Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our mother knows more about our fathers than she let's on

93 replies

Whoarewe00 · 08/08/2022 22:03

NC.

I grew up in a single parent family. My mother (who is extraordinarily selfish) only ever gave vague details about my father and claimed to not know where he lived, what he did for a living, what other family he had. Whenever I mentioned wanting to know about him she'd get frustrated with me and say he was "cunning and crafty" and she doesn't know anything to tell me so I need to drop it.

When I was in my 20's I discovered, by complete chance, that I have an older brother who was given up for adoption at birth.

He, like me, wanted to know who his father was but our mother claimed she doesn't know anything about him and can't even remember his name. We know we don't share the same father as me and our mother are Caucasian but my brother is not.

At first she said she met his father when she was working at a certain place, then later changed her story completely as though she'd forgotten what she'd said, as she then said he worked somewhere completely different.

AIBU to think she is deliberately withholding information she must have, from the pair of us?

How realistic do you think it is that she got pregnant to two completely different men she knew nothing about?

OP posts:
GlitteryGreen · 09/08/2022 13:08

Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 12:23

He was linked to a distant second (i think) cousin.

He made contact with her and she couldn't be of any help. She'd never heard of our mother and couldn't assist at all.

There was nobody else.

I dont recognise her family name and we wouldn't get anything from mum.

I'd assume that this 2nd cousin is from your brother's dad's side though....I wouldn't expect anyone on his side to be familiar with your mum or know her name.

It could easily be that your mum became pregnant from a short relationship/one night stand and never told the dad, so his family wouldn't necessarily know anything about her. Or even if she did tell him and he wasn't interested, he still likely wouldn't share her details with his family.

I'd get your brother to go back to this person and ask if they know of any men in their family of around X age, who might have links to the relevant area, and whether they could maybe ask their own parents or other older relatives just in case. It's definitely worth a try.

Also I'd tell your mum you're going to apply to Long Lost Family...might nudge her into giving you at least some information to try and stop you doing that.

balalake · 09/08/2022 12:56

Quite possible that it is two different fathers, agree there may be something you'd perhaps rather not know, but ultimately it should be information you have, to decide if you want to meet your father if he is contactable and alive.

Possibly the evasiveness could be out of shame, especially if the rest of your mother's family were hostile or condemning towards her.

MatildaTheCat · 09/08/2022 12:55

From what you say it sounds as if your mother has come from some kind of background of abuse. It’s entirely possible that she is blanking out the details and may believe what she is saying or it may be true. Babies born of incest are often brought up within that family.

I once met a woman who apparently lived a pretty straight life but would occasionally go on a massive binge and at least twice (quite likely more) became pregnant and had those babies adopted. That was around the millennium I think. She very likely didn’t know who the father was.

Your mother sounds very troubled and won’t give you what you want and need. I’m glad you have a brother for support, even if you discover nothing else you have him.

Livpool · 09/08/2022 12:47

Bobbimagee · 09/08/2022 00:59

I disagree with some pp and actually think it's not your mother's secret to keep. He's your father and you have a right to know who he is. She must have realised you'd want to know at some point. I would do your DNA on ancestry and look that way.

I agree with this.

My maternal grandmother died with my mum was a toddler. She knows her name and that is pretty much it - never even seen a photograph.

It is heartbreaking

WinnysPinny · 09/08/2022 12:45

As hard as it is perhaps she doesn’t want to be reminded of the past. For whatever the reasons were that the relationships didn’t last it could be just too personal for her to say

Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 12:43

TokyoTen · 09/08/2022 12:34

Apologies, I haven't read your full thread - but have you looked at your birth certificate and your brother's birth certificate? Apologies if you have, I couldn't see it mentioned from what I read. If it's blank then obviously it doesn't help, but it may give you a name.

There is no father listed on my birth certificate unfortunately. My brother doesn't have a birth certificate just an adoption certificate.

The adoption agency weren't given any details about his father, simply told that he wasn't interested.

I had social services involvement when I was a child so I'm going to do a freedom of information request to see if there is anything held on file about my father or my brothers adoption.

OP posts:
SuperPets · 09/08/2022 12:42

TokyoTen · 09/08/2022 12:34

Apologies, I haven't read your full thread - but have you looked at your birth certificate and your brother's birth certificate? Apologies if you have, I couldn't see it mentioned from what I read. If it's blank then obviously it doesn't help, but it may give you a name.

I'm sure it's never occurred to Op to look for her fathers name on her birth certificate, under "fathers name".

🙄

TokyoTen · 09/08/2022 12:34

Apologies, I haven't read your full thread - but have you looked at your birth certificate and your brother's birth certificate? Apologies if you have, I couldn't see it mentioned from what I read. If it's blank then obviously it doesn't help, but it may give you a name.

alloutofcareunits · 09/08/2022 12:26

@Whoarewe00 hopefully it isn't the case and you and your brother find out who your father/fathers are. Good luck in your continued search

Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 12:24

alloutofcareunits · 09/08/2022 12:10

Be prepared that you might find information that is unexpected, it's possible your father was a family member E.g. uncle, grandparent. I've came across this before in my line of work. This could be why your mother is being so vague, possibly conceived from sexual abuse/rape

I hate to say this but the thought had crossed my mind once or twice. When you have such little information and that information poses more questions than it does answers you have to consider everything. Even things like that 🙁

OP posts:
Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 12:23

SurpriseSurprise · 09/08/2022 12:03

Has your brother had any DNA matches on ancestry so far? Any cousins or anything?

He was linked to a distant second (i think) cousin.

He made contact with her and she couldn't be of any help. She'd never heard of our mother and couldn't assist at all.

There was nobody else.

I dont recognise her family name and we wouldn't get anything from mum.

OP posts:
alloutofcareunits · 09/08/2022 12:10

Be prepared that you might find information that is unexpected, it's possible your father was a family member E.g. uncle, grandparent. I've came across this before in my line of work. This could be why your mother is being so vague, possibly conceived from sexual abuse/rape

SurpriseSurprise · 09/08/2022 12:03

Has your brother had any DNA matches on ancestry so far? Any cousins or anything?

Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 11:51

I forgot to add - he said he doesn't actually have a birth certificate. Just an adoption certificate.

OP posts:
Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 11:50

BigFatLiar · 09/08/2022 10:32

If the father wasn't named how did they know who he was? It could be he wasn't interested as he didn't know he had a child until he was contacted. Or perhaps she simply told them he wasn't interested.

It's worth going on but do remember that when you contact others it may be a shock for them.

So he wasn't named but the information given about him was simply that he wasn't interested.

So therefore mum must have said he did know about the pregnancy and wanted no part in it.

My brother said it was agreed that he'd be put up for adoption before he was even born, that much was ascertained from the notes the adoption support worker had access to.

OP posts:
SuperPets · 09/08/2022 11:39

TheDangerOfIgnorance · 08/08/2022 23:04

I would suggest your brother access the website of the local authority where he lives (not where he was born) and look for the email address for post adoption support. He needs to ask for the Access To Information service. This may take a few months but his file will be pulled from archive and a copy sent to his own local authority where a summary will be made and given to him. He will be able to find out his birth father information from there and other pre adoption details. He also needs to apply to the GRO General Registry Office, a Gov site for his original birth certificate. That may also name his father. th ATI information could reveal secrets about your mother too. Since 1975 children are rarely relinquished, most are removed for other reasons. Talk it through with him and he needs to cite you as his support when he has his pre ATI interview.

He won't get any details about his father as his mother didn't tell them anything about him!

LadyEloise1 · 09/08/2022 11:33

When DH's father was told by dh's mother she was pregnant, he offered a £5 / a £10 ( disputed ) and ran for the hills.

It was a short relationship.

BigFatLiar · 09/08/2022 10:32

If the father wasn't named how did they know who he was? It could be he wasn't interested as he didn't know he had a child until he was contacted. Or perhaps she simply told them he wasn't interested.

It's worth going on but do remember that when you contact others it may be a shock for them.

knittingaddict · 09/08/2022 10:16

Whoarewe00 · 08/08/2022 22:43

Yes she said that we have completely different dad's.

I haven't done a DNA tests but my brother did ancestry DNA a few years back we and he knows he is 50% (ish) of Indian heritage and what region of India his paternal ancestors hail from, which ties in loosely with the limited information she gave him about his father, which was that he was an Indian man what worked at two completely different places 🤔

It never occurred to us to do a DNA to check whether we were full siblings as we look so different and were born in completely different places. I may ask him if he'd like to do it.

You just need to do a dna test too and compare results. He won't need to do his again. Put yours on Ancestry and see if you are a match.

Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 10:11

Thanks for all of your replies and suggestions! I have PM'd the poster who has experience with this type of thing / tracing.

My brother said he's happy to do a DNA test to see if we're full siblings, he was intrigued as he'd never considered that we would be but now can't rule it out. I've told him about the information access request (copy and pasted that posters advice - thank you!) and he's going to look into it.

I can now see that as he's already done an ancestry DNA it's only me who needs to do one.

As it stands the only information given to him from post adoption support was extremely vague but states that father wasn't named and he's not interested. That's pretty much what I was told about my father too.

Something of interest we want to look into is how it appears that our grandparents moved our mother across country when she was pregnant with him. His post adoption support contact felt there may have been some attempt to hide the fact mum was pregnant with a mixed race baby. It may be that there was a stigma at the time, unmarried white woman gets pregnant by a 'brown' man but I can't think who my grandparents would want to hide it from? They were quite isolated people, not part of any religious community or friendship group - which would make it difficult to return to any particular area and ask around iykwim?

..and it still doesn't explain the secrecy surrounding my father.

We were chatting about it all into the small hours and we're both equally confused and feel that there's alot more to our stories than was let on.

There is alot of dysfunction on our mothers side with all but one of 6 siblings having either mental health or substance abuse issues.

OP posts:
ThatshallotBaby · 09/08/2022 10:10

I feel for you. Secrets cost. The effects they have can shape people’s choices and lives.
Keep going. It’s great that you’ve found your brother, that is the true gift of this situation. You may never know, but to reach acceptance i think you both need to feel you’ve done everything you can to find out. Stick together. Nobody can take your sibling relationship away now.
Wishing you all the very bestFlowers

autumnboys · 09/08/2022 10:03

My sister and I used Ancestry DNA to trace our biological grandad. We didn’t have a name, my Dad had been adopted and when he traced his biological mum, she too would not/could not give a name, although she gave some details, which helped us a bit later on.

As others have said, it will tell you if you and your brother are full or half siblings. Good luck!

SleeplessInEngland · 09/08/2022 09:55

I know someone else in this situation. The mother took it to their grave (pretty much ruining their relationship with the daughter in the process) but I think the daughter found out who her dad was anyway through a DNA site afterwards. So I would try that first.

LadyEloise1 · 09/08/2022 09:50

Ancestry DNA should help.
It helped my DH clarify that the man who he thought was his father, actually was. It took time though.
He had messaged someone who came up on Ancestry but they never replied. If they had it would have saved him almost 2 years of wondering if what he had been told was true. His mother had died.
Thankfully someone else joined Ancestry, almost 2 years later who was a close match to his father and was also related to the woman who never replied to his enquiry.

Dalint · 09/08/2022 09:20

newbiename · 09/08/2022 09:04

Census records are not released for 100 years

Really? That is something I never knew! Jeez, why is that?

Swipe left for the next trending thread