Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it OK to refuse a gift?

65 replies

MeerCat11 · 07/08/2022 21:43

Hello, and thanks to any soul giving me advice on this: my husband and I are from different countries, which means our family issues oftentimes are complicated by cultural differences. We met in his country, decided to live for a few years in my country and after some time we agreed life will be easier if we stayed in his home country.

During the years when we lived in my country and lived close to my family, we (better said I) were learning how to set boundaries and I oftentimes failed. So I know how is his position now difficult.

Part of it was my birthday celebrations with extended family. After the last one, I told my husband I want no extended family party ever. That means him and me for sure, maybe friends for a couple of drinks, but otherwise, I want my birthday to come and pass without significant notice. I work a high-stress job, being an immigrant is anything but fun and I really would like to limit drama of any kind. My husband and mother-in-law's birthday was last month. When MIL started to count who has a birthday next and came to mine, I chimed in I am not going to celebrate mine. She laughed.

Now, I do not have a good relationship with MIL, but I am working hard to keep it neutral. We are two very different women, some of her traits are clashing with my values. I believe I am not her favorite daughter-in-law either, but we still see each other on weekly basis and manage to be civilized around each other.

Well, now the birthday is coming and she is asking my husband what I want for a birthday gift. He is really trying, however, she does not take no for the answer. Her stance is, that she likes to give gifts and she will give me one no matter what. He warned her that I am serious and I will reject the gift since I said I want nothing and I would feel very disrespected.

I did research the topic of rejecting a gift and seems that it is actually not the thing polite people do. None of the topics though take into account the possibility of a no-gift policy, so would I be unreasonable, if I was given something and would politely decline it?

I know getting a gift is not the end of the world, but I would love, for once, to see through with having the boundaries finally up and functioning. It starts with a gift here, a little thing there, and then we are back to the family drama, right (or AIBU)?

Once again, thank you for reading and for your opinions!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LookItsMeAgain · 08/08/2022 10:21

If she gives you something for you, as in not food that could be shared or flowers, then thank her for the gift, hang on to it for a week or so and either return it to the shop or donate it to a charity shop.
If she asks what you want, tell her that you're asking everyone to donate to a chosen charity in your name and you would really like her to donate there as you have all that you need or want at the moment.
Both are acceptable ways to deal with a pushy MiL when you've said you don't want any fuss.

johnd2 · 08/08/2022 08:53

With gifts, they decide what to offer and you decide what to do with it.
I would ask for money ie a tenner as it's the least tricky thing. Or failing that a gift card for a supermarket you go to.

Hollychristmasjoy · 08/08/2022 07:48

Just accept the gift and stop being so dramatic.

Skelligsfeathers · 08/08/2022 07:23

I cam see why you are not the favourite daughter in law. Bloidy gell.

Thefruitbatdancer · 08/08/2022 07:14

I think the op likes to think that they're is extra special by not celebrating her birthday like the rest of us plebs. She goes to great lengths to explain her situation, culture clash, values etc as if nobody else has every experienced it.

Bien22 · 08/08/2022 07:13

Never look a gift horse in the mouth. i really wouldn’t make this your boundary unless you don’t want to communicate with her at all anymore. Accept the gift, donate it but try to be gracious here.

i understand that you may feel disrespected as she is not accepting your wishes but this time s not the hill to die on. 💐

luxxlisbon · 08/08/2022 06:56

I really have no idea what being an immigrant or having a stressful job really has to do with any of this. You keep saying you want to avoid drama, while clearly creating and stirring up situations which cause drama.
You see your MIL weekly, it is a cultural norm (for many cultures) for her to buy her son’s husband a birthday gift.
Just say thank you and move on with your day. Literally no drama involved.

saraclara · 08/08/2022 06:54

What everyone else said. If you don't want drama, then don't create it.

berksandbeyond · 08/08/2022 06:52

I also find it hard to believe you work a stressful high powered job and yet cannot see that you cannot control everyone else's actions, only your reaction to them.
Let her buy you something, your power comes in how you deal with it next - off to the charity shop or a food bank or a women's shelter it goes?

Darbs76 · 08/08/2022 06:51

It’s the height of rudeness to reject a gift. Don’t do it if you want to continue to have a civil relationship

berksandbeyond · 08/08/2022 06:50

You're giving her too much power.
Graciously accept the gift and then donate it to charity the next day.

Thefruitbatdancer · 08/08/2022 06:49

The one year MIL misses her birthday will be the year the OP complains that she didn't get a gift........

