Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH examines his family members

205 replies

mercury101 · 08/08/2022 18:23

Is this strange? My DH is a doctor. I am too.

Whenever we go and visit his family, if one of them has a cough or cold they
ask him to bring his stethoscope and to examine them by listening to their chest.

My family have never asked this of me and I don't think ever would. Even if they did, I think I'd ask them to see their own GP anyway.

I find it weird him examining his sister and mother.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 09/08/2022 00:40

mercury101 · 08/08/2022 18:23

Is this strange? My DH is a doctor. I am too.

Whenever we go and visit his family, if one of them has a cough or cold they
ask him to bring his stethoscope and to examine them by listening to their chest.

My family have never asked this of me and I don't think ever would. Even if they did, I think I'd ask them to see their own GP anyway.

I find it weird him examining his sister and mother.

AIBU?

It's health and medical. Besides better someone you know giving their perspectives, rather than another medical person that may be swamped and not have enough time to be as meticulous as your dh, etc

Oinkypig · 09/08/2022 00:35

@Flat04 I do know what you mean about telling people to get xyz checked on hearing symptoms or seeing someone with something wrong. The tricky bit is when it moves to can you just…… do a bit more and have listen/feel. I suppose it’s expert opinion moving to expert advice? Or maybe the other way round? I just know a couple of people really regretting what they though was helpful advice and you make judgment through the lens of your own experiences.

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 09/08/2022 00:23

My dad was a surgeon and then a GP. He delivered my younger brother (in a hospital), has stitched up and stuck together pretty much all of us when we were kids, prescribed all our childhood and teenage medications, chased us round the kitchen table with flu jabs etc. Okay, we were in very rural locations so not many other options, but I don't recall there being any issues with him being our official GP.

Retired now, but I'll still send him photos of random rashes and he's always my first port of call before I phone my GP... hence haven't actually needed to see one in years.

I thought that was generally normal behaviour? Most of my relatives are doctors and do the same with their families...

elkiedee · 08/08/2022 23:58

My sister is a paediatric consultant. We often ask her for initial quick advice but she has never "examined" them as she is in Stockport/Manchester and we live in London. This would be to ask her if we should be worried, sensible things to do etc. If she said take your son to hospital now we would follow that advice, ditto with a GP appointment, otherwise it's reassurance and practical ideas for dealing with an illness that is hopefully no big deal.

mycatisannoying · 08/08/2022 23:44

Not odd. It's human.

OliviaBond · 08/08/2022 23:41

I think it's odd. Are his family a bunch of hypochondriacs? Most of us just get on with a cough or cold unless there's anything to suggest it requires a gp check.

Apandemicyousay · 08/08/2022 23:39

Medic here too and large close family with ‘normal’ dynamics. I would not examine family member and the GMC are really clear about us not managing family and friends. I would of course take an interest and if they wish, will ask questions to determine if it sounds like nothing/call the GP on Monday/go to A&E etc but absolutely will not examine. I think it opens you up to blind spots: you assume your family member will tell you everything and of course they might not have disclosed all, and incorrectly they have assumed it’s not relevant . You absolutely cannot prescribe for them anyway so determining they might need antibiotics isn’t very helpful. We know 90% of a diagnosis is in a detailed history, so examining will contribute relatively little but sets you up to have taken a clinical role without all the equipment and not necessarily all the facts. I’m with you!

WhimsicalGubbins · 08/08/2022 23:26

You’re being totally unreasonable.

So you’re saying, that if one of your family was worried about their health, you wouldn’t do a quick exam to at least put their mind at rest? I think that’s awful of you!

I work in the banking sector and I’m forever helping friends and family with their finances. I’m happy to do it because I’m qualified to. My nephew is a sparky, and you can be damn sure he pops over if anyone has anything wrong with their electrics.
It’s what you do for family and friends.

Pqpqpqpq · 08/08/2022 23:17

Read that as dh examining his families members. Must get to bed.... ☺️

Summerfun54321 · 08/08/2022 23:16

It’s a solid half hour wait to even get through on the phone to my GP. Then you have to book a phone consultation and only then can you book an actual appointment to be seen if they think you need to. I’d be at the front of the queue asking for GP advice if one was coming round to my house anyway for a cuppa, whoever it is!

Oinkypig · 08/08/2022 23:16

@Flat04 but that’s why the professional bodies have that guidance in place not to treat family/friends. The professional doesn’t have to draw the line, the line is drawn by their regulating body, some people have different areas of their body they feel to be vulnerable. We all ask people in our spheres for advice about all sorts of things, the line is crossed when it becomes a hands on exam.

Yes lots of people do but that doesn’t make it appropriate, I know of 2 situations where the outcome was tragic and was initiated by a harmless “could you just check…” now neither were the fault of anyone but it was the management around it that made them more difficult and had either of the “patients” chosen to make a complaint it would have been totally justified.

