Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents should stop their children talking on and on to people?

188 replies

CanIReadPls · 08/08/2022 10:30

I'm probably going to sound like an absolute Cruella Deville here but...

I was returning from abroad at the weekend. The flight was delayed and we ended up sat at the gate for a while.

There was a little girl of about 5 with her parents sat two rows in front facing me.

She came up to me and asked about a bracelet I had on - fine. Very sweet.

But then she was talking to me for agessssss. Question after question, telling me about her holiday, her birthday, her new toy and on and on. Her parents knew as well as they kept looking over to make sure she'd not disappeared.

I was very obviously reading a book. It ended up being a good half an hour, probably longer, before we were finally called to board and she went off to her parents.

AIBU to think you call your child back over to you once they've made a small amount of conversation with someone or is this totally acceptable to just leave your child going on and on at a stranger trying to read?!

I do have kids, I know they are chatterboxes sometimes and my own DC have asked people questions in the park or something before. But I'd always call them back over after a minute or two or say 'come on let the lady ready her book/walk her dog / get on with her day' or whatever.

I'd never just sit there whilst my child pestered someone for half an hour or AIBU?

OP posts:
FinneusMum · 08/08/2022 17:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

5zeds · 08/08/2022 17:46

Rather depends if OP asked the child to leave her in peace or just carried on chatting happily.

whumpthereitis · 08/08/2022 17:46

5zeds · 08/08/2022 17:28

@PuzzyGalore would you be equally proud of ignoring someone elderly or disabled? Would you assume that they were looking for you to be their “carer”. You were rude to someone and are proud of it. Why is that?

She wasn’t rude. She didn’t notice the kid, and even if she did it’s not rude to not want to be interrupted by a stranger unless it’s an obvious emergency.

anyway, she didn’t sound proud any more than she sounded ashamed (and I don’t see why she should be either), she’s just relaying an event.

whumpthereitis · 08/08/2022 17:41

5zeds · 08/08/2022 16:57

@whumpthereitis nah. I talk to all sorts of people and I’m not sure that’s the OPs issue. (I think) she’s fine with a quick chat but not with an extended one, so why not say so?

I have no problem saying something but clearly a lot of people feel awkward about it. A child is under the supervision of their parents, it’s on them to oversee and control what their child does, and not let them bother strangers (or at least not once superficial pleasantries have been exchanged).

SleepingStandingUp · 08/08/2022 17:35

5zeds · 08/08/2022 17:28

@PuzzyGalore would you be equally proud of ignoring someone elderly or disabled? Would you assume that they were looking for you to be their “carer”. You were rude to someone and are proud of it. Why is that?

Tbf it sounds like Puzzy didn't even clock the kid, not that she pretended she hadn't to piss off the Mom

Soproudoflionesses · 08/08/2022 17:34

PeanutButterOnToad · 08/08/2022 13:52

I’ve done my time as a parent of young kids, I don’t entertain other people’s any more. Tbh after a brief chat about the bracelet (because I’m not a total cow) I would just have said “sorry sweetie I’m reading my book” and ignored her.

This would be my approach too.

5zeds · 08/08/2022 17:28

@PuzzyGalore would you be equally proud of ignoring someone elderly or disabled? Would you assume that they were looking for you to be their “carer”. You were rude to someone and are proud of it. Why is that?

PuzzyGalore · 08/08/2022 17:18

whumpthereitis · 08/08/2022 14:28

I remember being sat in a service station in quite a bit of pain (I shouldn’t have been traveling at the time but didn’t really have too many other options), taking some time for myself because of said pain, and someone specifically came up to me to tap me on the shoulder and tell me off for ignoring his toddler that had apparently been trying to engage me. I hadn’t even seen or heard the kid as I had headphones on and my eyes closed. That one was definitely a WTF moment and I wasn’t particularly polite in my response to him.

IGiving a child free reign to bug other people is not on, no matter how ‘cute’ it may be for the parent/parents. That said, I don’t understand feeling awkward about telling a child to go back to their parents. An aspect of that may be a cultural thing though, fear of being seen as ‘rude’ (that’s an observation, rather than a criticism).

I had similar a few years back. Sat in a cafe with my DSis talking about something. When we left DSis said about a small boy who stood by the table for several minutes trying to impart some pearls of wisdom to us. The mother had apparently muttered about people ignoring small children and how unkind they were. My response, 'what child'. The mum was nearby and overhead and went puce with rage. Neither my DSis or I have any truck with providing free childcare for others

OhGoodnessItsSoExhausting · 08/08/2022 17:02

Well I think it's on you OP. Sometimes parents might think the adult is enjoying it.

This has happened to me a few times. Must be a little kid magnet! I don't mind 5 or 10 mins of kid chatter, but like you I get fed up after that. I normally say "you need to go back to mummy/daddy now". If it doesn't work I get a bit firmer "nice to talk to you but I'm going to read my book now so you need to go back to mummy/daddy. I'm not going to talk to you anymore now". If all else fails, just ignore!

SarahSissions · 08/08/2022 17:01

“what is this bracelet you are wearing”

Loud voice ”it’s a family heirloom from my great grandmother”

”why did she get it”

loud voice “the men at the docks liked her they wanted to buy her a present”

”why did they like her”

loud voice “she did favours for sailors”

”what kind of favours”….

Id play bingo, how far can I go before the parents step in

5zeds · 08/08/2022 16:57

@whumpthereitis nah. I talk to all sorts of people and I’m not sure that’s the OPs issue. (I think) she’s fine with a quick chat but not with an extended one, so why not say so?

Houseofbloodymen · 08/08/2022 16:56

The other day in a cafe my son (aged 1) approached a lady in the table next to me with a toy, she played with him for a good 5/10 minutes (interactive toy) I said please shout if he's annoying, honestly I'll take over if you're getting fed up, in the end I went and picked him up. As I felt embarrassed lol 😆

Aria2015 · 08/08/2022 16:54

YANBU. I have a chatterbox and I'm always mindful that he doesn't take up too much of someone's time chatting. I've also started teaching him about watching for 'signs' that people might not want to chat any more eg not asking questions back, keeping answers very short etc... Half an hour is way too long for a young child to monopolise the time of a stranger. I think its inconsiderate of the parents to allow it tbh.

NellesVilla · 08/08/2022 16:52

That would annoy me. I hate children and like cats, children know this, then pursue me. Can’t get away from them.

But OP, you’re the adult here. Do what I do next time with a: “Right, great to meet you. Must get back to my book now.” Do this loudly so the parents can hear and get the hint.

TokyoTen · 08/08/2022 16:47

I used to travel a lot for work - a rule of mine was never engage with kids! Otherwise you can't get rid of them!

InChocolateWeTrust · 08/08/2022 16:47

Yanbu. I regularly have to extract mine from bothering people. I try to point out to them that they need to spot if someone is reading/sleeping/listening on headphones/simply not interested

whumpthereitis · 08/08/2022 16:45

5zeds · 08/08/2022 16:31

Are you not understanding this 'person' is a young child

Young children aren't often known for reading social cues and actually buggering off when asked to.
well the “parenting” that needs doing is to teach the child how to “bugger off” when asked to. Which most 5 year olds can and do. So @CanIReadPls did you actually tell the child to leave you to read in peace, or that you didn’t want to talk any more?

Surely the parenting that needs doing is the parent watching their child and not letting them just wander up to and bother strangers?

Bobshhh · 08/08/2022 16:42

There is a child on our street who does this to me, literally waits by his door and if I walk past he runs out to chat and tell me about his day. He is very sweet but dear god it's hard to escape him!

Danceswithkids · 08/08/2022 16:37

BeanieTeen · 08/08/2022 12:53

YANBU.
I think it’s also weird to let your kids just go up to strangers to start a conversation.

Short of shutting her in a box there is no way of preventing my child from talking to everyone she sees. I do watch and immediately intervene if the person obviously isn't interested/doesn't respond, or give an 'out' for the person after a few minutes if they are being polite.

Most often people say it's fine though and let her talk! I often have to steer her away still rambling.

5zeds · 08/08/2022 16:31

Are you not understanding this 'person' is a young child

Young children aren't often known for reading social cues and actually buggering off when asked to.
well the “parenting” that needs doing is to teach the child how to “bugger off” when asked to. Which most 5 year olds can and do. So @CanIReadPls did you actually tell the child to leave you to read in peace, or that you didn’t want to talk any more?

Justleaveitblankthen · 08/08/2022 16:28

When my own DC were small, I used to get this all the time from other children in the area. They would make a beeline for me - much to my own DC's annoyance sometimes 😂
If it was ever not appropriate for whatever reason, I had no problem telling them to go back to their parents, "so they know you are OK. Off you pop now." Then don't engage further. Pretend you are making a phone call if you must I do this with people of all ages if I'm feeling anti-social

AnotherAnxiousMess · 08/08/2022 16:00

YANBU. It wouldn't bother me, especially if all I had to do was sit and wait somewhere. But, if it was my child, I'd definitely call them over after a few minutes and say to let the lady read her book or whatever... I love that kids have the confidence to just go up to anyone and chat away, but they also need to learn when a person has had enough and isn't interested, just leave them alone.

CruCru · 08/08/2022 15:23

I expect the other parents were enjoying a few minutes of peace. Or they genuinely think their children are so special that everyone loves talking to them.

I remember this happening to me and a friend in a pub. We asked the child to go back to his parents nicely then told him to more forcefully. Nope - he wasn’t going to take instructions from us. The dad did come over to check he was okay but spotted he was sitting with two girls and scooted back to where he’d been sitting.

I’d have gone over to the parents but we were 17 so didn’t want to make a fuss in case we got chucked out (it was the mid 90s). So we ended up going somewhere else. Shame because we had a really nice table.

raisinghell · 08/08/2022 15:12

girlfriend44 · 08/08/2022 12:44

why didnt you put your book down and chat to her and the family. It never ceases to amaze me how people can chat on forums but dont want to make conversation with ppl in real life.

You can read your book in bed or another time.

What a ridiculous comment. I don't know where to start...

CulturePigeon · 08/08/2022 15:00

Oh yes, OP, most definitely.

There's a great cartoon by Posy Simmonds which I wish I had the skills to upload where a child on a train is boring the pants of several other adults about Harry Potter while the parent is happily reading her magazine.

Far from being mean-spirited, I think it's neglectful to let your children ramble on and on - they need to be taught (tactfully and gently) the skill of conversation. No-one needs to be mean - it just needs parents to interject, perhaps to ask the other adult a question etc. I always get stuck with little kids nattering, and I was at one time a teacher, so it really was a busman's holiday. Sorry - don't mean to sound conceited, but I think I was pretty good at listening to children and unfortunately this got me stuck a few times.

It's lovely when children to engage in conversation with adults, but they need supervision to learn the skill of 'they speak/the other person speaks'. They need to learn to listen too as well as chatter. It's particularly important because children often obsess about a particular interest (quite natural) and boy, it can be hard work responding or trying to change the subject.