Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not make her go to dance camp

105 replies

partypingu · 08/08/2022 11:39

DD is 5 and refusing to go to dance / drama day camp.

I feel completely miserable, it's the only summer activity I've planned for her (apart from a trip to the seaside last week). Apart from the wasted money I am upset that's she's just hanging about doing nothing.

She doesn't want to see her friends, or go to the park, just to play at home / watch TV.

I know rationally that's she's only 5 and probably just needs to chill out at home but honestly it's been 3 weeks since school ended and there's another 3 weeks to go and should I let her just hang about at home the whole time? I'm limiting TV and we are going swimming every day but other than that she's doing absolutely nothing.

Her behaviour otherwise is excellent but I'm worried about her refusal to engage with anything / anyone.

I know I could force her to go but it feels wrong to make a 5 year old do a day long activity if they don't want to. Of course she would probably love it if she did go.

Can anyone talk some sense into me? If you are a more experienced parent can you tell me if any of this matters? I've lost perspective.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 08/08/2022 16:29

With some of the responses on this thread, I'm starting to see why some of my kids' friends are so reluctant to try anything new, and are just content to sit around on their tablets or watching tv all day. If they're never encouraged to try new things, how are they ever going to know if they like them? I'm firmly team let her be and let DS miss a day last week. He's tried drama for a few years from just before lockdown started so Inc zoom and then back to face to face (he found it boring), he tried just dance for about 5 months (he was shattered by the Friday class), we've been doing gymnastics for the last year, he did art classes at school and any art classes I can find, he's on his second week of summer school, next term he'd doing fitness class at school. He knows it's safe to try stuff because ci won't force him to go. It doesn't mean I let him off at the slightest whim, we talk about it and any consequences (so if you miss Tues, fine but if you don't go We'd, not Thurs trip)

EatingWormsMichael · 08/08/2022 16:29

My 7yo would prefer to stay at home too. I'm telling him to go to camp cos he seems to be OK once there, he has a fortnight to chill starting next week, and crucially I need to work this week.

He does have friends there which reassures me a bit.

He once did a camp aged 5 where he didn't know anyone and didn't seem to make friends and I felt bad about that at the time. He can't even remember it now though.

Why not see how she gets on at camp and take it day by day? She might love it and learn how to make new friends.

Plumtreebob · 08/08/2022 16:23

@partypingu - that’s a great reasoned response, I hope you find the right balance for you and your DD.

eddiemairswife · 08/08/2022 16:22

Why is it that people expect young children to be doing something all the time? If a parent is at home during the holidays, children should be playing with their toys, in the garden if it's fine, going to the shops with an adult, occasional days out at park or zoo' seeing local friends or relatives.

Goodskin46 · 08/08/2022 16:16

SleepingStandingUp · 08/08/2022 15:10

Out of interest, for any PP quoting her age as a reason she has to go, at what age would you say "well she's X age now so I'd listen to her"?

Honestly ?
From 12/13 earliest and even then I think DCs should be encouraged to continue with extra curricular activities.
DS is 18 and he says he wishes I'd pushed him harder to keep going with a couple of interests which he dropped in yr7/Yr 8.
I can only assume this child at some point showed some interest in dance for her to have been signed up to the camp. I have no truck with DCs chopping and changing at the 11th hour.
They need to learn to honour their commitments.

partypingu · 08/08/2022 16:15

I said she probably needed to chill out although I don't really see why as she's been off school for 3 weeks already with very little organised activity.

I didn't send her. I just couldn't justify upsetting a 5 year old over this. If she had asked for the club or agreed to it previously that would be different but it was my idea.

I will try and get her there tmw on the basis of if she doesn't like it she doesn't have to go back.

Thanks all. I was scared of AIBU but actually there's been a lot of thoughtful and interesting posts.

It has also reassured me that there isn't a right or wrong answer, I just need to judge when to push and when not to and it's hard.

In this case its not the end of the world if she doesn't go.

For completeness - it's dance and drama and very gentle and nurturing. My niece and other friends DDs have done it and enjoyed it. It's not going to be a tough day. But then, for her, being in a new place with new teachers is tough and I get that.

