Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD transgender

137 replies

lolypopp · 08/08/2022 19:08

With no gender dysphoria?
DD 13 says she’s lesbian which DH and I are okay with. However she now claims to be a ‘trans masculine’ and doesn’t have gender dysphoria but says she feels happier as a boy. It doesn’t make sense to me. I do support trans people but isn’t dysphoria an entry level requirement?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Trying20 · 09/08/2022 11:17

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

FOJN · 09/08/2022 10:17

As you’re so informed, I assume you also consider spaces that challenge your world view - because you wouldn’t allow yourself to get caught up in an echo chamber.

Absolutely, in fact I'd go so far as to say that I was resistant to the idea that there was anything sinister or concerning about gender ideology. You were probably still in nappies when I first met a trans person. I had a long and entirely positive relationship with that person and fully supported them through their complete transition. I was delighted for them when they got their GRC. However, that was nearly 30 years ago and things have changed. I tried to maintain my liberal credentials by ignoring the mounting evidence that all was not what it seemed which I thought was just people trying to find a way to live at peace with their bodies. That is still the truth for some but it is not for many others.

I do not believe an internet craze which leads people down the path towards irreversible surgery, sterility and loss of sexual function is harmless. The detrans subreddit had 36000 members when I last looked about a month ago and that had grown from 28000 the month before that. I cannot shrug my shoulders and just say, "oh well, some people make mistakes" when we know that many of the teens caught up in this trend are very vulnerable. We know that many of the teenagers seeking to transition have ASD, co-morbid mental health problems, a history of childhood trauma including sexual abuse or they are questioning their sexuality. We also know that there is a lack of robust evidence for medical and surgical intervention in minors experiencing gender dysphoria. The quality of the evidence for adults isn't great either. We owe it to teenagers to find a better way to help them navigate the challenges of adolescence in the modern world. The best evidence available at the moment suggests that supportive, watchful waiting is preferable to affirmation.

I have some thoughts on the conspiracy issue but they are not fully formed. I think it's interesting that the prevalence of gender confused teenagers seems to be higher in western developed nations, those with easy internet access. I think it would be naïve to reject the possibility that the two things may be related.

I'm including this open letter from parents to the AAP because it contains lots of informative links.

genspect.org/an-open-letter-to-the-american-academy-of-pediatrics/

This is a link to an interview with a detransitioner currently suing the NHS for the appalling care they received.

This is another account from a detransitioner.

mobile.twitter.com/imwatson91/status/1556633208288059392

There is a Twitter account called gays against groomers which you might find interesting but despite being able to copy other Twitter links I can't with that one, which is weird.

BTW my friend was very happy with their transition but then they made the decision as an adult after several years of therapy.

Trying20 · 09/08/2022 09:05

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Trying20 · 09/08/2022 09:04

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

BeanieTeen · 09/08/2022 09:04

Wtf is acceptable about 12 year olds proclaiming to be "lesbian" ?

I don’t understand the outrage here.
It’s quite normal for a child that age or younger to have crushes - generally on their classmates or celebrities often - it’s a very standard part of being prepubescent. If you’re a girl and your crush is a girl, or multiple girls, and you are not interested in any boys, it’s not a stretch to assume you are a lesbian. What’s unacceptable about recognising your own feelings and inclinations?
Many gay people will tell you that they knew from a very early age that they were not straight. There’s nothing ‘what the fuck’ about it.

courtgou · 09/08/2022 08:39

Threelittlelambs · 09/08/2022 08:25

My exDPs fifteen year old lesbian daughter is onto her second boyfriend now

Same for eldest DD friends who were lesbian, pan, trans, only one I thought was gay, is still gay. They rest were just jumping on the band wagon for a label.

I don’t see how this proves anything, yes for some teens its a passing phase while they’re trying to figure out who they are but for the majority of lgbtq+ people it isn’t. Just because you know a few teens that grew out of it doesn’t mean it’ll be the same for all.
My aunt came out as lesbian almost 20 years ago, she was told back then it was a phase and she’ll grow out of it, she’s now been married to a women for coming up to 7 years. I went through a few stages, bisexual, lesbian, straight, and then back to bisexual which I still am 10 years later, thank god my mum let me figure it out myself and supported me along the way instead of belittling me.

