of their own family.

Especially 'just in case' someone more deserving needed it in future

‘If you don’t give me an organ, you’re a terrible person’ (or words to that effect) is moral coercion.

and most people would consider their children to be ‘more deserving’ than a sibling, although no one actually ‘deserves’ someone else’s organs.

rarelyontime · 11/08/2022 17:24

thing47 · 11/08/2022 15:48

I do get this @rarelyontime but I'd just like to say that I think the majority of organ recipients are grateful beyond words to donors – I don't know what percentage of recipients don't make any efforts to look after themselves, but DH and I certainly haven't come across that many at all during his 30+ years of kidney disease. For the vast majority, kidney disease is just a condition they have, they are no more to blame for it than people who develop cancer or MS, for example.

The thing is, even if they did do everything perfectly, you still couldn't guarantee the organ wouldn't be rejected. In which case, I wouldn't be angry at the recipient, I'd just be generally angry at the world. I'd still have a lot of negative emotions to deal with, that I might never come to terms with.

You can't guarantee the recipient would live a long life. You can't guarantee I wouldn't have any complications. The only fact you could guarantee would be that I'd be a kidney down.

As someone who is really risk adverse, it just doesn't sit well with me.

Maybe I'm selfish hoarding all of my body parts, but at least I'm honest about it. I think it's much worse to pretend you would donate an organ but then back out if that scenario became a reality rather than a hypothetical.

Live donation? I would do anything for love, but I won't do that.

I think people who do consent to live donation - especially when it's not even for a loved one - are incredible people, and I just don't understand how they can be that selfless and kind. They're better humans than I am.

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 17:19

@whumpthereitis

Hardly moral coercion

Thankfully my family give a shit so this wouldn't be an issue, but I don't think too highly of those who would refuse to give a life saving organ to a member of their own family.

Especially 'just in case' someone more deserving needed it in future

whumpthereitis · 11/08/2022 16:56

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 15:51

Well no one ever owes anyone anything

But thankfully in a pleasant society people do things for others because they're decent human beings who care.

My sibling would never owe me an organ

But if they refused they'd have shown themselves as someone who doesn't care if I live or die

And that attitude would then be returned in favour

And they should do those things freely and without ‘moral’ coercion.

If I chose to donate an organ it would not be because it was expected of me, or because I was in fear of moral condemnation.

‘and that attitude would then be returned in favour’ - invariably means you’d cut them off and bless them with a quiet life, free from being hectored about ponying up organs. I’m not sure why that would be considered a dire consequence when i’d consider that as being threatened with a good time.

LoveMeForARaisin · 11/08/2022 16:24

But if they refused they'd have shown themselves as someone who doesn't care if I live or die

that’s a very black and white way of looking at it, and I think it’s quite unfair.

there’s a lot of nuance to it. For example, I would absolutely care if my sibling lived or died and it would cause me a lot
of emotional torment if faced with the situation where I had to decide whether or not I gave them my kidney. But I have my children to factor in to the equation and they will always come first (eg what if they need it at some point? What if I die in surgery etc). The same way I’d expect my siblings to put their children before me in similar circumstances. I could never be resentful of that.

also - there’s a legitimate fear that your own health (as donor) starts to deteriorate, whether related to the donation or not. It’s ok to want to keep yourself alive and healthy.

it’s just not as simple as saying “you didn’t give me your kidney and therefore you don’t care if I die”

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 15:51

Well no one ever owes anyone anything

But thankfully in a pleasant society people do things for others because they're decent human beings who care.

My sibling would never owe me an organ

But if they refused they'd have shown themselves as someone who doesn't care if I live or die

And that attitude would then be returned in favour

thing47 · 11/08/2022 15:48

I do get this @rarelyontime but I'd just like to say that I think the majority of organ recipients are grateful beyond words to donors – I don't know what percentage of recipients don't make any efforts to look after themselves, but DH and I certainly haven't come across that many at all during his 30+ years of kidney disease. For the vast majority, kidney disease is just a condition they have, they are no more to blame for it than people who develop cancer or MS, for example.

rarelyontime · 11/08/2022 11:32

fantasmasgoria1 · 11/08/2022 05:04

My child I would donate as would I for my husband. My sibling? I'm not sure I would. They are an alcoholic and even if my sibling promised they would stop drinking forever, I'm not sure, in fact I'm probably 90% certain a while after the operation they would begin drinking again.

I think the same rules apply as with lending money to family. Only lend what you're prepared to not get back, and be prepared for what you lend to be used in a way you just don't approve of.

You can't put a condition on an organ - once it's gone, you ain't getting it back, and the recipient could lead an unhealthy lifestyle that means that the organ won't last long.

I'm afraid I just couldn't. I'd be full of resentment if someone took my kidney and they contributed to it being rejected. But as I've said, it's a two-way thing. I also wouldn't accept a living donation as I think it's too big an ask from someone, even if they offer freely.

fantasmasgoria1 · 11/08/2022 05:04

My child I would donate as would I for my husband. My sibling? I'm not sure I would. They are an alcoholic and even if my sibling promised they would stop drinking forever, I'm not sure, in fact I'm probably 90% certain a while after the operation they would begin drinking again.

Fraaahnces · 11/08/2022 04:13

@tootiredforanything… I have a few relatives for whom I wouldn’t think twice about donating an organ… I wouldn’t pee on my brother if he was on fire.

tootiredforanything · 10/08/2022 23:38

I have two siblings. One is incredibly poorly at the moment and I would definitely give a kidney if it made
them better. As far as the other sibling is concerned ... no chance!

Fraaahnces · 10/08/2022 22:05

I just checked the Aussie legislation re kids donating organs. (Fortunately) Kids can sign up to the organ donation registry but they can’t donate until they are legally adult at 18. Must have been bone marrow.

Imaginary · 10/08/2022 11:42

Fraaahnces · 10/08/2022 04:07

I study with someone who was conceived as an attempt to find a compatible organ donor for her much older sibling. She did not have a compatible tissue type and her earliest memories involve hearing this story, constant, long hospital visits where she had to sit and be quiet and her sibling becoming sicker and sicker and eventually passing away. After that, the stories were “What a shame X wasn’t compatible… She could have saved her…” etc.
This girl was a failure to her parents from the time they tested her tissues and she had lived with that hanging over her for all her life. She said that she can’t watch any of those future dystopian movies like Gattaca or The Island because that was her life.

That's horrible. Imagine having a baby with the purpose of taking her organ.
Poor girl.

Imaginary · 10/08/2022 11:28

WhoMe231 · 09/08/2022 21:58

There was an article in the paper a few years ago, a girl (around 22 years old) gave her boyfriend her kidney…whilst she was recovering in hospital he cheated on her 😱 She said she is so angry to know her kidney is still out there in the world and she can’t use it. Made me seriously reconsider EVER donating anything of mine!

I'd be so pissed off if I was that girl's mother.
Imagine raising your little girl and sacrificing so much, and then she, barely an adult, donates an effing kidney to a boyfriend! Not her husband of 10 years who she has kids with, but some boyfriend who cheats on her! 😡

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 10/08/2022 11:19

NellesVilla · 10/08/2022 09:44

Hi @WeAreBob !

Tbh, I’ve confused myself a tad with regards to D and R. D- Donor/potential donor and R- recipient/hopeful recipient.

R has kids and a partner. Will need a kidney. Expects sibling to hand one over if they’re a “decent” person but is lc with sibling and doesn’t give a toss about sibling and is only in touch to ensure they will be tested for them. They think it the “least” the sibling could do.

D has no children, but may want them one day. They are in fairly good health so expected to hand over a kidney. As above, doesn’t like sibling and doesn’t feel they should be expected to undergo a bit procedure for someone who doesn’t give a crap about them and would basically take the organ and run.

And D is correct. They shouldn't have to hand over an organ to someone who makes absolutely no effort with them. Hell, even if they did make an effort, D still doesn't have to hand over the organ! It's a very selfish person to demand someone else's organ like it's nothing.

sueelleker · 10/08/2022 11:14

ipswi · 10/08/2022 09:59

I'm pretty sure this was the plot line of a film & book

"My Sister's Keeper" by Jodi Picoult. I was thinking this all the time I was reading the replies.

xogossipgirlxo · 10/08/2022 11:11

Lindy2 · 10/08/2022 10:13

I would for my sibling but it all depends on your relationship really doesn't it.

I know a child who died of lukemia while the whole paternal side of their family stood by refusing to even be tested as a bone marrow match. Not even their father. That I find absolutely tragic and shocking.

Oh God. This is very sad. Especially that it carries very minimal risk for donor. It's not giving your kidney FFS. How come his dad refused?

Swipe left for the next trending thread