Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think someone isn’t owed an organ from a sibling?

216 replies

NellesVilla · 09/08/2022 19:06

I’ve known a few people- weirdly- that have given/received kidneys from other family members over the years.

I think that it is incredibly kind and selfless to do this for another person in need, but think that there’s so much guilt involved and that one person doesn’t owe a kidney, particularly if the recipient is not their own offspring.

I know 2 x people; basics as follows:-

  • R for recipient and D for donor/possible donor. They are siblings, but not close siblings or even really in touch.
  • R is on dialysis and is hoping to get a new kidney in the next year or so.
  • D- a sibling- not a close sibling, has been cited as a possible match. The parents are not able to donate and are hoping that D will “come good”.
  • D thinks that R should offer the kidney like it’s a sweet and that it’s nothing. Also, that is not needed by R. R also isn’t interested in any sort of relationship with D and is happy to take the organ and run.
  • D is- regardless of the relationship- v sympathetic towards this plight- but couldn’t be less interested in risking their life for someone who doesn’t give a fig about them.
  • Sadly, R has kids. D doesn’t but may do so in the future.
  • Everyone thinks “how nice” it would be for R to help their sibling, but wouldn’t dream of offering themselves- friends, family etc.
  • Lastly the most interesting fact is, that D’s partner-father to the kids- is also not keen on being tested and has made up every excuse/reason under the sun to avoid being so. The partner feels that it would be nice for R to help out their sibling- obviously!!
OP posts:
PastaCheese · 12/08/2022 07:22

@thing47

Also it's not usually a case of asking

All viable adults will get letters for testing

If they are a match they will be presented with the options

As the closest relatives children will always be top of the possible match lists

PastaCheese · 12/08/2022 07:21

DoIDareSayAnything · 12/08/2022 02:09

It would be a cold day in hell before I (or my DH) took an organ from either of our children.

So you'd rather they grow up without a parent?

Christ

autienotnaughty · 12/08/2022 05:22

Very emotive topic and thankfully not one most of us face. I would say there's a valid point if you have dependent children, there's more of a responsibility to protect your own health so not to leave a child without a parent. I can also see that a adult without children may feel a increased pressure to help an adult with children. My dsis doesn't have children if she needed an organ I would be reluctant as I have a disabled ds who needs me. However I really hope if I need an organ she would help!!

If the donor say no it will likely damage the relationship with donors family. And (with no judgment) how would they feel if their brother dies? Not easy at all.

Tinkity · 12/08/2022 03:26

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 19:24

How anyone can refuse is beyond me

How a child can willingly say I'd rather my father die than give an organ

And what kind of father would pressure their own child to do this? I think that’s quite telling.

My dad needed a kidney and since we are a family of 9, my siblings and I were all confident one of us would be a match but our dad point blank refused to even let us get tested, he said there was no point wasting resources because hell would have to freeze over before he would accept a kidney from one of us and our mum was no help as she was in absolute agreement with him. We suggested getting tested so we could get the lay of the land and then discuss options but he was not having any of it. I’ve never seen him more deadly serious about anything in my entire life and not once did his conviction ever waiver no matter what he was going through.

DoIDareSayAnything · 12/08/2022 02:09

It would be a cold day in hell before I (or my DH) took an organ from either of our children.

Cadot · 12/08/2022 01:02

Immediate risks of kidney donation:

•	Pain
•	Infection (such as pneumonia or wound infection)
•	Blood clot
•	Reaction to anesthesia
•	Death (Worldwide mortality rate for living kidney donors is 0.03% to 0.06%)
•	Conversion to open nephrectomy
•	Need for re-operation (such as for bleeding)
•	Re-admission to hospital
•	Hernia
•	Intestinal obstruction
•	Testicular swelling and discomfort (male donors) 

Long term complications:

•	Developing a disease that could affect the function of the remaining kidney such as:
◦	Diabetes
◦	High blood pressure
◦	Obesity 
•	Natural decline in kidney function as get older
•	Developing end-stage renal disease (ESRD) 
•	Increase in the amount of protein spilled into the urine
•	Chronic pain
•	Nerve damage 

I would never allow my child to give me their kidney and face those health risks.

It's not a cure. Average kidney transplant lasts 10-12 years apparently. I'd rather die 10 years early and allow my child to live a long, healthy life.

