Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

First family dog?

213 replies

gotelltheoldmandowntheroad · 09/08/2022 18:41

Husband wants a German Shepherd, he also likes XL Bully and Rottweiler.

I am open to a dog but...

small house
do not want fur everywhere

We have two cats already so would look into getting a puppy.
We have a big garden and both often work from home so wouldn't leave him alone.

I know about having dogs, had them before, but not too keen, I'm a cat person. Husband and child are keen. Husband spoke about "family protection" but ultimately we are animal lovers but that seems to be a factor for him.

My questions are:

Dogs that won't add the least to my cleaning burden (that's my bag)

Safest around the child (from puppy and trained)

Perhaps that a non-dog person might like best?

Given he's mentioned those three breeds, which would you go for? Child is 6.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
ohblowmedown · 09/08/2022 22:30

Why do I read half the threads on here lately and assume they're a wind up?

wheresmymojo · 09/08/2022 22:25

If you absolutely have to get a dog (which you really shouldn't) then I would say a Staffy.

Can still look tough but a well trained Staffy from a good breeder, well socialised is a lovely thing.

They're very friendly, goofy little things.

I grew up with one and he was a brilliant family dog.

You still wouldn't ever be able to leave alone with DC though as per all dogs.

wheresmymojo · 09/08/2022 22:22

ParvuliThankYouDebbie · 09/08/2022 22:03

Interesting - why don’t they use Dobermanns for police work considering how intelligent they are? I’ve always wondered
I don’t know what the actual answer from professionals might be, but based on my experience of GSD vs Doberman, I’d say that the Doberman, though intensely loyal and focused on one person (possibly too much) wasn’t that concerned about pleasing the object of his affections in the same way that the GSD was. So, highly intelligent and with a job to do, might do the job the way he wanted to do it not necessarily the way the handler wanted it done. The GSD absolutely would do it the way the handler commanded. Just an observation based on two dogs owned by the same person. There might actually be physical attributes though - Doberman’s might not be as physically sturdy as GSDs for example?

I mean this would make sense for my cross. She clearly has a Doberman streak when it comes to choosing whether she may or may not decide to grace us with a faint whiff of obedience.

But my god - if you've got a treat in your hand you could teach her to do circus tricks. Until the treats run out.

Sellie555 · 09/08/2022 22:14

Lurchers or any sighthounds are the most amazing dogs! They don’t need huge amounts of walking, they doze most of the day, are not renowned for barking and arr super chilled.

i have a chocolate lab myself but I foster rescue dogs and the sighthounds have always been my fave rescues are they are just so lovely

also just cos the dogs yoi mention are big breeds, doesn’t mean they are naturally protective towards the family. In fact, it’s a myth that dogs will always protect their owners - most would actually run away of their owners were being attacked

IHeartPepsi · 09/08/2022 22:07

An XL bully? Ffs why?

Boxowine · 09/08/2022 22:06

Sigh. If people quit getting unsuitable breeds, breeders would quit breeding them. Get a nice friendly family dog that doesn't shed. If you have a dog in the house that you will be taking care of and cleaning up after you may as well get one that you can enjoy.

AsACloud · 09/08/2022 22:04

I have these three breeds. As per a PP, a GSD is a big dog if you’re worried about your house being on the small side and they do shed hugely! Fabulous dogs though. I think these 3 breeds are not the best option for a first family dog unfortunately. Personally I wouldn’t have any big breed in a small house as they need so much room, especially when they’re big bouncy puppies banging into everything 😂

ParvuliThankYouDebbie · 09/08/2022 22:03

Interesting - why don’t they use Dobermanns for police work considering how intelligent they are? I’ve always wondered
I don’t know what the actual answer from professionals might be, but based on my experience of GSD vs Doberman, I’d say that the Doberman, though intensely loyal and focused on one person (possibly too much) wasn’t that concerned about pleasing the object of his affections in the same way that the GSD was. So, highly intelligent and with a job to do, might do the job the way he wanted to do it not necessarily the way the handler wanted it done. The GSD absolutely would do it the way the handler commanded. Just an observation based on two dogs owned by the same person. There might actually be physical attributes though - Doberman’s might not be as physically sturdy as GSDs for example?

wheresmymojo · 09/08/2022 22:03

And she blows her coat a few times a year which means an entire other dog could be formed from her moulting.

wheresmymojo · 09/08/2022 22:02

We have a rescue that is German shepherd x Doberman.

I wouldn't recommend to a first time owner with children.

As guarding dogs they've been bred over generations to be highly intelligent but also very independent.

This means they get easily bored, if they're bored they will find ways to amuse themselves (and you won't like what this tends to involve which is destruction), they're demanding and while they learn tricks and commands very quickly they'll only do it when they want to.

Also they whine quite a lot - for attention, if they're bored, if they want to play, if they want the cats to play, etc, etc.

They're basically 35kg 18 month old toddlers with big teeth and no ability to speak.

I bloody love her but she's a full on handful and we have no DC!

And an XL Bully as a family dog is nuts. There's no reason on this Earth that a family needs such a crazily powerful dog.

It's like deciding you're going to learn to drive just to drop the baby at nursery and choosing to do it in a tank...just, why?

Minecraftatemychild · 09/08/2022 22:00

2bazookas · 09/08/2022 19:26

DH hasn't a clue. A " protection dog" is trained to threaten/stop a human being when the dog perceives risk. That training/dog outlook is totally incompatible with a family pet around small children (remember, normal 6 yr olds cry, shout, are loud, bouncy, unpredictable, and have small friends to play).

The three breeds he's picked are breeds commonly used as guard or protection dogs because of their powerful jaws, physique and breed temperament like strong confidence, dominance, assertiveness. A dog/child stand-off (misunderstanding over a toy, or food, or just an accidental shove / knock) is quite likely and the dog will win, because that's what it's wired for.

If you get a dog, choose some more compliant, less assertive breed, maybe a small labrador. Instead of a puppy, consider getting an 18 month to 2 yrs slightly older dog whose character and proper training are already established.

A degree of shed hair, foot prints, mud , smells and occasional mess is pretty much inevitable in dog ownership. Don't kid yourself , they do make more work.

This.

Your DH sounds kind of insecure. Why does he feel he needs “protection”? If you have young children and cats, I do not see happy family life in your future if you also get a dog that’s bred to respond aggressively and put it in a confided space with cats and kids. Accident waiting to happen.

Wolfiee · 09/08/2022 21:47

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/08/2022 21:34

Oh yep, this is very much my lane right now (sorting a breed database to give info to new owners)...

1 - under NO circumstances do you get a dog to act as protection for family. Do not do it, it is fucking dangerous. And certainly not if the plan is to send the dog off to be trained using shock collars and prong collars or if DH is a newbie to bite sports and fancies a crack at them. Just don't.

2 - those breeds, no no and no.

Gsd - damn near impossible to get a healthy one outside of working lines and you absolutely do NOT need or want a working line gsd at this point. So many have dodgy temperaments, do you want to be rehabbing a reactive fearful dog for the next four years?

XL Bully - unhealthy, poor temperament, 99% of breeders I wouldn't buy a soft toy from. Too big, too dribbly, don't do it.

Rottie - again, as puppies these are clumsy and daft, they are FAR too easy to misunderstand, mishandle and fuck up, and the only breeders willing to sell to someone who wants a protection dog, and has a 6 year old in the house is again, someone i wouldn't buy a soft toy from.

Examine EXACTLY what H thinks he wants from a 'protection' dog.

MY goal from a dog that will keep me safe is - big enough that people think twice, superduper incredibly easily trainable such that I can teach a big bark and a growl on cue, but of the temperament that ACTUALLY thinks everyone in the world is a friend.

This way I can cue the scary 'fuck off right now or ill eat your face' behaviours, but should an accident occur, no ones actually getting injured.

The probably with many of the 'protection' breeds is that they're either TERRIFIED and highly likely to make mistakes (GSD, Doberman, this is why police are now using Malinois) OR... they are high as kites off their tits wanting to BITE stuff, and if not intensively trained and super well managed will bite the wrong people (see, police dogs biting the wrong people, quite a lot).

So you want a dog that looks the part, can be trained to bluff, but is in fact safe as a dog can actually be.

If Husband actually wants to do some dog sports and training and isn't just thinking of his ego... then:

Picardy Sheepdog is a good choice, some of the same traits of the GSD, a courageous nature, very easily trained, sufficiently large most people think twice but not so large they're a pain in the arse to house, and being a rough coated shaggy breed they also take people by surprise... and don't shed like a GSD.

Superduper well bred Mastiff - not so easy to train, far better temperament and health than the XL Bully. They do shed needle like hair everywhere that is a pain in the arse to get up and they have a tendancy to smell a bit... cheesey.

