Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to say that DS should have the spare room?

167 replies

SplunkPostGres · 07/08/2022 21:41

I’ve just had the second anxious call at bedtime from DS at his Dad’s house. He has to sleep on inflatable mattress in the living room because his Fathers daughter (18) from his first marriage is sleeping in the spare room.

This always happens. He doesn’t have a proper room at his Dad’s because it’s kept as a spare room. Whenever both children are there, it’s always DS who sleeps in the lounge. Tonight they’re packing for a holiday tomorrow and DS with a bad knee can’t go to bed until they do. He is 9. He has ASD. He needs to go to bed. And I’m 250 miles away and unable to do anything about it.

AIBU to say that DS should have a proper bed at his Dad’s house?

OP posts:
Endlesslypatient82 · 08/08/2022 06:07

Midlifemusings · 08/08/2022 06:03

There was a reent thread on the stepparent forum and the consensus was that a child coming EOW and holidays absolutely does not need a bedroom or a bed and that a sofa or airmattress is perfectly fine. The view was that they have a bed and bedroom at their primary home and don't need two or any dedicated space at the second home when they are only there a few nights a month.

Interesting how different the views are on this thread that the child should be prioritized and given a bed / bedroom / space.

Given the absolute upheaval to the child’s life in this scenario (500 mile round journey every other weekend FFS) - I think the poor chap deserves a decent sleeping space upon arrival.

i can’t get my head around this 9 year old child doing a 1000 miles of travelling every 4 weeks.

Midlifemusings · 08/08/2022 06:03

There was a reent thread on the stepparent forum and the consensus was that a child coming EOW and holidays absolutely does not need a bedroom or a bed and that a sofa or airmattress is perfectly fine. The view was that they have a bed and bedroom at their primary home and don't need two or any dedicated space at the second home when they are only there a few nights a month.

Interesting how different the views are on this thread that the child should be prioritized and given a bed / bedroom / space.

Endlesslypatient82 · 08/08/2022 05:56

SplunkPostGres · 07/08/2022 21:46

She doesn’t live with her Dad. She’s a uni student who lives with her mum outside term time. It’s convenient for an airport run as she’s also going on holiday tomorrow but not the same destination as them.

contact schedule is standard eow and half holidays. I hate these two weeks in the summer as it’s a really long time for him.

Let me get this straight

EOW your young son has to do a 500 round journey to his father’s?

Endlesslypatient82 · 08/08/2022 05:55

Your poor poor son has to regularly do a 500 mile journey to visit his father and sleep in the lounge.

what an absolute shit show

Ottersmith · 08/08/2022 05:44

Ugh this sounds awful for you and your son. He should absolutely have the spare room and his Dad sounds like a dick. Is he abusive? If I was you I would log these incidents and see if you can change the contact situation after this holiday. If a child refuses to go for their visitation then there isn't much the courts can do about it as long as the mother was seen to try to persuade them. Next time he has to visit if he gets upset before having to go I would record it as proof that it is his personal choice and not you stopping him. Isn't it true that after a certain age they have to take the child's view into account.

SpidersAreShitheads · 08/08/2022 05:30

Anxiety can be an absolute bastard with ASD. Those suggesting a 9 yr old child should just suck it up and learn that it's just the way of the world have absolutely no fucking idea how bad things can get.

I've had my autistic child sobbing down the phone and desperate for me to come home (wildly different circumstances but still separation anxiety/needed the reassurance of me being there).

Sleeping in a blow-up bed isn't the issue although the change of sleeping arrangements may be tough. But expecting a 9yr old ASD child not to be able to stick to their normal sleeping time/routine and instead to wait up until everyone else has gone to bed will absolutely cause chaos and significant distress.

Obvs the relationship between OP and her ex has broken down - she says the ex won't even let DS speak to her on his birthday. I don't think it's a huge leap to suggest that the ex isn't properly considering DS's needs and instead is intent on punishing OP. I wonder how much he genuinely wants the contact or whether it's about depriving OP of it. Pure speculation obvs, but just based on the snippets of information here, he doesn't seem to especially put his child's needs first.

I probably would have gone and got DS now, but that's me. I understand why OP didn't and probably in the long term it's better that she didn't. I am pretty sure that DS won't tell someone at the airport to call his mum, even if he's upset. Just the idea of DS being in a different country though - Jesus, that's hard. If he has a total meltdown there's no way to reach him, you'll just have to wait it out til he's back. Listening to an autistic meltdown is horrible, it's so distressing - and depending on the child, it can go on for hours.

By the way, the PP who called it a "tantrum" at the airport can fuck right off. Go and educate yourself about autism.

OP, hopefully things are calmer in the morning. Once DS is en route he might feel OK. Sometimes the lead up to events and all the changes are the hardest but when he's there, the excitement and fun might take over.

But absolutely agree with @PyongyangKipperbang - keep everything as evidence and go and get legal advice. I think the visitation rights need to be looked at again. A diagnosis of ASD makes everything very different and if your ex can't or won't consider his additional needs, then the same contact may not be appropriate.

Hope you're OK.

ColdLasagna99 · 08/08/2022 04:05

If I were the 18 year old, I would have probably offered to move, but she probably doesn’t know how much your DS’s ASD affects him. Dad should have moved himself.

tillytown · 08/08/2022 01:46

I don't understand the pp who was calling the 18 year old selfish, it's the Dads responsibility to find a solution, not her. He should be the one giving up his bed and sleeping on the sofa, not her

clpsmum · 08/08/2022 01:07

Why can't he sleep with his dad or him sleep in dads room and dad have the sofa?

BungleandGeorge · 08/08/2022 01:05

Quitelikeit · 08/08/2022 00:51

And incase anyone is in doubt when you criticise the other parent to your child you do hurt their heart and mind. Best not to do it

when they are older ( 18+) yes but not when they are young!!!

please just don’t do it to satisfy yourself because they won’t understand it or be able to process it

Where has she done this? She reassured him he’d have fun on holiday? She’s complained about the father to other adults not the child. Tbh he doesn’t sound like dad of the year or that he’s interested in a positive relationship with OP, he refuses to let the child ring her if she steps out of line.

sashh · 08/08/2022 01:02

You are right OP he needs his own bed and to be able to go to it to de stress.

My spare room has a single bed with a pull out bed under so it can be a single, a double or two singles. Something like that or bunks would allow his sister a bed when she visits.

It's not ideal but better than this.

BungleandGeorge · 08/08/2022 00:56

I think you’re getting a bit of a hard time. The onus for caring for and reassuring your son really lies with his father and not you. He should have realised the boy was in pain, and that he was upset and that keeping him up past 10 because they are still packing and disturbing him was likely to cause distress. Not an easy situation for you being hundreds of miles away and having to deal
with your sons distress over the phone, that’s his fathers job. I do agree telling him to approach a stranger at the airport and saying you’d pick him up were unwise. For a start how can you follow through if the airport is hundreds of miles away, they’ll have taken off by the time you got there! And obviously you can’t go past the check in area without a ticket. Did your son agree to the holiday? Is it something suitable that he’ enjoy?

Quitelikeit · 08/08/2022 00:52

I don’t mean criticise but to tell the truth

Quitelikeit · 08/08/2022 00:51

And incase anyone is in doubt when you criticise the other parent to your child you do hurt their heart and mind. Best not to do it

when they are older ( 18+) yes but not when they are young!!!

please just don’t do it to satisfy yourself because they won’t understand it or be able to process it

endofthelinefinally · 08/08/2022 00:47

It is the 18 yr old's dad. Not her step dad.

DuchessDarty · 08/08/2022 00:40

The priority in my opinion WRT who slept where tonight is the DS's ASD.

This is a boy who will naturally be anxious at change. He already has a big change and environment he doesn't know coming up - the holiday tomorrow.

Having him sleep in the living room instead of in the guest room where he usually does is another change. Proper parenting of a child with ASD means limiting the amount of change they have to experience at once. Your Ex should have allowed his son to sleep in the spare room as per his normal arrangement, and given his bedroom to his daughter and slept in the living room himself. Or asked his daughter if she'd mind sleeping in the living room as a one off. She's old enough to understand.

I don't think it was the best move telling you son to tell someone at the airport if he doesn't want to go on holiday. You should tell him to tell his father.

I'd call your ex tomorrow and say you're calling to say have a good trip and can you speak to DS, and I'd remind your Ex that a new environment/change in routine will mean your DS is more anxious than normal. Be positive with your son - acknowledge his anxiety and say that it's normal but point out that he may find some of the things on holiday exciting.

When they get back, you need to think about having a talk with your ex about how you both handle your DS's ASD. That may include taking action to change the contact order.

maddening · 08/08/2022 00:38

His dad should either have a bed in his room or let ds have his room if dd is in the spare, particularly as ds goes to bed earlier

Kite22 · 08/08/2022 00:33

All 9 yr olds will say "Daddy (or Mummy) is being mean / horrible / nasty to me" at some point in their lives, if they think that will get them what they want from the other parent. Yes, even parents in the same house, who are very much still a couple.

If you as RP didnt provide a proper and permanent sleeping space/bed for your child SS would be all over you

I have to love your optimism, but you are WILDLY over-estimating the capacity that social care have for intervening in family life.
Unfortunately families housed by social services aren't even afforded this luxury. There are many child who share beds with siblings, for example.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 08/08/2022 00:21

There cannot be many occasions when they are both there at the same time so I am guessing the majority of the time he does sleep in a bed there.
A child saying Dad has been mean does not equate to Dad being an abusive prick

I get the DS crying when he leaves Mum but he really should have been encouraged to enjoy it, rather than Mum saying she only went along with it because of the court order.

PyongyangKipperbang · 08/08/2022 00:21

I think that NOW is the time to revisit the access arrangements. If you as RP didnt provide a proper and permanent sleeping space/bed for your child SS would be all over you, sadly the same rules do not seem to be applied by them to NRP (fathers mainly) who seem to be given a medal simply for seeing their kids at all!

I think start with your solicitor then the official channels. Keep and save all messages from DS, as awful as it is, texting him is better than calls as you can then show proof of how he feels and what is happening as he sounds too scared to say anything bad about his dad so may not give a full account if he is interviewed by CAFCASS, SS or other services.

And personally I do not think that "Abusive Prick" is a leap given that he either hasnt noticed or doesnt care that his son is desperately upset and either one makes him neglectful in my view, given that his son is terrified of his Dad getting angry (why, what will he do to the son, why is a 9 year old scared of saying he doesnt want to do something to his dad?), given that the son is in pain due to injury but the father gave the OP short shrift when she advised giving pain meds and that it sounds like he did the full "I WANT FULL CUSTODY" and dragged her through the courts during the divorce (no evidence of that but reading what the OP said, I have seen it so many times and would cheerfully place a bet of a years mortgage money on that one).

Cailleachian · 08/08/2022 00:17

Tbh, and I mean this gently, I t think the extended court cases have created a tension and that is causing a lot of the problems.

Sleeping on an inflatable in the living room, rather than being prioritised for the spare bed isnt ideal, but maybe an 18 year old girl doesnt want to sleep in the living room with her stepdad in the house.

Having a sore knee and not been given calpol sound so me like a 9 year old that has emotional pain from being seperated from you, that he's projecting into a physical illness. I get the feeling that you are more emotionally involved with him and his dad is more distant. I think he is looking for a feeling of being cared for, exaggerating a reason why he would need care, his dad is recognising the exaggeration, but you are recognising the emotional upset and want to soothe him, and you feel like you are caring for him by trying to get his dad to give him calpol.

He's 9, he;s a big boy now, and yest he may have some particular needs, but he still needs to navigate the world on his own terms. Daddy being mean isnt a reason to drop everything and travel 250 miles to pick him up if he throws a strop at the airport gates.

Kite22 · 08/08/2022 00:10

@plinkypots is right though @Hshhshsh - of course it is trying to micromanage. When a dc is with the other parent, then the other parent makes the decisions.

Exactly @Quitelikeit However hard it is for ex's on a personal level, the adults should always try to emphasise the positives and reassure / encourage the dc

mycatisannoying · 07/08/2022 23:57

RainyDays22 · 07/08/2022 23:19

I'd refuse to let him go again. If he goes to court, so be it. I'd stand there and tell them he doesn't even have a proper bed and his dad is a abusive prick towards him. Your DS is getting to that age where they'll take into account his own feelings about staying.

Abusive prick? Christ almighty, that's a bit of a leap.

Pinkdelight3 · 07/08/2022 23:56

On balance, I agree with @Quitelikeit and think positivity is going to help more than your suggestion about telling a stranger at the airport, as if he's some criminal abducting a poor kid rather than a dad trying to take his son on holiday. At the end of the day, the sleeping arrangement may not be the OP's favoured option, but it's an airbed in the lounge, hardly gross neglect.

LDN1 · 07/08/2022 23:54

Op,

You did right, given the circumstances. You've done your best.

Long term, revisit the court order as your son deserves better.