Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Britain is pretty backwards with breastfeeding?

218 replies

Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 19:56

I just had an interesting experience (month or so ago) and I’ve been left pondering is it just the UK that pretty backwards with regards to attitudes towards breastfeeding?

as needs must, ive fed both of my kids in public, as discreetly as I can but both kids hated nursing covers, I do prefer a breastfeeding room but ones not always available and when a kids gotta eat a kids gotta eat. in the UK I’ve for sure had quite a few looks and tuts but the head scratcher for me was on hols.

so in Disneyland Paris, a real melting pot of cultures as we know, visitors from around the globe. Fed baby from numerous locations around the park, sat next to Italians who struck up a conversation (no second glance or funny looks) smiles from french people who’ve told their kids to sssh to not distract baby from milk (I speak french and broken Italian so that helps lol. Chatted to some emiratis and Turkish people whilst feeding no second glance or anything weird. No one batted an eyelid until we went to a restaurant In Disney village, and was sitting behind a young British couple. Baby needed feeding, so feed, well the woman (mid to late 20s) hit the roof and demanded the waiter reseat her, he said there were no more tables, she proceeded to tell him she felt physically sick by what was happening behind her, and asked if she could have rest of the meal to go and a dessert to go. The waiter was baffled, and asked why, and said they didn’t have takeout boxes. She got huffy and left half of her food and walked out. I can assume she thought I was french as obviously speaking to waiters in french. After the left, the waiter gave me a wink and said it was a ridiculous attitude.

but it got me wondering , is it just us Brits that are a bit backwards breastfeeding wise? I know my holiday is hardly an academic study but no other group of people seemed to react . I’m on a few social media bf groups and there are so so many posts of discrimination and nasty comments. So what do we think? Is it a UK problem?

OP posts:
InChocolateWeTrust · 08/08/2022 20:50

I had friends in london who said everyone bf and you were more likely to be judged for not.

Where I lived (home counties) half of my NCT group of 8 were openly in the "breastfeeding is a bit cringe/urgh" camp. Honestly. Another was not, but didnt believe it should ever be done in public and always expressed for bottles out and about. Another was neutral about other people doing it but no intention of doing it herself. It was literally only me and one other who were keen to bf and the other lady was of south Asian heritage with very different cultural view of bf.

This was around 5 years ago. I was genuinely surprised how vehement a couple of the women were about it being "gross", it literally seemed to give them the ick!

Popcorncovered · 08/08/2022 20:47

Do you not believe women when they say they couldn't and it didn't work out? Do you think they are lying and it's just cos they didn't want to and didn't want to admit it?

It's not as simple as that. How do you define "couldn't"? It's quite rare for a woman to physically not be able to breastfeed.

But of course there are other reasons as to why they couldn't, e.g. baby born prematurely so it was difficult to establish breastfeeding, family/partner not encouraging breastfeeding as they also want to feed the baby, partner wants breasts for himself, PND. And many other reasons

Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 20:46

Soubriquet · 08/08/2022 20:36

British and Americans

Breasts are sexual to a lot of people.

There was a thread a while back about American mat leave that went into a convo about bf rates and the overarching opinion was that Americans are more favourable to bf than us in the UK.

i can’t comment either way but by way on anecdotes of the Americans I know a lot seem to pump at work because they go back so early so that must mean they are breastfeeding too?

OP posts:
turquoise1988 · 08/08/2022 20:45

@DearieMeWhatsUp Do you know what? As I was writing my previous post, I was thinking, "I wonder how long it will take for someone to come along and invent some way to get offended about what I've just said in order to try and start some beef?"

I swear you can not post on this forum nowadays without a little gaggle of posters, from the safety of anonymity behind their computer or phone screens, spending their evenings on here just gunning for an argument disguised as a 'debate.'

Please, for the love of humanity, find something else to do with your time.

And before you tell yourself that I am responding in this way because I don't have an answer to your questions...It doesn't matter whether I believe or don't believe anyone's reasons for breastfeeding. I genuinely, honestly, truly couldn't care less how anyone feeds their child and their reasons behind it.

Breastfeeding threads send some people on here into a total frenzy. They just go round and round in circles, for days on end. I was simply posting my unbiased opinion, free from judgement about how anyone chooses to feed.