Large Munsterlander - from the gundog group, not quite a setter, not a spaniel, bigger and more robust than the latter but less scatty than the former, very trainable, willing to do fun training and dog sports, easily trained to growl and bark on cue.

Briard - similarly capable as the Picardy, their roots are in droving and guarding livestock on the move, very trainable, very loyal to family, something that you would shit your pants if it growled or barked at you on cue. Downside is of course theres a LOT of grooming of one of these (but they don't shed much at all!).

If you discount the protection aspect (and i REALLY would) though I'd recommend a Standard Poodle if someone really wants to do some training, and a Deerhound if you want a big dog that is easy going, doesn't shed much, wouldn't thankyou at ALL for attempting dog sports and is generally very economical on space around the house (yes, I have had one in a very small house!).

I would wait until child is a year or two older for the latter two, and more like three years older for the rest, but you know your child and your ability to ensure child follows instructions and doesn't mither or become magnetized to the dog!

Interesting - why don’t they use Dobermanns for police work considering how intelligent they are? I’ve always wondered.

I love standard poodles - I’ve heard they’re surprisingly good guard dogs and massively intelligent. Won’t make OP’s husband look well ‘ard though

Bleepitandbleepitagain · 09/08/2022 21:38

@k1233

The bark really is enough! My big boy is a dope but jesus, few occasions it was needed his voice is enough to send shivers. Especially when he is standing loyally by your side.

Parents had a westie, lovely loyal breeds. And their bark is massive compared to their size!

So sorry you went through a stalker situation :(

autienotnaughty · 09/08/2022 21:36

I'd say lurcher or grey hound

Twentypast · 09/08/2022 21:36

thesurrealist · 09/08/2022 20:54

None of those are suitable for a first dog unless you have experience.

Dogs have their own personality same as humans so your husbands idea of protection for the family is highly dependent on what the dog is like and, frankly, a guard dog isn't one who I would personally want around young children.

Staffies (assume that's what you mean by bully?) would be the best of those choices in my limited opinion and experience (I've always had labs or collies). Every staffie I've ever met have been gorgeous, happy, wonderful creatures who are wonderful with humans.

I think your husband is a bit stupid and very delusional and I would personally worry about why he wants those breeds of dogs.

Last word from me - and you will know this already - all dogs are what their owners make them. My worry for your family would be that the dog your husband is looking for is not one compatible with family life.

My advice - stick to cats, but if you just have a dog, stick to what you knkw.

An XL Bully is nothing like a staffy. Google them. They are very strong powerful dogs. One killed an woman a couple of months ago.

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/08/2022 21:36

Meant to add, I love all three of the listed breeds, in the right home, from the right breeders with the right owners who have the right experience.

But the potential for any of those three to go spectacularly wrong if any one of those elements is off is huge!

underneaththeash · 09/08/2022 21:35

I think you can still get Pitt Bulls or maybe a Rottweiller too, they’d make equally suitable pets.

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/08/2022 21:34

Oh yep, this is very much my lane right now (sorting a breed database to give info to new owners)...

1 - under NO circumstances do you get a dog to act as protection for family. Do not do it, it is fucking dangerous. And certainly not if the plan is to send the dog off to be trained using shock collars and prong collars or if DH is a newbie to bite sports and fancies a crack at them. Just don't.

2 - those breeds, no no and no.

Gsd - damn near impossible to get a healthy one outside of working lines and you absolutely do NOT need or want a working line gsd at this point. So many have dodgy temperaments, do you want to be rehabbing a reactive fearful dog for the next four years?

XL Bully - unhealthy, poor temperament, 99% of breeders I wouldn't buy a soft toy from. Too big, too dribbly, don't do it.

Rottie - again, as puppies these are clumsy and daft, they are FAR too easy to misunderstand, mishandle and fuck up, and the only breeders willing to sell to someone who wants a protection dog, and has a 6 year old in the house is again, someone i wouldn't buy a soft toy from.

Examine EXACTLY what H thinks he wants from a 'protection' dog.

MY goal from a dog that will keep me safe is - big enough that people think twice, superduper incredibly easily trainable such that I can teach a big bark and a growl on cue, but of the temperament that ACTUALLY thinks everyone in the world is a friend.

This way I can cue the scary 'fuck off right now or ill eat your face' behaviours, but should an accident occur, no ones actually getting injured.

