Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to say that DS should have the spare room?

167 replies

SplunkPostGres · 07/08/2022 21:41

I’ve just had the second anxious call at bedtime from DS at his Dad’s house. He has to sleep on inflatable mattress in the living room because his Fathers daughter (18) from his first marriage is sleeping in the spare room.

This always happens. He doesn’t have a proper room at his Dad’s because it’s kept as a spare room. Whenever both children are there, it’s always DS who sleeps in the lounge. Tonight they’re packing for a holiday tomorrow and DS with a bad knee can’t go to bed until they do. He is 9. He has ASD. He needs to go to bed. And I’m 250 miles away and unable to do anything about it.

AIBU to say that DS should have a proper bed at his Dad’s house?

OP posts:
hoorayandupsherises · 08/08/2022 08:18

OP, I'd start another thread in SN, there's some shocking ableism on this thread.

yellowcarpetflair · 08/08/2022 07:57

@maddy68

Especially if he has asd you should be equipping him with emotional capacity to deal with the changes not cause him additional anxiety.

Do you also tell wheelchair users that they need to learn to walk too? Given how spectacularly ignorant and ableist this comment is, you probably do.

endofthelinefinally · 08/08/2022 07:55

I am so sorry your son is being put through this. Clearly his dad (like a few posters here) doesn't understand or know very much about ASD.
I think it might be an idea to discuss the situation with your son's psychiatrist and get some advice in writing going forward. The travelling and lack of routine/ sleep can't be good for him.

aSofaNearYou · 08/08/2022 07:42

*I think a young child needs a routine definitely and I’d be speaking to DH about everyone going to bed earlier as it’s not fair that DS is having to stay up late because he has to.

But I think teenagers and young adults trump young kids and older adults, who don’t have a need for privacy or as much sleep as they do.*

As an 18 year old uni student I was pretty mature and perfectly capable of being flexible about where I slept, I had no desperate need to be in a bedroom and a sofa for the night would not have been a problem. I'm not seeing why there's any pressing need for her to have privacy. She's the near adult, she should be the one that's able to be flexible.

Hollychristmasjoy · 08/08/2022 07:38

maddy68 · 08/08/2022 06:38

You are being ridiculous. An adult female should always have a room over a child

It's like giving up a seat on the bus.

It's School holidays. He is fine

Don’t be stupid. I wouldn’t let my child get up on a bus got a perfectly able adult.

TommySaid · 08/08/2022 07:37

Really? I don't think that's true at all. An 18 year old is a flexible young adult who could easily sleep on a sofa for a night. A young child needs a proper bed and a routine.

I think a young child needs a routine definitely and I’d be speaking to DH about everyone going to bed earlier as it’s not fair that DS is having to stay up late because he has to.

But I think teenagers and young adults trump young kids and older adults, who don’t have a need for privacy or as much sleep as they do.

If she was there every time then I could see why she’d be asked to move but as she doesn’t live there then I think it’s fair she gets priority over that room.

If DS needs a bedroom then he can share with his dad or dad can be the one to sleep in the sofa.

Deguster · 08/08/2022 07:35

Especially if he has asd you should be equipping him with emotional capacity to deal with the changes not cause him additional anxiety

oh, my sides… do you honestly think it’s as easy as saying “suck it up DS because I must instill your autistic ass with the capacity to deal with change!” Don’t you think the OP might have thought of that herself if it were remotely possible?

It’s pretty clear from these replies that PP think ASC can be “cured” with a bit of tough love. Which is, respectfully, ableist bullshit.

aSofaNearYou · 08/08/2022 07:32

An 18 y/o trumps a 9 y/o for the bedroom as 18 y/o do need more privacy.

Really? I don't think that's true at all. An 18 year old is a flexible young adult who could easily sleep on a sofa for a night. A young child needs a proper bed and a routine.

TommySaid · 08/08/2022 07:30

An 18 y/o trumps a 9 y/o for the bedroom as 18 y/o do need more privacy.

How often is she there?
If she lives at uni it can’t be that often.

He could sleep in his dads room but he’d had more privacy in the front room.
Is the mattress uncomfortable as that’s an easy fix?

I know lots of children who permanently sleep in the front room due to lack of bedrooms and they don’t get upset over it as they know you can’t magic up another room, most kids also have a lot more siblings to share with but it sounds like this is more about him feeling unwanted.

This is obviously not working though.
I think the distance is way too far.

How come you live so far away from each other?

Id speak to ex about getting a proper mattress for DS or a fold out bed. So he’s physically more comfortable.

Yousee · 08/08/2022 07:25

@Midlifemusings
I think I know the thread you mean and it was a totally different scenario for the following reasons as far as I can recall

  1. the "child" was an older teen
  2. there was a resident child on a camp bed in his parents room with no bedroom space at all while a room was reserved for his non resident adult sibling. There's a clear need for an autistic 9 year old to be given priority here I think.
Greensmoothie1 · 08/08/2022 07:16

Does your ex have a partner? If not, why can’t he share his room with his ds whilst his teen Dd has her own room? How often does his Dd stay over? Your ds is only there once a month so this sounds like an ok setup (but not ideal). Was last night a one off because they were getting ready to go on holiday?

Endlesslypatient82 · 08/08/2022 07:15

SplunkPostGres · 08/08/2022 06:34

Without outing us, as it’s a very specific contact clause, I successfully argued that only 1 contact a month should involve travel. His father has to have contact in the local area for the other weekend. It’s still not ideal but it means the travel is limited to monthly.

So once a month he does a 500 mile round journey.

do you drive him?

and then for the other weekend he has with his father - he goes somewhere closer

op - I would be taking this back to court.

this is no life for your young son

Itslookinggood · 08/08/2022 07:12

OP. I’ve been where you are. Your EXH sounds a lot like mine.

we don’t have the ASd but the rest of it is thr same. Child sobbing down the phone etc.

If your EXh has parental responsibility DS can’t legally be removed from his care. But the closer DS gets to 14, the more his views will be taken into account.

I’d say you’ve got a 2 step process here. 1. Holiday: Text DS today and find out how he’s feeling about the hol. Try to reassure, encourage etc, it’s only a week, etc. If he’s adamant he can’t go/ is distressed, he’ll have to tell his dad he can’t go because he is too anxious, and you’ll have to back him explaining that his ASD won’t allow him to go, etc.

then be prepared for the fight but be clear it’s the ASD up that’s the issue. If your EXh is anything like mine, he’ll need something to blame. That will probably he you, but you can deflect some of it through the ASD.

step 2, revisit contact. It isn’t your EXh who has rights, it’s your son. He’s now 9 and has a voice. It’s an awful process to go through, but it will be different now from when he was little.

my DS is 14 now and has no contact with his dad. There is not a thing EXH can do about it. For you, it really is just a question of hanging in there and trying to get through as best you can, with DS needs and wishes at the forefront, for the next 2-3 years.

Revolvingwhore · 08/08/2022 07:07

Endlesslypatient82 · 08/08/2022 06:24

Op

i am a lot more interested in how the hell your young son copes with a 500 mile round journey every fortnight?

Yes, what some people put their kids through in the name of 'fairness' is just terrible.

kateandme · 08/08/2022 07:04

There needs a conversation.i up it's hard and your ex might have a go but fuck that let him.he needs to be told.his son needs his space.it needs to happen now.ready for next visit.
No child should have to go through that uncertainty,overwhelm and tiredness every time.he can't wait for adults to go to bed.
How often do him and step sis overlap.can they share.or share with his dad.can there be a curtained off split somewhere.
It needs discussing.this can't go on.the tiredness and fear ,the not feeling safe or settled or own space will be pushing your dc go breaking.

EmpathyBypass · 08/08/2022 06:57

maddy68 · 08/08/2022 06:38

You are being ridiculous. An adult female should always have a room over a child

It's like giving up a seat on the bus.

It's School holidays. He is fine

Fucking hell

Aren't you a peach?

Shutuppppp · 08/08/2022 06:43

Honestly I think his dad should be sleeping in the living room. That's what I'd do if I were him.

maddy68 · 08/08/2022 06:42

SplunkPostGres · 07/08/2022 22:29

If I thought there wouldn’t be a confrontation, I’d be in the car now but he’s unlikely to just hand him over with a holiday booked. I need to get him home and then I can have conversations about what needs to change.
I told DS if he really doesn’t want to go tomorrow he can ask someone at the airport to call his mum.

You told him to phone his mum???
Wow
You are making him feel unnecessarily anxious. You are projecting your fear onto your child. You should be encouraging him to look forward to his holiday. Especially if he has asd you should be equipping him with emotional capacity to deal with the changes not cause him additional anxiety.

You are the problem here I'm afraid

maddy68 · 08/08/2022 06:38

You are being ridiculous. An adult female should always have a room over a child

It's like giving up a seat on the bus.

It's School holidays. He is fine

SplunkPostGres · 08/08/2022 06:34

Endlesslypatient82 · 08/08/2022 06:24

Op

i am a lot more interested in how the hell your young son copes with a 500 mile round journey every fortnight?

Without outing us, as it’s a very specific contact clause, I successfully argued that only 1 contact a month should involve travel. His father has to have contact in the local area for the other weekend. It’s still not ideal but it means the travel is limited to monthly.

OP posts:
SofaLola33 · 08/08/2022 06:28

Have you actually had a conversation with DS dad? DS may not be comfortable expressing to him.
It’s quite likely that his dad doesn’t see all that you have to do and doesn’t truly understand the impact, if you want DS to have a home away from home with his dad, you will need to work with him on that.

SofaLola33 · 08/08/2022 06:24

His dad may not realise that DS is not happy about it. My DS regularly would express to me his frustrations rather then to his dad, which I would then address (though always encouraged him to talk to his dad).

Potentially their dad may be thinking that’s DD is 18 and needs her privacy.

Endlesslypatient82 · 08/08/2022 06:24

Op

i am a lot more interested in how the hell your young son copes with a 500 mile round journey every fortnight?

Midlifemusings · 08/08/2022 06:24

Endlesslypatient82 · 08/08/2022 06:07

Given the absolute upheaval to the child’s life in this scenario (500 mile round journey every other weekend FFS) - I think the poor chap deserves a decent sleeping space upon arrival.

i can’t get my head around this 9 year old child doing a 1000 miles of travelling every 4 weeks.

I personally agree! I don't think that non custodial kids should be relegated to sofas or the living room. The kids are part of the family and there should be some brainstorming to figure out a workable solution. It was just the very different views from thread to thread that I was commenting on.

SplunkPostGres · 08/08/2022 06:23

Knackered this morning as obviously didn’t sleep much.

I think AIBU was the wrong forum for this, and that I should have chosen one of the SN channels.

There’s a lot of expectation for a 9 year old with ASD to ‘suck it up’ which frankly isn’t possible. Post diagnosis, the focus now is on the legal duty for his school to create an environment to accommodate his needs. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask his parent to do the same. Transitions and change in routines are flagged as trigger points for hîm, so he’s likely to have been in significant distress last night.

There’s also a few comments saying that I should have invalidated his feelings by not acknowledging them and just focusing on the positives. Again this is a child who’s had horrific meltdowns at school due to his inability to articulate his feelings. I’ve had to read a lot of literature on emotional intelligence for children and also spoken to child psychologists. Telling him everything is fine, even he’s clearly saying otherwise, is not the answer.

I’m on my knees with parenting a child with ASD and juggling a full-time career. I don’t need or want this on his Dad’s time. I just need him to do the bare minimum of parenting for two weeks, so I don’t have DS distressed and wanting to come home, or worse not wanting to go again.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread