Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD transgender

137 replies

lolypopp · 08/08/2022 19:08

With no gender dysphoria?
DD 13 says she’s lesbian which DH and I are okay with. However she now claims to be a ‘trans masculine’ and doesn’t have gender dysphoria but says she feels happier as a boy. It doesn’t make sense to me. I do support trans people but isn’t dysphoria an entry level requirement?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2022 20:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

So you think the best time to do that is when a confused, 13 year old shares something that’s bothering her?

midgetastic · 08/08/2022 20:23

I knew I was a boy

But I was wrong

FinneusMum · 08/08/2022 20:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Discovereads · 08/08/2022 20:21

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 08/08/2022 20:18

So you wouldn’t ask a teen announcing a big life chance exactly what they meant by X and Y?

Who knows maybe the teen is dysphoric and not recognising it, maybe it’s something else, but unless they have someone to discuss it all with, step by step, they aren’t going to get clarity of thought, are they? Teen SM might be admirably accepting but it isn’t very discursive or analytical.

Sure, I’d leave my door open to discuss things but I would not go all Spanish Inquisition on a 13yr old which is what the poster suggested. Asking questions with feigned ignorance specifically so she can “try and fail” to properly define things.

babyjellyfish · 08/08/2022 20:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Circumferences · 08/08/2022 20:20

Do you ACTUALLY think gay men are thinking “yes, my attraction to men is the same as how a woman likes men, so I must be a woman”? Do you think they could be talked into that?

Well, actually yes, many HSTS males have openly admitted to transitioning because of their sexual attraction to the same sex, with that being the sole reason for their "feeling like a woman". (I'm not the person you asked btw)

Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2022 20:20

babyjellyfish · 08/08/2022 20:18

Well encouraging them to believe in it isn't going to help either.

It’s still not the time or the place to say ‘I don’t know why your generation are like this’ or whatever your phrasing was. It’s kicking her when she’s down and it’s unnecessary.

babyjellyfish · 08/08/2022 20:18

Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2022 20:17

Fine, but it’s still not the time or place to have that conversation with a confused kid.

Well encouraging them to believe in it isn't going to help either.

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 08/08/2022 20:18

Discovereads · 08/08/2022 20:15

I do have teens. Well only one is still a teen as just had a birthday and my 19yo turned 20. But still have the 18yo. And two others that are mid20s. So very familiar with teens,

But that’s got nothing to do with making a claim that a made up parenting technique is what was used by Socrates and Ancient Greek philosophers to teach students to think for themselves. The poster was dismissing good criticism of her parenting technique by pretending it is something oh so great that only a person with a classical education would know about. It was sneering and at core a false claim.

So you wouldn’t ask a teen announcing a big life chance exactly what they meant by X and Y?

Who knows maybe the teen is dysphoric and not recognising it, maybe it’s something else, but unless they have someone to discuss it all with, step by step, they aren’t going to get clarity of thought, are they? Teen SM might be admirably accepting but it isn’t very discursive or analytical.

midgetastic · 08/08/2022 20:17

I thought I was a boy

Decades before such things were talked about

I did have sone body hatred
Snd I did struggle with sexist stereotypes as well

I think it's incredibly difficult these days when what is man /women is now defined as a belief

I would focus on not caring about the words - she can't ever stop being female but that's just the biology and in all ways she is just the same as any boy - so to you she hasn't changed anything

Lots of love also - it's horrid growing up , coping with body changes you hate and getting increased sexual attention that you don't want and then failing to meet the requirements of the girl gangs , being excluded from the male ones , bring laughed at fir being you

capedavenger · 08/08/2022 20:17

Amongst the teens I know it seems to be increasingly common to explore and experiment with both sexuality and gender. Teens, feel a huge amount of freedom to explore and express who they are in one way but conversely a lot of pressure to be something other than heterosexual.
I think it's great that she feels comfortable discussing it with you. Make it clear that you're supportive and understand that she's trying to work out who she is. Tell her you love and accept her no matter what and also let her know that she's free to change her mind a little further down the track. Nothing needs to be permanent just now. I think this is the best approach with young teens, acceptance, communication but steer away from and decisions that they might find hard to reverse.

Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2022 20:17

babyjellyfish · 08/08/2022 20:16

Being gender critical isn't a belief system.

It's being sceptical of the belief system (that we all have magical pink or blue identities which either match or don't match our genitals).

Fine, but it’s still not the time or place to have that conversation with a confused kid.

BeanieTeen · 08/08/2022 20:16

That questioning technique you despise was the main way Greek philosophers, including Socrates, taught their students how to think for themselves. But you go ahead and fantasise about cattle prods if you want. 🙄

All right then, great scholar of Greek Philosophy 😂😂😂
I don’t know much about Socrates or Greek philosophy… but I guess the ‘Socrates’ approach to parenting teenagers would make for an interesting read.

babyjellyfish · 08/08/2022 20:16

Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2022 20:12

It’s not direct. It’s putting gender-critical beliefs
front and centre as the topic for conversation, and that will just push her kid away. ‘Let her try (and fail)’ ffs.

Being gender critical isn't a belief system.

It's being sceptical of the belief system (that we all have magical pink or blue identities which either match or don't match our genitals).

Trying20 · 08/08/2022 20:15

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Discovereads · 08/08/2022 20:15

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 08/08/2022 20:08

You don’t have teens, do you?

She was proposing a parenting technique, but a formal debate. But there is absolutely no harm in getting a child to define their terms. No big decision should be unexamined.

I do have teens. Well only one is still a teen as just had a birthday and my 19yo turned 20. But still have the 18yo. And two others that are mid20s. So very familiar with teens,

But that’s got nothing to do with making a claim that a made up parenting technique is what was used by Socrates and Ancient Greek philosophers to teach students to think for themselves. The poster was dismissing good criticism of her parenting technique by pretending it is something oh so great that only a person with a classical education would know about. It was sneering and at core a false claim.

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 08/08/2022 20:15

PinkyU · 08/08/2022 20:12

@Lottapianos did you read the post telling the op to feign ignorance, back her 13 year old into a corner and watch her “fail”? Yes, very thoughtful 🤔

She wasn’t saying to feign ignorance. She was advocating being open about her genuine confusion and expressing it step by step.

WaverleyOwl · 08/08/2022 20:13

Get her off TikTok.

If she still feels trans 6 months from now, then it might be a thing. But it won't be.

PinkyU · 08/08/2022 20:12

@Lottapianos did you read the post telling the op to feign ignorance, back her 13 year old into a corner and watch her “fail”? Yes, very thoughtful 🤔

Pumperthepumper · 08/08/2022 20:12

babyjellyfish · 08/08/2022 20:10

I don't think it's passive aggressive, I think it's direct.

If you don't think a girl is a female child and a boy is a male child, that means you think a girl is a child who likes feminine things and a boy is a child who likes masculine things.

There aren't really any other possibilities. It's sex or stereotypes. Pick one.

This generation have gone for stereotypes, which is not only regressive in itself, but horribly damaging if you internalise the idea that you need to change your body to fit the stereotypes.

I'd just say, "In my day we believed that girls could like whatever they liked and do whatever they liked, including stereotypically masculine things, and still be a girl and not feel the need to change their name or their pronouns or their body. I don't understand why your generation doesn't believe this."

It’s not direct. It’s putting gender-critical beliefs
front and centre as the topic for conversation, and that will just push her kid away. ‘Let her try (and fail)’ ffs.

babyjellyfish · 08/08/2022 20:10

I don't think it's passive aggressive, I think it's direct.

If you don't think a girl is a female child and a boy is a male child, that means you think a girl is a child who likes feminine things and a boy is a child who likes masculine things.

There aren't really any other possibilities. It's sex or stereotypes. Pick one.

This generation have gone for stereotypes, which is not only regressive in itself, but horribly damaging if you internalise the idea that you need to change your body to fit the stereotypes.

I'd just say, "In my day we believed that girls could like whatever they liked and do whatever they liked, including stereotypically masculine things, and still be a girl and not feel the need to change their name or their pronouns or their body. I don't understand why your generation doesn't believe this."

Trying20 · 08/08/2022 20:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 08/08/2022 20:08

NOT a formal debate, I mean.

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 08/08/2022 20:08

Discovereads · 08/08/2022 20:06

Your questioning technique bears no resemblance to the Socratic method. For example, you’ve not put forth a thesis statement for examination at all, which is the first step.

You don’t have teens, do you?

She was proposing a parenting technique, but a formal debate. But there is absolutely no harm in getting a child to define their terms. No big decision should be unexamined.

MissMaple82 · 08/08/2022 20:07

Shes 13, she doesn't know what she is yet