Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to not allow popular kids characters/music in the house?

533 replies

Elilanna · 09/08/2022 07:37

No kids yet, but I'm hoping to have them in the near-ish future, work in the early childhood sector and have a young niece and nephew so I'm quite aware of what's popular with the little ones these days, but I'm personally not a fan and would rather not expose my own children to any of that media, at least not when they're very small - but I've heard a lot of criticism of this approach, that "only crunchy hippie mums do that!" and "it's part of our culture, you're depriving them of an important part of childhood!" Specifically I'd be avoiding Disney, Cocomelon, and the Wiggles, and even things I don't mind wouldn't be on baby's clothes & other belongings as I don't believe in turning your child into free advertising for a popular brand. I'm otherwise not very "hippie" or "crunchy", this is just the one thing where I'd like to limit their exposure.

So... tell me I'm not the only one who wants to do this?

OP posts:
CrossStitch87 · 09/08/2022 09:16

I’ve said it before. People really do overthink parenting to the nth degree these days. Find the joy in it! Stop tying yourselves up in your own arbitrary rules and guidelines because it makes fook all difference anyway.

Goldbar · 09/08/2022 09:15

I think there's two things here. The first is that being a parent is hard. It's also only one part of your life, which you're often trying to balance with other parts such as working and chores. And if you have more than one DC, you're trying to balance those DC - there are many toddlers who had hardly any screen time until their mothers were heavily pregnant/ had to care for a newborn and then it went through the roof. So often you compromise and things like Disney and Peppa seem OK at that point. I find Disney good for getting older preschoolers to watch an actual film, rather than just an episode of something.

The other thing is that your children are not mini-mes. They will form preferences and unfortunately those preferences will sometimes be different to your preferences. They will also be influenced early on by what their peers like and have. And while you don't always need to indulge their preference and give them what they want as opposed to what you would like them to have, it's nice for children to have some element of agency and personal choice in their lives.

Brented · 09/08/2022 09:15

Is it just American and Australian shows you have a problem with? Seems a bit xenophobic? We read books and watch things from all over the world and I don’t really see a problem with it, I like exposing my child to other countries and cultures and we tend to holiday as much as we can. The Sorcerer’s Apprentice was one of my favourite films as a child and I definitely plan on watching that with my children when they’re old enough to appreciate it. I don’t really believe in placing blanket bans on things (unless obviously harmful like playing with knives etc.), everything in moderation works well for us, but ultimately it’s your hypothetical child - so you can parent how you want!

3luckystars · 09/08/2022 09:15

As my sister says ‘I was a brilliant parent until I actually had my own children’

all the best with your imaginary children today.

Christmasiscomingitis · 09/08/2022 09:13

I wanted to do this. it fell through.
my parents attempted this too. we weren't allowed Internet until we'll after all of my peers. Popular TV shows were a no. We only watched Disney videos etc.
I was fine in primary school but was ostracised in secondary. That was a tough 5 years and as a result I don't have many friends now and none from school. I didn't have a single friend (except a few pity friends) in the whole of secondary school because I had nothing in common with anyone and couldn't relate to them. it made me wierd and my parents relented.

Coffeaddict · 09/08/2022 09:13

Beees · 09/08/2022 09:06

It still won't work. My child is 2 and has never seen Peppa Pig and we have no Peppa Pig books or toys but he still knows who she is and includes her in his pretend play because he's seen the books at nursery and his friends talk about her.

You might choose to watch other things but it won't stop your child making up their own minds about what they like or want to watch, read or listen to.

This. I hate peppa pig, I think she's a spoilt little brat, DS has never seen it however his Christmas present from nursery was a peppa pig book, his bath toy his aunt got him for his birthday is a peppa pig toy. He reads and knows this stuff from nursery.
Would you confiscate gifts given to your child for example by ''santa" or a nursery worker or family member if they happened to be related to one of these shows?
Also at 2 I probably could get away with losing this stuff if I really cared but as they age and become more aware of their own belongings are you really willing to be the bad guy in confiscating gifts?

skyeisthelimit · 09/08/2022 09:13

OP, you can watch what you want and wear what you want. I don't buy branded clothing as I think it is a waste of money, paying 4 times the price for something just because it has a certain label on it, but each to their own if they can afford it.

We love Disney and Harry Potter and other things, but avoided certain programmes like Spongebob.

DD didn't have her first kindle until she was around 7. You are the one in control so you can decide what happens.

TheCraicDealer · 09/08/2022 09:13

DD is nearly three and loves The Wiggles, which we only discovered as we YouTubed a sea shanty to show her after she got keen on pirates and they’d done a version. Watching her learn dance moves and sing along to some of their songs (like a Polynesian folk tune or counting to ten in Arabic) that she would never otherwise be exposed to can only be good for her in my view.

Cocomelon is shit but thankfully she’s seems to have grown out of it with no ill effects. Bluey however is amazing- watch Sleepytime Or Baby Race and come back and tell me it’s dross.

We certainly don’t buy piles of character stuff for her, but when she’s refusing to put on jammies and I say, “ok, choose between peppa pig ones or these (unbranded) ones”, she’s got her arse in pj’s in two minutes rather than having a mega tantrum immediately before bed.

I think it’s important to remember that they’re individuals with their own wants, preferences and interests. So long as they’re not watching telly all day, every day, what harm do you think it’ll do to let them have that little degree of agency?

CrossStitch87 · 09/08/2022 09:12

Oh don’t make them the weirdos. Don’t do that to them.

