Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To opt out of pensions

165 replies

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 13:10

Sorry, posting here for traffic. And name changing cos of figures.

AIBU to consider opting out from pension contributions to free up a bit more money each month?

Disclaimer: I'm good with money, we are careful with what we spend. But I'm not that clued up on taxes, savings, etc.

Things have just got so expensive, we need to free up a bit more money each month.

I'm self employed and haven't contributed to my pension in 2-3years, cos I just can't afford to.

My DH works for a large corporate and contributes 12%, in return his employers also put in 12%. This is around £400 a month pre tax off his salary.

I think if he was to opt out he'd get a extra £300ish a month into the bank. However he'd be loosing £800 a month into his pension.

He thinks it's a good idea. I'm less convinced. But honestly don't know where else we can get £300 a month from. Maybe getting into debt or freeing up some equity from the mortgage be a better option?

OP posts:
Testina · 09/08/2022 14:31

@WhoKnowsProbsNotMe makes an excellent point about cars. That’s often the quickest way to free up money - not leasing, or cashing in the “equity” with a downgrade.

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 14:31

AverageJoan · 09/08/2022 13:53

Missing the point but why are you making student loan repayments when you bring home £15-20 a day afterwards?

I agree with other posters, workplace pensions that good are very hard to come by (I thought mine was good but my employer contributes 7%). I would do everything I could to make sure I didn't have to sacrifice that pension and set myself up for retirement.

Because the £15-20 is after around £130 a day nursery fees for 2 children.

SE commuter belt, that's the standard rate around here.

OP posts:
Testina · 09/08/2022 14:29

@Octomore ”If you're not able to live more frugally, stretch your money further, or earn extra income now, then you're going to find it even harder to do so in your old age.”

I disagree with that. This is not about someone not able to make good choices with money. She’s already earning £30K+ for 3 days of childcare costs! That won’t be a factor in old age, and won’t be such a high cost in just a few short years. If there is nowhere else to take the money from, it’s a legitimate decision to suspend the pension contribution. Just a really last resort one!

Not even last last resort… someone suggested a Saturday job. Personally I’d miss £x in retirement to have that time with my family now. The x there is different for everyone though.

The question here for me is if there really is no other way to get the money, and to understand exactly the impact. OP isn’t there yet - they don’t know if the 12% is a strict match, or if they’d be opting out of a scheme they couldn’t opt back into.

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 14:29

NoSquirrels · 09/08/2022 13:36

Are you currently short of £250 in your present budget, or anticipating a shortfall when energy bills hike?

Currently breaking even but without having to go to extreme lengths to cut back.

Nice things we still pay for are:

  • £7 a week (term time) for a baby/toddler class for each child.
  • £30 once a month to have the extended family around for a meal.
  • Around £35 a month on petrol to drive to days out at the beach or a national trust (membership paid for by MIL).

We could probably also cut back our food bill. My daughter likes expensive fruit: strawberries, raspberries, mango, avocado. For convenience I often buy pre-marinated meat rather than marinate it myself, or get a microwave meal a couple of times a week. I know if I convinced my daughter to eat a banana instead and found time to cook from scratch every day I could cut a good £25 a week off my shop.

Suppose these are probably the sacrifices we'll have to make. Whether they make up for increasing costs is yet to be seen.

OP posts:
WhoKnowsProbsNotMe · 09/08/2022 14:23

I’ve worked in finance for a lot of years and all I can say is if this is really a must (as in for food/bills) and you have no other option is the only time this should really be considered.

best intentions aside it happens all too often that people get used to the additional surplus income, over and above that even if you don’t you will still lose the growth that would of accumulated if standard pension if not and it’s a defined salary or average earnings I would look into scheme rules (as in seek advice) as to what the ramifications of leaving for 2/3 years would be

I know it’s easier said than done (we’ve all been there even those who don’t admit to it) but maybe look at all household bills to check you are with the best providers, do you actually need everything that’s bought in a weekly shop - how much of this ends up being used, do you need all your monthly subscriptions (can you cancel) and the killer. . . do you have 2 cars if so do you really need 2 cars (e.g work commitments) or do you/you both have an expensive car could you possibly downgrade? x

Octomore · 09/08/2022 14:21

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 14:09

The pension minus a year or two worth of contributions for my DH, and maybe 5 years worth of contributions for me.

If it stands for anything I reckon our current combined pension pots are larger than most people our age. It's not a case of if we opt out for a little while now we'll be completely screwed in retirement.

"Larger than most people our age" is pretty meaningless as most people are woefully underprovided on the pension front.

What numbers are we talking here - how big are your pension pots currently, what are your current earnings, and how old are you?

If you're not able to live more frugally, stretch your money further, or earn extra income now, then you're going to find it even harder to do so in your old age.

Octomore · 09/08/2022 14:16

MintJulia · 09/08/2022 13:23

If 12% = £400, that implies your DS is a 40% tax payer.

If he stops his contribution completely, he will lose £400 a month from his employer and £160 tax relief from the govt.

So you would lose £560 a month long term, and only get an extra £240 in his salary cheque.

Common sense says this has to be a very last option by most people's standards. Are there no other economies you could make?

Your maths is wrong here. The OP says it's £400 pre tax, which would make his gross salary £40k.

DenholmElliot1 · 09/08/2022 14:15

Opting out of your pension and renting a home instead of buying one are the worst financial mistakes that anyone can make.

Show me a rich person who rents their home and doesn't have a pension.

confusedlots · 09/08/2022 14:15

Your childcare fees seem very high for 3 days a week? Is there no way to find a cheaper nursery/childminder? Maybe my maths is wrong, but does that not work out around £65 per child per day? And presumably that is what you are paying yourself so it's actually more expensive when you add on what you're getting from the government through tax free childcare?

tara66 · 09/08/2022 14:13

Keep paying for pension, old age comes along quicker than you may think.

hoorayandupsherises · 09/08/2022 14:12

I agree, this could be so so costly for you in the long term.

There's always some people with knowledgeable advice on here, as a starting point:

forums.moneysavingexpert.com/categories/pensions-annuities-retirement-planning

I would also put on a full breakdown of your outgoings versus income as someone might have an idea that you've missed.

And what about the 10 pounds a day thread on here to try to top up? It sounds like you need a temporary stopgap until you get the free hours? If so, is there anyway to pick up a few shifts of something at night/weekends when your DH is back from work? I've had to pick up a couple of late weekend shifts in hospitality and DH has picked up a driving shift. They're so desperate for people we named the times we could do and they took it.

FrownedUpon · 09/08/2022 14:12

How can he think it’s a good idea when he looks at those figures. He’d be crazy to give up that employer contribution.

You need your own pension as well. Don’t rely on his. Most people need to up their pension contributions rather than stop them.

quicklybeendrivenmad · 09/08/2022 14:11

Ex financial advisor and would not advise it, and as someone else has stated he would lose the tax break on his payments so you would probably not end up with £300 extra

Schooldil3ma · 09/08/2022 14:10

I'd really consider getting a Saturday job, or anything rather than doing this. Maybe you as a couple need to realistically look at if both of you can work office hours with such a high childcare bill.

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 14:09

MajorCarolDanvers · 09/08/2022 13:36

What are you going to live on in retirement?

The pension minus a year or two worth of contributions for my DH, and maybe 5 years worth of contributions for me.

If it stands for anything I reckon our current combined pension pots are larger than most people our age. It's not a case of if we opt out for a little while now we'll be completely screwed in retirement.

OP posts:
SavingsThreads · 09/08/2022 14:09

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 13:45

I already work 4 days. Any extra hours would just be offset by the cost of childcare.

You wouldn't need childcare if you work when your husband is at home?

alwaysmovingforwards · 09/08/2022 14:05

overnightangel · 09/08/2022 13:17

If you opt out of a pension where your employer contributes 12% you’re an absolute fool

Agreed.

OP, yes you'd get some extra money in pay packet today, but just be eyes wide open that today's you is absolutely kicking your future self in the arse very hard.

Not only giving up free money from the company, but also your own deductions / savings that are tax free. Plus all of that lovely compound interest that will build up over time.

If you still want to give it up, then do so.

If nothing else your employer will be very thankful you've generously agreed to the same work but gifted them a free reduction in your overall comp & ben package!!

Testina · 09/08/2022 14:04

“I'm not sure if it's a case of they'll match whatever he puts in up to 12%. We'll need to check that”

He really does need to check that before declaring what’s a good idea or not!

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 14:02

wibblewobbleball · 09/08/2022 13:34

I did exactly this when DH suddenly lost his income with no warning as we needed the cash. What I will say is that I am now finding it next to impossible to rejoin the pension scheme as it's hard to then cut that figure out of your budget again. I wouldn't recommend it.

This is helpful, and my main concern. We'll just end up never opting back in.

OP posts:
pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 14:01

NoSquirrels · 09/08/2022 13:33

Is your business actually viable at a 4-day level? Would you be better off working less hours until you’re free of childcare payments?

I make around £15-20 a day after childcare.

It's project work working with teams that are 5 days a week. So 3 days plus logging on in the evenings on my off days is really the minimum. Any less and I just wouldn't get the contracts.

I'm keen to stay in work, I have clients that return to me regularly. If I leave for a few years they'll go to someone else and probably never come back.

OP posts:
Glittertwins · 09/08/2022 14:00

Maybe reduce the contribution temporarily but do not ever give it up. This will be unrecoverable

Lockheart · 09/08/2022 13:58

As a short term absolute last resort because you can't afford the essentials and the situation is becoming dire, then yes I'd cancel the contribution. In the immediate term, food and a roof over your children's heads comes first.

But I would look into every single other option first and it sounds like you're not in dire straits yet! What do you need the money for? Can you cut back other areas? Do you have any areas where you waste money / spend unecessarily? Can you increase the money coming in another way?

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 13:57

balalake · 09/08/2022 13:31

Don't do anything without proper professional advice.

Do you have any pointers of where to go for this?

Ideally for free, we can't afford a financial advisor.

OP posts:
pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 13:57

Testina · 09/08/2022 13:28

Defined Benefit (Final Salary or CARE) schemes still have contribution rates. So can you confirm that this is definitely Defined Contribution? Because it’s a no to opting out of either to me, but it’s a never in your bloody life, extend your mortgage instead type no if it’s a DB scheme!

I’d make this an absolute last resort and do the sums on extending your mortgage instead first.

Is the 12% a match, so your husband has to pay the full 12% to get it?

I'm not sure if it's a case of they'll match whatever he puts in up to 12%. We'll need to check that .

It's definitely defined contribution though.

OP posts:
pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 13:55

CounterTop · 09/08/2022 13:19

And I know it’s not nice to hear, but if your self-employment can’t sustain you, maybe you need to ask yourself if it’s a viable business.

My business makes me more than what I made when employed. Plus gives me flexibility for if the children are unwell, which was the biggest factor in the move to self employment.

Last year I made around £30k pre tax, working 3 days a week. So around £1900 a month.

Unfortunately I'm an idiot that has two children under two and my childcare fees are £1700 a month for 3 days.

OP posts: