Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's still that teeny weeny bit of a pandemic thing happening?

310 replies

IAmOldNow · 09/08/2022 00:11

Not complaining, just observing:

Figures say: cases rising, hospitalisiations rising, fatalities: flat at best but if anything that'll be thanks to large scale immunisation, largely due to vaccines that may not prevent infection altogether but are, largely, proving to be pretty good at making sure the vast majority of us don't end up on a ventilator and/or: dead!

Currenrt reality says: huge client party tonight. Cue some 3k people crammed into a mostly indoors space, free alcohol, hugging, air kissing, any old thing you'd imagine from people who, literally, know and do not actively hate each other and haven't met in the flesh for two years.

AIBU to think that this is a) human and understandable but also b) bound to see 1/3 of the organisation out cold with COVID within a week?

For the record: I don't know the right answer! I went, too!

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 09/08/2022 17:19

If only life, ethics etc. were that simple!

We do need some basis for decision making. This one has served us well on many issues.

TheKeatingFive · 09/08/2022 17:18

I honestly don’t know how to express any more clearly that I’m advocating for flexible personal choice

But I don't understand what's stopping this happening, isn't this what we have?

CEVPeopleExist · 09/08/2022 17:16

As it happened, we had like for like comparisons with countries that had a mask mandate and countries that didn't. England and Scotland for example. Or countries pre and pistasl mandates. And absolutely nothing there suggested that masks are efficacious against omicron.

  • Yep - as acknowledged above, there’s conflicting evidence, & I honestly don’t feel equipped to judge individual studies (terminology, stats, management of infinite variables, biased reporting of lies, damn lies & statistics etc. all frankly beyond my capacity).
Firstly, all of that is such a blunt tool. Surgeons wear masks for a variety of reasons, it doesn't mean that masks are efficacious against something as infectious, minuscule and wading airborne as omincron.
  • Here, again, I trust the views of the docs I know who’ve worked in operating theatres on masks v omicron. Maybe other surgeons disagree - I’ve none to ask! 😂
Secondly, none of this advice has ever come from a comprehensive cost/benefit analysis of mask wearing. And there are costs to it, even if you don't see them.
  • I honestly don’t know how to express any more clearly that I’m advocating for flexible personal choice - I’m glad mask mandates are over (my first post) & there’s no way, with things as they currently stand, that I’d argue for returning to these (as a teacher, I‘ve seen their effects!) I know, when I’m advocating a wholesale cultural shift that facilitates the individual choice to wear a mask that it’s easier to equate this to a desire for a universal mandate or an oppressive moral imperative - & it’s infinitely easier to argue against these - but neither is my intention.
Thirdly, they've got plenty wrong so far in this pandemic. See particularly fomite transmission which turned out to be infinitely less of a problem than they thought originally so all that excessive hand sanitising probably made minimal difference. Everyone here is learning as they go.
  • Another point on which we already agree. Ref. comments above re. evolving science, fallible authorities, common consensus etc.
Fourthly, most highly vaccinated countries actually don't require masks any more, except in some specific settings, so that tells it's own tale.
  • Yup, again, it does, & again, it’s a tale that, I reiterate, I agree with - an imposed requirement is a step too far because of other considerations. Again, it’s interesting that people really do seem to really struggle to separate the idea of long-term mandated or policed behaviour from that of promoting a cultural shift that is proportionately more sensitive to CEVs, with the potential for a correspondingly transformative cumulative shift in their quality of life.
If the data clearly indicated their benefit and proper cost / benefit analysis suggested that benefit was worth it, then people would have a different view I think. But neither of those things are the case.
  • If only life, ethics etc. were that simple! 😂
TheKeatingFive · 09/08/2022 16:43

I'm no scientist, but am aware that research around such things is a hugely lengthy, complex process, for a range of reasons.

As it happened, we had like for like comparisons with countries that had a mask mandate and countries that didn't. England and Scotland for example. Or countries pre and pistasl mandates. And absolutely nothing there suggested that masks are efficacious against omicron.

As such, when the NHS, CDC etc. have advocated masks across extended periods, when multiple, different governments have installed mask mandates, when surgeons wear them in operating theatres, when my family of doctors swear by them

Firstly, all of that is such a blunt tool. Surgeons wear masks for a variety of reasons, it doesn't mean that masks are efficacious against something as infectious, minuscule and wading airborne as omincron.

Secondly, none of this advice has ever come from a comprehensive cost/benefit analysis of mask wearing. And there are costs to it, even if you don't see them.

Thirdly, they've got plenty wrong so far in this pandemic. See particularly fomite transmission which turned out to be infinitely less of a problem than they thought originally so all that excessive hand sanitising probably made minimal difference. Everyone here is learning as they go.

Fourthly, most highly vaccinated countries actually don't require masks any more, except in some specific settings, so that tells it's own tale.

If the data clearly indicated their benefit and proper cost / benefit analysis suggested that benefit was worth it, then people would have a different view I think. But neither of those things are the case.

CEVPeopleExist · 09/08/2022 16:18

And round and round we go.

I won't repeat earlier arguments, you'll be glad to hear - they're there for anyone feeling able or willing to engage.

But the masks thing?! I've tried to be measured, but sometimes there really is a place for sarcasm (lowest form of wit... sorry): a range of PPs above are clearly top-rated experts in their black & white assertions re. mask efficacy.

Here's a another attempt from me to present a nuanced view. So many such views seem to be being reframed as all-or-nothing demand / ruthless indifference to others' wellbeing / reductive simplification of different individuals' circumstances etc. If this is how the following comes across, so be it, but here goes (also in response to an earlier query directly to me about evidence for masks)...

To the people saying there's no evidence - your certainty is unusual! My understanding is that the evidence base for masks is really complex.

  1. I'm no scientist, but am aware that research around such things is a hugely lengthy, complex process, for a range of reasons.
  2. As such, I've skimmed some research essays & stats - & quickly accepted my total, utter inability to penetrate these!
  3. Therefore, in this area, as in many others, I defer to those more knowledgeable than me.
  4. Goodness knows, though, I'm conscious of the fallibility & ulterior motives of multiple authorities, though, so...
  5. ...I look for the majority consensus among widely respected sources: multiple internationally renowned health agencies etc.
  6. As such, when the NHS, CDC etc. have advocated masks across extended periods, when multiple, different governments have installed mask mandates, when surgeons wear them in operating theatres, when my family of doctors swear by them...
  7. I think it's infinitely more likely that they have some effect that that they don't.

We then get to an even more complex issue, which I think people often confuse with the straightforward issue of efficacy reasoned through above. This evidence, to me, quite clearly shows that the common consensus - the best we get in many issues relating to humanity & health - can be efficacious - BUT to what degree, & how far does this justify encouraging or imposing their use? This is tricky, but here, my reasoning is...

  1. The evidence above shows they can work: they can, literally, prevent transmission to some degree. To what extent, whether or not they will for me individually etc., I can't determine - how could I possibly?!
  2. But, here, common sense steps in as well: a) I know when I talk I sometimes spray (ugh but true: we all do!), & catching this in a mask can only reduce the likelihood of my transmitting - or receiving - something! b) I know that Covid can kill that old person stuck having to use the underground daily that I'm sitting next to right now.

And that leads to the 2 simple questions I posed in my last post:

  1. Will they be safer (perhaps by a miniscule amount) if I wear a mask? Yes.
  2. Am I prepared to endure that slight discomfort for them? Most of the time, yes.

And here's another, to address some of the accusations levelled at those of us arguing for more considered testing & masking...

  1. Am I saying everyone can, & should, test & mask without exception or consideration of individual circumstances? No. Am I therefore saying everyone who doesn't is selfish? No. BUT am I saying our society's attitude as a whole could be more rational & empathetic?

Hell, yes!

