Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Shannon Matthews the Musical should be cancelled.

165 replies

containsnuts · 09/08/2022 14:36

I'm not easily offended but I find this wildly insensitive and inappropriate.

shannonmatthews.co.uk/

That poor child was held hostage, drugged and went though a traumatic ordeal at the hands of her own mother and the peadophile boyfriend. Why anyone would want to make a musical comedy out of this awful display of child abuse I'll never know.

OP posts:
containsnuts · 09/08/2022 17:30

"It's just a satire about the things that go on in "benefits Britain" in the vein of Shameless. The idleness, the poor parenting and the idiotic money-making schemes, that kind of thing"

I think social commentary is fine if the story is not about an identified real person or has their consent if it does.

OP posts:
justfiveminutes · 09/08/2022 17:30

I'm not going to be outraged about something I haven't seen. It's sold out and getting some good reviews.

Georgeskitchen · 09/08/2022 17:25

This surely has to be a joke . If not why has it not been stopped? Poor Shannon as if she hadn't had enough to deal with!!

ReneBumsWombats · 09/08/2022 17:23

BlusteryLake · 09/08/2022 17:16

So your line on acceptability for a musical is whether or not the child victim was murdered? Mine certainly isn't.

I'm simply pointing out the key difference between the cases. I'm not saying anything about you, me or which of us is superior. You are.

It wouldn't surprise me if the makers of this show (which looks shit for all the obvious reasons and then some) claimed that posts like yours are partly what they're commenting on.

dehloh · 09/08/2022 17:22

Dotjones · 09/08/2022 17:19

If you don't like it, don't book tickets. SM:TM was released on CD in what, 2010? It was on Prime Music for years, not sure if it still is but I had a listen a few years ago. If it were worth getting angry about, people should have done so long before now.

It's just a satire about the things that go on in "benefits Britain" in the vein of Shameless. The idleness, the poor parenting and the idiotic money-making schemes, that kind of thing.

Spoiler alert: Shannon was much happier after being adopted by a normal family who didn't sit around all day watching Jeremy Kyle, eating Viscount biscuits and masturbating to child pornography.

If you don't like it don't book tickets is not enough, it's ok to feel outraged at something so despicable. In fact, we should be complaining about this, not just ignoring it.

justfiveminutes · 09/08/2022 17:22

It's a good job nobody is being forced to watch it.

Dotjones · 09/08/2022 17:19

If you don't like it, don't book tickets. SM:TM was released on CD in what, 2010? It was on Prime Music for years, not sure if it still is but I had a listen a few years ago. If it were worth getting angry about, people should have done so long before now.

It's just a satire about the things that go on in "benefits Britain" in the vein of Shameless. The idleness, the poor parenting and the idiotic money-making schemes, that kind of thing.

Spoiler alert: Shannon was much happier after being adopted by a normal family who didn't sit around all day watching Jeremy Kyle, eating Viscount biscuits and masturbating to child pornography.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 09/08/2022 17:19

Sure comedy is subjective and subversive yadda yadda but if the stuff you write centred on an abused child then your scraping the barrel

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 09/08/2022 17:17

Wow. Just wow.

So the ordeal that poor girl went through is comedy fodder but Scotland loses its shit over park benches beautifully decorated with suffragette ribbons.

BlusteryLake · 09/08/2022 17:16

ReneBumsWombats · 09/08/2022 17:12

Shannon wasn't murdered.

So your line on acceptability for a musical is whether or not the child victim was murdered? Mine certainly isn't.

KettrickenSmiled · 09/08/2022 17:12

containsnuts · 09/08/2022 16:59

This is not a distant historical event though, it happened quite recently and the person involved is still living. Who would want people singing, dancing and laughing at their childhood pain and trauma? Does calling it 'satire' make it fair game for laughs?

No, & if I were Shannon I would be wanting to sue. Not even sure if that's possible, but it's what I'd want to do.

ReneBumsWombats · 09/08/2022 17:12

BlusteryLake · 09/08/2022 17:08

Oh please! The OP isn't saying everything she doesn't like should be cancelled. But this particular show, yes. Do you not think there should be any boundaries when it comes to protecting child victims of crime and neglect? Where would you draw the line, or do you think a musical about Arthur Lobinjo Hughes would be OK, for example?