AnneLovesGilbert · 08/08/2022 20:45

Sorry she was weird.

I’ve only had positive comments when I’ve had any at about feeding, most of the time I don’t think people even notice. Kind smiles, offers of drinks, unprompted glasses of water, “oh I remember those days”, “aww, lucky baby” sort of thing.

The only people who’ve ever asked how I was feeding were women who’d formula fed who immediately told me it was too much like hard work to BF, dad needed a chance to bond, it’s lonely and isolating, they didn’t get on with it. I’ve never ever asked a woman with a baby how it was fed, I’m not remotely interested. But despite the large majority of mums in the U.K. formula feeding I’ve always found it odd when people ask at all and even weirder when they diss one of the answers you could give.

Fifife · 08/08/2022 20:44

I do think some women get really defensive about FF and BF. It is becoming more normalised and in the media and SM. I used to get a bit defensive as well about FF but my DDs now 9 perfectly healthy and I don't know why I got so het up about it. It's such a small part of the parenting journey. I didn't pursue with BF because I wanted my body back, was sick of cluster feeding and wanted my OH to share the load as I'd had no sleep. I slept 12 hours that night I gave up and my DD slept form 10pm - 7 am for the first time. I'm happy with my choice and I feel women should do what feels best for them with no guilt.

Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 20:43

Somethingsnappy · 08/08/2022 20:37

You see OP, already posters on here are getting all huffy about it. Such a touchy subject it seems. But no, I don't think you're wrong. As pp have said, the attitude is reflected in our breastfeeding rates. I don't know if you read the thread a couple of days ago, but although not the majority, a significant percentage admitted to being uncomfortable with seeing breastfeeding in public. Bearing in mind that this is Mumsnet, and very pro BF, the percentage in real life is bound to be higher.

For what it's worth though, I am now on my 8th year of BF (2 years per 4 children). Never had a negative comment (that I'm aware of).

I know, it’s quite remarkable, you’d think I actually said something offensive, either that or the lady in question is on the thread

OP posts:
FinneusMum · 08/08/2022 20:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Cactusprick · 08/08/2022 20:41

Some right dicks on this post.
OP you didn’t claim to be something special by breastfeeding so I don’t know why people have made that assumption?!
I didn’t get any comments or looks (as far as o was aware) when BF but I totally believe your story. Some people are arseholes. I can’t say yes or no in regards to whether the attitude is a Brit thing, cos I guess you can bump into arseholes anywhere!

also, the poster who said BF in public comes down to experience - nah it doesn’t. I was 27 and had no problem BF my first (and second) baby in public. I didn’t need “experience” to feel like I should or shouldn’t feed my baby when she was hungry, no matter where I was.

Itdoesntreallymatter · 08/08/2022 20:38

🤔hmm

Breastfed my kids for 7 years in UK. Never had a bad comment.

ArabellaDrummond · 08/08/2022 20:37

I think that BF rates in the UK are so low because the support and education around it is absolutely shit and it trickles down to not being the ‘norm’
I was adamant to BF my LO but three weeks in, absolutely no support from midwives on where I could turn to, my HV told me to just give up as I had a ‘big baby’. Knowing what I know now, I am absolutely gutted I gave up so soon.
I can’t comment on BF but I have been shamed for bottle feeding, mostly by the older generation though. Out of my friends who have had babies, only one has actually stuck to BF so I do salute you OP, I found it incredibly hard and I’m sorry that you had that reaction.

Somethingsnappy · 08/08/2022 20:37

You see OP, already posters on here are getting all huffy about it. Such a touchy subject it seems. But no, I don't think you're wrong. As pp have said, the attitude is reflected in our breastfeeding rates. I don't know if you read the thread a couple of days ago, but although not the majority, a significant percentage admitted to being uncomfortable with seeing breastfeeding in public. Bearing in mind that this is Mumsnet, and very pro BF, the percentage in real life is bound to be higher.

For what it's worth though, I am now on my 8th year of BF (2 years per 4 children). Never had a negative comment (that I'm aware of).

Popcorncovered · 08/08/2022 20:36

Could you point me to the research that shows these are the reasons breastfeeding rates are low in the UK please?

No, I can't. I don't even know if there is any. But I am old enough to know that these are the reasons that a lot of mums who never breastfeed or who stop breastfeeding before weaning age

Soubriquet · 08/08/2022 20:36

British and Americans

Breasts are sexual to a lot of people.

Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 20:35

TeapotTitties · 08/08/2022 20:15

Such high drama OP

I know my holiday is hardly an academic study

You're right, it's not.

🙄

OP posts:
Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 20:35

That’s interesting @turquoise1988 Dc1 was combi fed at the start (tongue tie) and I found myself justifying it constantly too…

probably just did above actually

oh yeah this lady, maybe she had her reasons, was just a bit of an arse and most aren’t that extreme even if they do have a problem but still even my own mother who breastfed myself and my siblings doesn’t believe it should be done in public… wondering how much of this is a cultural thing. Didn’t have any second glances feeding in France but I guess paris might be different than a rural village attitude wise

OP posts:
DearieMeWhatsUp · 08/08/2022 20:34

turquoise1988 · 08/08/2022 20:23

I would have thought your experience would be in the minority really, despite very low breastfeeding rates in the UK.

I don't know...people can be weird about it. Because the majority of women in the UK formula feed, it seems to create this weird illusion that women who breastfeed somehow see themselves as 'better' than everyone else, which is obviously not true. It's like women who formula feed sometimes see it as an attack on the choice they made, as if they aren't doing it 'properly' or 'the right way.' I have met so many formula feeding mothers who seem to think they need to give a reason to justify why they didn't want to breastfeed. It's usually 'my milk didn't come in' or 'I didn't produce enough.' It's sad...why not just...'it isn't for me' or 'I didn't want to.'

Anyway, I'm going off on a bit of a tangent. But I think that's why there is still much stigma attached to it in the UK. People like you experienced, OP, aren't usually such arseholes about it.

Do you not believe women when they say they couldn't and it didn't work out? Do you think they are lying and it's just cos they didn't want to and didn't want to admit it?

Wouldloveanother · 08/08/2022 20:31

Fixyourself · 08/08/2022 20:31

Such a sad country we live in where drinking cow tit milk in your tea is normal but breastfeeding a child with human milk is often frowned upon or deemed disgusting. Crazy!

Cow tit milk 😂 do you call eggs ‘chicken ovulations’ as well?

Fixyourself · 08/08/2022 20:31

Such a sad country we live in where drinking cow tit milk in your tea is normal but breastfeeding a child with human milk is often frowned upon or deemed disgusting. Crazy!

luxxlisbon · 08/08/2022 20:31

@Popcorncovered A lot of them feed for such a short time (or not at all) because they are worried about feeding in front of others, they/ their partner think breasts are just sexual, they have been brought up to think that it's "yukky".

I mean you’ve just entirely made that up!
A more likely reason is the lack of support with BF, and the lack of community around young parents these days making it incredibly difficult to be the sole source of nutrition and comfort 24hrs a day for your baby.

Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 20:30

Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2022 20:28

As god as your witness and all that, it’s not that heavy.

That’s just how I talk 🙄

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2022 20:28

Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 20:26

She did also say it to the waiter yes as to why she wanted to move but the conversation started with her telling her partner… honestly there’s no need to go all columbo and try and dissect the post, it’s not that heavy.

As god as your witness and all that, it’s not that heavy.

fyn · 08/08/2022 20:26

If you want back up - have a look at the comments on this article. It’s about a recent mumsnet thread, there are 2,000 comments basically saying how gross it is and that the woman should cover up - www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11084875/Mother-reveals-breastfeeding-shamed-partner.html#comments-11084875

Bluffysummers · 08/08/2022 20:26

Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2022 20:21

No, she said it to the waiter!

hit the roof and demanded the waiter reseat her, he said there were no more tables, she proceeded to tell him she felt physically sick by what was happening behind her, and asked if she could have rest of the meal to go and a dessert to go. The waiter was baffled, and asked why, and said they didn’t have takeout boxes. She got huffy and left half of her food and walked out.

She did also say it to the waiter yes as to why she wanted to move but the conversation started with her telling her partner… honestly there’s no need to go all columbo and try and dissect the post, it’s not that heavy.

OP posts: