Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's still that teeny weeny bit of a pandemic thing happening?

310 replies

IAmOldNow · 09/08/2022 00:11

Not complaining, just observing:

Figures say: cases rising, hospitalisiations rising, fatalities: flat at best but if anything that'll be thanks to large scale immunisation, largely due to vaccines that may not prevent infection altogether but are, largely, proving to be pretty good at making sure the vast majority of us don't end up on a ventilator and/or: dead!

Currenrt reality says: huge client party tonight. Cue some 3k people crammed into a mostly indoors space, free alcohol, hugging, air kissing, any old thing you'd imagine from people who, literally, know and do not actively hate each other and haven't met in the flesh for two years.

AIBU to think that this is a) human and understandable but also b) bound to see 1/3 of the organisation out cold with COVID within a week?

For the record: I don't know the right answer! I went, too!

OP posts:
CEVPeopleExist · 09/08/2022 18:11

Ok, one more thing, as I want to try to be considered right to the end: not all responses above are like this (eg. the one re. neurodiversity a really good point I’m conscious of as a teacher) but there’s such a general inability/unwillingness to acknowledge nuance, like an earlier poster highlighted, with the endless strawmanning of more nuanced points.

Proper-bye now.

BeanCounterBabe · 09/08/2022 18:08

CEVPeopleExist

why is wanting to go back to pre pandemic behaviour more selfish than you insisting we all carry on with uncomfortable and inconvenient measures?

SushiShopSearch · 09/08/2022 18:05

It's not a tiny bit of a pandemic. We are still in a pandemic.

CEVPeopleExist · 09/08/2022 18:00

My above a response to KeatingFive - thanks for engaging.

With the other posts since diving straight back into the usual bingocard of hysterical references to „autocracy“, „everyone“, „impositions“, „unpleasant“ & the evidently malicious, self-promoting motivations of people sharing my view(!), I think you’ll see why I don’t think the balance is quite right yet, or the UK entirely rational or empathetic in debate about this.

I know I can come across as smug myself - sorry; I never mean to, & am working on this! - but, really, some of these responses reflect such a lack of critical thought & empathy, it makes me despair for us.

No point saying more. Thoughtful disagreement‘s fun, furious hyperbole not so much. Nuffin more to say (you’ll be pleased to hear!)

Enjoy the weather over there.

PeloAddict · 09/08/2022 18:00

I just try to protect myself
So FFP2 masks if I'm somewhere out
People test before coming into my house (I have tests so can supply them)

BeanCounterBabe · 09/08/2022 17:58

If wearing masks was easy and no inconvenience more people would wear them. I find them extremely uncomfortable and a barrier to communication. In my case I suspect undiagnosed ASD. I have to wear them round the office at work (NHS). Luckily not while sitting at desks. I usually find people who think it is easy to wear a mask only wear them for short errands, not all day. If mask wearing becomes compulsory again it will hit the economy as people reduce shopping and leisure. I will reduce these activities myself if forced to start wearing masks again.

Call me selfish if you like but I have done my bit. Worked my arse off in a role directly affected by CoViD while trying to manage two DC including one with ASD, participated in a vaccine trial, spent two years on the SIREN trial having PCR and blood tests every couple of weeks, followed all the rules, including the stupid ones. Clearly not enough for some people though.

FromEden · 09/08/2022 17:57

I went to loads of events with tens of thousands of people, totally unvaccinated and never caught covid. What finally did me in was dd catching it at school and infecting me. Mild cold and done. Lock yourself down all you want but most people are over it.

IcedPurple · 09/08/2022 17:55

ApplesandBunions · 09/08/2022 17:54

I actually respect the honesty there, although admittedly it's somewhat undermined by the next few sentences of faith based claims about the utility of restrictions that have mostly already failed.

The poster sounds suspiciously similar to another poster who didn't think evidence were needed to support their claims.

As I said above, quite a few MNers are nostalgic for lockdown and miss all the drama and feeling superior to others for the 'selfish' behaviour of meeting with family every so often.

TheKeatingFive · 09/08/2022 17:54

is that the Zoom weddings person back again?

Thankfully no. They delighted us long enough 😆

ApplesandBunions · 09/08/2022 17:54

IcedPurple · 09/08/2022 17:49

Lockdowns are the best idea

FFS.