Shannon wasn't murdered.

KettrickenSmiled · 09/08/2022 17:10

the80sweregreat · 09/08/2022 15:19

They did make a drama out of this for tv.
Making a musical is a bit much : i would not go and see it myself

Yup. The billing raves about:

"an irreverent, potty-mouthed, black comedy romp through one of the most bizarre news stories of this century" which reduces the poor woman's appalling trauma to entertainment to laugh at.

Not fucking funny.

BlusteryLake · 09/08/2022 17:08

SuperPets · 09/08/2022 14:40

There are films, books, tv shows etc about everything, and much worse. What's your problem?

Don't like it, don't be tickets. Don't be that person screeching that things you don't like should be cancelled

Oh please! The OP isn't saying everything she doesn't like should be cancelled. But this particular show, yes. Do you not think there should be any boundaries when it comes to protecting child victims of crime and neglect? Where would you draw the line, or do you think a musical about Arthur Lobinjo Hughes would be OK, for example?

BlusteryLake · 09/08/2022 17:05

TommySaid · 09/08/2022 15:17

YANBU it’s not fair on this poor girl who has to go through life with everyone knowing what happened and things like this keep dragging it back up.

It wasn’t her fault but she’s the one that’s having to live with it and suffer the consequences.

Absolutely this. Shannon Matthews was a child victim in all this, it wasn't that long ago and she is still alive.

ReneBumsWombats · 09/08/2022 17:03

containsnuts · 09/08/2022 16:59

This is not a distant historical event though, it happened quite recently and the person involved is still living. Who would want people singing, dancing and laughing at their childhood pain and trauma? Does calling it 'satire' make it fair game for laughs?

They're not doing it because any involved person will like it and as before, I expect they'd say that Shannon isn't the target. And in answer to your question, yes. It is fair game. We don't have to watch it or like it but people are allowed to make tasteless comment. And you're allowed to say that it's shit.

It couldn't be more obviously screaming to try to cause a stir. As PPs said, the Fringe is full of people desperate to prove how edgy they are. This thread is exactly what they want.

Most overtly, desperately offensive stuff doesn't get very far.

Antarcticant · 09/08/2022 17:03

Are they forgetting that Shannon Matthews must still be alive - not to mention those of her family who believed she was missing, and all the people from Dewsbury who took part in the search for her, in good faith?

containsnuts · 09/08/2022 16:59

This is not a distant historical event though, it happened quite recently and the person involved is still living. Who would want people singing, dancing and laughing at their childhood pain and trauma? Does calling it 'satire' make it fair game for laughs?

OP posts:
NCHammer2022 · 09/08/2022 15:58

There’s a load of shite that thinks it’s edgy on at the fringe. This will dwindle out like the rest of it, after it’s had its 12 viewers congratulating themselves on how much more sophisticated their humour is than the rest of us. Not worth the publicity of a cancellation.

DancingUnderTheLights · 09/08/2022 15:55

When I first saw this I thought about the Brass Eye piece about Peter Sutcliffe the musical and thought this was actually going to have her mother star in it.

I've seen K*nt and the Gang before at the fringe. They can be funny but also offensive. They're purposely trying to be offensive in the hope that people like you promote it.

purpleme12 · 09/08/2022 15:55

I agree.

But then I also think it's awful people making jokes about Madeleine McCann but an awful lot of people do that

ReneBumsWombats · 09/08/2022 15:46

I expect that the producers would claim that they're not making fun of Shannon, they're satirically skewering the people who abused her and the society that created such people, then throw in something about moralistic outrage obscuring the true evil of the incident because they usually say that. Occasionally it's true but most people aren't Chris Morris.

At any rate, what do you expect from the guy who wrote Boris Johnson Is A Fucking Cunt? The weird thing is how he can't seem to think of anything more recent to satirise.

Just don't promote it. You're giving it publicity and offended attention and that's what it will thrive on.

liveforsummer · 09/08/2022 15:38

Yep inappropriate but so are many of the performances at the fringe - it's often the entire point

Dartmoorcheffy · 09/08/2022 15:38

What next? A musical about the Moors Murderers.

I despair at how low society has sunk to find this sort of thing comedy.

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 09/08/2022 15:37

You seem to be publicising it OP.

I hadn’t heard of it until this thread.