Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To opt out of pensions

165 replies

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 13:10

Sorry, posting here for traffic. And name changing cos of figures.

AIBU to consider opting out from pension contributions to free up a bit more money each month?

Disclaimer: I'm good with money, we are careful with what we spend. But I'm not that clued up on taxes, savings, etc.

Things have just got so expensive, we need to free up a bit more money each month.

I'm self employed and haven't contributed to my pension in 2-3years, cos I just can't afford to.

My DH works for a large corporate and contributes 12%, in return his employers also put in 12%. This is around £400 a month pre tax off his salary.

I think if he was to opt out he'd get a extra £300ish a month into the bank. However he'd be loosing £800 a month into his pension.

He thinks it's a good idea. I'm less convinced. But honestly don't know where else we can get £300 a month from. Maybe getting into debt or freeing up some equity from the mortgage be a better option?

OP posts:
Askinforabaskin · 09/08/2022 20:58

Absolutely bonkers unless it is honestly to put food the table for your hungry kids!

Can you see yourself having the discipline to start contributing again? You will get used to that extra couple of hundred.

if you were also paying into a pension I’d say then it maybe viable for the short term, but considering you aren’t I really don’t think it’s advisable.

butterflied · 09/08/2022 20:37

44PumpLane · 09/08/2022 13:15

Agree with abovedeck, do anything you can to avoid giving up the pension contributions.

Matched to 12% is generous and you really should they and take advantage of it.

I get where you're coming from, OP. But I agree with this.

CounterTop · 09/08/2022 20:35

I was also going to suggest upping your consultancy fees.

If you’re billing an average of 12 days a month, even adding £25 net to your daily rate will mean an extra £300/month.

Galliano · 09/08/2022 20:20

Paying £400 pcm (£4800 pa!) to commute to a job with a large corporate in the SE which then only pays £40k pa sounds bonkers even if the pension is good. It’s an employees market at the moment - has he looked at moving on to improve his overall reward package?

HannahSternDefoe · 09/08/2022 20:00

Swap your broadband from BT. They're really expensive. Cancel the TV. You'll probably be to knackered to actually watch anything to the end.
We went to Plusnet (which is still BT) but EE (also still BT) have offers on too.
Stop the trips to the NT places. Ask MIL to cancel it or buy something else that doesn't incur travel costs instead of renewing it. Maybe - if it's a family gift thing - see if she'll treat you to an annual trip to the zoo instead?
We've 2 older low mileage cars, running costs for each one (exc petrol) is c£500-600pa (MOT, Tax, Insurance, basic service/odd tyre, Greenflag covering both).
House insurance - is yours included with your Mortgage? Shop around and see if you can get a good deal elsewhere.
TV license is £159pa too.
Prescriptions are £9.35 per item.

I think you've "lost" quite a few things - and it's easy to do.
Set up a spreadsheet for everything - even takeaway coffees/lunch - that will give you a more accurate figure.

I think if your DH can get compressed hrs, that would help massively. Anything to avoid scrapping his pension - speaking as someone whose DH has just hit 60 and got his - it's not going as far as it would have a year ago, obvs..

Calmdown14 · 09/08/2022 20:00

Go at your food bill before the pension. Your kids are little, they'll soon adapt!

Aldi do frozen fruit (raspberries, strawberries not the forest fruits too tart to eat!) I add them to porridge or wheetabix when heating the milk.

Try and make meals a day ahead of yourself so you can have them as soon as you get in and then do prepping for following day once kids are asleep.

Is there any scope to extend your mortgage term? May not be possible on current deal but worth checking. It will obviously cost you more in interest but given you have a short term issue as a result of childcare you could overpay in a year or so to make it back up.

Given there is an end in sight I would tighten everything I could now to just try and get through to some free childcare which will make a massive difference

Sunshinegirl82 · 09/08/2022 19:49

Also, where are you shopping? Can you look at cheaper places for fruit etc? I get berries for my DC every week but get the "wonky" ones from Aldi and then divide into little pots for lunch boxes. Could you do a little fruit salad so you mix up her favourites with some cheaper stuff? Add some Greek yogurt to make it filling?

NoSquirrels · 09/08/2022 19:32

Pension contributions notwithstanding, your DH’s take home seems fairly low if he’s also incurring the £400 pcm travel costs. Have you done the sums on whether he should try to work a 4-day week (& you pick up more work that day), has he asked for flexible working because of childcare e.g. condensed hours 5 days over 4 etc? Could he WFH more to save on commute costs? Has he asked for a pay rise lately?

Put it all on the table and see what you can do. Don’t dismiss any ideas as unworkable.

Your childcare bill + mortgage is the killer, obviously.

You need to do a projection- how many months of shortfall until your childcare bill drops?

When did you last remortgage, when will you need to again?

Can you cut your childcare costs at all via nanny share, childminder, school-attached nursery when DC1 is eligible etc.

It’s tough. Flowers

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 19:23

VanGoghsDog · 09/08/2022 18:52

What seems to be missing from the sums is what the actual deal is with his employers pension (mine pays 15%, I only have to put in 3%, though I put more) and how big your pension pots currently are, plus your ages.

I mean, if you've got a million and a half each it's a different question to if you've got £2,500 and he's got £40,000!

More than other people your age isn't a good barometer.

I'm aiming for £500k in mine by age 55 and I do regular tracking and projections. That would probably bring a pension of £15k, excluding drawdown (i.e. maintaining the capital, though I dint need to maintain it). If you were to aim for that, what do your projections look like?

Mine is around £25k and his is around £100k.

We're mid 30s, so another 25-30years of contributions to make.

I thought that was really good, but now you've got me worrying that it's not.

OP posts:
pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 19:20

TerrifiedandWorried · 09/08/2022 18:54

"So this month we have £390 a month spare to cover food, clothes, petrol, car upkeep, tv licence, etc."

Are you being realistic here? Christmas, birthdays, haircuts, prescriptions, dentist, insurances, household repairs, optician...a

Look for an online Statement of Affairs calculator and do a realistic budget before making any decisions. You need to include everything, even the things you only pay for annually.

Honestly, I don't know. This situation is all pretty new to us. So I've not come across a month where any of those things have come up.

We had excess in our account before child number 2. This dwindled down while I'll was on maternity, which was always the intention. Then I returned to work 6 weeks ago after 6 months off, and the reality of it all has hit hard. I've never seen our account balance so low.

OP posts:
TerrifiedandWorried · 09/08/2022 18:54

"So this month we have £390 a month spare to cover food, clothes, petrol, car upkeep, tv licence, etc."

Are you being realistic here? Christmas, birthdays, haircuts, prescriptions, dentist, insurances, household repairs, optician...a

Look for an online Statement of Affairs calculator and do a realistic budget before making any decisions. You need to include everything, even the things you only pay for annually.

VanGoghsDog · 09/08/2022 18:52

What seems to be missing from the sums is what the actual deal is with his employers pension (mine pays 15%, I only have to put in 3%, though I put more) and how big your pension pots currently are, plus your ages.

I mean, if you've got a million and a half each it's a different question to if you've got £2,500 and he's got £40,000!

More than other people your age isn't a good barometer.

I'm aiming for £500k in mine by age 55 and I do regular tracking and projections. That would probably bring a pension of £15k, excluding drawdown (i.e. maintaining the capital, though I dint need to maintain it). If you were to aim for that, what do your projections look like?

MeanderingGently · 09/08/2022 17:51

I am totally in the minority here, but I speak as someone who has ALWAYS opted out of every pension scheme I was ever offered, in every job I have taken. Even the recent government one for those without a workplace pension.

I've always needed every penny I've earned and couldn't afford to be putting money away for the future, nor did I wish to join schemes which I wasn't particularly happy with.

However, I have accepted that come 66 years I will be living on a state pension only. I have a lifestyle which suits this, I won't have a car and will happily spend my time walking in the country lanes, reading, painting, writing and taking the weekly 'bus to Tesco!! I'm not far off retirement now and work in a low paid job which leaves me a similar amount per month, so I know I can do it.

If this is what you want for your older years, fine. If you are wanting a different type of retirement it might be worth keeping the pension arrangements you have.

dogatetheremote · 09/08/2022 17:42

Cut back on spending in the short term while you have childcare costs. Do not opt out of the pension, it just saves the employer money. Would your DH accept a salary of 12% lower than his colleagues for doing the same job?
Also check if the pension scheme provides death in service benefits or any other extras, if you opt out you don't get those anymore.
Apart from the difficulty pp mentioned of finding the extra money to contribute in future if he does want to opt back in, if the employer changes the scheme at any point in future he may find himself only able to join a less generous scheme later on.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 09/08/2022 17:40

So not to ask the obvious question, (maybe someone already did and I missed it). When was the last time you raised your rates?

You either need to cut costs or earn more. A lot of self employed/Freelance people fail to keep up with inflation when it comes to setting rates. Do the math, you might lose some business, but that can be offset by the increased revenue for the ones you do keep.

Baystard · 09/08/2022 17:27

OP I agree that it's frustrating that you'll need to be the one giving up time to batch cook but remember you don't need child care for this time and can fit it in a and when you can - a couple of hours of week will make a big difference to your food bill.

Re fruit - so you buy a selection most weeks? We tend to just buy whatever fruit is on offer at any time, so we might have blueberries one week, the next it's a watermelon, etc.

I don't disagree that it's unfair you're being stuck doing even more between your DH working hours and the 'woman's work' thing, but I'd be sticking with the pension contributions as I bet his employer only puts in 12% if DH does.

Once your childcare costs drop you can pick up the luxuries again.

Glittertwins · 09/08/2022 17:07

Catcrisis · 09/08/2022 15:54

Batch cook a big pot of rice and freeze them flat in IKEA freezer bags. Boom. You've made your own microwavable rice bags as they take exactly the same time to heat up but for a fraction of the price.

Do this and over cook every meal for a week or so and freeze. You'll then have a good supply of ready meals for whenever you need them. I can't remember the last time we made a meal for just one time only - even the roasts last to the next day and DH has everything zapped in the microwave on a Monday.

notapizzaeater · 09/08/2022 17:02

I've just popped your figures into a universal credit calculator and it looks like you might be able to claim some of the childcare back which will help.

NiftyFiftyPlus · 09/08/2022 16:38

Another one in the camp of please do not cancel payments into the pension. Honestly you will kick yourselves at some point in the future. The earlier the money is invested, the better. Compound returns!

Lots of pensions also have life cover included, make sure you aren’t giving up this valuable cover.

To get a good idea how much his take home pay will increase if he opts out, I suggest you visit The Salary Calculator website. You can input student loan info etc, you might discover you are giving up a considerable payment into a pension for very little extra take home pay.

Good luck with balancing the books, it will get easier once the children go to school.

puffyisgood · 09/08/2022 15:55

puffyisgood · 09/08/2022 15:45

The mortgage payments are quite a meaty item.

You say £1350 pcm on a mortgage, if that's a repayment mortgage, say payable over 25 years, then by moving to interest only you might be able to get it down to, say, more like £550 pcm. even moving to say 35 years might shave off say £300 pcm.

The key rules of money management [aside from the obvious Micawber principle/maximising incomings/minimising outgoings as far as possible] are to, as far as you can, avoid tax, chase handouts, pay as little/receive as much interest as possible.

Sorry, the point I missed out - employer pension contributions are a huge handout, it'd be bonkers to let them slip.

Debbiedoodah · 09/08/2022 15:55

How much is in each of your pensions and how old are both of you? This is an important factor

Catcrisis · 09/08/2022 15:54

Batch cook a big pot of rice and freeze them flat in IKEA freezer bags. Boom. You've made your own microwavable rice bags as they take exactly the same time to heat up but for a fraction of the price.

Sunshinegirl82 · 09/08/2022 15:53

We are in the SE and our (excellent) childminder comes in at around £54 a day which tax free childcare brings down to around £43 a day. If you can reduce your childcare costs that will make a big difference so definitely worth looking into.

puffyisgood · 09/08/2022 15:45

The mortgage payments are quite a meaty item.

You say £1350 pcm on a mortgage, if that's a repayment mortgage, say payable over 25 years, then by moving to interest only you might be able to get it down to, say, more like £550 pcm. even moving to say 35 years might shave off say £300 pcm.

The key rules of money management [aside from the obvious Micawber principle/maximising incomings/minimising outgoings as far as possible] are to, as far as you can, avoid tax, chase handouts, pay as little/receive as much interest as possible.

StripeyDeckchair · 09/08/2022 15:45

This is a terrible idea.
You are basically giving back part of DH salary (employer pension contributions) and the tax on his contributions.

You should also be extremely worried that you are not paying into a pension of your own.

By the time we want to retire the state pension age will have gone up (70? Older?) And the amount of the pension will be minimal. Everyone needs to look after themselves.