There are serious restrictions - no contact sports, have to be really careful not to damage the remaining kidney, lifetime health follow ups and risks of poor health outcomes etc. I wouldn't want my brother or husband to take those risks for me, either. The only people I would possibly accept it from would be my parents, because of the level of sacrifice involved.

I risked my life to bring my children into the world and I would risk it again (or give it up) to extend their lives, but not for anyone else.

thing47 · 11/08/2022 22:38

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 19:24

How anyone can refuse is beyond me

How a child can willingly say I'd rather my father die than give an organ

But turn this around and what sort of father would ask one of his children for a kidney? Do people really do this!!?

As I said upthread there's not a snowball's chance in hell that DH would consider a kidney donation from one of his children. In all the years we've been dealing with this, that is not a conversation which has ever taken place and if it did, he would shut it down instantly.

Carofay · 11/08/2022 20:58

Having re-read your post, I don't think you are BU. There is no relationship between R and D, they are essentially strangers and this is a big ask of a stranger. The fact that R has children is irrelevant: her choice, her responsibility and nobody else's. Partner needs to get tested as a potential match.

ChsmpagneWannaBe · 11/08/2022 20:42

Absolutely not. Your body your life.
F off with your kidney donation
If they had a relationship different story.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 11/08/2022 20:40

BreadInCaptivity · 11/08/2022 20:09

How a child can willingly say I'd rather my father die than give an organ

Which is exactly why a child should never be asked by a parent in the first place.

Totally agree.

Spaceprincess · 11/08/2022 20:16

It's nothing to do with anyone apart from the prospective donor/recipient.
D needs to talk to the donor team, anyone who isn't 100% behind it all for whatever reason isn't a match. They are used to this.
And that should be the end if it.

Carofay · 11/08/2022 20:12

I don't know if you are being unreasonable or not. I can only tell you how I feel. My sister is disabled, has complex needs and has had one kidney removed. I do some of her care but don't always get on with her as she can be a difficult character. When she had the kidney removed due to early stage kidney cancer, I instantly said that I would donate one of mine to her if anything happened to her other kidney. My mum was alive at the time and told me that I should not do so as I was 'whole'. Odd pov given my sister was always the favourite GC. As it turns out, it isn't an issue as I am a different blood group to my sister and therefore not a match.

It's a big decision as it involves surgery but I couldn't let a sibling die if I could do something to prevent it.

BreadInCaptivity · 11/08/2022 20:09

How a child can willingly say I'd rather my father die than give an organ

Which is exactly why a child should never be asked by a parent in the first place.

RagingWoke · 11/08/2022 19:58

Live donation is a huge decision, and I agree OP the idea a persons life is worth less because they don't have dc is abhorrent.
The attitude shown toward D is disgusting, even with a better relationship and no coercion the decision is entirely down to them and there is no shame or guilt in not wanting to volunteer for life changing surgery.

I'm sure those claiming a parents life is worth more are the same who would 'die for their dc' so the argument feels flawed.

mbosnz · 11/08/2022 19:50

I think the crux of the matter is that it is a very personal decision, and not one to be made lightly. A huge raft of factors may impact that decision. It is entirely up to the individual, and if a person decides not to donate, that is a perfectly valid decision that ought to be respected and accepted - and the individual should not be pressured or vilified for declining to do so.

PugInTheHouse · 11/08/2022 19:45

I think it's hard to imagine not giving a kidney if you're close to your family, I just couldn't imagine letting someone die rather than donating a kidney if I was a match. However I guess some people are basically strangers with their relatives so I suppose it isn't the same. If my immediate family were in agreement I'd donate a kidney to my close friends also, they are like family to me.

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 19:24

Mooovingonout · 11/08/2022 19:00

My ex is on transplant list for a kidney, has been pressuring our child to get tested to see if they are a match. Child is refusing. Child is an adult btw.

How anyone can ask that of another person is beyond me.

How anyone can refuse is beyond me

How a child can willingly say I'd rather my father die than give an organ

Clarinet1 · 11/08/2022 19:22

I’m actually on dialysis as I type this! I hope to be on the transplant list fairly soon. The obvious potential living donor would be DB who I have not thoroughly discussed it with yet. If he agreed to be tested I would be for ever grateful but I would never expect or demand it. We have no other siblings and both parents are dead. Neither of us has DC which I do appreciate would make a difference.