An emergency is totally different and you just have to manage but a pp talked about diagnosing a chest infection but not prescribing as fine, what do you do when on a Monday you’ve diagnosed it and by Thursday they still haven’t been seen by their GP? When do you step in? The rules are there not to make life difficult for people but because someone has been there done that and it’s ended in disaster.

ThinWomansBrain · 08/08/2022 23:15

As a teenager I did exchange holidays with a French family over a period of several years. The mother was a GP, and the slightest sign of a headache, being tired, slightly under the weather, she'd be taking my blood pressure, temperature, stethoscope... the same with her daughters
The summer I got sun stroke everything went in to melt down 🙄.
Other than in france, I don't thik I had my blood pressure taken until I was in my 40s.

lot123 · 08/08/2022 22:53

Can't say I agree with your creepy statement. I wouldn't care in the least if a male or female relative listened to my chest.

I have friends who are doctors and I try really hard not to talk about medical stuff in case it looks as if I'm taking advantage. But I've recently had major surgery so when they ask me how it's going, it's impossible to avoid the topic.

Different scenario and less frequent than medical queries but I have professional experience in investing in equities etc. I'm happy to chat to any of my friends or family and give advice on their money.

I'm less happy that my father in law has signed over a sizeable chunk of his money that I have to invest and manage. I told him not to invest it as a lump sum last year as stock markets looked set to fall. Predictably he insisted and most of his investments are in the red.

It makes me feel very awkward although mercifully he's a sufficient technophobe that he can't log on to see the current value. He's also made me do the same for my nieces. So we all have our burdens to bear, sometimes you have to grin and bear it.

MumoftwoGranofone · 08/08/2022 22:42

You are not being unreasonable at all.

mathanxiety · 08/08/2022 22:40

Not weird imo.

ExFIL diagnosed my gallstones and gave me a shot of anti nausea medicine to keep me from barfing on a plane flight.

DS has access to all medical reports I get these days.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 08/08/2022 22:39

I get this all the time as an NHS podiatrist. Where I lived before One of my neighbours turned up at 10pm wanting me to change her foot ulcer dressing as is wasn't comfortable. In the end I had to say I'm not a 24 hour on call service. Ring the surgery in the morning.
I dont mind family but not neighbours and neighbours friends.

Minecraftatemychild · 08/08/2022 22:38

Batshittery · 08/08/2022 18:36

Bearing in mind that it's near on impossible to get an appointment with a GP, I don't think it's odd at all

This.

”See your own GP” 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 er how

Hugsssssss · 08/08/2022 22:34

mercury101 · 08/08/2022 19:19

Personally, I wouldn't want a relative, let alone a male relative examining me.

Why is the gender important? I’m really suprised that as a dr you find it weird. It’s a medical check up using a stethoscope!

as an aside I always find it odd when anyone labels another family as “weird”. I assume that is because you are taking your family / ideas as normal. It seems from the thread that most “normal” families do lean on family members who are Drs for some advice or reassurance. I wouldn’t say you are weird for withholding the same from your family but it is weird to assume yours to be the “norm”

XelaM · 08/08/2022 22:29

No, you're the odd one. My uncle is a doctor and has always examined and given advice to family.

Bunnycat101 · 08/08/2022 22:28

Sounds quite normal but then I’m a person that has sent pictures of phlegm to dr friends to see if I should make a GP appointment. There clearly is a line though where I wouldn’t want family or friends to be my treating GP but when it is so hard to get an appointment/people worried re wasting time, it is very normal to ask family or friends if you should be worried about x or not. If my friends weren’t happy then I wouldn’t pester them. Where you might have to be slightly more careful with your husband is the frequency of examinations and whether that starts to push the balance over the relationship with your in-laws’ own doctors.

Sporty2022 · 08/08/2022 22:23

Do you realise how hard it is for lots of people to see a GP?
Having one in the family can certainly be handy- what’s more important than health?

WrongWayApricot · 08/08/2022 22:20

Erogenous🤣 it would be erroneous in those circumstances though

Tonty · 08/08/2022 22:19

mercury101 · 08/08/2022 19:19

Personally, I wouldn't want a relative, let alone a male relative examining me.

Don't be so silly, he's listening to their chest via a stethoscope not checking his mothers and sisters breasts for lumps. You've got a sick mind,THAT is your problem.

WrongWayApricot · 08/08/2022 22:19

When do you refuse?

When you have to palpate and erroneous area or get up inside your relative.

IrisVersicolor · 08/08/2022 22:13

mercury101 · 08/08/2022 19:42

Thank you for understanding. I'm shocked that some poster's responses towards me. I respect professional boundaries and I apply those boundaries to family members also.

You have professional boundaries with family members? How odd.