Why didn't you post that you don't want people to waste money on you & ask how to do it graciously without the back story of an immigrant, values & high stress job. This isn't a culture clash issue, this is you creating drame where there doesn't need to be one.

maddy68 · 08/08/2022 06:46

Wow. Just accept the gift graciously like a normal person

You don't have to have a party but a mil not giving a Dil a gift would be awful be grateful

Shoxfordian · 08/08/2022 06:38

She’s asking what you might want which is a good start- I think the charity thing is a little odd; maybe don’t say that- is there a book you would like, a lipstick, a perfume? Just give your husband suggestions for his mum

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 08/08/2022 06:34

For someone who hates drama, you certainly seem to like making it.

Yes, it's rude to refuse a gift. It won't hurt you in any way to smile and say "thank you MIL, that's lovely", will it?

diamondpony80 · 08/08/2022 06:21

cansu · 07/08/2022 23:01

You are actually creating drama not avoiding it!

Yeah, this.

I don't see how difficult it can be to just smile and say thanks if someone gives you a gift (even if you said you didn't want it). Declining a gift is rude when someone went to the trouble of buying one for you.

If you really don't want it, just accept graciously and then later donate it to a charity shop.

cariadlet · 08/08/2022 05:49

I understand where you are coming from. I don't like a fuss and have too much stuff already so don't want presents.

I know family feel weird about not getting me anything at all so I've asked for charity donations for the last few years.

My parents and sister have been fine about it but when I told my MIL that that's what I'd like, she got very stroppy with me for telling her what she should give me.

She's always asked my dd what she'd like for her birthday or Christmas but for some reason, she was offended when I did the same thing. 🙄

No point getting worked up over it. It's rude to refuse a gift so I accept whatever she gives me graciously and I think you will have to do the same.

Midlifemusings · 08/08/2022 05:49

For someone who doesn't want drama, you are actively creating it. You can't say you don't want drama and then make choices and decisions to create drama.

I am not sure if you are saying you will never attend any extended family party ever or just not for your own birthday. Are you never going to ever accept a gift again from anyone? Will you have a meltdown if your own family sends you birthday wishes on your birthday when you have decided it will not be celebrated?

Creating rigid rules about how others must act so you can get mad when they don't do as you told them is drama.

portinahurry · 08/08/2022 05:43

So much drama and mental space wasted on this. If she doesn't get you a gift she'll worry you didn't mean it, she's kind of obliged to get you something given your difficult relationship. Just say thank you and pass it on to someone else. If you can get a charity donation even better.

RedHelenB · 08/08/2022 05:22

Ever heard of the phrase " choose your battles"? You're being very weird about your birthday tbh.

zen1 · 08/08/2022 04:56

Refusing to accept your MIL’s gift will not help with keeping your relationship with her at a neural level - it will just create more bad feeling. By all means do what you wish with the gift, but don’t create tension by making a song and dance of not accepting it.

Mally100 · 08/08/2022 04:36

Fgs you are going out of your way to make an issue out of absolutely nothing. It is exceptionally rude to refuse a gift. Donate it, throw it away or do whatever but don't be so difficult just to make some ridiculous point.

Jenny70 · 08/08/2022 03:04

The other good thing about asking for a donation to charity, is that if she decides she wants to give you something else (hand cream, scarf, clothing, book), you can say thankyou the XYZ charity will really appreciate this... showing that you are accepting the gift, but also that your charity statement is heard as well.

melj1213 · 08/08/2022 00:13

For someone who doesn't want drama you're turning this into a very unnecessary one!

A stressful job and being an immigrant are not reasons to refuse a birthday gift - I have had a stressful job in a foreign country during a busy time of my work year and hate being the centre of attention so insisted on no big birthday bash but I still graciously accepted the few gifts friends and relatives kindly gave me when they saw me in the week or so of my birthday. It caused zero drama and zero fuss for them to hand over a gift and say "This is for your birthday,"; me to say "Thank you" and then continue on with our day.

Your MIL sounds lovely, she clearly wants to do something to mark your birthday - in my family even if people ask for no party/fuss then we still get them a card and small gift as an acknowledgement as it just feels wrong to almost pretend it hasn't happened - so just give her suggestions of things you need/want: the latest book in the series you're reading, your favourite flowers, your favourite brand of chocolate/wine/foodstuff, a new fountain pen to replace your current one, a charity you donate to etc and then everyone gets what they want - your MIL gets to feel she has acknowledged your birthday and you get something practical.

marvellousmaple · 08/08/2022 00:10

Weird!

Swipe left for the next trending thread