Also find it very weird you’d use pansexual as an example, unless they’ve told you themselves they’re no longer pan I suggest you look up the definition. Being in a relationship with someone of the opposite gender doesn’t make someone no longer bi/pan.

jeaux90 · 09/08/2022 08:35

Gender ideology is homophobic and sexist.

Women can wear what they want. It doesn't make them the opposite sex.

These idiots think that whoever wears the dress is a woman.

Your DD is just starting to explore her sexuality so just support her in that. But I would get on top of the sexist crap this ideology is brain washing her with.

I suggest you watch some Magdalen Burns on YouTube (RIP) she tells it how it is. But also have a look at transgendertrend.com lots of useful advice.

Threelittlelambs · 09/08/2022 08:25

My exDPs fifteen year old lesbian daughter is onto her second boyfriend now

Same for eldest DD friends who were lesbian, pan, trans, only one I thought was gay, is still gay. They rest were just jumping on the band wagon for a label.

montysma1 · 09/08/2022 08:08

Stating the basic science that humans cannot change sex is not anti trans.

FOJN · 09/08/2022 08:04

You refer to the 2012/2013 Tumblr Cohort - I just missed it I think, but I'd equally suggest neither are you. You've said there are plenty of first hand accounts out there that I'm "more than likely" ignoring or dismissing anything which doesn't conform to what I think I already know; but I've equally just provided a first hand account of my own experience which I've decided to dismiss.

Offering an alternative perspective is not the same as invalidating your experience. Some people may have been swept up in social contagion caused by exposure to certain internet forums and you were clearly unaware and have no experience of that. I believe both you and the detransitioners who report what happened to them.

Pointing out you were not part of the 2012/2013 Tumblr cohort is simply a way of explaining why you may not have encountered the phenomenon I am taking about. I didn't need to be part of that cohort to know about it because I've read and heard the first hand accounts.

I'm not saying that you're wrong; I'm saying I'm struggling to see how this widespread conversion is happening and being orchestrated and how we're brainwashing kids in this way... which is the question I asked. If you don't have the answer, that's fine. Just say that.

I've been following the progress of this ideology for about 5 years now so its hard to just give you a couple of pointers about where to get information. If I was to try you would have a reading list a mile long but honestly despite claiming you really want to understand I don't actually think you do. There really is no shortage of information out there from news reports to book to documentaries to interviews. A genuinely curious person would already have harnessed the power of the internet to inform themselves.

I don't think that gay conversion is the objective of gender ideology but surely you can see how transitioning might appeal to a confused teenager who may not have the best support network. Please read the reports from Tavistock whistle blowers to understand more. There are plenty of YouTube videos of some of the clinicians being interview. Here's one to get to started.

Trying20 · 09/08/2022 00:14

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

QueenCamilla · 09/08/2022 00:13

Wtf is acceptable about 12 year olds proclaiming to be "lesbian" ?

Seems that even your DD was expecting more of a reaction/attention to that statement. Got none but a nod. So here comes the next instalment in creative attention seeking.

My exDPs fifteen year old lesbian daughter is onto her second boyfriend now 🙄 Kids these days....

Trying20 · 09/08/2022 00:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

FOJN · 08/08/2022 23:59

It doesn’t correlate with my own experience. I can’t imagine any situation in which I’d have genuinely accepted that I was a woman in the wrong rather than a gay man.

Have you noticed there is a general theme to your posts? If someone else's experience isn't relatable to you then you doubt the veracity of it. I'd reflect on why you believe your experience must be universal and therefore offers the only valid perspective.

I'd suggest "transing the gay away" isn't relatable to you because you were not part of the 2012/2013 Tumblr cohort, that seems to be the origins of the phenomenon of social contagion. There is plenty of information about this, including first hand accounts, out there so perhaps you aren't looking hard enough but more likely you ignore or dismiss anything which doesn't confirm what you think you already know.

Trying20 · 08/08/2022 22:55

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

FOJN · 08/08/2022 22:33

It’s why I find the “trans out the gay” concept so bizarre.

