Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you expect an 8 year old to do these things without help?

88 replies

OhImVisiblyOver25 · 09/08/2022 09:57

Brush teeth properly
Shower
Wash shoulder length hair
Tie shoe laces
Do and undo top button on a shirt
Sit properly on a chair at the dinner table

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wnikat · 09/08/2022 15:50

Mine can't do some of that but he's always struggled with motor skills so I don't shame him if he e.g struggles to sit properly on a chair as I think he finds that harder than other kids, for example his little sister.

liveforsummer · 09/08/2022 15:27

Just because she can do it doesn't mean she doesn't find it hard. It's not lazy to not want to constantly do things you find difficult and making it a battle won't help. Lots of praise when she does do it but it's ok just to help out sometimes. Like a pp said she won't still be needing you to do it at 13

Suedomin · 09/08/2022 15:19

All children are different and develop at different rates . However I think all children at 8 will need reminding about things. I think it's too much to expect them to just so everything on that list.
Doing up laces, top button an a shirt and washing their own hair are particularly difficult

Minikievs · 09/08/2022 15:13

My 8 yo DD yes. At 8 years old my DS struggled with laces.

StandUpPirates · 09/08/2022 15:13

Brush teeth properly - yes and no. You should be supervising and brushing and flossing once a day until they are at 10.
Shower - yes
Wash shoulder length hair - DD needed help until about 10.5. Still needs help rinsing if she's tired!

Tie shoe laces - DD learnt this in the year she turned 9. Until then all shoes in her size were Velcro or button laces.

Do and undo top button on a shirt - I have no idea, DD has never had to do this. She could certainly button and unbutton a cardigan about 6 but that must be far easier than a small shirt button.

Sit properly on a chair at the dinner table That's entirely dependent on the food, mood and how much you engage them in conversation or activity you give them to at the table e.g. colouring. So at 8 yes, but not reliably or consistently or when you want them to.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 09/08/2022 14:48

My 7 year old can tie laces but only because he plays football and has big feet for his age. It took me a while to teach him. We used to race each other, one boot each.
He does a good job of brushing teeth but I still supervise.
He showers and can do his buttons.
Sitting still is very much a work in progress.

Hakeandling · 09/08/2022 14:48

from experience of own kids and those of friends :

Brush teeth properly-not necessarily-should be able to give them a good go but still need supervision
Shower-yes as long as shower straightforward and not likely to scald

Wash shoulder length hair-might still need help

Tie shoe laces-possible but needs teaching and practise

Do and undo top button on a shirt-yes

Sit properly on a chair at the dinner table-yes but for variable lengths of time

TheYearOfSmallThings · 09/08/2022 14:43

I’m in my own in the mornings with her and the baby

Has she been an only child or youngest child up until the age of 7/8, and then a baby sibling?

If so she may be acting up for attention, or it may be that you were helping her with stuff more than you realised, and now you can't. Either way, the suggestion to have something she likes at the end of the process (eg breakfast and cartoons) seems a good one.

Sartre · 09/08/2022 14:32

Yeah because my DC all definitely did the above at 8, probably from 7 comfortably tbh.

SleepingAgent · 09/08/2022 14:23

Would brush teeth yes but need reminded to do it for longer than 15 seconds!

I imagine quite a lot would need help with long hair to check it's done properly at that age. It's tiring rubbing and rinsing especially if very thick.

Shoelaces - hmm tricky one - some kids get co-ordination earlier than others, so I'd just keep encouraging the practising and help if necessary.

The others, by 8 and NT, yes.

SkankingWombat · 09/08/2022 14:10

OhImVisiblyOver25 · 09/08/2022 13:25

This is the issue we’re having. She can do these things, if she needs to be ready for something SHE wants to do she can do all of these things easily. If it’s not something she wants to do she pretends she can’t do these things. I’m in my own in the mornings with her and the baby and I’m trying to get all of us ready and it doesn’t help when I have to keep sending her back to the bathroom to get her teeth cleaned properly as she absolutely will not let me do it for her, plus I also think I don’t need to do it for her as she can do it herself but is just dragging ass with it. I hate starting the day off stressed and so does she.

To help motivate my DCs to get ready, they must be up, teeth brushed, been to the loo, dressed, and any items needs for the day packed/brought to me to pack before they can eat breakfast. They are very motivated by food! On days where they are exceptionally slow, I have been known to remind them that we will be leaving at 8.30 regardless of the volume of food consumed, and it makes no difference to me if their tummies are hungry and rumbly at school (obviously I do care, but I want to emphasise that they are causing any suffering to themselves and I am not prepared to be late because they faffed). Equally at bedtime, reading them a story is left until last. I remind them that every minute procrastinating is a minute less of their story.
Is there a part of your morning (or bedtime) routine your DD prizes that you can dangle carrot-like for once she's done everything else?

Fevertree · 09/08/2022 13:33

Bottom 3 yes
Top 3 no

123boom · 09/08/2022 13:33

My dd is 9, has no other issues, and can do all. However, she only recently mastered laces and I try and supervise brushing teeth as she will try and get away with none! I think kids can vary a lot with some of these things

OhImVisiblyOver25 · 09/08/2022 13:25

Bear2014 · 09/08/2022 12:57

Our 8.5 year old can do all of those things easily but very often won't.

This is the issue we’re having. She can do these things, if she needs to be ready for something SHE wants to do she can do all of these things easily. If it’s not something she wants to do she pretends she can’t do these things. I’m in my own in the mornings with her and the baby and I’m trying to get all of us ready and it doesn’t help when I have to keep sending her back to the bathroom to get her teeth cleaned properly as she absolutely will not let me do it for her, plus I also think I don’t need to do it for her as she can do it herself but is just dragging ass with it. I hate starting the day off stressed and so does she.

OP posts:
CarlCarlson · 09/08/2022 13:19

JuneOsborne · 09/08/2022 10:36

Children aren't special needs. They may have special or additional needs.

You knew what I meant 🤷🏻‍♂️

DoraDont · 09/08/2022 13:13

Dd turns 8 in December and can do most of the above, might struggle with a top button and shoelaces though.

shivbo2014 · 09/08/2022 13:03

My daughter turned 8 last week and she can do all of them but she doesn't wash her own her because it's really long and thick but if it was shorter and finer she'd manage fine.

Bear2014 · 09/08/2022 12:57

Our 8.5 year old can do all of those things easily but very often won't.

Rainbowshit · 09/08/2022 12:55

No to the teeth and the laces.

BlankTimes · 09/08/2022 12:53

@OhImVisiblyOver25 I know she’s old enough to do them properly.

If your child hasn't reached an appropriate skill level for their age, then it's time you observed objectively and actually noticed whether the problem is laziness or that child really struggling and still not completing that task.

I've seen a lot of children scolded and sometimes ridiculed for being lazy or called stupid when the fact was there was a very valid reason for them not being able to do a series of both gross and fine motor tasks. Being repeatedly derided for not being able to do certain tasks gnaws away at a child's self-esteem very quickly.

There's vast difference betweeen can't and can't--be-bothered that some people, often parents, just don't seem able to pick up on.
The child's level of intelligence isn't a factor either, as @QueenCamilla posted upthread.

If you're concerned about your child not doing what you consider to be age-appropriate tasks, please either self-refer or ask your GP for a referral to a paediatric Occupational Therapist so they can let you know if there's a valid reason for your child not being able to do the things his/her peers can.

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 09/08/2022 12:43

Well, I'd expect my 8 year old to try it on with the teeth, to be able to shower (and have to be kicked out of it in fact), washing hair he does, but I do it every now and then so I can properly condition it, and I comb it once a week(it's long and curly - really tough for a child to deal with alone). He doesn't have shoelaces or buttons, but I'd expect him to give it a go and be able to do it after a bit of practise, and certainly sit nicely at the table (and put up a protest at me insisting he uses the knife and fork properly).

My eldest would be fine with it all except the buttons and the laces (and no long hair) at that age - but he's got a co-ordination disorder so he doesn't wear buttons or laces anyway because why make trouble!

SkankingWombat · 09/08/2022 12:43

My 8yo is hypermobile and has ADHD, and struggles with some self care tasks as a result. From your list:

Brush teeth properly - Yes, but we still brush after her once a day just in case and check her brushing every so often with a disclosing tablet.

Shower - Yes.

Wash shoulder length hair - Not fully. She wets it, we add conditioner and comb it out (she has bum-length 3c curls so the tangles are still too much for her. We co-wash hence no shampoo), she will then have a go at combing if she fancies it. She washes the conditioner out herself.

Tie shoe laces - Yes, but only the 'bunny ears' method. It took a dedicated effort to teach this: 10 mins a day, every day for 4 months. She has been able to do this for a couple of years (it was a lockdown goal!) but still looks quite awkward in the way she handles the laces.

Do and undo top button on a shirt - No. The hypermobility affects her fingers and makes this very difficult. I buy the M&S shirts with a velcro top button.

Sit properly on a chair at the dinner table - Ish! Depends on the day! She used to wiggle around so much she'd regularly fall off it. That happens rarely now, but she'll still often sit crouched or on one foot. At school she has a band around the bottom of her chair to help her stay rooted.

If your DC is struggling with all of these things, I would be looking if there are any other signs of hypermobility/dyspraxia/ADHD.
Eg how is her handwriting? Check her movement against the hypermobility checks you can find on Google.

WonderingWanda · 09/08/2022 12:42

What do you mean by daily battle? Do you mean they can't get the hang of shoe laces and top buttons which can be tricky for some kids who are behind with fine motor skills so they ask you to do it and this annoys you? Or can they do all of these things well but either don't do them because they are forgetful or they don't like their top button done up, would rather play than clean their teeth etc? I'm not sure any of this requires a battle at age 8. My 9y/o can do some of those things but will need reminders but that's what parenting is.

OhImVisiblyOver25 · 09/08/2022 12:41

Ok thanks everyone. I know she can do these things because at the end of the battle she can magically do them. I don’t mind helping her with her hair as it’s very thick but brushing he teeth just strands there with the toothbrush in her mouth and doesn’t even attempt to move it around her mouth. No special needs.

OP posts:
OhImVisiblyOver25 · 09/08/2022 12:40

Thornethorn · 09/08/2022 12:26

Based on your response I'm more concerned about your parenting than your child's independence skills.

Yeah sure you are.

OP posts: