Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dad wants £500

170 replies

Glassback83 · 08/08/2022 16:40

Ds is 16 this month and we wanted to treat him. We decided to get him a PC and my dad said he could build one (he’s been building them for years), so we agreed. We spent £400 on some hard drives and another £250 on a monitor. Initially, Dad said he had bits lying around he could use but said to give him a couple of hundred pounds for other bits. The PC would be from us and my parents. Got a message from Dad yesterday and he’s asking for £500. He’s explained that he’d added everything up that he’s put in it and divided the cost between us, even though some of the parts were laying around in the back of a cupboard. Says he’s had to buy a couple of things, o e of which I know is less than £10. Too late to change our minds now as it’s already built. AIBU to be really pi**ed off? Feel like I’ve been conned by my own parents.

OP posts:
1VY · 08/08/2022 20:35

DS says he can give you an exact part list if you need one. But I’m not sure if that will help you if your dad has already bought the existing components and is not willing to return them.

SwanBuster · 08/08/2022 20:34

1VY · 08/08/2022 20:32

I asked my 14 year old son who has just built his own PC and this is what he said .

Both the cpu and motherboard are over 7 year old parts yet your father is charging you current prices.

You should get a ryzen 5 5600 CPU for £150 and a B550 motherboard for £120 for brand new parts.

Also using a £200 liquid cooler aio is massive over kill , he suggests getting a Noctua NH-D15 air cooler for £90 .

The graphics card is much cheaper than it should be, they are about £300 on eBay.

I think he is trying to give you very old parts for current market prices.

Your son knows what he's talking about 👍

SwanBuster · 08/08/2022 20:34

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 08/08/2022 20:30

Oo adding all that up at prices today from online store it comes ro just over 1500 for those parts pc parts are not cheap atm I am busy buying parts to upgrade my sons pc and its shocking the price increase I think tbh you probably over spent on hard drives never spent 400 quid on them ever and the monitor was also over priced so 650 and you expected your dad to pay over 1000 for his present since you only gave him a few 100 quid gaming pcs are expensive and the parts he has used are made from good brands that last

The parts are old. You cannot use modern price comparison websites to gauge them.

1VY · 08/08/2022 20:32

Glassback83 · 08/08/2022 16:57

This is what he sent me and doesn’t include what I bought. 4 x 8gb 3000mhz ram

59.47
1 x Gigabyte 1080ti GPU

  • 359.69 Coolermaster HAF XB Case
  • 203.00 Corsair Hydro H100 CPU Cooler - 80.00 Asus TUF Z270 Motherboard
  • 165.00 Intel Core i7-6700K CPU

61.00 900W Power Supply

50.00 PCI-E to USB 3 5Port Card

18.00 Windows 10 PRO

5.89
Sandisk 32Gb Windows10Pro ISO -
8.00

Total

  • 1010.05

Split cost between us

= Total each
£505.25
That will be our contribution.

I asked my 14 year old son who has just built his own PC and this is what he said .

Both the cpu and motherboard are over 7 year old parts yet your father is charging you current prices.

You should get a ryzen 5 5600 CPU for £150 and a B550 motherboard for £120 for brand new parts.

Also using a £200 liquid cooler aio is massive over kill , he suggests getting a Noctua NH-D15 air cooler for £90 .

The graphics card is much cheaper than it should be, they are about £300 on eBay.

I think he is trying to give you very old parts for current market prices.

LemonSwan · 08/08/2022 20:32

Pegasushaswings · 08/08/2022 20:21

I don’t even know why I’m reading this thread, I don’t understand any of it!

Lol same!

I have had so many sparkling spec computers die on me I am wondering what I am missing 🤣

Might just have to hijack the thread and ask for recommendations

I jest and don’t jest… if anyone wants to recommend an off shelf RELIABLE workhorse suitable to run Vectorworks Designer & Adobe full suite and that when it dies it dies slowly and doesn’t have a spontaneous kernel death then please do 🤣

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 08/08/2022 20:30

Oo adding all that up at prices today from online store it comes ro just over 1500 for those parts pc parts are not cheap atm I am busy buying parts to upgrade my sons pc and its shocking the price increase I think tbh you probably over spent on hard drives never spent 400 quid on them ever and the monitor was also over priced so 650 and you expected your dad to pay over 1000 for his present since you only gave him a few 100 quid gaming pcs are expensive and the parts he has used are made from good brands that last

SwanBuster · 08/08/2022 20:29

BelleHathor · 08/08/2022 20:24

Wonderful Child! And just wanted to say props for all the Ryzen love !