The phenomenon has been widely reported. It was raised as a concern by clinicians at the Tavistock some time ago. I remember reading multiple articles about it. I have no doubt they are qualified to make the observation. Some clinicians reported parents telling them they would rather have a trans child than a gay child. It's no surprise to find that detransitioners are rarely heteosexual.

I don't have a share token for the full article but the bit you can read makes the concerns clear.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/tavistock-gender-clinic-converting-gay-children-tz8cs77p3

I can appreciate you find it hard to understand but that does not mean it isn't happening.

I'm sure you will be horrified to learn that a Tavistock clinician had a strong suspicion that at least one parent wanted their child to receive puberty blockers so that the child could maintain a pre pubescent body. I'll leave you to draw your own conclusions about their motivations.

itsgettingweird · 08/08/2022 22:15

I left school in the 90's. My friend is a decade older than me!

Trying20 · 08/08/2022 22:14

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

itsgettingweird · 08/08/2022 22:09

Good points trying.

That's obviously only her experience. She just said other than being called a Tom boy growing up and the generation above trying to get her to be more feminine she never actually felt she wasn't a woman or feminine.

She just didn't fancy men!

She did what society expected of her as a woman until she felt safe to admit she fancied woman.

Trying20 · 08/08/2022 22:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Trying20 · 08/08/2022 22:01

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

itsgettingweird · 08/08/2022 21:53

I have a homosexual female friend.

She made some excellent points when discussing this a few months back.

She grew up when being bay was wrong. Married had children and divorced when that became ok. Started same set relationship when that became for acceptable.

She dresses in jeans/ combat shorts, polo t shirts and hoodies, trainers. She has shirt hair. Never dresses in dresses or skirts and smart to her is trousers and shirt, blazer if cold.

Like me she's very liberal but also thinks we over discuss these things nowadays which makes kids want to experiment.

She also said during our deep conversation about life that evening she is glad she's an adult in the 21st century. That as a gay woman who dresses the way she does (btw I dress equally the same but I'm also a dress person - dependent on what way the winds blowing!) she thinks as a child growing up in this current climate and being "out" she'd have had people trying to shoehorn her into some box and put a label on it.

But as she says she's just a homosexual woman who dresses how she's comfortable. She'd never considered it to be masculine or questioned her sexual assignment or gender - it's just her sexual preferences are same sex.

I agree with above posters that I'd approach it with asking her what her choices mean to her. Ask her to define what she means. She needs to know she doesn't have to label herself to define who she is. Who she is is enough without needing to box and label it.

I do worry for teens nowadays. They seem to think just being Anne, Jane, Thomas or Matt isn't enough. They have to describe themselves much more definitively .

AnonymousHelper · 08/08/2022 21:44

Dysphoria is not a requirement for being transgender. Although it is often, not a side affect, but a sign normally towards having a different gender identity, dysphoria is not always an issue people struggle with.

Middersweekly · 08/08/2022 21:38

OP my DD is gay and came out at 15 (now 19). I told her I was totally supportive and love her regardless. She has mostly always dressed androgynously and at 17 she cut her hair short. It made her feel happier and more confident in herself. Around the same time we had the conversation about gender dysphoria. Despite looking outwardly quite male (and getting mistaken often as male) she insisted that she was happy being female and had no desire to transition. I would keep the lines of communication open with your DD at this stage. It sounds like she is happy to come and discuss her feelings with you which is great. I wouldn’t rush into discussions about transitioning or gender dysphoria at this stage. I would wait for her to come to you and talk.

Threelittlelambs · 08/08/2022 21:37

Firstly, you are posting in the wrong place, asking advice on trans issues from MN. MN posters are notoriously anti-trans

No, I have teens and DD was friends with 6 trans teens in her year group - do you really think it’s that common? What we are seeing are children drawn into these cult status groups where being trans and joining the trans movement is seen as a challenge.
These groups are allowed in schools and allowed to post their agenda all over social media targeting children to join their cause.

These children are taking up valuable resources away from genuine cases and genuine children in crisis to look cool to their friends.

We will look aback at this time and wonder who let these groups target our children.

I know of one female to male (Friends husband) and yet I know of so many teens lost and confused because they feel they ‘should’ be XYZ - a lot of these are now self harming, because they are stuck doing something they don’t want to do.