Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boundaries/consequences for older teens?

34 replies

Eselch · 09/08/2022 11:34

Just wondering if AIBU to want to put some consequences in place for this stuff.

DH and I have 4 DC between us - 19,17,16&15. They live with us FT.

There are a number of small issues that are starting to cause resentment.

We have a tiny bin for rubbish so have to recycle - but DC will put it in the rubbish rather then rinse and recycle it. I end up sorting it.

crockery and cutlery is dumped in the sink rather than put in the dishwasher. If the dishwasher is full of clean pots, rather than put it away, they ignore it and dump their stuff in the sink.

they don’t clean the kitchen after they’ve made food.

I’ve asked them to let me know if we run out of something so I can replace it (I go shopping every 2 days) - but multiple times I go to cook with something and it’s all gone.

Empty packets are frequently just left in the fridge or cupboard.

DC have taken all 20 Tupperware boxes to work and not bothered bringing them home so I have nowhere to store leftovers from last night.

when they do their washing they just leave it for someone else to fold, and leave pocket crap on the side for days on end until someone else moves it.

they expect lifts everywhere, but never say please or thank you.

I KNOW it’s minor. But it’s four of them, and it’s constant, multiple times a day. Its always me that solves it. I tidy up after everyone, and have to go to the shop to replace stuff. They are good kids. But this stuff is SO annoying and inconsiderate and it’s really starting to grate on me.

YABU - that’s just life with teenagers
YANBU - they’re capable of sorting all of the above themselves

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thenewduchessoflapland · 10/08/2022 17:17

1.You shouldn't be doing any of their washing;they are all old enough to do it themselves.

2.Ditto for their bedsheets.

3.Thé ones who have lost all the Tupperware pay to replace it and will continue to do so until they learn not to be lazy;makes me wonder if they are binning the empty tubs at work.

4.A chore rota needs to be come up with

5.Your DH needs to stay burying his head in the sand.

MaggieDragon · 10/08/2022 17:02

Honestly at those ages I wouldn’t be thinking in terms of punishment at all other than them experiencing the direct consequences of their own actions ( eg if they don’t fold their clothes, they have crumpled clothes, if they don’t throw a packet away you don’t know to replace it etc).

I think part of it (IME) is less that they’re lazy and more that they simply don’t make the necessary mental leap (eg from seeing the dishwasher is full of clean dishes to thinking “I’ll empty it”) and there’s a developmental aspect to that. So it’s a boring question of reminding them and (and this can work wonders) really thanking them when they do get it right. Even if it’s just putting something away which they obviously should do anyway, it’s worth pointing out that you noticed and appreciated it. I even thank mine for thanking me sometimes 😂

Eselch · 10/08/2022 17:01

Maray1967 · 10/08/2022 16:52

Start with this tonight: no one is getting lifts to work from Monday if every single Tupperware box is not back here, properly washed and dried by Friday, or replaced if lost. And stick to it. Make them jointly responsible- they should be used to that from school days.

I have ones who keep plates etc upstairs - they have to go back up and bring them down before we eat in the evening.

Oh yes I have one of these too - she half filled the dishwasher with crap from her room this morning!

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 10/08/2022 16:52

Start with this tonight: no one is getting lifts to work from Monday if every single Tupperware box is not back here, properly washed and dried by Friday, or replaced if lost. And stick to it. Make them jointly responsible- they should be used to that from school days.

I have ones who keep plates etc upstairs - they have to go back up and bring them down before we eat in the evening.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 10/08/2022 16:45

DH has suggested sitting down with them and reiterating house rules and giving them all a list of basic expectations, which I hope will work. And to outline consequences - no more lifts or pocket money if they don’t follow house rules. But I’ll also ask them why they’re struggling to do various things and ask them to come up with their own solutions - that’s a great idea.

This sounds really good.

I'd also them that leaving things for you to do makes you tired, disappointed, frustrated, etc, and is just unfair. It's good for them to appreciate that things they do (or don't do) affect the people they live with. I think they tend to forget that.

I'm sure they will still do things that drive you crazy, but it sounds like they're basically good kids who need some reminders that there's a lot you're doing for them, and they're somewhat taking you for granted.

Learning to say thank you when someone gives you a lift is an invaluable life skill and one they should definitely practise.

My oldest is 21 and it's quite funny watching her get frustrated with the 19 and 17 year olds because they leave the bathroom a mess, etc. It's nice that she's now on our side.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 09/08/2022 20:24

it's really tricky. often on MN people suggest that if one's teens do anything less than muck in cheerfully without being asked then you have raised selfish ingrates who are an embodiment of one's parenting failures. But teens do developmentally become quite inward looking and very absorbed in their own worlds though - friendship group issues, school/college work, personal crises seem to take over their headspace.

I reinforce the boundaries and expectations repeatedly, even if I don't enforce "consequences". They roll their eyes and act like I'm being a drama queen at even a gentle rebuke, and I remind them again that it is their inability to follow basic instructions that gets us to this point. They then do the thing (they are not awful people), and 2-3 days later we start the cycle again Grin.

Eselch · 09/08/2022 20:08

Thanks all, it’s all very helpful.

Unfortunately we can’t change the wifi code or block the wifi as it causes chaos on our security system so that’s out. We tried it before and it was a nightmare. A

We also gave up on eating dinner as a family a year ago as I was sick of fussy eaters and people whinging they wanted to eat at different times so now 80% of the time they eat their own, or grab leftovers after me and DH have eaten, so I can’t threaten that either!

I do tell them to tidy up their mess if they are here - but, like most teenagers, they treat the place like a hotel. So they’ll make a mess first thing in the morning, clear off to work or school and then see their mates/boyfriends/girlfriends and not reappear at home until at least 9pm. I WFH so it’s me that has to look at it and deal with it every day!

To be clear though they do have boundaries in place and expectations/chores - they do their own washing, ironing, bedding, tidying of bedrooms etc. and there’s a rota for feeding and walking the dogs. This often gets ignored when they decide to go out with their mates though.

And the other problem is if we stop giving lifts, they would either go to their grandparents who would take them at the drop of a hat with no thought to how that would be undermining our parenting, or lose their jobs which would make them even worse!

DH has suggested sitting down with them and reiterating house rules and giving them all a list of basic expectations, which I hope will work. And to outline consequences - no more lifts or pocket money if they don’t follow house rules. But I’ll also ask them why they’re struggling to do various things and ask them to come up with their own solutions - that’s a great idea.

OP posts:
ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps · 09/08/2022 20:07

Call them back. Every time. Even just for one mug.

Never do it for them.

I work in a supported living environment for 13 adults with learning disabilities - they live in a house together, not separate flats and share a kitchen and laundry room and also share bathrooms (though there are obviously multiple bathrooms they don't all have ensuite) so its very like parenting teens because they can't do exactly what they want due to the fellow residents sharing communal areas and common possessions like crockery, cooking and eating together etc.

I also have 3 teens at home.

The same tactics mostly work, but its a lot easier if you start earlier of course.

Don't fold their laundry - remind in a neutral voice but leave it. They might end up rewashing it a few times but they'll twig eventually.

It's hard to leave things lying but do.

Don't rush to replace things which run out unless they're on the list - but do have a communal shopping list (an app is a good idea).

Draw up a cooking rota if you think that'll work or just cook with what's in even if meals are odd or boring.

Call them to put their things in the dish washer no matter what they're doing. If they actually refuse you could put the dirty dishes in their room if that won't inconvenience you more than you are willing to cope with.

Good luck. Grey rock is your best strategy - neutral voice, remind, repeat, remind, repeat...

nokidshere · 09/08/2022 19:51

I just text mine.

Kitchen..

Kitchen.....

KITCHEN.....

until they do it. To be fair it doesn't take more than 3 times, quicker if they want something.

crumpet · 09/08/2022 19:34

My teens are a mixed bag , helpful with some things, hopeless at other and need (sometimes strong) reminders. But at the end of the day I am quite happy to say to them that if they act like a 5 year old then they will still be treated as children, which can mean consequences. If they want to be treated as near adults then they should be behaving as such.

itsgettingweird · 09/08/2022 19:30

Natural consequences.

So "well I was going to cook X but someone didn't tell me we are out if Y. So if whoever it was or any of you pop to the shop and buy it then I can make dinner".

Same with making dinner.

"I can't make dinner because a b and c are all over the side and all the dishes are in the sink dirty. So when you tidy up after yourselves I can start".

I think motivation is the key at this age. Make the, see what they can't have because they haven't done x y and z.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 09/08/2022 19:09

OP what happens if you ask one of your kids to empty the dishwasher or wash up everything in the sink?

AtleastitsnotMonday · 09/08/2022 19:04

It's sole destroyingly boring I know. Get 4 big blue ikea bags, if you take laundry out the machine it goes in their bag (unfolded or sorted in anyway). Any pocket jazz left lying around get chucked in too. Bag goes to their room for them to deal with. If you want to go to the extreme and can tell who's plates in the sink, Chuck them in a bag in their room for them to deal with too.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 09/08/2022 19:02

BlackbirdsSinging · 09/08/2022 18:44

The trouble is you might have left it a bit late OP. By that age they should already be doing things having been taught to at an earlier age.

It's not about teaching them - that's a one-off thing.

It's about reinforcing the right habits throughout their teen years and beyond, which is a non-stop never ending thing (at least in my experience so far).

OP, I don't tell mine to do things, but I do periodically remind them (sometimes quite tearfully if I'm really exhausted) that they're effectively assuming I'm their servant and will do all this stuff for them, and I point out how exhausting and hurtful it is.

Mine are pretty good about things like emptying the dishwasher, taking out rubbish, washing up after dinner, etc. But they also still leave crap everywhere, and the house can be a mess and get me down, and at times like that I remind myself that they are teens and a bit shit and I still love them.

It's hard.

I think yours are on the selfish side, and do need to improve their ways somewhat.

Ponderingwindow · 09/08/2022 18:53

We only have one so it’s easy to know who the perpetrator is. She gets called to correct the problem when it is found.

if you don’t know the culprit, I would use a rotating system for correction, but I would stop cleaning up after them.

also, you can do things like take away wi-fi and consoles, especially for the non-working ones.

The 19 yo is trickier, but there it’s either understand that living at home like an adult requires acting like an adult or being treated like a child. The 19yo is working and has the option to move out and be a slob.

Sunnyqueen · 09/08/2022 18:51

Bin all the shit they leave out on the sides from washing. Disposable plates/cups/cutlery only to be used. Collect a tenner each off them to replace the tupperware.
Definitely stop them giving them to lifts to work! (who does this??)
Stop cleaning up after them in the kitchen, block the WiFi till its done each evening.
But yanbu it does all sound fairly typical and mundane but that doesn't mean it wouldn't drive you a bit mad.

BlackbirdsSinging · 09/08/2022 18:44

The trouble is you might have left it a bit late OP. By that age they should already be doing things having been taught to at an earlier age.

InTheCup · 09/08/2022 18:42

Natural and give and take consequences is the way to go with older teens.

Don't do your washing = no clean clothes
Don't tidy up after you have made something = no lifts for one day.
Take it turns to empty dishwasher
Don't tell me when we have run out of something = I'm not cooking tomorrow and will get myself a takeaway
Put rubbish in the wrong place = it will end up hung from your bedroom door in a bag.

Hankunamatata · 09/08/2022 17:54

Warn them. If continues I totally would change wi fi password or lock them out. If cant treat home with respect you dont get the things that go with it.
I'd also go for kitchen cleaning rota so one teen does it a day, plus day dh and day yourself.

I'd also allocated hoovering and bathroom cleaning on rota.
Mine are younger but it's amazing how much tidied they have become when they have ti clean

Crazykatie · 09/08/2022 17:47

No lifts until they pull their weight, they do their own tidying and folding, they will very quickly get the message, your are too soft, time to change.

Bonheurdupasse · 09/08/2022 17:18

Topgub · 09/08/2022 17:00

Stop tidying up after them

Stop giving them lifts

Stop giving them money

This OP.

Surely this is the other side of 'treating them as adults'.
Stop doing things for them.

notanothertakeaway · 09/08/2022 17:02

Could you frame it as "actually I didn't have time to do your laundry today because I had to do do X that you hadn't done"? Point out the consequence of their laziness and let them see that if they pull their weight, you will all benefit

poorbuthappy · 09/08/2022 17:02

The only thing which solved the dishwasher unloading problem in our house was me writing their names on the calender so 1 child does it each day.
Shopping list - Alexa brilliant for this. Kids just shout at her to replace stuff.
I still threaten to remove phones with my lot purely because I still pay for them. (ok so they're 17 and 2x13 so a little bit different)
I've been known to drive round the village to collect my darlings (well the twins anyway) to bring them home to tidy up after themselves.
You have to be consistent hard and a team with your DH.
Without him on side you'll struggle.

Topgub · 09/08/2022 17:00

Stop tidying up after them

Stop giving them lifts

Stop giving them money

monsterastuckiosa · 09/08/2022 17:00

Agree it's really tough.

I sometimes find that asking them to come up with a solution is helpful – explain what's happening, why it can't continue, and get them to suggest systems and approaches that will work.

Having the ideas come from them sort of pre-loads the responsibility being theirs, rather than them kicking back against you telling them 'how it's going to be'.