Lock yourself down all you like. The world (outside of China) has long since moved on.

I actually respect the honesty there, although admittedly it's somewhat undermined by the next few sentences of faith based claims about the utility of restrictions that have mostly already failed.

IcedPurple · 09/08/2022 17:53

GoldenOmber · 09/08/2022 17:51

is that the Zoom weddings person back again?

I wonder if they've given up on the 'look East' mantra since it all went tits up over there?

CrossStitch87 · 09/08/2022 17:53

Nonsense, I don't remember being consulted about the NI rise, or inflation, or fuel prices. Government can do what they like, our only power is that we get to boot them out after five years

its different when its something that affects your physical person though. Or it should be, in my view.

swimlyn · 09/08/2022 17:52

When people talk about 'sensible light touch restrictions' what they really mean is restrictions which don't restrict them.

What a daft generalisation. Simply. Not. True.

IcedPurple · 09/08/2022 17:52

I honestly don’t think we do have it. Living somewhere that I think has come closer to what I’d call a good balance - it has the same absence of restrictions, but very different collective attitudes to individually taking precautions to protect the vulnerable - the difference with the UK is distressingly stark.

Where are you living?

Is the difference 'distressingly stark' in terms of infection rates?

I'm sure you'll do the usual coy MN thing and not tell us the name of this wondrous country where you reside, but it would be genuinely interesting to know how this unnamed country has achieved much lower infection rates despite an absence of restrictions. Pretty much everywhere outside China has abandoned most if not all restrictions. Even Oz and NZ are pretty much back to normal.

GoldenOmber · 09/08/2022 17:51

is that the Zoom weddings person back again?

TheKeatingFive · 09/08/2022 17:49

limits to the number of people who can gather for social events and a return to limited numbers of people in shops at one time are easy wins

They aren't easy wins for those who depend on businesses operating to capacity for their livelihood, no.

IcedPurple · 09/08/2022 17:49

Lockdowns are the best idea

FFS.

Lock yourself down all you like. The world (outside of China) has long since moved on.

CEVPeopleExist · 09/08/2022 17:49

I honestly don’t think we do have it. Living somewhere that I think has come closer to what I’d call a good balance - it has the same absence of restrictions, but very different collective attitudes to individually taking precautions to protect the vulnerable - the difference with the UK is distressingly stark.

When I go to the UK & no longer need to explain to perfectly lovely friends that some people genuinely are still shielding, or stand next to a large sign on an NHS surgery door requesting people mask up if possible to protect vulnerable patients only to watch 100% stride happily maskless into the enclosed waiting room my parent has to sit in - then, I may think we’re closer to what I see here.

I’ll especially know we’ve made it when chats like this one don’t lead to so many cries of hyperbolic woe that people with my views are seeking to impose „misery forever“, but a more nuanced response (whether that response is in agreement or disagreement) & some sympathy to the people still enduring very real risks to life every single time they go out - & the people who care for & about them.

Things as simple as more honest government messaging & reporting re. CEVs, if only by just giving them the respect & column-space far more fashionable causes currently enjoy, could shift individual behaviours etc. to really transform these people‘s lives.

I wanted to give some numbers then, but couldn’t - doesn’t it say something about our attitude of collective denial that there are no figures, to the best of my knowledge, about how many people are living this way, besides those being shouted into the vacuum by minority charities?

TheKeatingFive · 09/08/2022 17:47

If they did nothing, why would they bother?

We do lots of things for unevidenced reasons. Optics, to make statements, as a comfort. And yes I see why all of those could be important in hospitals. Equally they may be more effective against the transmission of other things that aren't covid.

If we had just a little less virus circulating it would make a big difference overall.

I think we need to get used to the reality, it comes in waves. We might be able to flatten a wave very slightly, but ultimately it makes little difference, the wave will just last longer.

It's been notable that this wave has been very effective in hunting down those who haven't had it before. It seems you can run but not hide here.

Dotjones · 09/08/2022 17:46

CrossStitch87 · 09/08/2022 17:39

You can’t just impose stuff on the population on a long term/permanent basis without consultation and conclusive evidence that there is a point in doing so.

Different in the middle of an emergency situation such as an active pandemic (and even some of those decisions were ropey in the circumstances) but we are no longer in an emergency situation.

Nonsense, I don't remember being consulted about the NI rise, or inflation, or fuel prices. Government can do what they like, our only power is that we get to boot them out after five years.

With Covid, we're in for a very difficult autumn and winter. At the moment conditions are as in our favour as much as they will get - lots of sunshine, warm so windows open, people socialising outdoors etc. When it gets cooler, Covid will start ripping through society and I fear deaths will rocket.

What people have shown is that, left to manage Covid themselves, they won't act responsibly. Lockdowns are the best idea, but WFH were possible, mandatory mask wearing indoors and on public transport, limits to the number of people who can gather for social events and a return to limited numbers of people in shops at one time are easy wins that will make the difference between life and death for tens of thousands this winter.

But CoViDz OvEr innit.

CrossStitch87 · 09/08/2022 17:39

You can’t just impose stuff on the population on a long term/permanent basis without consultation and conclusive evidence that there is a point in doing so.

Different in the middle of an emergency situation such as an active pandemic (and even some of those decisions were ropey in the circumstances) but we are no longer in an emergency situation.

IcedPurple · 09/08/2022 17:38

GoldenOmber · 09/08/2022 10:16

I'm always amazed by how few humans seem to be able to operate in a grey area of nuance. It doesn't have to be 'everything as it was in 2019' or 'lockdown'. There is a middle ground

There isn’t ‘a’ middle ground, though. There is a huge huge range of potential middle grounds. We are already in one - the culture of some people wearing masks in shops, or of wedding guests being asked to take tests they can buy from Boots to make sure they’re not asymptomatic carriers of a particular virus, that isn’t back to 2019.

You want a specific middle ground which trades off the things you want to keep against the restrictions you don’t mind having. Which is fine for you, but it isn’t like your preferences are some objectively most sensible thing to do. To some people your preferences will look like not enough, to some it’ll look too much.

And people will use their own likes and dislikes and their own circumstances to decide what they think is ‘sensible’, without seeing how it falls on everyone else. (Personally, as someone who relies on public transport, I get a bit fed up of people saying “ah yes OBVIOUSLY we should keep masks on public transport” when they drive everywhere and wouldn’t be affected - same as how “we need masks in shops, it’s not HARD” sounds different if you’re just popping in for 15 minutes to if you’re doing a 9-hour shift there as an employee. Or “better ventilation!” can sound less like an easy win when your business would have to pay to have it installed at a time of rising costs everywhere when you’re struggling to keep afloat, or pay for ongoing electricity costs of running air purifiers when power costs are going through the roof.)

So it’s not that nobody wants nuance. It’s that people have, reasonably enough, different starting positions and therefore ideas about what nuance looks like.

Excellent post. I agree completely.

When people talk about 'sensible light touch restrictions' what they really mean is restrictions which don't restrict them. Same as how people are 'selfish' for doing things they don't want to do. It's been that way throughout the pandemic.

Let's face it, quite a few people, a disproportionate number of them on MN, didn't find lockdown all that troublesome and are nostalgic for aspects of it.

IcedPurple · 09/08/2022 17:34

Just a little bit of consideration for others? A light paper mask for a few minutes when in close quarters? Far too much to ask obviously…

Unless you can provide good evidence that a 'light paper mask' will have significant effects on reducing transmission, then yes, it is far too much to ask.

And where did you get a 'few minutes' from? If you include public transport as 'close quarters' then that would be an hour a day for me. And longer for many others.

So yes, if you're going to ask people to do something unpleasant - and wearing a mask, even a 'light paper' one is unpleasant for many of us - then you need to be able to show why you are asking this of them. Making passive aggressive posts about others doesn't cut it.

blahblahblahspoons · 09/08/2022 17:31

One thing that is interesting is that all medical settings of any kind near me still have masks.Doctors, hospitals, dentists, opticians. If they did nothing, why would they bother?

They clearly do a lot. Not just against covid. If you want to get treated when you have a heart attack it's beneficial to have less viruses circulating and taking out the available (dwindling) medical staff.

I have a friend whose operation has been cancelled 3x due to lack of staff - mostly down to covid. If we had just a little less virus circulating it would make a big difference overall.

FelixFlower · 09/08/2022 17:29

The autocratic personalities are longing for winter so that they can tell everyone how feckless and selfish they are for daring to live self-determined, fun and fulfilling lives🤓

Swipe left for the next trending thread