GoldenOmber · 09/08/2022 15:30

My experience of the “why not wear a little paper mask for just a few minutes, it’s such a teensy easy little simple thing, it’s only during a pandemic, whyyyyy won’t you keep doing it” is:

a) it isn’t easy teensy simple for some of us;
b) it isn’t ‘just a few minutes’ for some of us;
c) it does not reduce transmission (hello from Scotland, both mask- and covid-capital of Britain for most of the past year);
d) and the people who want me to do it won’t ever reach a point when they’re happy to say okay you can stop, and I am not doing this for the rest of my life.

so: no. I’ll continue to manage not coughing and sneezing in peoples faces as I always have.

JustDanceAddict · 09/08/2022 15:20

CrossStitch87 · 09/08/2022 15:11

It started out as fear but ended up tipping into mindless cruelty

agreed. It gave a certain type of individual carte blanche to throw their weight around and try to tell people what to do.

As for roping off kids’ playparks and benches…it went far too far.

Agree. A lot of it was absolute nonsense.

x2boys · 09/08/2022 15:16

CrossStitch87 · 09/08/2022 15:11

It started out as fear but ended up tipping into mindless cruelty

agreed. It gave a certain type of individual carte blanche to throw their weight around and try to tell people what to do.

As for roping off kids’ playparks and benches…it went far too far.

Yes it seems ridiculous now roping off kids playgrounds but in the very beginning people were terrified ,and nobody quite knew how dangerous a load of kids playing together on equipment was going to be or not the scenes coming out of Italy were horrifying ,but two years on with vaccines and a lot more knowledge about covid we can only look back in hindsight .

CrossStitch87 · 09/08/2022 15:11

It started out as fear but ended up tipping into mindless cruelty

agreed. It gave a certain type of individual carte blanche to throw their weight around and try to tell people what to do.

As for roping off kids’ playparks and benches…it went far too far.

lightand · 09/08/2022 15:07

Exactly

People dont seem to see longer term any more.

CruCru · 09/08/2022 15:05

I wonder if others remember how it was in Spring 2020? All the people writing “STAY. THE FUCK. HOME” on here (and elsewhere). Derbyshire police following lone walkers with drones. A chief constable said his police would check people’s shopping trolleys to ensure that they were only buying “essentials” (what the hell for?). A friend’s father in law died (of coronavirus) and she and her family were shouted at by a passer-by for sitting outside in a group of more than six immediately after his funeral.

It started out as fear but ended up tipping into mindless cruelty.

Technically I am CEV but I am damned if I want anyone to restrict their lives to protect me (especially young people). I kept to the restrictions when they were in force but I’m not keeping to others’ made up rules. There’s no need to try to demonstrate virtuosity to near strangers.

TheKeatingFive · 09/08/2022 14:48

I was not commenting on "the whole history of lockdown", I was commenting on what is sensible to do right now, imho ‘masking in close quarters

As another poster pointed out, this is coming after two years of restrictions that many found tough. That context is important. However many people struggle with masking in any case, it's not an easy simple gesture for everyone.

Do carry on saying it’s pointless to mask. A hell of a lot of professionals seem to disagree with you

There are a huge variety of views among professionals. But where's their actual evidence that they're making any difference? Real life comparisons between countries didn't show that at all.

I didn’t say that either.

you're the one who brought up sneezing, so quite what did you kea by it.

You’d argue with a mirror I guess

Takes two to tango sunshine

ancientgran · 09/08/2022 14:44

I think money worries with the cost of living crisis is affecting people going out. Don't know what the split would be, I'm sure some is covid but probably not all.

CrossStitch87 · 09/08/2022 14:42

Google I agree. Town centres are pretty dead nowadays. I do think restrictions have made life a bit smaller for a lot of people, and I would include myself in that. I have kind of lost the notion to go out as much (and I think have maybe lost confidence a bit too). I imagine this is exacerbated in those who are still WFH full time

creekal · 09/08/2022 14:40

Do carry on saying it’s pointless to mask. A hell of a lot of professionals seem to disagree with you.

Is this a fact? Doctors wear masks because they are told to, that doesn't automatically mean they agree it's effective. I'm sure it does something but it's effectiveness is definitely disputed.

Anyway, I won't be wearing a mask forevermore even if it does work perfectly.

ancientgran · 09/08/2022 14:39

Astrabees · 09/08/2022 11:14

it really is a minor illness now. One of my friends aged 82 has just had it and got over it very quickly ( 4 x vaccinated). I can't see any reason we should not be back to normal now. Earlier this year we went on our first holiday abroad since the pandemic began and it was just so good to be able to relax without any restrictions.

I must be imagining how ill I have been for six months. Thanks for that. Or maybe it isn't a minor illness for everyone.

georgarina · 09/08/2022 14:39

swimlyn · 09/08/2022 14:25

So you don't mind receiving a sneeze in your face?

You remember back in 2019 when no one wore masks, right? Was it considered fine to sneeze in someone else's face?

swimlyn · 09/08/2022 14:37

@TheKeatingFive
No you didn't. You ridiculed someone, who's already given up a significant amount over the last two years, for not wanting to do something pointless.

I didn’t ridicule anyone. You misunderstood. I was not commenting on "the whole history of lockdown", I was commenting on what is sensible to do right now, imho ‘masking in close quarters’, and otherwise not generally masking.

Do carry on saying it’s pointless to mask. A hell of a lot of professionals seem to disagree with you.

Not wearing masks doesn't mean people are sneezing on others faces ...
I didn’t say that either.

You’d argue with a mirror I guess…

Googlecanthelpme · 09/08/2022 14:30

Well yes to a degree life is back to normal. Work events, parties, weddings etc

although a good friend works in events and they are not getting the foot fall they usually would at all. Things like beauty expos or roadshows, tradeshows etc. I dont
know how bookings are looking moving forward but friend has had to take other work because the footfall is only 1/3 of what it used to be and there’s no money (commission) to be made really.

also I find the towns very very quiet, I’ve had a couple nights out and nowhere as busy as they’d have been pre covid.
This is probably a combination of cost of living and people reassessing their life choices post covid though.

I don’t think it’s business as usual as if covid never happened, I think the differences are really clear when you scratch the surface. Although agree from a very high level view, it probably does look like it.

Twattergy · 09/08/2022 14:29

Chose if you want to go to mass events or not.
Mass events have always had capacity to drive illness rates for flu, norvirus, colds and other transmissible diseases. A number of which of which can lead to hospitalisation or death.
Covid no longer requires different management to those other diseases.
Unless death stats significantly spike or a newer deadlier version emerges.

TheKeatingFive · 09/08/2022 14:27

So you don't mind receiving a sneeze in your face

Not wearing masks doesn't mean people are sneezing on others faces ...

Sartre · 09/08/2022 14:25

It’s still around but it’s in its endemic stage now which just means it’s a virus we have to live alongside like any other virus. It will kill people every year, just as the flu does and the most vulnerable will receive a vaccine alongside their flu vaccine but it isn’t something we all need to hide away from anymore. It was never massively dangerous to most people, it’s fatal to a small percentage again, just as the flu is. We don’t shut up shop every autumn/winter due to flu and can’t for covid. I’ve had covid three times now and I’ve had much worse colds.

swimlyn · 09/08/2022 14:25

So you don't mind receiving a sneeze in your face?

TheKeatingFive · 09/08/2022 14:24

I don’t get what you mean here. I treat people with the fullest respect.

No you didn't. You ridiculed someone, who's already given up a significant amount over the last two years, for not wanting to do something pointless.

if you can't see the impact that has, that's your issue

TheKeatingFive · 09/08/2022 14:22

A light paper mask hugely restricts the transmission of airborne snot etc. Surely that’s obvious.

That doesn't mean it's effective against omicron. Omicron doesn't need snot to spread. Just tiny air particles which aren't contained by masks.