Wetblanket78 · 09/08/2022 09:12

Some programmes on cebeeies are actually quite educational. Would you really refuse to buy your child an item of clothing they really like? Or refuse to buy them a gift they asked for they like they played with at a friend's house.

No matter how much you try to control what they do, see and have. At some time they will see, come into contact with or have a gift bought for them you don't want them to have but will get a lot of enjoyment out of.

Angrypandy · 09/08/2022 09:12

Up until about 3 this works fine as an approach, as you have complete control over what they watch and there's no need for them to watch any of that stuff. After that age they want to watch the same stuff as their playmates and it becomes harder to say no. I do not want my Year 6 son to play fortnite, but I do want him to have friends and be able to join in with them - that's the dilemma.

yikesanotherbooboo · 09/08/2022 09:10

I absolutely hate advertising at children and their manipulation by industries so am with you. I was also a parent of young children 20-30 years ago when there was a lot less of it so I could avoid advertising of sweets and snacks or buying of media associated toys to a large extent.Having said that , some of these things are fun. I have lovely memories of my middle child whiling away hours singing and dancing to The Wiggles or my oldest sitting with me watching Jungle Book while the baby was quiet for a moment.We all have ideas of how we want to parent and hills we are prepared to die on , you only have to read threads here on mn about food to realise that. Most of us make some compromises along the way and mine would be different to eg my sister's . We also have to learn that it really does and should take a village to raise a child and that because my mil or DM or our nanny have or had different ways of doing things as long as they are from love it is usually alright.

hewouldwouldnthe · 09/08/2022 09:10

We all have silly ideas until reality hits.

BlancmanegeBunny · 09/08/2022 09:10

It is so easy to be a parent before you have children!

YANBU ........but you are being very naive to think it is that clear cut.
Parenting is about being flexible and picking your battles.

Before having children I think we all said or thought "my children will never do X" and then looked back and laughed at how theory and reality play out!!!

MassiveSalad22 · 09/08/2022 09:09

User478 · 09/08/2022 07:40

You do what you think is best with your hypothetical children.

You do what you can with your actual children.

I quite like the Wiggles.

Done and dusted in the first post 😄

Love the Wiggles.

Having said that never felt the need to buy character clothes!

ItsDangerousInKingsmarkham · 09/08/2022 09:09

Bluey is great and Peppa Pig grows on you. It is more self aware than you think. Grampy Rabbit is voiced by Brian Blessed and Miss Rabbit is a feminist icon. There's no job she can't do

I agree about PP. My FIL is basically Daddy Pig. Not a bad person exactly, but a bit of a self important buffoon. It makes me laugh to see him depicted so well, and often ending up with egg on his face when he's been overly confident about something he knows nothing about.

ReneBumsWombats · 09/08/2022 09:09

Also, Disney is great these days. Plenty of strong, feminist characters. Strong, black, lesbian couple in Lightyear and their daughter as a heroine. If anything, the need for positive representation and messages is overshadowing the need for strength of plots (Encanto).

TKRedLemonade · 09/08/2022 09:08

User478 · 09/08/2022 07:40

You do what you think is best with your hypothetical children.

You do what you can with your actual children.

I quite like the Wiggles.

Oh my god this!!!!! I’m using this next time my pre kids BIL makes a comment on our parenting!!!! Love it!

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 09/08/2022 09:08

Why would you want to isolate your child like that? Hmm

PepsiMaxandPringleStacks · 09/08/2022 09:07

MummyDummyNow · 09/08/2022 08:12

I remember saying "My baby will only have educational wooden toys."

There is a sea of plastic pink crap in their room.

My wooden toys have all been chucked because my second born is obsessed with being a pirate and wooden toys are so much more painful to get hit with than plastic toys Blush (we obvs had the talk no you can't hit your sister/mummy etc but tantrums do happen)

ItsDangerousInKingsmarkham · 09/08/2022 09:07

Too American? 🤦🏻‍♀️

DH is American. I wasn't aware I should be limiting my DC's exposure to him purely based on his nationality?

ReneBumsWombats · 09/08/2022 09:07

Bluey is great and Peppa Pig grows on you. It is more self aware than you think. Grampy Rabbit is voiced by Brian Blessed and Miss Rabbit is a feminist icon. There's no job she can't do.

BillyWilliamTheThird · 09/08/2022 09:07

I thought I’d be able to raise my kids without tacky Disney shit or Peppa Pig.

Then other people got involved. It only takes one bin bag full of hand me downs and a birthday party and your house is full of that crap.

itsgettingweird · 09/08/2022 09:06

Elilanna · 09/08/2022 09:03

To clarify - it wouldn't be a ban of every show. I just specifically wouldn't do Disney, Cocomelon or Wiggles, and a few others - I'd probably be able to find alternatives.

So what do you do when you visit friends houses (and meeting parents and having regular coffee mornings are generally needed for sanity!) and they have an older child or your children are older and they have this showing on TV?

Thing is as much you you plan not to at your house your child and you will go to others and eventually your child will go to friends houses without you and have a life away from your home rules.

It just can't last forever.

Beees · 09/08/2022 09:06

Elilanna · 09/08/2022 09:03

To clarify - it wouldn't be a ban of every show. I just specifically wouldn't do Disney, Cocomelon or Wiggles, and a few others - I'd probably be able to find alternatives.

It still won't work. My child is 2 and has never seen Peppa Pig and we have no Peppa Pig books or toys but he still knows who she is and includes her in his pretend play because he's seen the books at nursery and his friends talk about her.

You might choose to watch other things but it won't stop your child making up their own minds about what they like or want to watch, read or listen to.