Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to not allow popular kids characters/music in the house?

533 replies

Elilanna · 09/08/2022 07:37

No kids yet, but I'm hoping to have them in the near-ish future, work in the early childhood sector and have a young niece and nephew so I'm quite aware of what's popular with the little ones these days, but I'm personally not a fan and would rather not expose my own children to any of that media, at least not when they're very small - but I've heard a lot of criticism of this approach, that "only crunchy hippie mums do that!" and "it's part of our culture, you're depriving them of an important part of childhood!" Specifically I'd be avoiding Disney, Cocomelon, and the Wiggles, and even things I don't mind wouldn't be on baby's clothes & other belongings as I don't believe in turning your child into free advertising for a popular brand. I'm otherwise not very "hippie" or "crunchy", this is just the one thing where I'd like to limit their exposure.

So... tell me I'm not the only one who wants to do this?

OP posts:
curiouscatgotkilled · 10/08/2022 20:37

You'll be sorry you missed out on Bluey and Hey Duggee.
I had similar ideals before my actual children arrived, I'm not even sure why, TV isn't the devils work, it's nice! And really helpful in the long days of parenting small children.

user1491320660 · 10/08/2022 20:30

Elilanna · 09/08/2022 07:37

No kids yet, but I'm hoping to have them in the near-ish future, work in the early childhood sector and have a young niece and nephew so I'm quite aware of what's popular with the little ones these days, but I'm personally not a fan and would rather not expose my own children to any of that media, at least not when they're very small - but I've heard a lot of criticism of this approach, that "only crunchy hippie mums do that!" and "it's part of our culture, you're depriving them of an important part of childhood!" Specifically I'd be avoiding Disney, Cocomelon, and the Wiggles, and even things I don't mind wouldn't be on baby's clothes & other belongings as I don't believe in turning your child into free advertising for a popular brand. I'm otherwise not very "hippie" or "crunchy", this is just the one thing where I'd like to limit their exposure.

So... tell me I'm not the only one who wants to do this?

I keep my kid away from Youtube, especially Ryan and Adley. Netflixs is watched daily and I have no problem with it. Not sure what you do not like about CoCo Melon, my daughter loves it and we both sing along. I think it hard to say what you would be like before having a child and knowing their personality. My daughter watched Ryan for a couple of weeks and I didn't like the effect it was having her, so I decided that it was no longer to be watched. As much as you think you know how to handle being a parent, the reality is far, far different. As a funny aside I kept my daughter away from pink only for pink to know be favourite colour!

Anastar23 · 10/08/2022 20:27

🤣 I had the same stance.. then I had kids. Don’t do it is my advice tbh 🙈

JennyWren87 · 10/08/2022 20:13

Nope YANBU. In the beginning you get to decide! Once they're exposed to popular cartoons at friends houses and like them then I'd allow it no problem. But for now we've picked up that our 21 month old loves dinosaurs so "Land before Time" is our chosen program/movies. He absolutely loves them and won't watch anything else.

Mamiamamia · 10/08/2022 20:11

Elilanna · 09/08/2022 07:37

No kids yet, but I'm hoping to have them in the near-ish future, work in the early childhood sector and have a young niece and nephew so I'm quite aware of what's popular with the little ones these days, but I'm personally not a fan and would rather not expose my own children to any of that media, at least not when they're very small - but I've heard a lot of criticism of this approach, that "only crunchy hippie mums do that!" and "it's part of our culture, you're depriving them of an important part of childhood!" Specifically I'd be avoiding Disney, Cocomelon, and the Wiggles, and even things I don't mind wouldn't be on baby's clothes & other belongings as I don't believe in turning your child into free advertising for a popular brand. I'm otherwise not very "hippie" or "crunchy", this is just the one thing where I'd like to limit their exposure.

So... tell me I'm not the only one who wants to do this?

Do a bit of research into Waldorf, you don’t have to get into the whole Anthroposophy side of things, and can just take from it what resonates with you (it doesn’t have to be an all or nothing approach) - I think you would find that this fits with your views for the early years.

NannaKaren · 10/08/2022 20:05

Hmmmm just spat my Tea all down me…laughing. Hysterically now!

saraclara · 10/08/2022 20:04

I remember the first time we took our first born to the cinema. It was to see The Little Mermaid. DD was entranced and actually had tears in her eyes and a gorgeous smile of happiness on her face at the (totally inaccurate) happy ending.

My MIL bought the girls a video of the animated Disney Robin Hood. They adored it. Sometimes she'd have them for the day (maybe at 3 and 4 years old) and I'd come home from work to find the three of them in random dressing up clothes pretending to be Robin, Maid Marian and the sheriff.

I'd been anti Disney before they erre born, but the above are amongst my favourite memories of my girls being small.
Oh, and the daughter who was so emotional about the happy ending of the Little Mermaid, was and is super sporty, and was the least 'girly' of all her school friends. These films and cartoons are nowhere near as scarily formative as some parents think.

Buttercupsx · 10/08/2022 20:00

@TheKeatingFive PM’d you

Tumilnaughts · 10/08/2022 19:59

I was the child of someone who thought this way. I grew up isolated from my peers culturally which made making friends and sustaining relationships relationships difficult as I didn't have the same reference points. I didn't catch up until I was in my early twenties. This was the time before YouTube though so maybe your hypothetical children will not be as unfortunate as I.

barefootnomads · 10/08/2022 19:53

So far I’ve got away with my DD not having character clothing, and we don’t have much tv time. But she’s around other children a lot and see’s cocomelon etc and so we watch some of it at home as she enjoys it. I don’t think you should ban or avoid kids characters, and I am crunchy/hippie!

Frazzledstar1 · 10/08/2022 19:53

What will you do when they are at school and they get an end of term treat to watch a movie in class and it’s something on your no list? Pull them out? They’ll end up being singled out from their peers. I can understand you wanting to limit these things (although we love Disney in this house, such rebels!) but it may not be realistic to completely shield them from everything.

Also, my girls love their LOL Surprise and Ariel PJs, and I don’t think it’s doing them any harm at all 🤷🏻‍♀️

Runmybathforme · 10/08/2022 19:52

For me it was " my baby will never have a dummy, disgusting things ". I lasted a couple of weeks. He had colic .

BendingSpoons · 10/08/2022 19:49

We have mostly done this. We don't buy clothes with characters on. They still choose their own cool clothes (reversible sequin tops being the current favourite). Same with toys. We have plenty of cars for example, but no Paw Patrol ones.

DCs watch bit of TV but not loads. Maybe 30 mins 3 times a week, sometimes more, sometimes less. It has only been very recently (DCs age 6 and 3) that they have control of the remote, so previously we have chosen what they watch. We put on kids programmes but steer towards the ones we prefer. Current favourites are Number blocks, Topsy and Tim, Go Jetters.

marktayloruk · 10/08/2022 19:48

Make sure they're not isolated.

Bleachmycloths · 10/08/2022 19:44

User48 has the best reply.
As a parent and grandparent I am laughing my head off 🤣. I have heard similar stories from about-to-be parents. Two years down the line, it’s a different story. If you get through the first 2 years safely, happily and sane it’s a major achievement. Good luck.

TheKeatingFive · 10/08/2022 19:38

Shit I don't know what's happening to my posts today.

My job is to research and consider the consumption and impact of pop culture ( amongst other things) on it’s target audience, young and old. I do think about it.

I'd be interested in your methodology here, how are you accessing the views of the kids themselves for example?

My view is to expose children to a range of things early on. That was my advice to the OP.

I don't think anyones disagreeing with you there. Just that banning The Wiggles/Teletubbies/Hey Duggee is an odd policy, particularly when the OP isn't even pregnant.

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 10/08/2022 19:36

SleeplessInEngland · 09/08/2022 07:43

I’ll just say this - we all have big ambitions of our children never watching tv or eating bad food but when you realise certain things stop a 2 year old’s tantrum in its tracks it becomes very hard to maintain that stance.

Good luck.

This

But if you can live up to the ambitions then I admire you and YANBU

TheKeatingFive · 10/08/2022 19:35

My job is to research and consider the consumption and impact of pop culture ( amongst other things) on it’s target audience, young and old. I do think about it.

Buttercupsx · 10/08/2022 19:28

TheKeatingFive · 10/08/2022 19:10

We have differing views - that’s ok
I find it weird that many don’t apply critical thinking to children’s tv.

Well what do you consider to be good children's tv then? I find it odd that adults don't think a bit harder about the target audience for this material. Success here is not appealing to adults.

This is just a thread on Mumsnet - a fraction of the population. It’s not indicative of all.

I don't think 'my child watched something at a friends house / nursery' is particularly unrepresentative as a practice, to be fair.

To say children have an inability to develop their own tastes - that sounds and is tosh.

Goid job I never said that then, hmm?

They are not born as identikit cloned kids with a predetermined love for the same things

Again, no one said they did. It's vey clear from this thread that children find their own specific favourites within the wider offering.

My job is to research and consider the consumption and impact of pop culture ( amongst other things) on it’s target audience, young and old. I do think about it.

You originally call my view out as rubbish. That’s fine. I’m not here to convince you of it. My view is to expose children to a range of things early on. That was my advice to the OP.

LinaDeVille · 10/08/2022 19:27

When you're trying to wrestle a headstrong 3 year old into some clothes for nursery and you are running late.

Not wearing that. Don't like it

How about the Peppa t-shirt?

Oh yes please mummy. Great! Job done

OhFatty · 10/08/2022 19:26

I wish people would stop saying ‘plastic tat’ - you mean your childrens prized possessions.

I completely understand not wanting to have too many toys, but it’s horrible to refer to any one’s belongings as tat.

LinaDeVille · 10/08/2022 19:24

If i were you, id reserve judgement on parenting until you're a parent yourself

saraclara · 10/08/2022 19:21

raising a child is less about building a micro-climate for them and more about helping them negotiate the world.

I couldn't agree more. Wise words there for any parent.

TheKeatingFive · 10/08/2022 19:10

We have differing views - that’s ok
I find it weird that many don’t apply critical thinking to children’s tv.

Well what do you consider to be good children's tv then? I find it odd that adults don't think a bit harder about the target audience for this material. Success here is not appealing to adults.

This is just a thread on Mumsnet - a fraction of the population. It’s not indicative of all.

I don't think 'my child watched something at a friends house / nursery' is particularly unrepresentative as a practice, to be fair.

To say children have an inability to develop their own tastes - that sounds and is tosh.

Goid job I never said that then, hmm?

They are not born as identikit cloned kids with a predetermined love for the same things

Again, no one said they did. It's vey clear from this thread that children find their own specific favourites within the wider offering.

Ketzele · 10/08/2022 19:05

See, I was the weird kid at school, 50 years ago now. Free school meals, single parent, no TV, lefty politics, no inside toilet, no Enid Blyton, no Barbie... My mum insisted that we should rebel against mainstream culture and partly as a result we were oddballs. (She had been a lonely oddball child too.)

I had my children as a lesbian mother. One of my children is white and one black. One is adopted. We live in the suburbs. So I knew they would be 'different' and was determined not to exacerbate that. So they were allowed to wear all the pink they wanted, watch crappy TV, enjoy all the earth-polluting crazes.

I'm not saying there were no limits - they were always exposed to alternative choices and they definitely got exposed to my values - but I think as a parent you have to accept your child will need to negotiate their peers, and usually they want to fit in. I don't think my job was to make it harder for my kids to fit in, though I did always try to help them stay true to themselves (accepting that they are a different person to me).

What would have made my parenting life easier would have been if the nice mums of this area had been a little less focused on what their kids were eating, watching and wearing, and a bit more on top of how their little angels lived their values.

Sorry if that sounds bitter. I'm not, really. My kids are great and have plenty of friends. My point is really that you won't get any argument from me if you ban Disney. But understand that raising a child is less about building a micro-climate for them and more about helping them negotiate the world.