Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Britain is pretty backwards with breastfeeding?

218 replies

Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 19:56

I just had an interesting experience (month or so ago) and I’ve been left pondering is it just the UK that pretty backwards with regards to attitudes towards breastfeeding?

as needs must, ive fed both of my kids in public, as discreetly as I can but both kids hated nursing covers, I do prefer a breastfeeding room but ones not always available and when a kids gotta eat a kids gotta eat. in the UK I’ve for sure had quite a few looks and tuts but the head scratcher for me was on hols.

so in Disneyland Paris, a real melting pot of cultures as we know, visitors from around the globe. Fed baby from numerous locations around the park, sat next to Italians who struck up a conversation (no second glance or funny looks) smiles from french people who’ve told their kids to sssh to not distract baby from milk (I speak french and broken Italian so that helps lol. Chatted to some emiratis and Turkish people whilst feeding no second glance or anything weird. No one batted an eyelid until we went to a restaurant In Disney village, and was sitting behind a young British couple. Baby needed feeding, so feed, well the woman (mid to late 20s) hit the roof and demanded the waiter reseat her, he said there were no more tables, she proceeded to tell him she felt physically sick by what was happening behind her, and asked if she could have rest of the meal to go and a dessert to go. The waiter was baffled, and asked why, and said they didn’t have takeout boxes. She got huffy and left half of her food and walked out. I can assume she thought I was french as obviously speaking to waiters in french. After the left, the waiter gave me a wink and said it was a ridiculous attitude.

but it got me wondering , is it just us Brits that are a bit backwards breastfeeding wise? I know my holiday is hardly an academic study but no other group of people seemed to react . I’m on a few social media bf groups and there are so so many posts of discrimination and nasty comments. So what do we think? Is it a UK problem?

OP posts:
StepAwayFromGoogling · 08/08/2022 20:25

Popcorncovered · 08/08/2022 20:23

A lot of posts on this thread are from mums who have fed out and about in the UK without problems. But that doesn't prove that there is no problem. The fact is that the vast majority of mum don't breastfeed or stop breastfeeding before weaning age.

A lot of them feed for such a short time (or not at all) because they are worried about feeding in front of others, they/ their partner think breasts are just sexual, they have been brought up to think that it's "yukky".

Obviously some mums formula feed for other reasons, but yes, lots of people have a strange attitude towards it

Could you point me to the research that shows these are the reasons breastfeeding rates are low in the UK please?

turquoise1988 · 08/08/2022 20:23

I would have thought your experience would be in the minority really, despite very low breastfeeding rates in the UK.

I don't know...people can be weird about it. Because the majority of women in the UK formula feed, it seems to create this weird illusion that women who breastfeed somehow see themselves as 'better' than everyone else, which is obviously not true. It's like women who formula feed sometimes see it as an attack on the choice they made, as if they aren't doing it 'properly' or 'the right way.' I have met so many formula feeding mothers who seem to think they need to give a reason to justify why they didn't want to breastfeed. It's usually 'my milk didn't come in' or 'I didn't produce enough.' It's sad...why not just...'it isn't for me' or 'I didn't want to.'

Anyway, I'm going off on a bit of a tangent. But I think that's why there is still much stigma attached to it in the UK. People like you experienced, OP, aren't usually such arseholes about it.

Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 20:23

L1ttledrummergirl · 08/08/2022 20:11

Having breastfed 3 dc for over a year each I disagree. Most people weren't aware I was feeding and when people did realise they were quite happy to mind their own business.

I only had a few people comment and they were mainly older woman, all very positive and supportive.
This was 20 years ago.

40 years ago my dmum was breastfeeding my sister with a cover when a fuckwit started giving her a hard time. We lived in Germany at the time.

Yabu to assume 1 dickwad is representative of a population.

Well obviously she isn’t representative of the UK as whole and whilst I might have had a few awkward looks from time to time ‘in’ the UK, I’d never ever experienced anything as blatant before but there are so so many examples on Fb mum and breastfeeding groups you do wonder if it’s the same elsewhere or if it’s a British thing

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 08/08/2022 20:23

Popcorncovered · 08/08/2022 20:23

A lot of posts on this thread are from mums who have fed out and about in the UK without problems. But that doesn't prove that there is no problem. The fact is that the vast majority of mum don't breastfeed or stop breastfeeding before weaning age.

A lot of them feed for such a short time (or not at all) because they are worried about feeding in front of others, they/ their partner think breasts are just sexual, they have been brought up to think that it's "yukky".

Obviously some mums formula feed for other reasons, but yes, lots of people have a strange attitude towards it

Where did you get all that from?

Popcorncovered · 08/08/2022 20:23

A lot of posts on this thread are from mums who have fed out and about in the UK without problems. But that doesn't prove that there is no problem. The fact is that the vast majority of mum don't breastfeed or stop breastfeeding before weaning age.

A lot of them feed for such a short time (or not at all) because they are worried about feeding in front of others, they/ their partner think breasts are just sexual, they have been brought up to think that it's "yukky".

Obviously some mums formula feed for other reasons, but yes, lots of people have a strange attitude towards it

Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2022 20:21

Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 20:20

If I never utter another word. It’s gods honest truth.

the woman remarked with some head tilts and eyes to her partner that she felt sick and then beckoned the waiter over…

No, she said it to the waiter!

hit the roof and demanded the waiter reseat her, he said there were no more tables, she proceeded to tell him she felt physically sick by what was happening behind her, and asked if she could have rest of the meal to go and a dessert to go. The waiter was baffled, and asked why, and said they didn’t have takeout boxes. She got huffy and left half of her food and walked out.

DappledThings · 08/08/2022 20:21

Breastfed two children for 14 months each, EBF to 6 months. Did so in cafes, parks, churches, the optician, trains, etc. Never used a cover, never moved anywhere other than where I was.

Had two positive comments and no negative ones. Nobody else ever noticed, commented, gave me a look or anything.

When DC were little we lived in SE London, everyone breastfed. One of my friends was really worried about being judged for bottle feeding.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 08/08/2022 20:21

Breastfeeding rates are not low in the UK because everyone has a stick up their arse. FFS. There's loads of posters here saying they've never had a negative experience. You had one woman say something to you and because she was British you've decuded everyone is uptight about it?!

Sometimeswinning · 08/08/2022 20:20

There is a massive divide between the keep going breastfeeding is best and the give up fed is best.

It's sad we can't all meet in the middle. Offer support/make it so no woman feels uncomfortable breastfeeding in public or feels bad when it's not suiting their lifestyle.

Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 20:20

Wouldloveanother · 08/08/2022 20:11

I put YABU as I’m not sure about your ‘physically sick’ story, it seems very exaggerated.

YANBU about attitudes to breastfeeding being more relaxed abroad though. Brits are real prudes compared to other nationalities.

If I never utter another word. It’s gods honest truth.

the woman remarked with some head tilts and eyes to her partner that she felt sick and then beckoned the waiter over…

OP posts:
x2boys · 08/08/2022 20:19

Well hopefully things have changed my kids are 12 and 15 now but when my oldest was born I found there was very little support for mothers that wanted to give breastfeeding a go , maybe inteasd of just insisting breast is best and then ignoring new mothers concerns they should actually invest in supporting new mothers in making this choice, ( if that's what they want)

Brented · 08/08/2022 20:19

I’ve only experienced the opposite. I mix fed and had some lovely comments when breastfeeding, but some very rude and hurtful comments when I bottlefed. I would prefer no comments at all, and people just to let mothers get in with things.

GrandSlamFinalee · 08/08/2022 20:18

Part of the reason why France has fairly low breastfeeding rates is because most women only get 3-4 months maternity leave. It used to be the same in Spain and Italy, although it’s now slowly increasing over there.

It would be interesting to adjust for and compare rates in a country where a 3 month maternity leave is the norm vs 9-12 months like in the UK.

Thejoyfulstar · 08/08/2022 20:17

I have lived in the Middle East and currently live in Europe and completely agree. I've breastfeed 3 kids, anywhere and everywhere, and the very few weird reactions that I have had have been from an English lady and an Irish man. On a flight from the Middle East I was feeding my baby and an English woman walked past, looked at us and made an audible 'urgh' sound. The Irish man was so awkward and seemed scared I would think he was being creepy.

NorthCountryBlues · 08/08/2022 20:16

Hmm. Yes and no. BF rates are low in the UK and that is fact. Anecdotally I’ve generally had positive experiences feeding in public (in a total of 6 years feeding 3 different babies/toddlers, I only had 2 dirty looks which I don’t think is horrendous).
And that holds for the other countries I publicly fed in - the States, Canada, France, Italy, Norway.

I think we are generally less baby friendly in the UK that in some other countries and that might extend to feeding attitudes.

Popcorncovered · 08/08/2022 20:15

Yes

123ROLO · 08/08/2022 20:15

I was on a busy train couple of weeks back going Newcastle to York and a lady was very openly breast feeding, there was the odd curious glance but no one seemed to care.

Not saying my experience represents the whole of the UK, but I think the majority of people are completely indifferent to people breast feeding, just the odd ones who have an issue with it are the ones to shout the loudest

TeapotTitties · 08/08/2022 20:15

Such high drama OP

I know my holiday is hardly an academic study

You're right, it's not.

InChocolateWeTrust · 08/08/2022 20:14

3wildones
Alas while I don't think it's as bad everywhere as OP suggests, I experienced the following bf my 2 (each to about age 1)

  • "friends" saying I "loved getting my tits out" after I had bf eldest (age 6 weeks) in cafes with them a whopping 3 times
  • being asked to leave a quiet seating area in a golf club (DH was having a lesson on the range, I was having a drink bought from their cafe) because I was feeding 12 week old. They suggested a do it in our car.
  • many, many people suggesting I quit bf to go on weekends away when babies were 3, 4 months old
  • an older relative telling me bf was stopping me "getting my figure back".
  • endless people getting irritated that I wasn't willing to starve DS (a bottle refuser) into taking a bottle by refusing to bf him for a couple of days (at 4 months old) in order to be able to go along to social activities baby free (I wasnt bothered about going!!)
RenegadeMrs · 08/08/2022 20:14

I think you were just unlucky. I bf both mine in public in the UK a fair bit and never had any issues. Didn't use a cover either as it was too much of a faff.

RedRed20 · 08/08/2022 20:14

That’s not what she was saying, not sure where you’ve got that from.

OP, I breastfed my first for over a year and currently breast feeding my second. Never got any funny or rude looks. I live in a part of SE London where most women seem to breast feed. All except one in my NCT class did.

you do often see in papers that people have very funny attitudes like that woman.

Wouldloveanother · 08/08/2022 20:12

actually I just looked online and France has ‘worse’ breastfeeding rates than the U.K.

SunscreenCentral · 08/08/2022 20:12

You're not wrong OP. It's not much different here in Ireland 🇮🇪

You need confidence to do it in public spaces but that comes with time and experience I've found.

Also I was 38 second time round and I didn't care so much if someone was "offended"

L1ttledrummergirl · 08/08/2022 20:11

Having breastfed 3 dc for over a year each I disagree. Most people weren't aware I was feeding and when people did realise they were quite happy to mind their own business.

I only had a few people comment and they were mainly older woman, all very positive and supportive.
This was 20 years ago.

40 years ago my dmum was breastfeeding my sister with a cover when a fuckwit started giving her a hard time. We lived in Germany at the time.

Yabu to assume 1 dickwad is representative of a population.

Wouldloveanother · 08/08/2022 20:11

I put YABU as I’m not sure about your ‘physically sick’ story, it seems very exaggerated.

YANBU about attitudes to breastfeeding being more relaxed abroad though. Brits are real prudes compared to other nationalities.