Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents should stop their children talking on and on to people?

188 replies

CanIReadPls · 08/08/2022 10:30

I'm probably going to sound like an absolute Cruella Deville here but...

I was returning from abroad at the weekend. The flight was delayed and we ended up sat at the gate for a while.

There was a little girl of about 5 with her parents sat two rows in front facing me.

She came up to me and asked about a bracelet I had on - fine. Very sweet.

But then she was talking to me for agessssss. Question after question, telling me about her holiday, her birthday, her new toy and on and on. Her parents knew as well as they kept looking over to make sure she'd not disappeared.

I was very obviously reading a book. It ended up being a good half an hour, probably longer, before we were finally called to board and she went off to her parents.

AIBU to think you call your child back over to you once they've made a small amount of conversation with someone or is this totally acceptable to just leave your child going on and on at a stranger trying to read?!

I do have kids, I know they are chatterboxes sometimes and my own DC have asked people questions in the park or something before. But I'd always call them back over after a minute or two or say 'come on let the lady ready her book/walk her dog / get on with her day' or whatever.

I'd never just sit there whilst my child pestered someone for half an hour or AIBU?

OP posts:
orangetriangle · 08/08/2022 21:50

I'm going to go against the grain here and say it personally doesnt bother me talking to children love kids mine are grown up now
However I would not let mine out of my sight to talk to strangers for any length of time if at all my daughter when young would talk to all and sundry if you let her but equally she was very nervous if getting lost etc
As a child in the 70s I would chat to all and su dry I must have been downright annoying !!!

Darbs76 · 08/08/2022 21:29

I’d have definitely called mine back or gone over and said come on now the lady is busy reading her book. It is quite rude to just allow her to talk for 30 full mins

whumpthereitis · 08/08/2022 21:27

5zeds · 08/08/2022 21:11

I think I’d expect her to manage to tell a five year old that she wanted to read her book…but then I’m from “the east”.🤣

and yet you wouldn’t bother to keep control of your stranger-bothering offspring so she wasn’t disturbed in the first place.

5zeds · 08/08/2022 21:11

I think I’d expect her to manage to tell a five year old that she wanted to read her book…but then I’m from “the east”.🤣

whumpthereitis · 08/08/2022 21:09

5zeds · 08/08/2022 20:58

Children may be welcome, but they’re also expected to behave in a certain way, appropriate for where they are

A lot of countries ‘in the east’ are also much, much more direct in communicating and speaking their mind, and it’s not considered rudeness.

True. So OP could have expected to say she didn’t want to talk.

Except OP’s not in the monolith known as ‘the east’, and is loathe to appear rude. She also, reasonably, expects people to oversee their children and not expect a stranger to entertain them.

PuzzyGalore · 08/08/2022 20:59

5zeds · 08/08/2022 20:46

Manners usually include being aware of your surroundings and others, but I read your post as you had ignored the child on purpose. If it was just you once overlooked a child and it’s mother was upset, then I don’t really get it but I can see it wasn’t meant.

I would never ignore a small child on purpose but just don't notice them. I'm very short sighted so a small blurry shape isn't going to make much of an impression on me. If he or she is screaming at me yeah will notice but in that case I would expect the parent to remove it

5zeds · 08/08/2022 20:58

Children may be welcome, but they’re also expected to behave in a certain way, appropriate for where they are

A lot of countries ‘in the east’ are also much, much more direct in communicating and speaking their mind, and it’s not considered rudeness.

True. So OP could have expected to say she didn’t want to talk.

rainbowmilk · 08/08/2022 20:56

“The east” is often trotted out on here as if large swathes of the globe are identikit countries with the exact same approach to children (see also “continental Europe”). I’ve lived in Japan and children there are typically expected to be quiet and not bother people. I never saw people being expected to chat to a random person’s kid whilst they were on their phone - it’d be the height of bad manners.

whumpthereitis · 08/08/2022 20:47

5zeds · 08/08/2022 20:25

I find England very intolerant to kids, Scotland and Wales less so. Then basically the further east I’ve gone the more welcoming people have been. I honestly don’t understand why you can’t just ask anyone not to talk to you if you don’t want to interact with them.

Where further east? Because I’m from one of the countries in ‘the east’, and outside of holiday resorts where they kinda have to smile sweetly and tolerate whatever, there really isn’t this mythical idyll of a country where children are never criticised and are always welcome. Actually, I can think of a lot of eastern countries where the people are stereotyped as abrasive, cold, and standoffish.

Children may be welcome, but they’re also expected to behave in a certain way, appropriate for where they are. The old lady in Greece that smiles and coos at a child is the same one that wouldn’t hesitate scold said child if they saw them misbehaving. You can bet parents would take an issue with that here.

A lot of countries ‘in the east’ are also much, much more direct in communicating and speaking their mind, and it’s not considered rudeness. I consciously have to code switch depending on whether I’m in the UK or my birth country.

5zeds · 08/08/2022 20:46

Manners usually include being aware of your surroundings and others, but I read your post as you had ignored the child on purpose. If it was just you once overlooked a child and it’s mother was upset, then I don’t really get it but I can see it wasn’t meant.

PuzzyGalore · 08/08/2022 20:26

5zeds · 08/08/2022 17:28

@PuzzyGalore would you be equally proud of ignoring someone elderly or disabled? Would you assume that they were looking for you to be their “carer”. You were rude to someone and are proud of it. Why is that?

I was completely unaware of the child. I was with my DSis and having a conversation with her. Why would I be looking around for passing random children who might want to talk to me.

I have always been taught to give the person I am talking to my full attention. Don't you or are you one of those people who is always looking your phone, the contents of your hanky, etc?

5zeds · 08/08/2022 20:25

I find England very intolerant to kids, Scotland and Wales less so. Then basically the further east I’ve gone the more welcoming people have been. I honestly don’t understand why you can’t just ask anyone not to talk to you if you don’t want to interact with them.

happinesslovescompany · 08/08/2022 20:25

Honestly I still feel like a proper CF. In 1983 we took our kids to Tenerife for a paupers holiday (all we could afford to eat was boiled eggs, bread and jam). Our most chatty child was placed next to newly weds on the return flight. We were happy that they were experiencing how clever our girl was. It's only in later life that we know they're probably on Mumsnet saying how their honeymoon was ruined by the chatty kid. If you read this we are truly, truly sorry! We're now proper old fuckers now and the kids can't be arsed but we still KNOW WE WERE WRONG!

Longingforatikihut · 08/08/2022 19:44

It's not just children.

I love to relax with a book and a cream tea in a quaint little cafe on my holidays alone. Unfortunately sitting alone seems to signal to wait staff that I could do with some company and despite what MN says, No is not considered an acceptable sentence so I get some jibbering biddy plonked next to me who I don't know from Adam and my afternoon is ruined. I would be more tolerant of sharing my table if they could just stfu and let me read my book.

A certain cafe in Bakewell refused to let me sit alone twice so now I don't go there.

whumpthereitis · 08/08/2022 19:38

Buttercupsx · 08/08/2022 19:17

You need to reread my original post. I did not say mumsnetters are becoming ‘like men’. I mentioned the levels of hate for children being almost as comparable to the hate for men (on this forum). It was an observation.

No one said you have to perform like a seal and I never suggested you should.

I mentioned our cultural attitude towards, what you are keen to call, strangers. It’s ok, I get where you are coming from. You’ve made it crystal clear.

At least I’ve got clarity going for me I suppose.

Yes, strangers, people with whom one is not familiar. it’s an accurate descriptor. Actually Brits on a whole I find quite polite, to the point where there’s an inclination to tolerate a lot more discomfort than they actually want to, for fear of being direct and seeming rude. Definitely not the most standoffish, culturally. Not by a long shot.

doctorboo · 08/08/2022 19:35

I went away for one night a couple of months ago, child free, first time in 11 years and I couldn’t wait for a quiet lunch, dinner and overnight stay.

At lunch time the waiter sat me out on the terrace - all seemed very relaxing until two small children popped up who just wouldn’t leave me alone.
I was initially polite but ended up speaking to their mum and explaining that it was my first night away from my own children and that I wanted a quiet lunch.
She told me that it was “their special day too” and she didn’t call them back until their own meal arrived.

I should have moved inside for the ‘peace and quiet’ but didn’t want to sit inside on a sunny day.

JudgeJ · 08/08/2022 19:29

BogdashinaO · 08/08/2022 10:33

I feel it was completely on you to bring the conversation to an end. Not too quickly though, it's a wonderful social skill that my DC mainly lack.

Making a nuisance of yourself is not a 'social skill', only a dopey parent would allow their child to go and pester a random person,

dottymac · 08/08/2022 19:21

You are absolutely not being unreasonable, and the parents obviously just needed some peace from their kid for a bit 🥴😄

WinterMusings · 08/08/2022 19:19

CanIReadPls · 08/08/2022 10:33

I get that but I'd still call them back and then if the person said 'oh don't worry' or whatever I may let them carry on a bit longer. But I'd still always call them so I didn't seem like I was leaving my kid to natter on at them 🤣

@CanIReadPls

But that can come across as you don't like the look of the person & think you need to protect your child from them.

it is awkward to disentangle yourself sometimes, but you had the perfect 'prop' your book. Very easy to say 'it's been lovely chatting with you, but I'm going to read my book now'.

kids are blunt, they accept blunt. They're far less complicated than adults.

Smileyoriley · 08/08/2022 19:19

YANBU. From a mother of four.

Buttercupsx · 08/08/2022 19:17

You need to reread my original post. I did not say mumsnetters are becoming ‘like men’. I mentioned the levels of hate for children being almost as comparable to the hate for men (on this forum). It was an observation.

No one said you have to perform like a seal and I never suggested you should.

I mentioned our cultural attitude towards, what you are keen to call, strangers. It’s ok, I get where you are coming from. You’ve made it crystal clear.

Tiani4 · 08/08/2022 19:07

Being social doesn’t mean you have to perform like a seal each and every time someone wants to interact with you. You can be an absolute social butterfly, a picture of decorum, and still want to be left the fuck alone at times.

This ^

Topseyt123 · 08/08/2022 19:06

girlfriend44 · 08/08/2022 12:44

why didnt you put your book down and chat to her and the family. It never ceases to amaze me how people can chat on forums but dont want to make conversation with ppl in real life.

You can read your book in bed or another time.

When I am sitting down reading a book then surely that means I wish to be left alone, not spend ages chatting drivel to random children of strangers!!

OP should have firmly told the child to go back to her parents after the first couple of minutes. If the child didn't take the hint then she should have taken them back and asked the parents to keep control of their child rather than letting them go up and accost others.

Tiani4 · 08/08/2022 19:05

Yanbu OP to have felt fed up if the child didn't listen to you suggesting she went back to her parents as you wanted to sit and read. I bet the parents thought they were giving you a gift if their DCs company when it was really just a gift of endless inane questions and noise!

Sometimes you just want peace and quiet whilst you wait

My ex MIL used to say - after about half hour - to my DCs (her only DGC) when we visited her (!!) "I'm going to read my book now. I'm done talking so go find your Mum"
Lol even when her son (my ex H, was there!)

She was maybe a bit extreme but I learnt something from her which is to be upfront when you're not interested and need quiet time.
I will hoopla chat for bit but have said "I'm too tired to talk and want to sit quietly, off you go now back to your parents" to other peoples DCs jabbering on when I'm tired, had enough and have a headache. Unfortunately my DCs used to attract other DCs clinging on who would follow us around so I had lots of practice saying "Off you go now"

I was Shock at the child that tried to take food off of a PPs plate earlier whilst still talking at them !!

How rubbish were their parents to let their DCs constantly bug other people on tables out for a quiet meal together ?!! I'd be straight over to remove my child if they were bugging other people!

xJoyfulCalmWisdomx · 08/08/2022 19:03

girlfriend44 · 08/08/2022 12:44

why didnt you put your book down and chat to her and the family. It never ceases to amaze me how people can chat on forums but dont want to make conversation with ppl in real life.

You can read your book in bed or another time.

A good book is better than a boring conversation with a stranger's 5 year old. Be honest.

Swipe left for the next trending thread