PugInTheHouse · 11/08/2022 19:01

In RL I couldn't do this, I have 2 kidneys but one is badly scarred and doesn't work fully so I am guessing I couldn't do it. However I can't imagine not doing it for my sibling if I could, but then we are a close family.

If we weren't then I probably wouldn't, it's an absolutely massive thing to do!

Mooovingonout · 11/08/2022 19:00

My ex is on transplant list for a kidney, has been pressuring our child to get tested to see if they are a match. Child is refusing. Child is an adult btw.

How anyone can ask that of another person is beyond me.

BreadInCaptivity · 11/08/2022 18:45

mbosnz · 11/08/2022 18:28

And quite frankly, I'd be more than happy for said sibling to get in a snit with me for not gladly handing my body organ over to them on demand and a silver platter, and never speak to me again. Because I'd be in a snit with them thinking they were owed it as of right, because that's the sort of nice thing you do for family.

Family. The most guilt laden, and manipulated/manipulative word in the English dictionary, I sometimes think. The shit you're supposed to do and put up with, all in the name of 'faaaaaaaaamily'.

I agree with you - it's way beyond doing a nice thing....

There is a reason we have two kidneys. The fact we can survive with one doesn't mean that state is optimal.

In addition as a pp noted a transplant isn't a cure, it's a treatment and depending on the age of the recipient future transplants may be needed.

Just how many family members are expected hand over an organ?

What are the ramifications on family dynamics if it fails and the recipient is no better off but the donors health is compromised?

Think of cases where the donors illness is a cause or exacerbated by lifestyle choices. How do people think family relationships will pan out if they treat a donor kidney no better than they did their own?

mbosnz · 11/08/2022 18:28

And quite frankly, I'd be more than happy for said sibling to get in a snit with me for not gladly handing my body organ over to them on demand and a silver platter, and never speak to me again. Because I'd be in a snit with them thinking they were owed it as of right, because that's the sort of nice thing you do for family.

Family. The most guilt laden, and manipulated/manipulative word in the English dictionary, I sometimes think. The shit you're supposed to do and put up with, all in the name of 'faaaaaaaaamily'.

mbosnz · 11/08/2022 18:25

When it comes to family it is a general nice thing

In your opinion. My opinion is that your opinion is a load of utter codswallop.

This isn't hypothetical in my family. Two of my sisters had severe kidney issues, one to the point that it was life threatening as a child.

My two children were both diagnosed with kidney reflux at birth, and had to be on antibiotics daily until the ages of three and five respectively.

No, I would not step up to give my sister a kidney. Particularly not if she rather casually regarded it as just the nice sort of thing family members do. Yes, I reserve my kidneys (which aren't too great either) for my daughters. Because for me, that's the nice sort of thing parents do for their children, who they are perfectly entitled to put first over and above their siblings.

BreadInCaptivity · 11/08/2022 18:18

There have been a could of threads about this over the years.

One I remember was a single mother (father not in the picture at all) being heavily pressured to donate by her elder sister and husband.

The sisters prior to the elders illness had not been particularly close.

The OP wanted to be "a good person" but was understandably wary of the risks, her ability to recuperate and still look after her child and obviously what would happen to her child in the worst case scenario.

The abuse she received from her sister and husband was really awful.

Upshot she got a lot of support from the thread telling her not to do it as her priority was to her child and that she could tell the transplant team who could tell the sister she was not a suitable donor without revealing the reason why.

Inherently it's a massive thing to do for someone and it's perfectly reasonable to say no.

Personally I'd do it for DC but no one else, because frankly the risk becomes irrelevant to me because I'd no want to live in a world without them (or them in pain) knowing I could do something about it.

However, I'd not risk the pain of my child being motherless (or having long term complications) for anyone else.

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 18:04

mbosnz · 11/08/2022 17:59

I scarcely think undergoing a rather serious operation, and literally giving someone a kidney rates merely as 'doing a nice thing'! It's not like taking in someone's parcel, or making sure they're stocked up with milk and bread upon their return. . .

When it comes to family it is a general nice thing