Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Shannon Matthews the Musical should be cancelled.

165 replies

containsnuts · 09/08/2022 14:36

I'm not easily offended but I find this wildly insensitive and inappropriate.

shannonmatthews.co.uk/

That poor child was held hostage, drugged and went though a traumatic ordeal at the hands of her own mother and the peadophile boyfriend. Why anyone would want to make a musical comedy out of this awful display of child abuse I'll never know.

OP posts:
BarryGw · 11/08/2022 16:10

MavisM · 11/08/2022 16:07

Have you taken the time to find and listen to it or are you offended by a concept without hearing it in full? It’s hilarious. Hopefully all you’re doing is promoting to those who will listen to it and/or discover Ku*t and the Gangs other materials which are equally as amusing. Just because you find it distasteful doesn’t mean it should be cancelled. Just move on. Seriously mustn’t have anything better to do!

But be honest, it's fun (albeit frustrating) to watch the sheep being offended by something they've not even seen. It's doing the ticket sales wonders!

MavisM · 11/08/2022 16:07

Have you taken the time to find and listen to it or are you offended by a concept without hearing it in full? It’s hilarious. Hopefully all you’re doing is promoting to those who will listen to it and/or discover Ku*t and the Gangs other materials which are equally as amusing. Just because you find it distasteful doesn’t mean it should be cancelled. Just move on. Seriously mustn’t have anything better to do!

EdSt · 11/08/2022 16:06

Sounds like you are easily offended.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 16:04

Nope. I'm suggesting people should research befofre getting offended.

Well actually, people have as much right to be offended as you have to be offensive, but anyway. If that was your purpose, maybe discuss the show when you first come blundering in rather than just laughing at the outrage while blatantly trying to cause more. Now if you do try to explain the true nature of the show, it's obscured by the crap. You lost your opportunity to enlighten.

NCHammer2022 · 11/08/2022 16:02

I don’t know who this Kunt dude is but he has a good line in sock puppets.

Also, you call yourself Kunt & the Gang and have a musical ensemble playing at the Edinburgh Fringe and that’s not middle class? Give me a break.

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 15:53

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 15:46

I just happen to find Kunt's work hilarious and think he gets rough press sometimes.

But you like that! And so does he! The marketing for the show actively courts it!

Then you can go off and laugh at everyone who is as offended as they're told to be for not being clever enough to get it, like you!

I haven't seen the show so I can't comment definitely, but I'll be very surprised if Shannon's suffering is the actual butt of the joke. As I said near the start of the thread, I expect it's more about skewering her family and the society that produced them.

But jeez, it's being overtly marketed as offensive so why complain if people believe it?

Then you can go off and laugh at everyone who is as offended as they're told to be for not being clever enough to get it, like you!

Nope. I'm suggesting people should research befofre getting offended. That's all. Don't claim to be clever. Don't claim anyone on here is stupid. If anything I'm suggesting there is a laziness. It's easier to just be offended, rather than look into something yourself. It's just the way society is going. Cool name tho! Happy I'm not a wombat :-)

Inkblotter · 11/08/2022 15:48

neshtastic · 09/08/2022 17:35

Hitler is dead though. Shannon Mathews is still alive.

So if she was dead then it would be ok? So Maddy McCann on Ice would be acceptable to you?

I for one applaud K for having the kahunas to put on such a witty take on such a dark tale, with such catchy tunes 👍

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 15:46

I just happen to find Kunt's work hilarious and think he gets rough press sometimes.

But you like that! And so does he! The marketing for the show actively courts it!

Then you can go off and laugh at everyone who is as offended as they're told to be for not being clever enough to get it, like you!

I haven't seen the show so I can't comment definitely, but I'll be very surprised if Shannon's suffering is the actual butt of the joke. As I said near the start of the thread, I expect it's more about skewering her family and the society that produced them.

But jeez, it's being overtly marketed as offensive so why complain if people believe it?

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 15:39

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 15:25

Yes but you still had to come over and attempt to provoke more outrage because what you saw, however funny you found it, wasn't enough for you. Same thing.

I'm just asking if you enjoy the show because it's clever, funny social satire or because the outrage makes you feel somehow superior. It seems to be the latter, because you're not discussing the show, you're just telling everyone how stupid they are. At least Kunt and the theatre company have done something creative and potentially made some serious, worthwhile commentary. You're no different to the people you're trying to wind up.

Apologies for not addressing the show in my previous comment, I've been a fan of the Shannon Matthews the Musical CD (first released in 2010) since I first discovered Kunt many years ago. It's funny, lyrically clever, in line with the rest of his catalogue, and in my opinion not particularly in bad taste, but obviously that depends on your sensibilities.
The cast of the stage presentation are excellent. They keep the naivety of the original CD but also bring it to life and add to the humour.
I certainly don't enjoy things just because they are outrageous, I just happen to find Kunt's work hilarious and think he gets rough press sometimes.
I also don't think I'm superior or that the posters on here are stupid. I just find it frustrating when people post opinions based on little more than headlines.
I'm a big fan of healthy debate, but you can't have a healthy debate with someone who has no knowledge of the thing they are attempting to debate.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 15:25

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 15:17

No, I was only aware of this thread because Kunt himself linked it on his Twitter due to some of the hilarious and unresearched comments.
I'm a fan of his work so thought I'd defend it while I had lunch. Passes the time, etc. I totally get the show isn't for most of the people on here so the OP is essentially playing to a home crowd, but it's really not as offensive and bad taste as people (the media) are making out. Especially if you actually know the real story.

Yes but you still had to come over and attempt to provoke more outrage because what you saw, however funny you found it, wasn't enough for you. Same thing.

I'm just asking if you enjoy the show because it's clever, funny social satire or because the outrage makes you feel somehow superior. It seems to be the latter, because you're not discussing the show, you're just telling everyone how stupid they are. At least Kunt and the theatre company have done something creative and potentially made some serious, worthwhile commentary. You're no different to the people you're trying to wind up.

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 15:17

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 15:11

So is your appreciation because of its sharp social satire or just because you enjoy the outrage?

It sounds as though you're the counterpart to people who trawl the Internet looking for stuff to be offended by: someone who trawls the Internet looking for offended people. You're both the same, really.

Someone should write a show about that...

No, I was only aware of this thread because Kunt himself linked it on his Twitter due to some of the hilarious and unresearched comments.
I'm a fan of his work so thought I'd defend it while I had lunch. Passes the time, etc. I totally get the show isn't for most of the people on here so the OP is essentially playing to a home crowd, but it's really not as offensive and bad taste as people (the media) are making out. Especially if you actually know the real story.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 15:11

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 14:50

Loving it. Posts like this are comedy gold! Getting outraged over something you've not even seen and know absolutely nothing about. The world is a funny old place!

So is your appreciation because of its sharp social satire or just because you enjoy the outrage?

It sounds as though you're the counterpart to people who trawl the Internet looking for stuff to be offended by: someone who trawls the Internet looking for offended people. You're both the same, really.

Someone should write a show about that...

Draughtycatflapreturns · 11/08/2022 14:58

Is that the show with the big first act number “It’s dusty here living under the bed”?

Rahrahrahrahannoyed · 11/08/2022 14:55

At the very, very least the child and her family should be held in mind. I know they have anonymity but that is not the point at all because it would still affect her. Very insensitive if it happens.

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 14:50

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 14:43

Have to say, Barry, you seem to be enjoying the outrage at least as much as they are. You should be grateful that they're giving you what you want.

Loving it. Posts like this are comedy gold! Getting outraged over something you've not even seen and know absolutely nothing about. The world is a funny old place!

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 14:48

rightonthyme · 11/08/2022 14:36

Barry and Andrew presumably working hard on the marketing... how's the Fringe going?

The Fringe is going great as far as I know. Most nights are selling out thanks to ridiculous publicity like this lol. These people don't seem to realise that getting outraged with no actual knowledge of what or why will just push people to go and watch it. I have no financial involvement, I'm just a fan of Kunt and like winding people up in the name of the cause ;-)

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 14:45

bellamountain · 09/08/2022 19:37

Yep!

Nope! Try doing some research before you get outraged!

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 14:43

Have to say, Barry, you seem to be enjoying the outrage at least as much as they are. You should be grateful that they're giving you what you want.

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 14:41

Wouldloveanother · 09/08/2022 17:43

What the actual fuck! This is horrific, the worst form of ‘entertainment’. What the hell do they think they’re doing? Especially using her full name as the title

And you're basing your opinion on the fact you've seen it? No? Wow! What the actual fuck!!

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 14:39

clickychicky · 09/08/2022 17:34

Hopefully no one will go and see it

You're unlucky there :-( It's selling out night after night!
But that said, should people comment on something they've not seen??

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 14:38

Dotjones · 09/08/2022 17:31

What would you be suing for though? It's perfectly acceptable to make a film or piece of art about real events, generally people can only sue when the piece of art grotesquely distorts the truth and paints them in an unfair light.

In the Shannon Matthews case, unless they've greatly changed it since the CD was released over a decade ago, Shannon barely features at all (from memory, just an anguished scream when the police find her and tell her they'll be taking her back home to her mother). It focuses on Karen Matthews and Michael Donovan, who "masterminded" the plot to fake a kidnapping, wait until a reward was offered then "find" the girl and cash in. Also featured as a subplot is Craig Meehan's child porn habit.

I don't see what case anyone would have to sue. The harm done to Matthews was predominantly caused by her mother with a bit of help fom Donovan. The musical just uses the facts to tell the story in songs. It's true it ridicules Karen Matthews and Donovan to a great extent, but I doubt they'd be able to sue given that it's largely fact based. Regarding Meehan, if anything he comes off better than the others, basically he's just a normal guy in a shit job with no involvement in the faking of the disappearance, albeit gets caught with child porn when his computer is taken by the police to check for evidence.

Refreshing to see a response from someone who actually knows what they are talking about. I saw the preview twice before it went to the Fringe. Not changed massively from the original cd. And the cast are amazing. It in no way satires Shannon.

rightonthyme · 11/08/2022 14:36

Barry and Andrew presumably working hard on the marketing... how's the Fringe going?

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 14:35

Typical MN

Frothing over something most have 0 idea about

There is a reason it's a sell out

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 14:34

dehloh · 09/08/2022 17:22

If you don't like it don't book tickets is not enough, it's ok to feel outraged at something so despicable. In fact, we should be complaining about this, not just ignoring it.

Have you seen it? I'm guessing no.
But still you want the world to complain about something you have no actual knowledge of. Stop acting on shock headlines and do some research! You people are just lazy and love being outraged.

BarryGw · 11/08/2022 14:31

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 09/08/2022 17:19

Sure comedy is subjective and subversive yadda yadda but if the stuff you write centred on an abused child then your scraping the barrel

It's centred on the messed up family and their motives. Shannon is only ever referenced. She does not appear in character or any other form. But if you'd bothered to do any research you'd know that.