Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our mother knows more about our fathers than she let's on

93 replies

Whoarewe00 · 08/08/2022 22:03

NC.

I grew up in a single parent family. My mother (who is extraordinarily selfish) only ever gave vague details about my father and claimed to not know where he lived, what he did for a living, what other family he had. Whenever I mentioned wanting to know about him she'd get frustrated with me and say he was "cunning and crafty" and she doesn't know anything to tell me so I need to drop it.

When I was in my 20's I discovered, by complete chance, that I have an older brother who was given up for adoption at birth.

He, like me, wanted to know who his father was but our mother claimed she doesn't know anything about him and can't even remember his name. We know we don't share the same father as me and our mother are Caucasian but my brother is not.

At first she said she met his father when she was working at a certain place, then later changed her story completely as though she'd forgotten what she'd said, as she then said he worked somewhere completely different.

AIBU to think she is deliberately withholding information she must have, from the pair of us?

How realistic do you think it is that she got pregnant to two completely different men she knew nothing about?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LatteLady · 10/08/2022 09:45

We have a similar issue in our family, one of my DM's sisters had two children "out of wedlock" in 1950s Ireland, Aunty B told her son who his father was but would never tell her daughter. My granny was progressive back then and just added the children to her own brood, which was akin to my father's experience as he found out when he was a teenager that his eldest sister was in fact his mother, it affected him for all of his life and marred his relationship with his own children.

As a group of cousins, we concurred that she probably did not know as she was quite wild growing up. My mother as the eldest, would often get a message from my granny to go and look for her and bring her home.

I know that this has been very challenging for my cousin over the years, but she does have a very big family (her DM was one of 12) who support her, yet I can understand her longing to know.

Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 23:01

I've spent some time on ancestry this evening updating my tree and reviewing some hints. I'm definitely going to take the DNA test. There is a lady on the previous page who is going to help me to unpick it all once I have the results.

My brother dug out his old adoption file today to see whether he'd missed anything, there's definitely no mention of his father's identity but something that did come up was that our mother had a termination in 1973 or thereabouts.

We think, as it looks that way, that mum was put under pressure by our grandparents (likely our grandfather) to have my brother adopted as soon as he was born and they relocated her during her pregnancy to keep it a secret from other relatives.

We've gone over some other stuff about the family that shows our mother was controlled quite alot.

So I'm now wondering whether she was strong armed into the termination aswell as whenever the topic of terminations came up, which it has over the years, she expressed being against it.

I feel that I'm probably only here where I am because she finally stood up for herself and said enough is enough.

I'm feeling quite sad for our mother tonight. It's no wonder she has her issues.

We're still wanting to know where we came from but I'm not going to push anything with her, she has suffered enough.

OP posts:
GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 09/08/2022 21:59

Have you tried asking on those local Facebook groups for people who knew your mother, rather than your possible father? How old was she when she had your brother? It sounds like her parents upped sticks to avoid judgement of an unmarried daughter being pregnant.

It's possible either her old friends / neighbours / acquaintances remember her being close to someone around the relevant time.

Isabelle70 · 09/08/2022 21:32

I would certainly do the Ancestry DNA test. I did the test that my late mum had bought and never got round to using. Turns out a lady I had worked with for 15 years was a second cousin!
I am also classed as an adopted child but my late mum was my actual birth mother. Back in 1974 when she married my step dad, in order for him to adopt me I was put up for adoption they adopted me as a married couple! I only have a adoption certificate.
Reminds me to go and see if I have any more relatives ……

RitaFires · 09/08/2022 21:18

I think your mother has deliberately given you a false name because she doesn't want you to find out who your father is. So I would discount using anything she tells you to search.

Would there be any family friends that might know something that you could reach out to?

Doing an ancestry DNA test is probably your best bet of finding out anything.

QuebecBagnet · 09/08/2022 21:10

Definitely think joining “local “ fb groups to where your mum used to live and posting any names you’ve been given of a potential father is the way to go.

years ago there was a similar thread on here an the poster had been trying to trace her dad for years after not seeing him since she was a toddler. She mentioned the area which was very close to me and I helped suggest some Facebook grouos/pages, she’d found him 12 hours later. She did have a definite name though.

QuebecBagnet · 09/08/2022 21:06

SuperPets · 09/08/2022 13:38

I think her brother being Indian while she isn't is more conclusive to the 2 fathers notion than geography or timing

I knew two full brothers who were mixed race, Caucasian dad and Indian mum. Older brother looked very Caucasian and younger one looked very Indian.

pawkins · 09/08/2022 20:53

OP your grandparents would have moved away to hide the shame of their unmarried daughter being pregnant. From the neighbours and locals probably. I know someone who had a baby out of wedlock who was born in the early 1990s who was sent away so the neighbours wouldn’t know. After the baby was born, she was immediately put up for adoption. It sounds incredible now but I imagine it still happens to this day.

Is your brother older or younger ? Your grandparents would likely not have been supportive of your mother and two ‘scandalous’ pregnancies.

Have you returned to where your mother lived at the time? Do you look like her? If you ask around to find somebody involved in the local community eg church warden - you may be able to find out some information?

I watched an episode of LLF recently where the mother had two children outside marriage. She then married, converted faith and had another family. It didn’t appear to end well. The children who were searching for her found her but she seemed disinterested and perhaps not in her right mind. At the end of the programme they still hadn’t visited her. But they found each other and were happy that way at least.

MRex · 09/08/2022 20:51

SuperPets · 09/08/2022 20:32

Nothing alike, sure, but people who are half indian generally look it!

Not always, no. I even know a blonde haired green eyed half Indian, and vice versa a pale Indian mum who had a very dark skinned.son.

Good luck with the search OP, I hope you both have success whatever you find. It could be worthwhile for your brother to look up possible school friends from her original area, they may have stayed in touch until she moved. The second cousin may also be able to help if she knows anyone in the family who lived in that town, it really depends how big her family is whether that's possible or not. For you the DNA test seems like a logical next step.

BEAM123 · 09/08/2022 20:45

Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 11:51

I forgot to add - he said he doesn't actually have a birth certificate. Just an adoption certificate.

There will be a birth certificate somewhere, and he could get a copy of it from the GRO /via post adoption support However if your mother never named the father, that info won't be on there. But there will be an address of where he was born etc and it's possible they may still have records (though again, if your mother's lips were sealed there may still be nothing on the father )

SuperPets · 09/08/2022 20:33

Dalint · 09/08/2022 09:20

Really? That is something I never knew! Jeez, why is that?

Because you aren't supposed to be able to have all that info on living people.

SuperPets · 09/08/2022 20:32

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 09/08/2022 17:11

Not necessarily.

Lots of full siblings look absolutely nothing alike.

Nothing alike, sure, but people who are half indian generally look it!

bellac11 · 09/08/2022 20:26

Dalint · 09/08/2022 08:59

There are other ways too of finding some information such as by looking at censuses from your very early years to see whether your mother may have been living with someone at the time of your birth (or 9 months before lol).

Lol - how old do you think OP is!!!!

The most recent census published is 1921

bowchicawowwow · 09/08/2022 20:07

Ancestry DNA is absolutely the way ahead I think. You can also upload the ancestry dna results to other genealogy platforms such as 23andMe to get a wider database to draw on

If you join some of the DNA detective Facebook groups there are lots of people who are willing to help untangle your results and they are very aware that it doesn't always end in happy family reunions.

Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 18:33

I've done a few things over the years to look for my father.

I called every local person in the yellow pages with the name I was given. I posted on a couple of Facebook groups related to the area. I put something on a site for people searching for family members which comes up at the top of Google results when you type in my name. I sent messages to people on Facebook with the name I was given.

Back when I had a better relationship with our mum I showed her a few of these people's Facebook profile pictures and asked could this person or that person be him. She said "yeah it might be" about two completely different people.

One of the men I came across never replied to my message (the rest did) so I, perhaps selfishly, sent a message to his brother (linked on his profile) and asked whether his brother might be the person I was looking for. It turned out that the man who didn't respond had actually died, unbeknownst to me, and then his poor family were getting messages like that.

His brother was very kind about it all and managed to eliminate him from the pool of possibilities.

Our mum will never understand the problems something like this can cause, not only to us but to other people who get caught up in the cross fire as we go searching with such limited information.

OP posts:
LadyEloise1 · 09/08/2022 18:18

@Whoarewe00
I think the 2nd cousin your brother matched with is on his Dad's side so no surprise she didn't know of your mother.
He should investigate this match further as it may lead to his father.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/08/2022 17:48

GlitteryGreen · 09/08/2022 13:36

Yeah see this would say 2 different fathers to me, although no harm in checking via the DNA thing. Plus if you upload yours you might get some matches for yourself as well.

Another thing you could try - although it is a bit public - is if you know the town/area your mum lived in when you were born, you could try joining a local fb page and asking if anybody knows/remembers her? People often post looking for news of old neighbours etc on my local page, and one person actually posted looking for their dad who they had never met. They had a name though so might be a next-stage thing for you. Worth a shot :)

It's also very useful for tracking down people who have fled domestic abuse or other very real threats.

Which is why it's a shitty thing to do.

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 09/08/2022 17:11

SuperPets · 09/08/2022 13:38

I think her brother being Indian while she isn't is more conclusive to the 2 fathers notion than geography or timing

Not necessarily.

Lots of full siblings look absolutely nothing alike.

BigFatLiar · 09/08/2022 16:34

My brother doesn't have a birth certificate just an adoption certificate.

He should have a birth certificate, if he knows where and when he was born he should be able to obtain a copy.

GlitteryGreen · 09/08/2022 13:43

SuperPets · 09/08/2022 13:38

I think her brother being Indian while she isn't is more conclusive to the 2 fathers notion than geography or timing

Well yeah, me too😂 But as others have said, you can't always know ethnicity by appearances alone and if OP has never explored her own DNA heritage then anything is possible really.

SuperPets · 09/08/2022 13:38

I think her brother being Indian while she isn't is more conclusive to the 2 fathers notion than geography or timing

GlitteryGreen · 09/08/2022 13:36

Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 13:18

I was born in 1994, my brother was born in 1986. There is 8 years between us.

I'll change places for the sake of anonymity but our mother lived in, let's say Manchester, for the sake of the thread - all of her life until she was pregnant with my brother. She then moved to Yorkshire* when she was pregnant with him and gave birth to him there. I was then born in Yorkshire 8 years later.

Yeah see this would say 2 different fathers to me, although no harm in checking via the DNA thing. Plus if you upload yours you might get some matches for yourself as well.

Another thing you could try - although it is a bit public - is if you know the town/area your mum lived in when you were born, you could try joining a local fb page and asking if anybody knows/remembers her? People often post looking for news of old neighbours etc on my local page, and one person actually posted looking for their dad who they had never met. They had a name though so might be a next-stage thing for you. Worth a shot :)

WireSkills · 09/08/2022 13:24

A friend of mine knew she was adopted within her family. She knew she also had a younger half sibling who was also adopted within the family.

She knew who her supposed father was but he also wasn't in the picture when she grew up but they knew of each other and would see each other occasionally. As she was adopted within the family she thought she knew the whole story about her family, so didn't really think anything of it when someone bought her and her husband Ancestry DNA kits for Christmas (from her husband's side of the family).

She did the test, sent it off, got the results back (100% Irish, not unexpected!), got linked to her half sibling and a few other relatives - no surprises there.

About 18 months later she got a notification of another familial match. This was shortly followed by an email from the guy who had matched with her. The email she'd received had said "likely first cousin".

Turns out it wasn't a first cousin. It was another half sibling that neither her or any of the family knew about and he was the youngest of the three of them. One family member remembered hearing a rumour of another baby, but nothing was ever known for certain. He had been given up for adoption to the system instead.

Do an Ancestry test @Whoarewe00 - even if you can't find your father, he may very well have gone on to have another family. It may be unexpected or surprising for that family to find out about you, but there's a chance that even your own father knew nothing of you.

I'm sure you're Mum isn't fibbing when she says she has no contact details for him as many years will have passed, but I would say it's very unlikely that she knows nothing about them (unless she was particularly promiscuous and had some one night stands!). It is a shame that she can't or won't talk to you about it.

Perhaps tell her that you're going to do a test, to give her one final opportunity to say something, just in case she's really not told you for a reason (if he was violent, for example).

Good luck

Whoarewe00 · 09/08/2022 13:18

I was born in 1994, my brother was born in 1986. There is 8 years between us.

I'll change places for the sake of anonymity but our mother lived in, let's say Manchester, for the sake of the thread - all of her life until she was pregnant with my brother. She then moved to Yorkshire* when she was pregnant with him and gave birth to him there. I was then born in Yorkshire 8 years later.

OP posts:
GlitteryGreen · 09/08/2022 13:11

Also, what is the age difference between you and your brother? If it's a good few years I'd definitely expect it to be 2 different dads as otherwise it would have needed to be a longer term relationship and someone in your mum's life would have likely known her to be with this man, even if it was an affair etc.