😁 You'll be very pleased to know then that even back then, that computer was AMD, not intel - a 386dx @ 40 MHz 😂

BelleHathor · 08/08/2022 20:24

SwanBuster · 08/08/2022 20:12

They looked a bit different when I was upgrading this in 1991 as a 12 year old.

I was a strange child though 😂

Wonderful Child! And just wanted to say props for all the Ryzen love !

Pegasushaswings · 08/08/2022 20:21

I don’t even know why I’m reading this thread, I don’t understand any of it!

SwanBuster · 08/08/2022 20:17

blisstwins · 08/08/2022 20:08

And that his grandfather customized it. If you can afford to pay the 500 without incurring debt it is a sweet thing and there won’t be a next time. Just story to be told some day after your dad is gone.

‘Do you remember when Dad tried to pass off his old components to us for £500 and then had a crisis of conscience? Happy times!'

SwanBuster · 08/08/2022 20:12

cloudygreyskies · 08/08/2022 19:56

It is beautiful.😍

They looked a bit different when I was upgrading this in 1991 as a 12 year old.

I was a strange child though 😂

Dad wants £500
blisstwins · 08/08/2022 20:08

tempester28 · 08/08/2022 17:32

It looks like a fairly decent spec and they are contributing £500 - you might not have decided to spend that much if buying one from Currys, but also wouldn't get as much for your money. If your son is playing games that take a lot to run he will appreciate a decent computer.

And that his grandfather customized it. If you can afford to pay the 500 without incurring debt it is a sweet thing and there won’t be a next time. Just story to be told some day after your dad is gone.

NoMichaelNo · 08/08/2022 20:06

The CPU, GPU and motherboard are quite old, a 3060TI is better and cheaper than a 1080TI for example.

The CPU is a old quad core, he could have got a 11th gen I5 or I7 for around the same money with much better performance or gone to AMD and saved even more money.

Why have you brought 4TB of SSD?

The case is a rip off, AIO is about right.

Honestly you've been conned.

SwanBuster · 08/08/2022 20:00

scintilla87 · 08/08/2022 19:54

Commenting purely in admiration of @SwanBuster ’s beautiful computer!

Thank you! I built the white one for a very good friends son in late 2020.

I gave him the GPU (a GTX 1080) because of the Graphics card shortage, he is still very happy - all in £620 with a Ryzen 3700x and 32gb ram, 2tb ssd etc. Amazon warehouse deals back then were wonderful!

HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 08/08/2022 19:58

Wow, with parents like these who needs in laws?

cloudygreyskies · 08/08/2022 19:56

It is beautiful.😍

scintilla87 · 08/08/2022 19:54

Commenting purely in admiration of @SwanBuster ’s beautiful computer!

Luredbyapomegranate · 08/08/2022 19:43

Can you just take back the hard drives you bought and buy one?

If you can that’s what I’d do.

If not then it’s good he’s climbed down.

SwanBuster · 08/08/2022 19:43

Frequency · 08/08/2022 19:33

When I was looking at building mine I researched a lot of GPUs as the prices for them back then were just silly so this was the most costly part. The 1080ti was struggling with some of the newer games played on the highest settings back then.

It's what I have in my system and tbh it's fine for me, I have no issues and won't be rushing out to upgrade it anytime soon, but I'm not a 16yo boy I play Sims 4 and watch YouTube and occassionally pretend to write some bits of code.

If OP's son is wanting to play the newer, graphics heavy games on ultra-high settings he might be dissapointed. That being said it will play most games on medium-high settings.

Motherboards I admit I know virtually nothing about. I understand they have different sockets and ports and some don't have wifi built in etc but other than that I wouldn't understand why a better quality motherboard would effect performance.

Its not about performance per se when it comes to motherboards. The problem is motherboards are built to support a certain cpu generation / architecture. They might support multiple generations like with Ryzen (you could use a B450 with a bios upgrade with Ryzen 5xxx) but especially with intel cpus they are generally a one gen thing.

hence why you would need to upgrade that in tandem with the CPU.

GPU wise, I maintain a 1080ti is a beast for almost any game (Cyberpunk excepted), just drop the resolution/settings a little. Sure, it would be nicer to have an RTX 3080 or a Radeon 6800, but then you’re spending 650-700 on that alone.

cloudygreyskies · 08/08/2022 19:42

Lemonswan you don’t want to buy such an old computer for gaming. This is meant to last him throughout uni. It’s not even suitable for Windows 11. Nothing wrong going for 2nd hand but you want the best spec you can.