The probably with many of the 'protection' breeds is that they're either TERRIFIED and highly likely to make mistakes (GSD, Doberman, this is why police are now using Malinois) OR... they are high as kites off their tits wanting to BITE stuff, and if not intensively trained and super well managed will bite the wrong people (see, police dogs biting the wrong people, quite a lot).

So you want a dog that looks the part, can be trained to bluff, but is in fact safe as a dog can actually be.

If Husband actually wants to do some dog sports and training and isn't just thinking of his ego... then:

Picardy Sheepdog is a good choice, some of the same traits of the GSD, a courageous nature, very easily trained, sufficiently large most people think twice but not so large they're a pain in the arse to house, and being a rough coated shaggy breed they also take people by surprise... and don't shed like a GSD.

Superduper well bred Mastiff - not so easy to train, far better temperament and health than the XL Bully. They do shed needle like hair everywhere that is a pain in the arse to get up and they have a tendancy to smell a bit... cheesey.

Large Munsterlander - from the gundog group, not quite a setter, not a spaniel, bigger and more robust than the latter but less scatty than the former, very trainable, willing to do fun training and dog sports, easily trained to growl and bark on cue.

Briard - similarly capable as the Picardy, their roots are in droving and guarding livestock on the move, very trainable, very loyal to family, something that you would shit your pants if it growled or barked at you on cue. Downside is of course theres a LOT of grooming of one of these (but they don't shed much at all!).

If you discount the protection aspect (and i REALLY would) though I'd recommend a Standard Poodle if someone really wants to do some training, and a Deerhound if you want a big dog that is easy going, doesn't shed much, wouldn't thankyou at ALL for attempting dog sports and is generally very economical on space around the house (yes, I have had one in a very small house!).

I would wait until child is a year or two older for the latter two, and more like three years older for the rest, but you know your child and your ability to ensure child follows instructions and doesn't mither or become magnetized to the dog!

k1233 · 09/08/2022 21:31

I agree with everyone else. The breeds he wants aren't suitable for your lifestyle.

My first dog was a staffy. I had a stalker at the time, lived by myself and wanted a deterrent. He slept in my room and was bloody scary when he barked. Extremely well trained and an absolutely beautiful dog who loved everyone. All bark, but that's all I needed. I had a cat and they were besties. Dog needed a lot of physical activity daily and was very intelligent.

When he got an aggressive cancer I researched his successor. Due to my own injuries, he was getting a bit heavy for me to lift in and out of the car (22kg), so I wanted a dog around 10kg that was stocky with a square head. I googled extensively and came up with a list of possibilities which I read the breed standards for. That's where purebreds are best. If you get one from a reputable breeder, they breed for the traits in the standard and breeds have pretty consistent underlying personality traits. I ended up with a westie. Never thought I'd have a small white fluffy, but he's absolutely perfect.

This is the start of his breed standard:
General Appearance:
Strongly built; deep in chest and back ribs; level back and powerful quarters on muscular legs and exhibiting in a marked degree a great combination of strength and activity.

Characteristics:
Small, active, game, hardy, possessed of no small amount of self-esteem with a varminty appearance. (Oh my is he true to this part!)

Temperament:
Alert, gay, courageous, self-reliant but friendly
^^
He's definitely an alert dog. There is no getting into my house without him letting me know you're there. He's actually bailed someone up on my roof (neighbour retrieving a plane after a test fly), so he can be ferocious. He doesn't have the breed stigma of the staffy but is a good deterrent none the less.

Once I'd selected the breed I did a lot of on line surveys to ensure he'd fit with my lifestyle. I was fortunate my staffy's cancer went into a four year remission. In that time I'd selected a breeder and got on her books. When my staffy passed away I let her know that I'd be looking for a pup in about 9months time (that's how long it takes me to get over a loss and consider a new pet). That fit in with her planned litter and I got my wonderful little westie who I knew was perfect from the moment he stepped into my life.

That's something all pets deserve IMO. To be the most perfect in the eyes of their family.

So, that's a super long post to say I don't think you're ready for a dog if you can't, as a family, agree on an appropriate breed that fits in with your lifestyle. It should never be a five minute impulse buy. It should be a decision with a lot of thought and effort put into breed selection, getting to know the good and bad traits of the breed, finding a breeder and waiting, sometimes 12months or more, for a pup from a reputable breeder.

Bleepitandbleepitagain · 09/08/2022 21:31

If the husband is willing, it could work. Although as he wants a protection dog, the training would be damaging.

My husband wasn't into training and had a bit of a mindset of "protection dog" which had to be trained out of him!

But do agree that if the dog isn't wanted, and the only other trainer is someone who is looking for a protective dog, with no training in doing so. Its a recipe for disaster. Especially with a young child.

Dogs need consistency. With all signing from the same hymn sheet. Or you're buggered. Mix that with a strong willed breed, not going to work.

category12 · 09/08/2022 21:25

Yes, @Bleepitandbleepitagain but it's unlikely the OP wants to put all that effort in when she doesn't even want a dog, really.

Bleepitandbleepitagain · 09/08/2022 21:22

I'm going to go against the grain, to a degree.

If the work is willing to be applied to create a stable dog, and their temperament and "needs" are taken into account, any dog can be a good family dog.

That said, adjustments would need to be made regardless.

I have a tiny chi cross who bullies my big chunky mastin rescue. Do I allow it? No. They are only together when I am over them watching. I have two under 5. Both are lovable idiots with my babies, but do I allow them alone? No. Does it involve different garden times and juggling different aspects? Yes.

Do we all get so much out of it? Of course. We'd all be lost without either of them. But the work isn't miniscule. Navigating kids needs, dogs needs, dogs instincts and training. While also training kids how to be with a dog isn't easy. Its a job in itself.

I juggle it, cos I and my children love them. Its worth it. But I'm always super aware dogs are dogs, so when one kid wants to be in one room and another in another room, I have to navigate that aspect and where the dogs are.

Play dates I have to preplanned walks, and frozen treats to keep them occupied in a crate. Or at least watch them fully just incase the guest kid leaves a gate open as naturally they aren't used to it.

I'm house proud. The work load with a bigger dog clean wise, is immense compared to a smaller one.

The hours for months of sitting up late at night training. Money spent with trainers. Then time with the kids training them how to be with my bigger boy.

None of it was easy. It was bloody exhausting. Also so worth it. I now have two dogs who adore my children and well trained children and dogs.

In the process I picked up a new job of always being super aware. At all times. My old tiny no teeth gummy bear never held the same potential threat as a bigger dog does.

They can be the best thing to happen to your family. But a lot of work. A lot of wanting it to work. A lot of training both dog and kid. And someone wanting a big dog as a protection aspect, likely isn't the wisest choice to own any of those breeds. People like that are the reason they end up having a bad name, as they encourage the bad behaviour.

More chance my big boy would hide if danger showed its face! Cos I never wanted him to realise his strength and despite being little myself, and littler my kids, he respects their word.

Lightningrain · 09/08/2022 21:21

You really don’t sound like you want a dog so in your circumstances I would stick to your guns. Everyone in the household will need to be involved, particularly with a puppy and it just won’t work if you don’t want a dog before it even arrives.

if you do decide to go ahead, I echo what PP’s have said about none of those breeds being suitable. I love GSDs but you’d have to know what you were doing to find one that won’t have issues with it’s temperament (they can be nervy) or their backend. I know someone that’s had 4 (each supposedly from a decent breeder) and they’ve had issues with them all. Don’t get me started on the breeding of XL Bullies….

Unless you or your DH want to devote a lot of time to training, physical and mental exercise I wouldn’t be considering any high drive dog. It will be bored and cause problems. If he’s adamant about those breeds then I would really stand your ground about not getting a dog.

GiantCheeseMonster · 09/08/2022 21:20

In your circs I wouldn’t get a dog in a million years. But if you do, I wonder if a Boxer might fit the bill - looks “tough” but is soft as butter and a lovely family dog. All dogs need training though and puppies are a total PITA. You don’t quite believe how much of a pain until you get one. Mine is 9mo now and I am only just starting to not regret getting him, and I’m the one who wanted him in the first place!

Cheesesteak · 09/08/2022 21:19

I have 4 dogs, one being a German Shepherd, the others being English Bulldogs and a Bassett Hound.

My DD is 8 months old. The GS is honestly golden. He is the least boisterous around her. He is well trained. It was hard work though and if someone comes to the house we have to introduce him, once he has been introduced he is back to my husbands side and doesn't bother guests. He isn't bothered by dogs or people when taken for his walks (twice a day, along with a rather large back garden to run in).

For context I have two large gardens one for my DD and one for the dogs. My house is also a decent size, with rooms for the dogs so we can separate when we need to.

Please for the sake of your child do not get an XL Bully and if you're not sure please don't get a dog at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread