Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To opt out of pensions

165 replies

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 13:10

Sorry, posting here for traffic. And name changing cos of figures.

AIBU to consider opting out from pension contributions to free up a bit more money each month?

Disclaimer: I'm good with money, we are careful with what we spend. But I'm not that clued up on taxes, savings, etc.

Things have just got so expensive, we need to free up a bit more money each month.

I'm self employed and haven't contributed to my pension in 2-3years, cos I just can't afford to.

My DH works for a large corporate and contributes 12%, in return his employers also put in 12%. This is around £400 a month pre tax off his salary.

I think if he was to opt out he'd get a extra £300ish a month into the bank. However he'd be loosing £800 a month into his pension.

He thinks it's a good idea. I'm less convinced. But honestly don't know where else we can get £300 a month from. Maybe getting into debt or freeing up some equity from the mortgage be a better option?

OP posts:
Testina · 10/08/2022 10:55

@IfIGoThereWillBeTrouble whilst I agree generally with you about looking for all the implications, “His pension probably has a death in service benefit which” is unlikely given OP has confirmed it’s a DC scheme.

Iamthewombat · 10/08/2022 10:32

CaptainofmyownShip · 10/08/2022 09:08

Citing £600k per person as the figure to aim for is unrealistic and disincentivising . You don't need anything like that in order to have a reasonable retirement.

She has literally done the maths for you and spelled out the numbers. Which bits do you disagree with? The value of the state pension? The projected investment return? The irrefutable fact that as you draw down on capital, there is less of it to produce a return?

VanGoghsDog · 10/08/2022 10:31

CaptainofmyownShip · 10/08/2022 09:08

Citing £600k per person as the figure to aim for is unrealistic and disincentivising . You don't need anything like that in order to have a reasonable retirement.

Well, I wouldn't want to disincentivise anyone by telling the truth, heaven forbid.

But, you don't have to take my word for it, there's about a gazillion pension advice websites which show how much you need.

£600k only gives you an income of £18k. That's just reality. And most people probably want more than that.

But the key is to look at what you want to live on, when you're going to want to draw it, and how much you need to achieve that. There are plenty of online calculators to help with this.

Onandupw · 10/08/2022 09:43

@CaptainofmyownShip unfortunately that is the reality. Even to replicate the average wage will need a substantial sum saved - and the challenge will be for the half of the population earning over the average wage who will have to accept a notably reduced lifestyle in retirement if they don’t have substantial amounts in their pension.

indeed there is a whole issue around the correlation between happiness and money etc etc

but for the main part most people want to have the same level of lifestyle in retirement.

there is a big issue in the uk about denying the reality of the sounds needed to find retirement- not to even mention decedent care for those that get to that stage.

BovrilonToast · 10/08/2022 09:40

If you’re self employed are you paying yourself in the most tax efficient way? Obviously if you are subject to IR35 you may not have much choice but running a limited company is not that complicated and may be more efficient!!

CaptainofmyownShip · 10/08/2022 09:08

VanGoghsDog · 09/08/2022 23:03

Whether it's "enough" depends on what you need/want in retirement.

I work on a notional 3% investment return, so to draw that 3% with no erosion of capital (you can drawdown capital too, I plan to use that for new car, holiday, bigger expenses, but obviously as you drawdown your income will reduce) on £125k you'd get just over £3k pa. If you work on today's figures the state pension is c£9k for a single person, not quite double that for a couple, but say that means you'd be living on c£20k. Not really doable is it, even without a mortgage.

The usual figure to aim for is around £600k now I'm afraid. Per person, but not exactly double that for a couple.

You need to do some projections.

And you need to maintain that payment in.

As a pp said, look at your husband's job, commute and take home carefully. Him changing jobs might be the best investment you make right now!

Also, though, most people I know were really broke for the first five years of their kids' lives, so don't beat yourselves up!

Citing £600k per person as the figure to aim for is unrealistic and disincentivising . You don't need anything like that in order to have a reasonable retirement.

blisstwins · 10/08/2022 01:50

saveforthat · 09/08/2022 13:15

Employers pension contributions are free money. So is tax relief to a certain extent although you pay tax when you draw the benefits. How old are you?

Any interest rate under 12% would be better, never mind the compounding. I would not pass up the pension in light of the match and you not contributing.

milkyaqua · 10/08/2022 01:10

Very shortsighted to do this. Don't!

IfIGoThereWillBeTrouble · 10/08/2022 00:36

Don’t do it. His pension probably has a death in service benefit which means if he dies you get eg twice/three times his annual salary plus a pension each month. If he did stop paying into the pension (don’t!) you would need to spend some money on life assurance to replace this.

As you aren’t currently paying into a pension you need life assurance too (if you haven’t already) in case you die first. (Sorry to be so morbid, but it happens, and then the surviving spouse struggles to raise the kids with no income)

Our pension scheme has a “50:50” option where you pay in half of your normal contributions for half of the normal benefits. It’s not ideal but less bad than stopping totally. Could your DH enquire if his scheme has something similar?

AdoraBell · 09/08/2022 23:07

Definitely not.

VanGoghsDog · 09/08/2022 23:03

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 19:23

Mine is around £25k and his is around £100k.

We're mid 30s, so another 25-30years of contributions to make.

I thought that was really good, but now you've got me worrying that it's not.

Whether it's "enough" depends on what you need/want in retirement.

I work on a notional 3% investment return, so to draw that 3% with no erosion of capital (you can drawdown capital too, I plan to use that for new car, holiday, bigger expenses, but obviously as you drawdown your income will reduce) on £125k you'd get just over £3k pa. If you work on today's figures the state pension is c£9k for a single person, not quite double that for a couple, but say that means you'd be living on c£20k. Not really doable is it, even without a mortgage.

The usual figure to aim for is around £600k now I'm afraid. Per person, but not exactly double that for a couple.

You need to do some projections.

And you need to maintain that payment in.

As a pp said, look at your husband's job, commute and take home carefully. Him changing jobs might be the best investment you make right now!

Also, though, most people I know were really broke for the first five years of their kids' lives, so don't beat yourselves up!

ThreeRingCircus · 09/08/2022 22:34

We are in a very similar situation OP, two DDs and DH and I are mid 30s. DH has £90k in his pension and I have £40k. It may be more than many people our age but it absolutely is not enough, look at some of the pension calculators to show you what you could get in retirement. I had a nasty shock when I first looked!

So I would do absolutely everything else before I cut any pension contributions. When you get some free hours from nursery that will help, don't just absorb the extra money.... divert it straight to building back the savings pot if you're used to living without that money each month. This is what DH and I did when our nursery bills reduced and it has helped.

In reality OP these years of extortionate childcare costs are very temporary and go by quicker than you think they will. If I had to live on beans on toast for most meals for a little while then I'd do that before touching the pension.

Lavender2021 · 09/08/2022 22:25

confusedlots · 09/08/2022 14:15

Your childcare fees seem very high for 3 days a week? Is there no way to find a cheaper nursery/childminder? Maybe my maths is wrong, but does that not work out around £65 per child per day? And presumably that is what you are paying yourself so it's actually more expensive when you add on what you're getting from the government through tax free childcare?

Nursery childcare around me is £70 a day you might be lucky and find the odd £60 but they are not as good. The government give you £2000 a year/ £500 every 3 months.
Childminders are hard to come by and often don't work after 5pm or don't work all week!
Childcare is a nightmare in the county.
Many people work for very little while the child/ children are smaller but then the short school days start and holidays so you never win!

Octomore · 09/08/2022 22:21

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 19:23

Mine is around £25k and his is around £100k.

We're mid 30s, so another 25-30years of contributions to make.

I thought that was really good, but now you've got me worrying that it's not.

Yeah, that's not super high Im afaid. I'm about 5 years older than you and DH and I have combined pensions of c. £250k in defined contribution pots, plus a defined benefit pot valued at c. £390k. We're not super high earners either.

Definitely pursue any other option you can. Extending your mortgage could be a good call.

Crochetandcoke · 09/08/2022 22:17

How far are you off retiring and is there a chance of recovering that pot at some point at the line? Really depends, if you're nearing retirement or it's like 30 odd years off

LimeTwists · 09/08/2022 22:16

That is a superb pension and you need to make that the absolute last resort.

Augend23 · 09/08/2022 22:13

I do seriously wonder if you should look at extending the term of your mortgage. Even if you just fixed on a 35 year term for 2 years until the childcare fees are down it might make things more manageable.

Currently as you well know, your fixed costs are so high that they dwarf most potential savings.

£1350+1530 = £2880

So afte just mortgage and childcare you have £1,300 to spend on all your other bills plus food and other living expenses.

Things like your BT bill sound fairly reasonable if you're also paying for 2 mobiles on it. Energy is expensive given October's price rise hasn't happened yet - worth looking at your usage maybe?

Does your husband have to commute in every day? £400 a month seems a big commuting cost on his salary? It feels like this is the straw that breaks the camel's back of this budget. I assume there are no options that are any cheaper - like cycling or driving to a different station or cycling across London or really pushing for 3-4 days a week from home? If it's not a job that can be done from home is it a transferable job? It would need to have a London weighting of £8k per year compared to a job with 0 commute costs - he could take a job he could cycle to for £32k a year (plus equivalent pension contributions so might have to up that a bit) and you wouldn't be any worse off. Jobs on £40k can be relatively hard to come by, but £32k is a lot more doable.

Maths below:

On a graduate paying tax, ni and student loans, the effective tax rate from 25k is now 42.25% so for anything you earn over that you lose 42.25p in the pound. So if you have to spend £400 a month after tax to get to your job this is 400*12/0.5775 = £8,300 per year pre tax cost. That shows you the pre tax pay cut you could take if you were able to remove that post tax cost without being worse off. It needs adjusting for pensions etc but it's a useful guide to remind you just HOW expensive that commute is when it's something you could potentially exchange out for a cheaper version.

Octomore · 09/08/2022 22:11

Galliano · 09/08/2022 20:20

Paying £400 pcm (£4800 pa!) to commute to a job with a large corporate in the SE which then only pays £40k pa sounds bonkers even if the pension is good. It’s an employees market at the moment - has he looked at moving on to improve his overall reward package?

This is a good point - it's over 10% of his salary! Either changing job to reduce the commute, or moving house, could be a good idea to address this.

Merryoldgoat · 09/08/2022 22:11

Why is his take home only £2075?

if £400 a month is 12% the he’s earning £40,000.

using a basic calculator he should be bringing home £2247 or £2192 depending on his SL.

reegee · 09/08/2022 22:10

As a pp said, I would look at your mortgage and would definitely not reduce pension contributions given the level of employer contributions.

I work for a financial services company and your mortgage provider should be able to help, whether that's by reduced payments for a period, change from repayment mortgage to interest only for a period or a term extension. As your mortgage is such a large chunk of your income, this is the obvious place to look to make a significant cashflow change in the short term.

If you know your mortgage balance, rate and remaining term it's fairly easy to estimate what the impact of the above changes would be to your monthly repayment.

redskyatnight · 09/08/2022 21:55

We also had 2 children under 2. You just have to accept that while they are little, you can't do a lot else other than cover bills. The good thing is that small children don't need lots spending on them, so I'd suggest cutting the days out (picnic in the park perfectly fine) and fancy food. The impact of doing that for 2 or 3 year is going to be less than DH opting out of his pension.

MercuryOnTheRise · 09/08/2022 21:34

I think it's a silly idea to give up the pension but having said that £390 for everything, including food is, imo, a very small amount. Ready meals, children's activities and days out don't compute from that amount.

Either you have to earn more or reduce your outgoings. Agree with potential suggestions of flexible working and potentially a Saturday job or couple of hospitality shifts to tide you over this lean period.

Like others I'm coming up to retirement. Pensions are very very important.

Flowersintheattic57 · 09/08/2022 21:15

The compound interest you lose will never be earned back.
If you are only bringing in £20 a day after bills, is your H paying half the childcare?
If its the last resort, see if you can reduce his pension payments rather than cancelling them. As pp have said, it can be hard to rejoin.

cestlavielife · 09/08/2022 21:12

my childcare fees

Why "my"? Should come out of the whole pot

Get a longer mortgage etc
Dont cut pension contribs

TerrifiedandWorried · 09/08/2022 21:02

pensionoptions · 09/08/2022 19:20

Honestly, I don't know. This situation is all pretty new to us. So I've not come across a month where any of those things have come up.

We had excess in our account before child number 2. This dwindled down while I'll was on maternity, which was always the intention. Then I returned to work 6 weeks ago after 6 months off, and the reality of it all has hit hard. I've never seen our account balance so low.

Go back over a year of bank statements. Any plans you make will be no good if the information you use is inaccurate.