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 08/08/2022 16:11

SleepingStandingUp · 08/08/2022 15:09

Mine were lazy and wanted to do nothing. But they didn't need to do nothing and they don't need to do one day of dance club. She can ask again tomorrow and she may well want to go for not having been forced today.

I don't care if she goes or not. All I've said is that a 5yo shouldn't need to chill out for 6 weeks.

MarshaMelrose · 08/08/2022 16:06

@SleepingStandingUp
Your missing my point. You don't need to be stressed to enjoy chilling out.

But the op op said they needed to chill out. I was just quoting them.

Floofboopsnootandbork · 08/08/2022 16:06

drawacircleroundit · 08/08/2022 14:05

No negotiation - I’d make her go. I definitely wouldn’t say, “Just try it today” because she’ll play you like a pipe. In fact, if she is refusing to go, she already is.
if you let her win this one, forward 10 years and you have a school refuser.

I hated these sort of things when I was a child, my mum forced me into it for a few years until she realised I was just hiding in the toilet for most the day to avoid whatever activity I was being forced into. She gave in and finally let me “win” after a few years, didn’t turn me into a school refuser at all, I always had almost perfect attendance, but it sure as hell ruined my relationship with my mum.

20 odd years later and the thought of them still sends shivers down my spine 😂

Schooldil3ma · 08/08/2022 16:03

@partypingu did you send her, did she enjoy it?

BringOnSummerHolidays · 08/08/2022 16:00

Is this for childcare like a holiday club? Or is it run by a drama or dance school? If later I won’t force her. They are quite hardcore and tough work. Most the children that goes are quite into the activity. Maybe try a holiday club with multi sports and craft, drama and other stuff another time? They can pick things to do in those.

I have sent DC1 one to a musical theatre club and she didn’t like it. The girls in there are sing and dance too well for her to keep up.

Lovetogarden2022 · 08/08/2022 15:59

I would absolutely be sending her anyway

NCHammer2022 · 08/08/2022 15:55

My 4 year old has to be dragged to every new activity and, once there, has a great time and doesn’t want to come back. Dancing, swimming, visiting her new school, play dates, etc.

I’d make her go the first day and judge from there.

Dixiechickonhols · 08/08/2022 15:52

At 5 though having never been she doesn’t know if she will like it or not. It’s good for them to try new things. She might love it and want weekly lessons. She might not and so next holiday you try her at gymnastics or football camp.
It gives them confidence. When school does dance in pe next year she has some moves or when she goes to rainbows or swimming she sees Katie from dance camp and has a friend.

Comtesse · 08/08/2022 15:50

1 week out of 6 doing a dance camp is not unreasonable. It’s hardly going to lead to burnout if the rest of the time is pretty unstructured. 5 year olds are not very good at decision taking which is why parents are in charge. Plus it’s already paid for - I don’t like wasting money because a child “didn’t feel like it” (prepared to admit my lot never want to go out but if you push and shove and chivvy then they end up enjoying themselves).

drawacircleroundit · 08/08/2022 15:42

SleepingStandingUp · 08/08/2022 14:36

But why would you have forced them to go? Other than to assert yourself as the boss who can make people do whatever you want? I don't need the childcare, if he did he'd have gone. Presumably same for OP. He wasn't an integral cog in any network of cogs, so he wasn't letting the team down by say, not being able to play a game. It's meant to be his summer HOLIDAY where there's as much freedom as possible (because some People have cc to work etc) to enjoy his time. What do you get from forcing them to do something they don't want to beyond a power rush?

It’s not the power rush at all - I don’t crave such a thing - but it is the assertion.
I think we’re actually close to being on the same page; I do believe that kids should have down time, and I’ve been guilty in the past of shoehorning in piano, karate, athletics, trampolining…
I’d also have let my ones off if they had hated it - but I would not let them think that they had influenced this decision. When they were young, I wouldn’t let them think they had this influence.
Then, at about 11, I started letting them have a bit more autonomy. Piano was dropped, for example. Sneaky days off school once a year or so, when they weren’t actually that ill. But never, ever at their request.
Does that make sense? I suppose I went in hard young and now their autonomous decisions and pushing are reasonable. Not sure if that’s causation or correlation. But I see so many young kids with parents too afraid of conflict to parent, and too many teenagers with appalling disregard for authority that I might have overcompensated! The fact that your DS happily went back to the activity (if I remember the thread post) suggests that your relationship with him is lovely and the autonomy you are giving him is working well 😊

Dixiechickonhols · 08/08/2022 15:39

2bazookas · 08/08/2022 15:30

An all-day activity among strangers is quite a big ask of a 5 yr old.

But what else can you do. Mine had to do all sorts of camps as I worked. I tried to chose a mix so if she hated one it wasn’t 6 weeks of it.
The dance camp was run like school - drop off. Do a a dance class. Break. Do a dance class. Lunch (packed). Do craft. Break. Do a dance class and home. She didn’t know anyone but soon made friends, the girls running it were nice. They were themed and inc a party day and a little show at end. It was fun party dancing not hours of intense training.
Unless she’s been before she’ll have no idea if she likes it unless she tries.

Dalaidramailama · 08/08/2022 15:32

@trailrunner85

My daughter Irish dances during term time and she also competes which can involve a lot of travelling. Along with brownies and swimming this is the time of year she gets to just really chill out and she loves it.

2bazookas · 08/08/2022 15:30

An all-day activity among strangers is quite a big ask of a 5 yr old.

trailrunner85 · 08/08/2022 15:28

It would be non negotiable for me - she goes, gets waved off with a cheery smile, and if she absolutely hates it then she doesn't have to go again. But you at least give it a try.

With some of the responses on this thread, I'm starting to see why some of my kids' friends are so reluctant to try anything new, and are just content to sit around on their tablets or watching tv all day. If they're never encouraged to try new things, how are they ever going to know if they like them?

OP, by your own admission you're a "homebody" and that's fine. But your DD is five. She doesn't know what she likes yet. Don't default to just staying at home because it's the easy option. Yes, having some down time is important, but if this was her only summer activity other than swimming, I'd have at least make her try.

SleepingStandingUp · 08/08/2022 15:17

illiterato · 08/08/2022 15:14

I’m surprised people think swimming every day is too much for a 5 year old. I doubt she’s doing one mile of crawl. Probably just splashing round. Hardly exhausting. And if it is she probably needs more exercise, not less.

Tbh unless she's a total fish, it's more the repetitiveness of swimming seven days a week for weeks on end. By the time you're there, undressed in, out, redressed and home it's unlikely you're going for 20 minutes. Tbf it massively depends on how far away it is, what they do etc

Obv if it's ok their private pool and she just chicks dd into a cozy after bfast and let's her play for an hour, it's not quite so onerous 😂

illiterato · 08/08/2022 15:14

I’m surprised people think swimming every day is too much for a 5 year old. I doubt she’s doing one mile of crawl. Probably just splashing round. Hardly exhausting. And if it is she probably needs more exercise, not less.

Mascia · 08/08/2022 15:11

SleepingStandingUp · 08/08/2022 14:52

having so much stress in her life that she needs to chill out for 6 weeks at 5 chilling out isn't a reward for being stressed. It's part of the normal balance of life.

Fully agree with this.
I also don’t quite get all those people saying OP should force her daughter to go no matter what.

As for „if you let her off now you‘ll have to deal with a school refuser in 10 years“ - what kind of relationship will they have in 10 years if she keeps imposing her will on her daughter just to show her who’s in charge?

Of course five year olds don’t get to decide everything, but if my child preferred to stay at home during summer holidays and I didn’t need to send her for work reasons, I would let her stay at home.

SleepingStandingUp · 08/08/2022 15:10

Becky6758 · 08/08/2022 15:01

You have already paid for it and she’s 5.
Just take her.

Out of interest, for any PP quoting her age as a reason she has to go, at what age would you say "well she's X age now so I'd listen to her"?

SleepingStandingUp · 08/08/2022 15:09

Mine were lazy and wanted to do nothing. But they didn't need to do nothing and they don't need to do one day of dance club. She can ask again tomorrow and she may well want to go for not having been forced today.