5YearsLeft · 08/08/2022 19:40

SwanBuster · 08/08/2022 18:37

its good - but it misses important aspects which I mentioned.

the CPU - the 6700k being totally outdated in 2022 as a quad core.

the (in effect associated) motherboard - total rip off for such an old piece of tech. It would have been better to base the system around 5xxx gen Ryzen.

the GPU - a 1080ti is still a beast, but you can now get. 3060ti which outclasses it and is more modern (raytracing support) for a similar price.

Yes sorry @SwanBuster I know the thread has moved on, but obviously you know you’re absolutely correct re: the 1080 vs 3060. I just focused on the first items on the list OP’s dad sent her. When I saw over £300 for that case, I really didn’t even bother getting to the bottom of the list. That already answered the entire question for me, re: “am I being conned”: yes. If the first two items show you’re being conned, the next ten will, too. And the fact OP kept saying “hard drives” and £400, which sounds wrong from having to do hard drives over here recently (either you build new which requires one, or you update, which requires adding one, but you shouldn’t have to build new with two). I just had to update a PC over here, and I would really recommend that if anyone already owns a PC, you think about adding new parts vs. buying an all new machine. You’d be surprised how easy it is to switch things out now (and I’m NOT good with things like this at all), and you’ll get a lot more for your money, normally, especially since often, you only need to upgrade maybe one or two aspects of your computer. BUT I would look up all prices yourself before trusting anyone to just do it for you, without markup.

SwanBuster · 08/08/2022 19:36

LemonSwan · 08/08/2022 19:26

Just going on my experiences. Sure the performance is probably not anywhere as high as available now. But I would just rather reliability. The only way to know that is to buy an older model which didn’t spontaneously combust a day out of warranty.

Sure as a gaming computer this might affect his gameplay. But he would probably rather play a micro second in lag than not play at all and I doubt the friends he is playing with have the US super computer either. So it’s hardly dramatic.

There is absolutely no ‘might’ about it. A CPU / GPU combination can deliver a smooth experience and a given target frame rate for a given game at a given resolution, or it will not. It’s black and white.

Comparing a computer for gaming to one used for general productivity purposes is an apple and an orange comparison.

SwanBuster · 08/08/2022 19:33

QueenOfRap · 08/08/2022 19:19

No idea about computers but I’ve had similar with a family member over a bike. I hope you get it resolved OP🤞

I don’t need,, or want, a PC but reading the posts has made me really want @SwanBuster to build me one 🙈

Happily I would!

Dad wants £500
Dad wants £500
Dad wants £500
Frequency · 08/08/2022 19:33

When I was looking at building mine I researched a lot of GPUs as the prices for them back then were just silly so this was the most costly part. The 1080ti was struggling with some of the newer games played on the highest settings back then.

It's what I have in my system and tbh it's fine for me, I have no issues and won't be rushing out to upgrade it anytime soon, but I'm not a 16yo boy I play Sims 4 and watch YouTube and occassionally pretend to write some bits of code.

If OP's son is wanting to play the newer, graphics heavy games on ultra-high settings he might be dissapointed. That being said it will play most games on medium-high settings.

Motherboards I admit I know virtually nothing about. I understand they have different sockets and ports and some don't have wifi built in etc but other than that I wouldn't understand why a better quality motherboard would effect performance.

Wondersocks · 08/08/2022 19:31

Glassback83 · 08/08/2022 18:53

Think my mum might be the driving factor behind this.

😂 @Glassback83 why does your poor mother get blamed for this?

It’s good that he u-turned though, I doubt he was actually conning you, I know a few techie people and I see this happen time and time again with them. These are the steps in the process I’ve observed:

Step 1- “ that X is a silly price, it’s gets good reviews but half of that stuff you wouldn’t choose and it doesn’t even have -Y”

Step 2- “ I wonder what be the optimal X if you were to do it yourself, I probably have half of what I need lying around, and I have that really good Z that I need to do something with anyway”

Step 3- waaaaaay too much research and time spent on forums- now essentially decided they have to make the greatest X ever

Step 4- first round of purchases, one or two at least don’t play well with the other parts

Step 5- second round of purchases and now way off schedule

Step 6- waay off schedule, at least twice the price of the first X which was supposedly way over price, and enough processing power to run CERN, but the Microsoft office is not installed and there’s no microphone or camera because “it’s better to get those separately anyway”

Step 7- “doesn’t matter that i have all this extra bits because I can just use them in the next X project- will save a bit of time and money”

REPEAT

It probably will be a really good PC though, let’s hope your DS “gets it”